Joe Davis, Doug Danner, Jeff Greenhill and Marty Maline represented the interests of horsemen.

RECEIVING BARN ISSUES:
1.) Chip informed the committee that whether or not the property in the vicinity of the receiving barn is sold, the receiving barn will remain as is with no changes.
2.) Horsemen have expressed concern that they are unable to determine when to bring their horses over from the receiving barn since there are no speakers working. Chip explained that it was his understanding that the problem has been resolved, but he will check into it.
3.) Chip explained that the restroom in the receiving barn will be fitted with an exhaust fan and they will also look into adjusting the door.
4.) The skylights in the receiving barn are still in poor repair. There is a concern that in the event of a snow storm, shards of plastic will potentially injure a person or horse. Chip explained that he was operating under the assumption that this issue had been addressed.

HORSEMEN’S LOUNGE:
The television is not working properly and several chairs in the horsemen’s lounge are in poor repair. Chip explained that the issues will be corrected.

POTHOLES ON THE BACKSTRETCH:
Chip informed the committee that the pothole work on the back stretch has nearly been completed.

SMOKING IN THE BARN AREA:
The committee agreed that smoking in the barn area will not be tolerated. A first offense will require appearing before the stewards. A second offense of smoking in the barn area, because of the danger involved, will result in ejection from the grounds which in many instances is honored by other racetracks.

TEST BARN STATUS:
Chip informed the committee that the renovations to the test barn are near completion.

DORM ROOM AUDIT AND SAFETY CHECK:
Chip informed the committee that an audit will be performed of the dormitory and tack rooms along with a safety check to assure smoke detectors are working properly. Any one occupying a dorm. room without proper authorization will be ejected from the grounds.

BATHROOMS ON THE BACKSTRETCH:
Chip informed the committee that, as requested, the bathroom will be steam cleaned on a regular basis.

TRACK SURFACE:
Jeff explained that the surface has improved with renovations completed over the summer. He explained that he has tilled the surface recently and that will slow the times. Committee members expressed interest in seeing how the track performs with freezing and thawing conditions during the winter.

TELEVISIONS IN THE RECREATION HALL:
Chip explained that televisions in the recreation hall will be replaced as needed.

BARRIERS ON THE HORSE PATH:
Barriers on the horse path in the vicinity of barns 25 and 26 to prevent vehicle traffic are too low to the ground and present a hazard to both horses and riders.

PURSE STATUS:
Robin Rogers reported that after the first weekend of races, that business was slightly off. A discussion ensued regarding the decrease in purses from last year and if it was appropriate. Chip explained that as far as the Kentucky Thoroughbred Development Fund (KTDF), Turfway was required to spend the money down last year or lose it. Therefore, the KTDF purses are significantly reduced. As far as the association purses, Turfway reduced the amount offered because of the plan to run eight extra days this year. The committee explained that maintaining the purse structure is more important to them then additional days. Chip agreed to review the status of the purse structure after this weekend and consider dropping the four optional days in February in order to reestablish association purses at last year’s level at the beginning of the race meeting.

SALT SUPPLY:
Chip assured committee that the supply of salt available to the backstretch is adequate.

SPIRAL STAKES:
Chip explained that the Spiral Stakes will be moved to April 2 of 2016.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Owner Directors
Michael J. Bruder
F. Thomas Conway
Frank Jones Jr.
Mark C. Bacon
Travis Foley

Trainer Directors
Dale Romans
William R. Connelly
William (Buff) Bradley
Ken McPeek
Rick Hiles

Alternates:
1st John Hancock- Trainer
2nd R.C. Sturgeon-Trainer

At a recently held Board of Directors meeting, Rick Hiles was, once again, unanimously elected by the new board as the President of the KHBPA. Frank Jones was elected as the First Vice President a position he has held for several years and Dale Romans was elected as the Second Vice President.

Travis Foley and Mark Bacon were elected for their first term as KHBPA Directors. They replaced Dr. Randy Sheen and Pete Salmen neither of who ran back for office.

John Hancock replaced Rick Hiles as a KHBPA Director when Rick assumed the position of President of KHBPA.

If you have any questions you may contact the main office of the KYHBPA at 502-367-6800 or via email at Kentuckyhbpa@gmail.com

Horsemen who are informed by the stewards that they have a positive test are thrust into a situation that may jeopardize their reputation and in some instances their livelihood. Testing has become so sophisticated that positives are regularly listed in picograms i.e. trillionths of a gram. Contamination from other sources including, human contact, horses shipping into receiving stalls that have not been properly sanitized, and a host of other viable possibilities create a scenario that even the most cautious trainer may find himself in the unenviable position of defending himself against a positive test for one of the horses under his/her care. The trainer responsibility rule (TRR), requires that a trainer shall be responsible for the presence of a prohibited drug, medication substance, or metabolic derivative, including permitted medication in excess of the maximum concentration in horses in his/her care.

Additionally, a trainer shall prevent the administration of a drug, medication, substance, or metabolic derivative that may constitute a violation of this administration.

In many jurisdictions, stewards take the TRR to mean there is no defense to the trainer’s predicament. There are no mitigating circumstances that can alleviate or lessen the established penalties for the various classifications of medications found in the horse’s system. A substance may be found in a horse’s system in such a minute amount that it could have no pharmacological effect on the horse’s performance. Yet, “a positive is a positive,” is the customary response from stewards to this defense.

It is frustrating to horsemen when they determine the reason for the overage in their horse’s system which may be totally unrelated to anything that they have intentionally done, but because of the TRR they are still held accountable.

However, recent decisions in various commission and court proceedings may provide horsemen with at least an opportunity to explain the justification as to why the horse’s sample was compromised. Then the stewards or hearing officers will be required to consider the mitigating circumstances and use their discretion in deciding the outcome.

One such decision is that of Daniel Werre. Mr. Werre was contacted by the stewards. They informed him that the postrace sample of one the horses he trains, who had recently won, revealed traces of Levamisole, a Class A prohibited substance. Mr. Werre explained during his initial hearing with the stewards that his horse was not intentionally administered the medication. In fact, another of his horses was being treated with Levamisole to treat Equine Protozoal Myelitis (EPM) in the stall adjacent to the horse with the positive. The split sample indicated that the substance was identified at a rate of 2.6 nanograms. A nanogram is one billionth of a gram.

The stewards, after hearing the evidence, found Mr. Werre liable for a Class A violation. They suspended his license for one year and fined him $5,000. In addition, the stewards ordered disqualification of the horse and a forfeiture of the purse. Mr. Werre, subsequently appealed the steward’s ruling, but as is often the case, the administrative hearing officer determined that Mr. Werre was ultimately responsible under the trainer responsibility rule and recommended that the KHRC affirm the steward’s ruling.

Mr. Werre next filed an appeal with Franklin Circuit Court. He raised several issues in his petition including: 1) the stewards failed to consider mitigating circumstances, 2) the classification of Levamisole as a class A substance is per se arbitrary and capricious, 3) the classification of Levamisole as a Class A substance violates Mr. Werre ‘s right of due process of the law and 4) the KHRC failed to demonstrate the propriety of the penalty imposed.

The Court overruled the KHRC on several issues. Judge Phillip Shepherd found that there were numerous mitigating circumstances that the KHRC failed to consider when imposing a penalty requiring a one year suspension of Mr. Werre’s training license.

Judge Shepherd also indicated in his ruling that the KHRC has misclassified Levamisole as a class A substance. He explained that a class A substance is described as having no legitimate therapeutic indication in the equine athlete and has not been approved for use by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Yet, Levamisole has both a therapeutic use and is FDA approved.

The improper classification of Levamisole led the KHRC to impose a penalty on Mr. Werre that was not proportionate to the seriousness of the violation, and this should have been regarded as a mitigating circumstance. The KHRC’s failure to consider the mitigating circumstance described above when penalizing Mr. Werre was an abuse of discretion. Given this internal inconsistency, the Court agreed that the classification of Levamisole as a Class A substance is arbitrary and capricious.

Judge Shepherd was highly critical of Dr. Mary Scollay, KHRC equine medical director. He cited two separate instances, Stewart v. KHRC and the present case, where Dr. Scollay, the expert witness for the KHRC, testified that she was unaware of any literature describing the effect of Levamisole on horses. In the present case, Dr. Scollay appeared again as the expert witness for the KHRC and testified that in her opinion Levamisole has a stimulatory effect on horses and that was based on literature she read about humans using Levamisole to cut cocaine. Judge Shepherd decided that Dr. Scollay’s testimony in Stewart was similar to the testimony she provided in this case (i.e. the attempt to extrapolate the potential effects of a drug on the horse solely from literature concerning its effect on humans). In Stewart as here, Judge Shepherd determined that the KHRC cannot meet its burden and prove the propriety based on evidence about the effects of drugs on humans.

Accordingly, based on the evidence, the Court found that the KHRC has not met its burden of showing the propriety of the one year suspension of Mr. Werre’s trainer’s license and overruled the KHRC in favor of Mr. Were. In 2014, Princess of Sylmar, finished second in the Grade I Delaware Handicap. Her post race test results reveled an overage of the corticosteroid, Betamethasone.

The Racing Medication and Testing Consortium (RMTC) has established thresholds for twenty-six (26) medications, including Betamethasone, which make up the National Uniform Medication Policy (NUMP). In a newsletter circulated by Joe Gorajec, Executive Director of Indiana Horse Racing Commission, he provides a question and answer section from Dr. Dionne Benson, DVM and Executive Director of the RMTC.

Dr. Benson, in response to the question, “How were the thresholds developed?” explains. The majority of the thresholds, were developed using research studies funded by the RMTC or studies shared with the RMTC from similar international studies….Most of the studies have been published or are in the process of being published in peer reviewed journals.

Yet during a recent National Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association (NHBPA) medication panel discussion, experts emphasized that 19 of the 26 medications making up NUMP have no research to support the findings. Karen Murphy, Pletcher’s attorney, successfully argued that the Betamethasone regulation was built on a foundation of sand. She advised that any state considering adopting the uniform medication regulations developed by the RMTC should hit the pause button. “You cannot defend a regulation without peer-reviewed research,” Murphy explained.

Apparently, Delaware’s Deputy Attorney General in the Civil Division agreed with Murphy’s assessment since he recommended the case against Pletcher be dropped.

The decisions in both the Werre and Pletcher cases may be instrumental to horsemen attempting to prove their innocence in a medication violation.

Mike Bruder, Chairman of the Horsemen’s Committee, R.L. “Bobby” Williams, Jeff Barkley and Marty Maline attended representing the horsemen’s interests.

PURSE STATUS-Ron Geary presented the status of the purse account. He also provided an estimation, based on his calculations, where the purse account would be at the end of the race meeting. He explained that the purse account overpayment would be less than fifty thousand. The KTDF overpayment will be slightly higher. Mike suggested that, prior to printing the condition book for next year, it would be a good idea to sit down and discuss the distribution of purse money.

RECOGNIZING SCOTT JORDAN-Mike Bruder, after hearing about the efforts of Scott Jordan, Ellis Park starter, in caring for a fallen exercise rider as she lay unconscious on the track felt the committee should recognize his humanitarian efforts. “Scott came to her aid until the EMTs arrived than moved the starting gate to provide easy access for the ambulance to escort her to the hospital.” Mike explained.

KITCHEN ISSUES-The committee asked about the intentions of management regarding running of the track kitchen for 2016. Ron explained that they plan to have a debriefing of all the departments at Ellis Park within a few weeks following the close of the race meeting. No decisions will be made until after that takes place. Dan mentioned that as far as the issues discussed at prior meetings, every intention is to have them addressed during the off season. Ron noted that the siding on the outside of the kitchen had been addressed.

SCHEDULE FOR OFF SEASON TRAINING-The committee requested clarification on the date that training ends at Ellis Park for the winter. Based on calculations the final day would be October 23, 2015.

REMOVING POSSESSIONS FROM DORM. ROOMS-Dan reiterated that all possessions must be removed from dormitory rooms during the off season. This will allow Ellis Park to clean and fumigate the rooms. This will not apply to tack rooms.

WATER DISCOLORATION-Ron emphasized that the plan is to remove sediment and clean the water tanks which he is confident will address the discoloration issue.

TURF AND DIRT SURFACES-Ron and Dan explained that the intention is to winterize the turf course which includes weed removal and fertilizing. In addition, dirt will be added to the track surface. The intention is to assure the dirt and sand is sifted and stockpiled. Glen will oversee this effort. Ron also stated that dirt will be added to stalls during the off season where it is needed.

BOB JACKSON-Ron explained that Bob and he continue to discuss his return to Ellis Park. Bob’s health and welfare are the first priority. BATHROOMS-Ron explained that every effort will be made to assure that the bathrooms are in good working order for the 2016 race meeting. The committee wishes to express their appreciation to Mona for a job well done in keeping the restrooms and showers clean.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Ron Geary, owner and CEO; and Dan Bork, Director of Racing, attended representing Ellis Park.

Mike Bruder, Chairman of the Horsemen’s Committee, R. L. “Bobby” Williams, Jeff Barkley and Marty Maline attended representing the horsemen’s interests.

PURSE STATUS-Ron Geary presented to the committee the status of the purse account along with an estimation of where the purse account would end up at the close of the summer race meet. He explained that by his calculations, he still feels the purse account would be near a break-even point. Dan mentioned that this should allow purses to be substantially higher for the 2016 racing season.

Mike questioned the calculations pertaining to the nomination and starting fees that should be deducted from the purses allocated for stakes races. Dan agreed that this was an oversight and is in the process of being corrected adding more revenue for purses.

JIMMY BECK DAY-Jimmy Beck, the long time starter and friend to many horsemen racing at Ellis Park will be remembered with a blanket presentation following the 5th race on Saturday, August 21, 2015. The event coordinated by Clem and Julie Frank along with Scott Jordan, the present starter at Ellis Park, will include the blanket presentation along with a get together on the backside near the 5/8ths pole immediately following the last race.

Please take a brief moment to attend the ceremonies at the winner’s circle after the 5th race or celebrate Jimmy’s life with friends and family on the backside after the last race.
,br/> FLAG REPLACEMENT-Mike commented that he had been approached by one of the veterans responsible for raising the flag each racing day. The veteran explained that the flag is frayed and needs to be replaced. Ron mentioned that he was sure a new flag was available and will see that it is pressed into service.

JACK CONWAY FOR GOVERNOR FUNDRAISER-Ron explained that the fundraiser for Jack Conway for Governor in conjunction with the “Groupie Doll” stakes race at Ellis Park was a tremendous success. Jack presented the trophy to the winning connections of the “Groupie Doll” stakes. Ron also stated that another event will be held for Jack Conway at Saratoga on August 30, 2015.

HORSEMEN’S PICNIC-The KHBPA/Ellis Park horsemen’s picnic held on August 19, 2015, was well attended and as usual the barbecue chicken dinner was a huge hit.

KITCHEN ISSUES-The problems that have been highlighted at several prior meetings have not been addressed. Dan assured the committee that the problems have not been ignored. Ron explained that the head of backside maintenance has been dealing with an injury since early in the race meeting and has fell behind on various projects including the kitchen. WATER COLOR-The problem with the discoloration of the water has not been resolved. Ron stated that they intend to clean the water tank following the end of the race meeting to see if that clears up the issue.

RESTROOM ISSUE-Apparently one of the backside shower and restroom facilities is backing up on a regular basis. This is a continuing problem and it was suggested that perhaps the septic system and leach lines are not handling the waste water. As opposed to regularly emptying the system, a more permanent solution is in order.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

DON’T MISS OUT…
Sunday, July 19th is KY HBPA College Laptop Giveaway Day!
After every race one lucky winner will receive a laptop!
That’s right, we’re giving away NINE laptops!
Come out to Ellis Park to enjoy a fun-filled day of racing and a chance to be one of the NINE lucky winners!

Enter to win at the Main Gate or the tents by the Paddock!

KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee: Mike Bruder, Chairman; R.L. “Bobby” Williams, Jeff Barkley, and Marty Maline.

RACING SURFACE-The discussion centered on the weather conditions which have plagued Ellis during the early days of the race meeting. Also, questions were raised about the amount of sand on the racetrack. Dan explained that they have been closely monitoring the situation. He attributed the sand erosion to the lengthy downpours we have experienced. He also mentioned that it is difficult to get sand due to the fields being cultivated where the sand is located. Committee members agreed when the track has the opportunity to dry out, it plays fair and safe.

PURSE STATUS-Bob Justus reviewed the status of the purse account. He explained that, thus far, the purse account is doing well, thanks, in part, to the increase in Historic racing revenue to purses and the supplement from Kentucky Downs to purses. A discussion ensued about the possibility of a purse raise. There are problems at both Belterra and Arlington with purses being decreased. Therefore, a purse increase may attract horsemen to run at Ellis Park as opposed to other tracks. However, due to the unpredictability of the weather and how it affects the number of horses running, it was decided to continue to monitor the purses for the time being and determine a little later if a purse raise is appropriate.

WATER COLOR-Jeff Barkley provided a picture of the color of the water coming out of the hydrants in his barn. Ron Geary agreed to have the backside maintenance crew check to see if there is a possibility of broken pipe in the vicinity of Jeff’s barn since there was no report of rust color water in other barns.

MAINTENANCE ISSUES IN THE TRACK KITCHEN-Mike reviewed issues affecting the track kitchen. They included water leaking into the front windows, chipped and peeling paint on the outside walls, and an exhaust fan is not working in the kitchen area. Ron assured the committee that he report the problems to the maintenance staff.

AIR CONDITIONER IN THE CHAPLAIN’S OFFICE-Dan Bork explained that it is his understanding that the problem with the air conditioner has been resolved.

JACK CONWAY FOR GOVERNOR-Ron Geary informed the committee that in conjunction with the “Groupie Doll” stakes race on Saturday, August 8, at 3:00 Central time, he will be sponsoring an event for Jack Conway, Attorney General for Kentucky, who is running for Governor of Kentucky. The special event is in the Gardenia room and Jack will be on hand to present the trophy to the winner of the “Groupie Doll.” Jack is a long time horsemen and has owned racehorses with his father, Tom Conway, a member of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission and a Director of the KHBPA. Horsemen are requested to attend and show your support for Jack Conway as the next Governor of Kentucky.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

BELTERRA TRACK OPENING-A rumor has circulated that Belterra’s track may not be open for training on April 20th as originally scheduled due to the flood that occurred earlier in the month. Chip said that he had talked with Belterra management about three days ago and everything was on scheduled. Marty said that he would also contact Dave Basler of the Ohio HBPA to see if there has been any change in the April 20th opening of the barn area. After talking with Dave, later in the day, he discovered that the track will be open for training on April 21st.

TVG-Horsemen have commented that just prior to the Spiral Stakes being run the television coverage on TVG switched to the fourth race at Santa Anita, coverage on TVG was relegated to watching the Spiral on taped delay. Chip and Marty will send a joint letter to TVG requesting assurance that this will not happen in the future.

POTHOLES-Horsemen have requested that Turfway initiate a plan to repair the increasing problem with potholes in the barn area. Chip has agreed to explore a request with the backside improvement commission and also pursue another company to do the blacktopping. Members of the committee mentioned that the contractor that had repaired the potholes approximately three years ago did a very credible job.

SKYLIGHT REPAIR IN RECEIVING BARN-In response to an inquiry, Chip explained that he had approved a bid on the project and it would be completed during the offseason.

BATHROOMS ON THE BACKSIDE-Chip informed the committee that the company responsible for cleaning the restrooms for the entire plant including the barn area has been terminated. He expects the problem to be dramatically improved for the next racing season.

TRACK SURFACE-Jeff and Chip provided an overview on the status of the racetrack and maintenance plans for the future. Jeff attributed many of the issues to the fiber that was too long and the oil and wax mixture. Chip explained that they are continuing to work with the fiber to reduce the size and are returning many of the bales of the unused fiber. In addition, they will change the mixture of wax and oil to more oil which they are confident will lessen the effects of the surface sticking to horse’s feet.

SPIRAL STAKES WRAPUP-Chip explained that Spiral day was down considerably in attendance and handle. He attributed this to a host of issues. The races carded prior to the Boubonette and Spiral stakes, University of Kentucky basketball team playing in the NCAA tournament during the races, and the lack of publicity and promotion. He stated that they are already in the midst of making changes to correct the problems that they have control over.

PURSE UPDATE-Robin provided a purse update. Purses paid out for the race meeting, including KTDF, increased over a million dollars from last year and included four more racing days. This included two purse raises of $500 and $2,000 per race. Total handle, from all sources, increased 15.88%. The underpayment at the end of the race meeting will be approximately $50,000. By the time of the next race meeting, due to revenue generated from simulcast wagering over the summer and fall, there is estimated to be approximately one million three hundred thousand dollars for purses at the beginning of the December race meeting.

THOROUGHBRED AFTERCARE ALLIANCE (TAA)-The TAA has approached Chip regarding the possibility of having Turfway and horsemen contributing to the TAA. The TAA is an organization that oversees and monitors horse retirement facilities and after inspecting the farms contributes to the care of the horses. Keeneland and Churchill along with horsemen racing there will be contributing. It is purely voluntary. Chip expressed the view that it is a worthwhile program.

LASIX ISSUE-Marty reviewed with the committee the recent decision of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission (KHRC) to initiate a regulation which will allow racetracks in Kentucky the ability to card Lasix free races. Horsemen and racetrack practitioners throughout the United States, concerned with the health and safety of both horses and jockeys, have overwhelmingly expressed their opposition to the regulation. At the meeting, various racing commissioners explained that the regulation is both unconstitutional and illegal. Yet the KHRC still voted to pursue the regulation. Several, legislative hurdles must be overcome prior to passage.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

SUMMER STABLING-Chip presented the latest update on the possibility of summer stabling. He provided information on how many horses are needed to make summer stabling a reality. He stated that he would be agreeable to meeting with horsemen and discussing the concept.

POTHOLES ON THE BACKSTRETCH-This continues to be an issue that has not been resolved. Chip instructed Cliff that this needs to be a priority. Cliff explained that the contractor has been working on the problem, but has had problems due to the extremely cold temperatures. He cannot clean the holes prior to inserting the cold patch due to the ice buildup in the holes. It was suggested that at least fill the holes with limestone if cold patch is not possible.

BATHROOM FACILITIES-Several issues were discussed including lack of toilet paper in some facilities, faucets providing only hot water, and people using toilets to wash dishes and clothes. The chaplain has printed signs regarding flushing toilet paper and against using the toilets to wash dishes and clothes, he requested that the signs be posted in the restrooms, in both English and Spanish. The committee was agreeable on posting the signs, but the question was raised whether everyone is able to read them. The chaplain also equipped the restrooms with dishpans, dishwashing liquid and sponges to assist in cleaning their dishes. In addition, the possibility of providing washers and dryers on the backside was briefly discussed.

SKYLIGHTS IN THE RECEIVING BARN-The skylights in the receiving barn were discussed. Cliff informed the committee that they are securing quotes for replacing the skylights in poor repair.

WEATHER FOR THE WEEKEND-Chip mentioned that it appears that Friday will be fine and they will be attentive to the conditions for Saturday and Sunday. They will make every effort to make it work for the weekend, but they are cognizant of the importance to provide safe racing for both the jockeys and horses.

PURSE STATUS-Handle in nearly every category remains strong, and the underpayment is significant. Chip explained that he will monitor the betting this weekend to determine if another purse raise may be in order.

ACCESSING TURFWAY PARK RACES ON TVG-A question was posed regarding why Turfway Park races are rarely shown on TVG and when they are shown, it is significantly delayed. Both Chip and Marty agreed to send letters to TVG representatives requesting justification for the apparent slight as it pertains to Turfway Park races.

TRACK SURFACE-Chip explained that he has reached an understanding with Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent, that track equipment utilized to mix the contents of the track will be used sparingly in proximity to racing to prevent the track from becoming too deep on race days.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Doug Danner, Jeff Greenhill, and Marty Maline attended representing horsemen’s interest.

TRACK SURFACE-Horsemen have expressed concern regarding how deep the track was last Friday. Jeff explained that he had used the rototiller on the track last Friday, after training was completed. He explained that it was important to mix up the various elements that comprise the synthetic track surface. He would have preferred to run the rototiller on a non-racing day, but various factors required him to run the rototiller on Friday.

UNBROKEN HORSES STABLED ON THE TRACK-Horsemen have expressed concern with the fact that there are horses being broken on track grounds. Tyler explained that if there are unbroken horses on the backside they will be removed. Chip stated that this is a danger to everyone and unbroken horses are strictly prohibited in the barns or on the track. Tyler mentioned that the outriders will police the track and monitor whether a horse is ready to be galloping on the track.

POTHOLE UPDATE-Jeff explained that crevices around the manure bins and some potholes have been repaired, but there is more work to be completed. Members of the horsemen’s committee stressed that repairing the potholes should be a priority to prevent a serious injury to a person or horse. Chip agreed and stated that he will renew his efforts to see that this issue is addressed in a timely manner.

SNOW AND ICE REMOVAL IN THE BARN AREA-There appeared to be confusion surrounding the removal of ice and snow on the backstretch. Chip explained that the person who they contracted with in the past for snow removal is no longer in the business. They will again emphasize to the new person the importance to salt the main road and the roads between barns. Chip also stated that there is an adequate supply of salt for the backstretch.

SKYLIGHTS IN THE RECEIVING BARN-Previously, Chip received notice about the deteriorating condition of the skylights in the receiving barn. Horsemen are concerned that with a heavy snow or ice accumulation the skylights could easily cave in sending shards of plastic onto people and horses in the receiving barn. Chip explained that he had brought the problem to the attention of the maintenance crew and will seek an update on the status of the situation.

SUMMER STABLING-Chip assured the committee that they are doing everything possible to generate interest in summer stabling among horsemen. He has also reached out to other organizations, including the Breeder’s Cup to determine if they need advanced stabling prior to staging the Breeder’s Cup at Keeneland. He emphasized that, at the present time, they do not have four hundred horse committed, but they will be aggressively promoting the project in February.

PURSE RAISE-Chip announced that due to the continued strong field size, wagering has remained strong and a purse raise is in order. Starting with Friday’s races, on January 30, 2015, purses will be raised $500 per race and an extra race will be added on Sundays. This amounts to a ten percent increase in purses.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

1.) STATUS OF FILLING POTHOLES ON THE BACKSTRETCH-Chip, Jeff, and Cliff responded to inquiries regarding the status of the pothole project. They explained that a independent contractor specializing in pothole repair will be starting today on areas of concern on the backstretch.

2.) OPENING MUTUEL MACHINES IN THE RECREATION ROOM-Chip informed the committee that this issue has been resolved to the satisfaction of horsemen.

3.) SUMMER STABLING UPDATE-Chip provided a copy of the brochure that Turfway is distributing to several locations throughout the country in order generate interest in the proposal to have Turfway remain open for training in the summer and fall. The committee mentioned the names of several horsemen potentially having interest. Particularly, the horsemen who must vacate Rice road adjacent to Keeneland in preparation of Keeneland hosting the Breeder’s Cup. Chip mentioned that he will be reaching out to the horsemen affected. Chip maintains that they must have at least 400 horses paying $7.00 per day to make it possible.

4.) ADDING ADDITIONAL DAYS OF RACING OR A PURSE INCREASE-Chip apologized that Robin Rogers Controller, has been under the weather and has not finished her calculations regarding the status of the purses thus far. The consensus is that additional races and opportunities to run are preferable over a small purse increase. Committee members explained that with the huge number of horses available to run at Turfway, horsemen need additional races. Chip explained that he will gather information from Robin and meet with Tyler about the possibility of more races being added.

5.) TRACK SURFACE UPDATE-The committee discussed the meeting with Mick Peterson of the Racing Surfaces Testing Laboratory. Committee members expressed concern with the surface sticking to horse’s feet. Jeff explained that this is due to temperature fluctuations. He expressed the opinion that it appears mostly when the temperature dips below 28 degrees. The committee agreed that the lower temperatures appear to cause the situation. Chip insists that while running, the horses appear to jettison off the material, it occurs as the horses are walking. He explained that Mick Peterson has taken a sample of the surface for further review. Everyone agreed the balling up in the horse’s feet occurs when they are walking, but it is still a concern. Jeff also mentioned that with the warming temperatures the horse path can be smoothed out.

6.) LACK OF HOT WATER IN BARN 14 AND RECEIVING BARN UPDATE-Cliff explained that he was not aware that the lack of hot water in barn 14 was an ongoing problem, but after hearing about what is happening, he is fairly sure it can be fixed by replacing the pressure relief valve. As far as the receiving barn, a sprinkler system pipe ruptured, it has been turned off and will be fixed on Monday and Tuesday of next week. In the meantime, Art has used the bobcat to smooth out the shedrow where the water had leaked.

7.) CONDITIONS OF CERTAIN RACES QUESTIONED-Horsemen have requested clarification of a certain practice in the condition book. In $5,000 races non-winners of the year and or the past six months, races won for $4,000 or cheaper are excluded from consideration. Therefore, a horse could win several races for $4,000 in the past several months and still be eligible to run in a $5,000 race for non-winners of the year. Tyler explained that this practice has been followed for the past several years. After a lengthy discussion, where varying points of view were presented, Tyler explained that his next condition book is at the printer, but afterwards he will attempt to balance the number of races that do not include the condition with those that do include the condition.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline
Executive Director, KHBPA

A meeting of the Turfway Park/KHBPA horsemen’s committee was held on Thursday, December 4, 2014.

In attendance representing Turfway Park was Daniel “Chip” Bach, General Manager of Turfway Park; and Tyler Picklesimer, Director of Racing and Racing Secretary.

The KHBPA horsemen’s committee is comprised of Joe Davis, Jeff Greenhill, Doug Danner and Marty Maline who also recorded the minutes.

INSTANT RACING-Committee members asked about the status of Instant Racing since it appeared that Turfway was moving forward with the initiative when horsemen left after the Spring race meeting. Chip explained that the owners of Turfway Park felt it would be prudent to allow the legal issues associated with Instant Racing to be settled.

ENTRY SCHEDULE-Several horsemen have expressed concern with the current entry schedule. On certain days entries are being taken two days prior to running, since many therapeutic medications must be given three days prior to running, horsemen are required to pay a veterinarian to treat a horse before knowing if the horse is actually entered in the race. Tyler explained that at the beginning of January the entry schedule will be restructured to address this issue.

VETERINARIAN AVAILABILITY DURING RACING-Concern has been expressed that there will be no veterinarians available during racing. Chip assured the committee that there will be a veterinarian available during racing. TRAINING HOURS-After a brief discussion, it was decided that training hours will be from 7:00 A.M. to 11:00 A.M. this is based on the majority of horsemen expressing their preference for this time frame. Also, there will be no training on Mondays, unless inclement weather dictates cancelling other days of training and Monday is used as a backup day.

ALLOTTING STALLS IN SPECIFIC BARNS-A number of horsemen are disgruntled over having to be moved from the barns they have occupied for several years. Tyler explained that it is strictly a numbers game. If one horseman has increased or decreased their number of horses it requires changes in the barn space that is allotted.

SNOW REMOVAL AND SALT ALLOTTMENT-Chip explained that snow removal will be the same as in years past. The issues with the first snowfall and the delay in removing the snow on the backstretch have been resolved. The problem is with the nationwide salt shortage. Chip stated that Turfway has secured their initial allotment, but further request for salt is not guaranteed due to the shortage. Therefore, if there is significant precipitation this winter, salt use may be rationed.

WORK ORDERS-Chip explained that he expects that the work order backup will be resolved. Troy, Cliff and Jeff are addressing the issues on a daily basis. He expects that Mondays will prove to be advantageous for getting caught up since there is no training. Also, anyone who has submitted a work order and there has been no response after a reasonable period of time call Chip for help. Morning, noon or night at 859-630-2298.

BARN WINDOWS WOOD ROTTING-Chip explained that Jeff has replaced several windows, if there are others, fill out a work order.

RAILS AROUNG PROPANE TANK-Chip explained that the railing around the specific propane tank has been removed due to the wood rotting. It will be addressed shortly.

RESTROOMS-The committee felt the restrooms have improved, but lack of toilet paper is still an issue.

TURN-OUT PINS-Chip agreed to have the turn- out pins smoothed out so that horsemen can take advantage of them.

ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING ON THE BACKSTRETCH-The cleanliness of the administrative building has been called into question. Apparently, it is not being cleaned as before on a regular basis. Garbage cans are overflowing and floors are not being swept on a daily basis.

RUTS IN THE HORSEPATH-During the November snowfall, when training resumed the horsepath was impassable due to ruts from tires tracks which had frozen. It was suggested either smooth out the ruts or leave the snow on it.

BACKSIDE DEVELOPMENT FUND-Chip explained that Turfway Park has funds available in the backside development fund. He proposed spending a portion of the funds for new electric heaters in dormitory rooms. Also, horsemen committee members suggested an electric hot water system similar to the one at Belterra. Chip agreed to explore the system.

Respectfully submitted, Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee consisting of Mike Bruder, Chairman, Jeff Barkley, and Marty Maline attended. Bobby Williams was unable to attend.

SHIP-IN POLICY-Several horsemen have expressed concern with Ellis Park’s policy of allowing horses shipping in for a specific day of racing to stable in various barns. The unloading and loading of horses throughout the day, causes a great deal of congestion and commotion in the barn area. Also, apparently, there has been concern expressed by the State veterinarians attempting to locate various ship-in horses for pre-race examination and lasix administration. Dan felt that reasonable alternatives could be adopted for the next race meeting. It was also recommended that horses be required to stable in the receiving barn similar to the procedure in other states. Also, if horsemen are allotted specific ship-in stalls that those stalls should be located in proximity to the receiving barn.

STABLING IN THE OFF-SEASON-As per the contract, horsemen are eligible to stable at Ellis Park for 45 days following the end of the race meeting. Horsemen have requested consideration for an additional 45 days. Several ideas were explored to make it work for both horsemen and the racetrack. The committee pointed out the number of local horsemen running horses consistently at Ellis Park. Bob Jackson suggested having horsemen sign a list of how many horsemen are interested in stabling at Ellis Park and the number of horses under their care. He stressed the list must be accurate in order to determine what would be a reasonable stall rent to charge. PROTOCOL FOR HORSE AMBULANCE-Horsemen have inquired about the procedures that are normally followed to instruct new ambulance drivers on what is expected of them. For instance, is there a specific gap to enter the racetrack in the event of a problem. Also, how is the ambulance positioned in order to assure the public does not view the situation. Bob explained that one of his employees, familiar with the procedures, reviews with the ambulance driver what is expected of him. Also, he suggested that it is his understanding that the veterinarians attending the horse will direct the driver on how to position the ambulance.

SECURITY FORCE-Horsemen have suggested to the committee that security should be more attentive to people entering the barn area. It was suggested that an occasional check of licenses may be in order. Bob stated that he will discuss issues raised with the head of security.

POSSIBILITY OF A MAKE-UP DAY AND A REIMBURSEMENT-The committee discussed the possibility of a make-up day for the one cancelled due to the track flooding. In addition, it was suggested that a $200 payment should be made to the owner to defray the expenses of the cancellation, since entries have already been taken for the last Friday of the race meeting. It was agreed that Dan would attempt to run some extra races on the last few days if there are enough entries. Also, $200 per horse will be provided to horses still intending to race after scratch time.

SUITABLE TRACK EQUIPMENT-The question was posed whether the track has sufficient track equipment. Bob stated unequivocally that they have enough equipment. Regarding the drainage problem which caused the cancellation, he agreed that the ditch and drains will require cleaning due to the sand that has ran off of the track. He stated however, that this is an extensive undertaking and will require months to complete.

KITCHEN PROPRIETOR-There is concern that the current track kitchen proprietor, Kenny Miller, may not be interested in returning after this summer. The general consensus is that the kitchen is being run very well. Bob explained that he has heard the same rumors about the track kitchen. The committee felt it is imperative to address the issues regarding the track kitchen. Bob Explained that after further investigation, they realized that some of the problems will require extensive work, but they are planning to address the issues. The committee is of the opinion that every effort should be made to convince Kenny to try another year.

PURSE STATUS-Bob Justus explained that as the race meeting is winding down, he estimates that the purse overpayment will be manageable. While some aspects of the pari-mutuel handle have been favorable some areas have not performed to expectations. Overall Ellis Park management is optimistic that with the “instant racing” improvement and some simulcasting growth a reasonable purse structure can be maintained for next year.

Respectfully submitted, Marty Maline, Executive Director KHBPA

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee consists of Mike Bruder, Chairman, and Marty Maline, both in attendance. Bobby Williams and Jeff Barkley were unable to attend.

PURSE STATUS- Bob Jackson explained that the first weekend was very strong based on the all sources figures. Marty presented purse comparisons between last year and this year. The figures indicated that we lost a significant amount of purse money the first week. Mike reminded that the focus must be to eliminate a sizable overpayment which handcuffs us for the preceding year. Regarding the KTDF fund, Bob informed the committee that Ellis Park will receive a one- time grant of $300,000 from the KTDF. He stated that, with approval of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission (KHRC), the money will be available for the second condition book and the KTDF supplement will increase $5,000 per race.

VETERINARIAN AVAILABILITY-Bob Jackson informed the committee that Ellis Park has retained a veterinarian for the 2014 racing season to assure a racetrack practitioner is available. Since the KHRC instituted the program whereby only KHRC veterinarians can administer lasix, it has become increasingly difficult to have veterinarians interested in being at the racetrack on a regular basis.

KHBPA LAPTOP GIVEAWAY-Mike Bruder announced that the KHBPA computer giveaway will be held on Sunday, July 27, 2014. A laptop and carrying case, sponsored by the KHBPA, will be presented after each race. Bob stated that the event will be publicized in the racing program starting tomorrow.

MUTUEL MACHINE ON THE BACKSIDE-Bob informed the committee that a new phone line was installed on the backside to prevent a cessation in service to the mutuel machines in the kitchen. In response to a question about installing “wifi” to prevent this type of problem, Bob explained to install “wifi” would require laying additional cable and they are not prepared to tackle that at this time.

TRACK KITCHEN-Marty began the discussion of the kitchen by informing the committee that the health department had recently inspected the facility and gave it a 100% class “A” rating. Mike explained that Kenny Miller, the proprietor, has done a fine job of getting the kitchen prepared for the summer race meeting. There are, however, issues that need to be addressed:

1.) The ceilings and walls are in need of repair, in both the kitchen and bar area.

2.) The windows are leaking and need to be caulked.

3.) The exhaust fan over the stove is not working. (Bob stated that they now have the part and it will be fixed next week.

4.) There is a section of siding missing on the outside of the kitchen that may be causing some of the leaking.

5.) The walk-in coolers, in the kitchen and bar area, are no longer working. Bob informed the committee that the two in the kitchen area were installed by a previous owner and are not his responsibility. However, the walk-in cooler in the bar area is the property of Ellis Park, but he was not aware that it was not working.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Please contact the KHRC if you have any questions. (859) 246-2040

Bill Connelly, Joe Davis, Jeff Greenhill, Doug Danner and Marty Maline attended representing the Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee.

FRIDAY NIGHTS-Several horsemen commented that there were a tremendous number of patrons that were shut out at the mutuel windows on Friday night. Chip agreed that the crowd was 30% larger than a normal Friday crowd. He assured the committee that their Mutuel Supervisor had pursued every avenue to secure enough mutuel clerks, but there were no more available. He mentioned that he expects another large crowd this Friday. He reminded the committee that horsemen, interested in wagering, after leaving the paddock can use the mutuel machine located in the KHBPA Horsemen’s lounge or the mutuel machine in the winner’s celebration lounge next to the entrance of the paddock.

SUMMER STABLING UPDATE-Chip informed the committee that it appears that there is not enough interest in summer stabling to warrant going forward with the project. Therefore, after consulting with his boss, Turfway has decided to cancel summer stabling. He commented that he felt confident that they would pursue stabling in the latter part of summer up to the time the December race meeting begins. Chip also stated they are currently communicating with River Downs-Belterra in an effort to see that horsemen are not displaced from the time Turfway Park closes the barn area and River Downs-Belterra opens.

POTHOLES-Chip assured the committee that he will prioritize pothole repair on the backside following the weekend storm.

TVG SNAFU-Several horsemen complained that TVG cancelled Turfway Park’s signal during the Saturday, February 22, 2014, race program and carried into Sunday, February 23, 2014 race program. Chip estimated that approximately $80,000 was lost in purses. He explained that due to an issue between Twin Spires and TVG, Turfway Park’s signal was cancelled. Chip informed the committee that he had talked with the General Counsel of TVG. She informed him that they had sent notice regarding the cancellation of the signal, but it had been sent to Twin Spires instead of Turfway Park. Chip mentioned that he actually had, in his possession, a statement from TVG that Turfway Park was paid in full. It was suggested that since the ADWs are licensed by the Kentucky Horse Racing Committee, they should be made aware of the issue.

RETIREMENT-Richard Riedel, Executive Director, of the Kentucky Racing Health and Welfare Fund requested that horsemen and stable employees be made aware that sign-up for the retirement fund is March 7, 14, and 21 of 2014 at Turfway Park in the KHBPA office.

WINNING PICTURES-Several horsemen have complained regarding issues with receiving their winning pictures on a timely basis. In addition, it has come to the attention of the committee that when they receive the pictures, in many instances, there are mistakes. Chip assured the committee that Turfway Park is cognizant of the importance of winning pictures to owners and trainers, and he will see that the matter is resolved to their satisfaction.

APPROACHING WINTER STORM-Chip assured the committee that Turfway Park is prepared in the event the approaching storm is severe. They have salt available and the snow removal team is on stand-by. In the event the track is closed, training will occur in the receiving barn.

PONY BARN-Chip informed the committee that the pony barn is beyond repair. It is his intention to have an alternative by the next race meeting in December of 2014. He expects that the pony barn will be torn down.

TELEVISIONS ON THE APRON-Chip explained that he has been assured by his plant superintendent that the televisions located on the track apron and favored by horsemen will be in working order next week.

CHANGING CHANNELS-Chip assured the committee that television channels available for horsemen on the backstretch will be changed following racing on Sundays to insure preferred programs are available.

GAMING LEGISLATION STATUS-A meeting of the race tracks and the members of the legislature was recently held. While it appears several concerns were resolved, apparently there are still issues to be addressed. Horsemen expressed concern that the session is winding down without passage of gaming legislation.
Respectfully submitted,
Martin A. Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Joe Davis, Jeff Greenhill, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee.

TRACK SURFACE-Jeff discussed the current condition of the racetrack. He explained that even with the horrendous weather conditions, they have been able to maintain a reasonable amount of cushion. He cautioned that there is moisture in the track due mainly to the strong winds associated with the last significant snow. Several areas of the track surface were inundated with blowing snow. Chip mentioned that Mick Peterson, the respected track engineer, has reviewed Turfway’s track maintenance records and supported the actions taken.

SNOW REMOVAL-During the past two significant snows, committee members stated that portions of the backstretch had the snow removed on a timely basis while other areas especially between the barns was barely touched. Jeff suggested that the crew responsible for the snow removal had some equipment issues, but he was confident the issues have been addressed.

BED BUG UPDATE-The chaplain had personally observed the new exterminator and had informed members of the committee that he did a thorough inspection and treatment for bedbugs. Also, he had suggested measures to assure the eradication of the bedbugs. Chip explained that he would review the letter from the chaplain and incorporate the measures if appropriate.

HEALTH FAIR-The annual health fair, sponsored by the Kentucky Racing Health and Welfare Fund in association with the KHBPA, is scheduled at Turfway Park, for Tuesday, February 11, from 11:00 until 2:00 in the recreation hall and track kitchen. “Taste of Cincinnati” finalist, Chef Bud will be catering the event.

PURSE STATUS-There is a slight underpayment in purses, but the simulcasting of Turfway Park’s races is down significantly which required a decrease in purses in the condition book. Chip is hopeful that with River Downs closing down their simulcasting facility, perhaps many of their patrons will gravitate to Turfway.

INSTANT RACING MACHINES UPDATE-Chip explained that the Supreme Court is expected to rule on the Instant Racing issue sometime in February of this year. Turfway is currently in the process of performing due diligence regarding the issue.

WINNING PICTURES SNAFU-Several horsemen have expressed concern with the inability to receive winning pictures on a timely basis. Chip informed the committee that he is addressing the issue.

OPTIONAL DAYS IN MARCH-Chip informed the committee that it is unlikely they will run the optional days in March due to purse constraints.

SUMMER STABLING-Chip explained that it appears that there is not enough interest among horsemen to keep Turfway Park open for summer stabling. Therefore, it is unlikely that it will be open this summer.

POT HOLES-The serious pothole situation was discussed. Jeff explained that they have the asphalt ordered, but it will be necessary to have the weather moderate before the patching occurs.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline

Mike Zeigler, Director of the NTRA Safety Alliance also attended. PURSE STATUS-Robin reviewed the status of the purse account. She explained that we started the January race meeting with an underpayment that is not as favorable as she initially estimated. Chip stated, due to the severe weather, including ice, snow and frigid temperatures at the beginning of the December race meeting, handle was appreciably down. He is cautiously optimistic that the handle will rebound in January.

SMOKING POLICY IN THE ADMINISTRATION BUILDING-A discussion ensued regarding making the Administration building completely smoke free. Chip suggested that the hallway and perhaps the track kitchen should be smoke free while allowing smoking in the recreation hall. A suggestion was made that the issue should be broached with the proprietor of the track kitchen. In the meantime, smoking will be off limits in both hallways of the administration building. Chip mentioned that new laws which may soon be in effect will eliminate smoking from all buildings in Kentucky. He also informed the Horsemen’s Committee that the building will soon be renamed in honor of Father Frank Niehaus.

BACKSIDE SPEAKERS TOO LOUD AND FULL OF STATIC-The issue of static and loud volume of the backside speakers was discussed. Cliff explained that, at the beginning of the race meeting this was a problem that they felt had been resolved. Dave agreed to check the area mentioned.

TELEVISION MONITORS ON THE APRON AND WINDOWS IN THE GRANDSTAND-Chip explained that they are aware of the pigeon droppings on the TV screens located on the apron adjacent to the racetrack. They have tried several measures to prevent pigeons from roosting in the area. Various alternatives are being addressed to deal with the problem. In addition, the windows in the grandstand will be cleaned in the spring of the year.

TRACK SURFACE AND HORSE PATH-Jeff explained that he understands concerns that constant working the track may cause issues with the artificial surface, but due to weather conditions it is required. He mentioned with moderating temperatures, less maintenance is necessary. There was a brief discussion regarding adding fiber to the track. Jeff felt that it may be advisable to add the fiber once the weather breaks to prevent it from sticking to the tractor tires as has occurred previously. The renovated horse path is working well every since the horrendous weather at the beginning of December where freezing temperatures and ice caused substantial issues with the horse path.

SUMMER STABLING-A discussion of summer stabling will be tabled until the next meeting.

HERPES VIRUS IN MARYLAND-Tyler explained that based on information received from Rusty Ford, Investigator for the Kentucky Department of Agriculture, we are reasonably safe in Kentucky.

ISSUES WITH RESTROOMS-A lengthy discussion regarding actions of certain individuals debasing the restrooms was initiated by committee members. Jeff explained that, Courtney, who is responsible for their cleaning is faced with a difficult task. It was suggested that an education or backside orientation should be implemented. Perhaps that will help resolve the restroom problem.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

TRACK SURFACE-A discussion ensued regarding the renovated track surface. Chip explained that the plan is to follow up the three loads of the oil/wax mixture with two loads of a fiber mixture due to arrive in the near future. Committee members commented on the improvement in the surface. There is less kickback and horses are closing with regularity. In addition, Jeff Chapman received accolades for his handling of the snow removal on the track surface. Chip mentioned that Mick Petersen, a well respected track engineer, has been very helpful in developing a maintenance plan for the surface.

HORSE PATH-The horse path has been inundated with ice and is dangerous for both riders and horses. Dave England explained the history of the horse path and why it was necessary to change the surface. The polytrack had become non functional and for years many horsemen had complained. In addition, it was important to establish drainage in the area. This was completed at considerable expense. The amount of snow and ice accompanied with frigid temperatures created difficult conditions especially at the entrance and exit gaps. Dave personally treated the areas with Calcium Chloride and it appears to have helped the situation. He cautioned anyone from pouring rock salt directly on the horse path it may cause the compressed limestone to breakdown which will worsen the problem. Dave also suggested that each horseman should keep a bucket of salt at their barn in the event that icy conditions occur in the immediate area around their barn and tack rooms. Turfway Park will provide a five pound bucket and the salt.

BED BUG INFESTATION-Doug Eldridge, Chaplain, explained the ongoing problem with bedbugs in the dormitory rooms. Turfway Park has spent a considerable amount of money on exterminators. However, the problem persists. They are prepared to spray again, but horsemen must provide assistance by removing cloth furniture and mattresses without plastic covers. In addition, clothing should be cleaned and stored in plastic containers with lids to prevent the bugs from hiding in the clothes. It was suggested that security should make security checks to assure that everyone is complying with the rules regarding removing unacceptable items from their rooms. It is the only way that the problem can be resolved.

WORK ORDERS-In response to a concern regarding the timeliness of correcting maintenance issues Cliff assured the committee that the work orders are being processed in a timely manner.

PURSE STATUS-Robin explained that they are completing the reconciliations, but at this juncture it appears wagering is significantly down from last year. Marty stated that Churchill Downs experienced similar decreases in handle across the board during their recent November race meeting. Tyler cautioned if the trend continues, it may require purse adjustments in January.

BATHROOMS-Joe stated that there have been complaints regarding the condition of the bathrooms on the backside. Chip assured that the problem will be addressed.

LEGISLATION TO RESTRUCTURE THE KTDF FUND-Senator John Schickel has agreed to file legislation that will restructure the KTDF fund. Currently, a Kentucky bred claiming horse running in an optional claiming race receives none of the KTDF supplement added to allowance races. Senator Schickel’s legislation will allow the Kentucky bred claiming horses to receive KTDF supplement money. Senator Schickel will be at Turfway Park on Thursday, December 19, at 10:30 in the morning to announce his filing of the legislation.

Please attend and show your support for Senator John Schickel on Thursday.

Respectfully submitted, Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Originally published 03:39 p.m., June 26, 2013
Updated 04:16 p.m., June 26, 2013
Though unhappy with Ellis Park management over the introduction of rock-littered sand to the racetrack last fall, local horsemen on Wednesday indicated their intention to proceed with racing when the 2013 live meet begins on July 4.

“I’ve been at this track for 30-odd years, and this is nothing new,” owner-trainer Bill Short of Evansville declared at a meeting of horsemen at the track kitchen Wednesday morning.

“I went out” on Wednesday morning to exercise horses, Short said. “There were some rocks. But it’s a lot better” than it was when the track opened for training May 20.

“It’s 100-percent better that it was,” another horsemen declared.

“(On Wednesday) morning, we talked with several horsemen and a lot of exercise riders … From those conversations, it sounds like the track is much better than it’s been,” Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association Executive Director Marty Maline, who conducted the meeting, said.

“There are rocks out there,” Maline said. “But it’s not as bad as it was.”

Ellis Park had a contractor use a mobile rock-screening machine on Saturday and Sunday to remove rock from the racetrack. Those operations ceased after a storm moved in Monday morning, dumping three to five inches of rain in the Evansville area.

Some horsemen were alarmed Tuesday morning to see that some rocks had worked their way to the surface during the heavy rain. They’re concerned that a rock kicked up by a horse’s hoof could strike another horse or a jockey in the face.

Local horse owners and jockeys said they are particularly upset that sandy soil dug up from the nearby Horseshoe Bend river bottoms wasn’t run through a sifting machine to filter out rock and other debris before it was placed on the dirt track last November.

“Somebody made a bad decision,” Maline said.

“We shouldn’t be having this conversation; everybody knows that,” Ellis Racing Secretary Dan Bork said.

“If they just sifted the damn sand … we wouldn’t be there,” one horseman declared.

“We’re past that,” Bork replied.

But he and several horsemen expressed confidence in longtime track superintendent Glenn Thompson’s ability to tend to the racing surface.

“Glenn is the best trackman in North America. No doubt about it,” Bork told a reporter after the meeting.

“I think we’re going to be all right,” the racing secretary told horsemen. “If Glenn tells me he’s going to have this track all right, it will be all right.”

While local horsemen seem resolved to race, a key concern is whether owners and trainers based at other tracks have confidence to send horses to Ellis this summer. The track will accept entries this Saturday for next Thursday’s opening day.

“I know it will be a tough day for entries the first day,” Maline told horsemen at Wednesday’s meeting.

“I know a lot of horsemen are calling you, asking your opinion,” he said. “I can tell you, (horsemen) at Churchill (Downs) and Turfway Park, they are as concerned as you.”

“Obviously it’s a problem,” Bork said. “I get calls from horsemen … You know how it is. Once there’s a little bit of fire, it blows up.

“We’ve got to let people know it’s starting to get better,” he said.

“There is every intention of running a race meet if the entries show up,” Maline said. “You need to reach out to your fellow horsemen.”

“For people calling you, do you feel confident in telling them it’s improved?” he asked.

One horsemen asked Bork whether, if few horses are shipped in, the track would run fields with as few as four horses.

“We’re going to have a meet,” the racing secretary replied.

“I know you’d like to see small fields,” Maline told the local horsemen. “But for the sake of racing, we need full fields.”

In the meantime, the HBPA intends to press Ellis Park to ensure the integrity of the racetrack.

“I told them they need to re-sift the racetrack,” Maline said. “They’ve got to do something to regain the confidence of horsemen.”

“They’re not prepared to resift it at this point,” he said. “Just my opinion: Whether they resift or not depends on how the entries go.”

Maline said he is also pushing Ellis to repair its rain float, which is a steel plate pulled behind a tractor to seal a rain-soaked racetrack and bring moisture to the surface to promote drying, and to fix its owns rock-screening equipment, which he said “is in poor repair.”

While progress has been made, Maline said, “We don’t want to them to drop their guard” on making further progress.

RSVP – Sonny Gousha at hsonnyg@aol.com or call 502-533-0359
Donations can be sent to The Robert Stallings Memorial Fund – PO Box 23147- Louisville, KY 40223

Donations are tax deductible. The Foundation is a 502(c)(3) status charity.

“So far we have more than 650 horses committed to summer stabling,” Dave explained. “It has really come at an opportune time, with Indiana Downs running exclusively thoroughbreds for their entire race meeting and stall space at a premium along with no racing at River Downs this summer, horsemen needed a suitable alternative. Turfway Park will provide horsemen looking for stalls an answer to their dilemma.”

Turfway Park has easy access to twelve race tracks and includes several advantages including: A one mile all weather race track, safety rail, turnout pens, starting gate, clocker, 24 hour security, dormitories, bathhouses, restrooms and many other amenities. Free shuttle service to Indiana Downs.

If you are interested, contact Dave England at (859) 240-9747.

Attending representing KHBPA horsemen, David England, Jeff Greenhill, Joe Davis, and Marty Maline.

HORSE PATH IMPASSABLE-A heated discussion began regarding the condition of the horse path. Jeff Greenhill explained that the horse path is frozen solid and dangerous due to the sharp ridges caused by harrowing of the horse path prior to it freezing. Marty stated that he received numerous complaints from horsemen who attempted to use the horse path, but were unable to due to concern that their horse’s feet would be damaged. He also mentioned that it is his understanding there were reports of horses slipping on the ice and falling. It is especially frustrating to horsemen, since issues with the condition of the horse path have been repeatedly discussed and continue to be a source of concern for horsemen. Chip summoned Jeff Chapman to come to the meeting. Jeff arrived and explained that he needs different equipment to deal with the conditions he experiences on the horse path. The discussion continued with the idea that another surface like limestone that is more conducive to the weather variables should be explored. In the meantime, Jeff promised that the surface will be smoothed in order that the horse path is safe and usable for tomorrow mornings training.

TURFWAY PARK TRAINING FACILITY (i.e. SUMMER STABLING)-Chip explained that Kevin Kline, his supervisor, is planning to have an operations meeting with the staff of Turfway Park later in the month to discuss issues involving the track. He explained that the implementation of summer stabling is a priority. Marty recommended that members of the horsemen’s committee would be interested to hear an overview of Kevin’s ideas and discuss our thoughts on developing Turfway Park as a Training Facility. Dave England stated that in order for a Turfway Park training facility to be successful not only this year, but for years to come, we must develop a business plan. He suggested that the business plan should include marketing, publicity, (i.e. “getting the word out”), a reasonable budget, stall assignments with a great deal of flexibility included and interaction on a regular basis with horsemen stabling at Turfway to assure they are satisfied with their accommodations. Chip agreed to approach Kevin about scheduling a meeting.

STATUS OF THE PURSE STRUCTURE-Cliff explained that while there is a significant overpayment in association purses, the KTDF fund has a significant surplus. This is due, in part, to a payment received from Kentucky Downs from instant racing proceeds. Rick Leigh recommended that an increase in the KTDF supplement should start with tonight’s races. The committee agreed with Rick’s suggestion.

BATHROOMS CLEANLINESS-Cleaning the bathrooms on a regular basis was discussed. Chip assured the committee that he would talk with the individual involved.

LIGHTS OUT AT THE 3/8THS POLE-For the third time, this topic has been discussed. The committee stressed the importance of having proper lighting while training in the dark. Chip explained that he would instruct the plant superintendent that the main body of lights utilized for night racing will be turned on during training hours until the issue with lighting is resolved. In addition, Joe Davis commented that the issue with lights in his barn remains a problem. He stated that several weeks ago, the electrician tagged the lights, yet he never came back to fix them.

SNOW REMOVAL-During the recent snow, the main roads were clear, but between barns there was very little snow removal. Chip assured the committee that they had paid a company to service the area and he would register the horsemen’s concerns.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

03.07.2013

7:45am

Dr. Don Shields has been a Southern California racetrack practitioner for more than 25 years since his graduation from the University of California-Davis School of Veterinary Medicine in 1987.

While he has specialty training in diagnostic ultrasound and has performed numerous stem-cell and platelet rich plasma treatments to injured tendons and ligaments of horse, Dr. Shields is a staunch advocate for the use of furosemide, or Lasix, to treat exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhage in horses.

He provided the following answers via email to questions on EIPH and methods to control it.

From your perspective as a racetrack equine practitioner, why do you think furosemide is the best way to treat exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhage? As with all professional sports, horse racing is a very strenuous activity. Exercise induced pulmonary hemorrhage (EIPH), or bleeding, is a common occurrence caused by the stresses encountered by our magnificent equine athletes during training and racing. Furosemide is currently the only medication which has been scientifically proven to decrease both the incidence and severity of EIPH. This beneficial effect of furosemide was clearly demonstrated in the landmark 2009 study by Drs. Hinchcliff, Morley and Guthrie.

While rest may allow the damaged lung time to heal the acute injury caused during EIPH, it has never been demonstrated to prevent future episodes of EIPH.

There are a number of adjunct medications that have been utilized in conjunction with furosemide in an attempt to further reduce EIPH. These adjuncts include medications such as conjugated estrogens, aminocaproic acid, tranexamic acid and carbazochrome. While numerous trainers and veterinarians believe they have seen a clinical effect with some of these adjuncts, none of these medications has yet been scientifically proven to be efficacious at decreasing EIPH. This fact does not mean these medications do not work. It must be noted that no adjunct medication has ever been tested in the same manner and utilizing the same study design that was employed by Drs. Hinchcliff, Morley and Guthrie, which clearly proved the efficacy of furosemide.

Hypothetically, if furosemide is banned on race-day, what would the possible results be?

We do not need to guess at what the possible impact to our equine athletes might be. The study by Drs. Hinchcliff, Morley and Guthrie clearly demonstrates that more horses will bleed more severely without the administration of furosemide. In this study, twice as many horses did not bleed at all when they were treated with furosemide. There were also no EIPH grades of 3 or 4 “bad bleeders” when horses were treated with furosemide; however, without furosemide bad bleeding (grades 3 & 4) occurred in about 12% of the horses.

Here is a chart demonstrating the grades of EIPH encountered during this study when horses raced with and without furosemide. The same 152 horses were examined endoscopically after racing once with furosemide and once without the administration of furosemide. The study is available online.

EIPH in furosemide treated horses EIPH in non-treated horses GRADE Horses % GRADE Horses % Grade 0 65 43 Grade 0 32 21 Grade 1 75 49 Grade 1 67 44 Grade 2 12 8 Grade 2 35 23 Grade 3 0 0 Grade 3 16 11 Grade 4 0 0 Grade 4 2 1

Studies have demonstrated that approximately 60% of the sudden deaths during racing have been attributed to pulmonary hemorrhage, EIPH grades of 2 or more have been shown to adversely affect racing performance, and EIPH is believed to adversely affect the overall health of racehorses. We know that EIPH is pathology, an injury to the lung of the horse, and that this injury causes further lung pathology. In his presentation to the participants at the International Summit on Race Day Medications, Dr. Robinson discussed the pathology caused by EIPH including interstitial fibrosis, septal wall thickening, venous wall remodeling and the infiltration of new blood vessels into the lung tissue. Studies have also shown that horses with EIPH have more severe exercise-induced hypoxemia (an inadequate level of oxygen in the blood) as compared to normal horses, suggesting that horses with EIPH have impaired lung function.

The administration of furosemide greatly reduces both the incidence and severity of significant bleeding. Significant bleeding is considered to occur with EIPH of grades of 2, 3 or 4 because these grades of EIPH negatively affect performance. Grade 1 EIPH has not been shown to have any negative effect on performance.

Do you have any estimates on the percentage of horses you endoscopically examine post-race (treated with furosemide) that show some signs of EIPH? Lung function seems to be minimally affected or unaffected by small quantities of blood; however, quantities of blood above this low level negatively affect both lung function and racing performance as well as create lung pathology. It is far more accurate to discuss the levels of bleeding, the actual severity or grades of EIPH found post-race, rather than chatting about whether horses show some signs of EIPH. The fact that some signs of EIPH may still be evident in a large percentage of the horses treated with furosemide is meaningless without discussing the actual grades of the EIPH detected.

As is stated above, grade 1 EIPH has not been demonstrated to impact performance; however, EIPH of grades 2, 3 and 4 have been proven to negatively impact performance. Thus it is more important and accurate to discuss significant bleeding (EIPH grades 2 – 4) rather than any and all signs of EIPH no matter how miniscule. Using the data from the study, it is apparent that 53 of the 152 (35%) horses racing without furosemide bled significantly – a grade 2, 3 or 4. However, only 12 of the 152 (8%) horses bled a grade 2 when furosemide was administered prior to racing (there were NO grade 3 or 4 bad bleeders following furosemide treatment).

One single dose of furosemide reduced significant, race-affecting EIPH by 77%! This single administration of furosemide also doubled the number of horses that demonstrated no bleeding whatsoever from 32 of 152 horses (21%) without furosemide to 65 (43%) with it.

If we simply looked at any signs of post-race EIPH (grades 1 – 4), the study showed that 79% of horses racing without furosemide had evidence of EIPH and yet with furosemide 57% still had some evidence of EIPH. However, of that 57% that were treated with furosemide and still demonstrated some signs of EIPH, 86% of these bled a grade 1 and thus were likely unaffected by this low level of bleeding. This is why we need to be clear about what we are discussing and should focus on the grades of EIPH that have been shown to injure our equine athletes and affect their performance.

Have you found any difference in the percentage of Thoroughbreds that exhibit EIPH among top-class stakes horses and lower-level claiming horses? I currently do not have enough of these top-class horses in my practice to provide statistics on this issue. If these class horses are worked and raced less often, their lungs may be less affected by previous bleeding episodes. Many other variables may also affect this statistic. The general veterinary care for these horses may be better, works may be longer but at a slower speed, furosemide may have been utilized preventatively more often, etc. Comparisons like these must take numerous variables into account to provide valid results.

In Europe and elsewhere, horses may train on furosemide but there is a withdrawal time and it is not permitted on race-day. Do you think that would work in the United States?

There are those who state that furosemide enhances performance, while others state that no amount of furosemide will allow a horse to run above its capabilities. It has been my experience that people training on furosemide are not trying to enhance the performance of their horse during a workout. Furosemide is being utilized because it has been proven to decrease both the incidence and severity of EIPH and thus to decrease or prevent injury to the lungs of the training horses. I must assume this fact is why horses may train on furosemide elsewhere.

If furosemide is medically beneficial to a horse during training, is it not just as medically beneficial during racing? Why is it morally, ethically and medically justifiable to allow injury to occur to our magnificent equine athletes when we know how to significantly lessen or prevent that injury? Millions of Americans take blood pressure medications daily and millions more take low-dose aspirin tablets to lessen or prevent the occurrence of numerous health issues including heart attacks and strokes. Medically speaking, it is far better to prevent injury and pathology than to try to heal it. We know how to greatly reduce the incidence and severity of EIPH and the attendant injury it causes. I believe it is unconscionable to allow injury to increase in incidence and severity when we know how to prevent this from happening.

It must also be acknowledged that diagnosing the incidence or severity of EIPH by looking for blood at the nostrils (epistaxis) is malpractice. The incidence of blood at the nostrils post-race has been published and is generally considered to be less than 1% of the racing population. As you would expect, the vast majority of horses suffering EIPH that results in epistaxis have bled badly (EIPH grades 3 or 4). According to the study above, roughly 12% of horses racing without furosemide will bleed badly (a grade 3 or 4). That means that looking for epistaxis to determine if a horse bled badly detects only 8% of the horses that actually did bleed badly, and yet this is often how regulatory sanctions are dispensed. Looking for epistaxis is simply an unfair way to dispense mandated rest and is never a medically sound way to diagnose the incidence or severity of EIPH.

As far as the betting public is concerned, working horses on furosemide and then racing without it may be providing very misleading information. If the study statistics hold, only 8% of horses racing on furosemide will suffer performance-affecting EIPH (grades 2 – 4) while 35% will race off-form due to significant EIPH when racing without furosemide. Which horses will bleed significantly and suffer form reversals in a particular race is anyone’s guess, but referencing data from works with furosemide will further confuse the issue when racing without it.

Has your practice evolved philosophically regarding furosemide (i.e., initially prescribing furosemide to horses that scoped with some signs of EIPH in training, evolving to using it as a preventative medicine)? If so, why?

I have always believed that furosemide should be employed preventatively. We know that the vast majority of horses will suffer EIPH to some degree during their careers. In fact, the prevalence of EIPH in Thoroughbred and Standardbred racehorses approaches 80 – 100%. Although evidence of EIPH is not present following every race, when horses are scoped successively following several races, most have evidence of some level of pulmonary hemorrhage. We simply do not know which horses will bleed or how badly they’ll bleed during any given race.

I firmly believe that it is medically sound and ethically preferable to lessen or prevent the injury to the horse’s lungs caused by EIPH by administering furosemide.

What do you think may be the biggest misperception about furosemide? Perhaps the biggest misconception is what continues to drive this entire issue. Is there really a medical question that still needs to be answered? I have spent quite some time providing you and your readers with scientific facts and medical knowledge regarding furosemide usage. What I have provided are exactly that, facts. The debate over whether furosemide greatly lessens the incidence and severity of EIPH and the attendant lung injury it causes has been settled. We have proof that furosemide works and works very well…and yet the controversy continues.

By administering furosemide to working and racing equine athletes we are lessening or preventing injury to their lungs. Is there a moral, ethical or medical debate over whether lessening or preventing injury to our equine athletes is the right thing to do? Can horses work and race without furosemide? Of course they can, they’ll just suffer more injury and pathology than they would have if furosemide had been administered. People certainly can also stop taking low-dose aspirin and their blood pressure medications. The result in humans will also be an increase in injury and pathology. The utilization of therapeutic medications in a preventative fashion is intended to lessen or prevent injury and pathology. The pre-work/race administration of furosemide does exactly this by decreasing the incidence and severity of EIPH.

According to the study, horses racing without furosemide are likely to suffer performance-affecting EIPH roughly 35% of the time. Providing data from workouts utilizing furosemide while preventing its administration for racing should certainly further increase the number of horses racing off-form during any particular race. Thus furosemide administration is not only in the best interest of the horse as concerns its health, but its use also provides a consistency to the data provided to the betting public.

So if the medical questions of the efficacy of furosemide as well as its use in preventing or decreasing injuries sustained by our equine athletes have been definitively answered, then what is this controversy about? Perhaps it all boils down to money? There are those who believe that European and other world buyers will pay significantly higher prices for our horses if they are not running on furosemide. Is it moral, ethical, medically sound or even a good business practice to trade increased pulmonary injury and pathology to the lungs of our racehorses for the imagined increased profits to be reaped in the sales ring?

We certainly can race without furosemide, as long as we don’t mind mandating an increase in the injury and pathology to be suffered by our equine athletes. For the record, I do mind and don’t believe this course of action would be in the best interest of the horse. New to the Paulick Report? Click here to sign up for our daily email newsletter to keep up on this and other stories happening in the Thoroughbred industry

This entry was posted in The Breeders’ Cup Forum and tagged dr. don shields, EIPH, furosemide, Horse Racing, lasix, medication in racing, the breeders’ cup forum, thoroughbred by Ray Paulick. Bookmark the permalink.

Attending representing KHBPA horsemen, David England, Jeff Greenhill, Joe Davis, and Marty Maline.

SUMMER STABLING-David England reviewed the number of horsemen, thus far, who are planning to stable at Turfway Park during the summer of 2013. He continues to work toward the number necessary to assure that Turfway Park remains open. If by February 20, he is not successful in attaining the goal necessary to make it work, the effort will be abandoned. He feels many horsemen may be willing to commit at a later date, but it is imperative that the number necessary to make summer stabling a reality be reached by February 20. He urged horsemen, even if they are still exploring other options, to sign up. He explained that he has checked several training centers and they are currently filled. He mentioned that he and Joe Davis have been meeting with Indiana Downs management about renting stall space at Turfway and those discussions have been fruitful. However, Joe indicated that the February 20 date is pivotal since a firm commitment must be made that summer stabling is going to happen prior to the Indiana Racing Commission meeting. If not, Indiana Downs will once again run a portion of the days and Hoosier Park will run the rest of the thoroughbred days instead of all the days being run at Indiana Downs. It was also reported that River Downs is very close to announcing that they will be running their race meeting at Beulah Park.

RECEIVING BARN LOUNGE-Horsemen shipping in have complained that smoking in the lounge is not being policed. Presently, it is difficult due to the heavy smoke, to spend any time in the lounge to escape the cold.

WORK ORDERS-A discussion ensued regarding the need for a better system to address work orders. Chip suggested that they will provide an update on a regular basis to the KHBPA office in order that horsemen are aware of the status of their work order request.

SECURITY-A general discussion regarding security concerns resulted in Chip deciding to schedule another meeting with the security director and members of the Horsemen’s Committee.

AMBULANCE PARKING-Chip agreed to suggest an alternative parking area for the ambulance during training hours.

PURSE STATUS-Cliff reviewed the present status of the purse account. A lengthy discussion ensued regarding the purse cut and raising the Spiral Stakes $50,000. Chip explained that as far as the purse cut, he suggested it was more of a purse reallocation. Turfway Park agreed to run the remaining two Fridays and Saturdays in February at the request of the KHBPA to assure horsemen more opportunities to run. Also, they decided to run extra races to make up for the races lost due to weather conditions. As far as the $50,000 additional added to the Spiral Stakes, Kevin Kline, Chip’s supervisor, is confident this projects a positive image to Turfway Park. According to Chip, Kevin is committed to increase the awareness of Turfway Park to many more potential corporate sponsors, along with prominently displaying Turfway Park in their casinos. Cliff indicated that the casino is sponsoring a portion of the Spiral purse and their entire portion will go towards the purse.

LIGHTS ARE STILL OUT AT THE 3/8THS POLE-Horsemen reminded that the issue with the light being out at the 3/8ths pole continues to be a problem and a concern to horsemen.

EQUIBASE NO SCRATCH TIME-It is brought to the attention of the committee that Equibase, which horsemen rely on for information, is not posting the scratch time at Turfway Park.

HAWTHORNE QUARANTINE-The committee felt that horses entering from Illinois still must seek a permit from the Kentucky Department of Agriculture prior to shipping to Turfway Park. Horsemen are reminded that the Department of Agriculture is not open to receive permits on the weekends. Horsemen should contact Rick Leigh for further information.

WAGERING TERMINALS IN RECREATION BUILDING-Chip informed the committee that wagering terminals will be open each day by 11:00.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

David England, Jeff Greenhill, Joe Davis, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

SUMMER STABLING UPDATE-Dave England provided an update on the number of horsemen who have committed thus far to summer stabling. He estimates that we are nearing the goal necessary to keep the barn area open. Dave is continuing to call horsemen and commented on the number of horsemen who have expressed interest. Joe Davis informed the committee if it is determined that Indiana Downs runs all the thoroughbred racing dates they may be interested in leasing a number of stalls. Information has been received that an agreement is nearing completion that has River Downs running their racing dates at Beulah Park. In addition, Marty has sent out a release to several outlets and to the National HBPA. The Bloodhorse has responded with an article and the National HBPA has sent the release and a copy of the brochure regarding Turfway training to nearly thirty affiliates. Cliff informed the committee that he is in the process of finalizing a proposed contract for horsemen interested in stabling at Turfway.

TRACK SURFACE UPDATE-Jeff informed the committee that since the last meeting the incidence of people driving on the horse path has reduced significantly. However, everyone expressed the importance of staying vigilant and reporting to the stewards anyone guilty of driving on the horse path.

A discussion ensued about the track surface. Chip explained that various groups have given proposals on the track surface. Jeff explained that various samples are currently being weather tested. He provided the committee with samples of each companies approach to conditioning the track surface. Chip informed the committee that they are continuing their research.

PARKING AT THE RECEIVING BARN-Chip reported that they have been able to remove several feed and horse trailers that were parked in proximity to the receiving barn immensely improving the parking situation. He reminds horsemen and feed men that their trailers must be registered at the guard gate.

HAWTHORNE QUARANTINE-Rick Leigh reports that horsemen entering horses from Illinois still must seek a permit from the Kentucky Department of Agriculture prior to shipping to Turfway Park. Horsemen are reminded that the Department of Agriculture is not open to receive permits on the weekends. Contact the racing office for further details and to receive a permit request application.

HEALTH FAIR-The winter/spring Turfway Park KRH&WF health fair will be held on Wednesday, February 13 starting at 11:00 A.M. until 2:00 P.M. in the horsemen’s administration building. The list of services provided include, Dr. Pam Fletcher, dermatologist; Dr. Jim Wright, dentist; Dr. Dammel, chiropractor; Mobile Mammography Screenings; Hearing Solutions; Northern Kentucky School of Nursing; Women’s Crisis Center; and Race for Education. Several others are still being confirmed. Bud will be serving his award winning burritos and all the fixings to everyone attending.

DRUG AND ALCOHOL PROGRAM-Are you ready for confidential help with a drug or alcohol problem? Talk to someone before you jeopardize your job, health, or life. Call Judy 0’Banion 525-1487.

LIGHTS OUT AT THE 3/8THS POLE-Jeff Greenhill informed Chip that there is an area near the 3/8ths pole that is void of lighting which is a problem while training in the dark. Jeff Chapman informed the committee that they are aware of the problem and are in the process of fixing it.

PURSE STATUS-Cliff informed the committee that revenue received from ADWs will have a positive impact on the overpayment of purses. Also sponsorship revenue for upcoming stake races on Spiral day will all be applied solely to the purse account.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

“We have sent out several hundred brochures throughout the country,” Dave explained. “I have been on the phone day and night, and we have hundreds of commitments. Churchill Downs and Indiana Downs are considering providing free shuttle service.”

Turfway Park has easy access to twelve race tracks and includes several advantages including: A one mile all weather track, safety rail, turnout pens, starting gate, clocker, 24 hour security, dormitories, bathhouses, restrooms and many other amenities.

“With its central location and safe training surface, Turfway Park is a perfect training facility,” commented Buff Bradley.”

“The Turfway track is very safe and works well for 2 year olds and bringing horses back from layups,” Mike Maker explained.

Interested?

Contact David England (859) 240-9747.

I have received a call from a Kentucky horseman who has a positive for Levamisole.

According to Dr. Tobin, Levamisole is an immune stimulant, related to the wormer, Tetramisole. Apparently, it metabolizes to aminorex and pemoline, both stimulant drugs. The trainer did inform me that the Kentucky stewards informed him that Levamisole is a Class “A” substance. He is sending the split to Louisiana State University.

Perhaps you may recall the Aminorex positives in Ohio and Pennsylvania. One veterinarian practitioner, practicing in both Ohio and Kentucky informed me that Levamisole is not prevalent since the Aminorex positives surfaced. However, recently, there have been a number of Levamisole related pemoline positives in New York.

Please avoid the use of Levamisole in horses.

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

David England, Jeff Greenhill, Joe Davis, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

1.) HORSE PATH ISSUES-A lengthy discussion ensued regarding the condition of the horse path. Jeff explained that putting salt on it created a major problem. There was no possibility of running equipment over it when it is wet. He stated that people driving on it is causing ruts when it freezes. The committee discussed fencing to eliminate people driving on it. In the meantime, anyone caught driving on the horse path may lose their driving privileges on the backside. Finally, horsemen loading horses are to use the main road during training. For the safety of horsemen and horses, unloading horses between barns during training hours is expressly prohibited. If horses need to be unloaded during training, it must be done in proximity to the receiving barn.

2.) PARKING AT THE RECEIVING BARN-Ship-in horsemen have complained about the lack of parking in the vicinity of the receiving barn. Chip and Jeff explained that they are working with security to alleviate the problem. This includes having horse trailers, feed trailers and compost moved to a different location in order to make more room available.

3.) SHOWER SPIGOTS CLOGGED-People using the showers in the vicinity of barn 19 have suggested that the water is down to a trickle in some of the showers. Cliff explained that he will check on the situation and replace spigots if needed.

4.)SUMMER STABLING-The discussion continued, Chip explained that initial discussions with Racing Commission personnel appear favorable to a request to provide backside funds for a roof on an equisizer machine. The next step is to firm up the count of the number of horsemen who will be interested in training at Turfway Park in the summer. The brochure highlighting the advantages is nearing completion. Dave and Chip are working out the details which will allow Dave to begin contacting horsemen throughout the country who may be interested in stabling at Turfway Park for stabling and training.

5.)Hawthorne Herpes Status-Chip announced that with the recommendations from the State Department of Agriculture, Turfway Park will follow numerous other racing jurisdictions and not allow horses currently stabled at Hawthorne as well as any horse on the grounds during their fall race meet to stable or race at Turfway Park until further notice. He expressed his regret to horsemen from Hawthorne that have supported Turfway Park in the past, but the safety of horses stabled at Turfway Park must take precedence.

6.)SIMULCASTING-The horsemen’s committee questioned why Turfway Park was not open for simulcasting Wednesday or Thursday of this week. Chip explained that there was a lack of signals available to wager on both days.

7.)HORSES SUFFERING CATASTROPHIC INJURY-Several horsemen expressed outrage regarding the treatment of a horse suffering a tragic injury while racing requiring euthanasia. Marty explained that he discussed the issue with Dr. Farmer, Chief Kentucky Horse Racing Commission (KHRC) veterinarian and Dr. Mary Scollay, Equine medical director for the KHRC. Both explained that it is the KHRC procedure to always load a horse on the horse ambulance if it is still standing as opposed to euthanizing it on the racetrack. Further, Dr. Scollay informed him after additional consultation with a noted veterinarian surgeon, a horse in that condition is not experiencing any sensation of pain. The horse was immediately euthanized upon being loaded into the ambulance.

8.)STATUS OF PURSE ACCOUNT-Cliff explained that at the present time there is a significant overpayment of purses following the December Holiday race meeting. He will monitor the purse account closely, but with the decrease in racing days in the upcoming months he is hopeful that the purse account will stabilize.

Respectfully submitted, Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Chip Bach, General Manager; Cliff Reed, Vice President and CFO; Tyler Picklesimer, Ass’t Racing Secretary; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent attended representing Turfway Park management.

David England, Jeff Greenhill, Marty Maline, and John Griffith attended representing the KHBPA Turfway Park racing committee.

1.) CONTINUOUS LOUD MUSIC IN DORMITORY A-Horsemen have expressed frustration with the security staff for failing to address the problem with continuous loud music at all hours emanating from dormitory A. Chip explained that he understands the issue and will see that security addresses the problem.

2.) PLACEMENT OF ROAD BARRICADES-Horsemen are requesting that road barricades be positioned closer to actual training hours as opposed to three o’clock in the morning. Chip stated he will also alert security about this issue.

3.) WORK ORDER DELAY-Horsemen have expressed concern with the failure to address work orders on a timely basis. Chip explained that, other than emergencies, they will attempt to address work orders within 48 hours. As opposed to writing out numerous work orders on the same problem, if the situation is not addressed within 48 hours, please contact the maintenance office or him personally.

4.) MANURE BIN PICK-UP-Jeff Chapman explained that while manure is not removed daily, it is removed on a timely basis. They have hired a new person to assist in seeing that the manure is pushed back into the manure bins on days it is not removed. Jeff also wanted to emphasize that the manure bins are for manure only. Throwing bailing twine and other trash into the manure bins is causing problems including breaking equipment. He requests that trainers instruct their employees not to discard items other than manure into the bins.

5.) SETTING TELEVISION CHANNELS-Once again stable employees are complaining that the television stations are being arbitrarily changed. Instead of having the ability to watch sports channels they receive a steady stream infomercials. Chip stated that he will impress upon the video personnel to change the channels back to ESPN prior to leaving for the day.

6.) HERPES SCARE-There is a concern that horses that have left Hawthorne may end up running at Turfway while still under quarantine. Chip and Tyler assured the committee that they will be closely monitoring the situation. 7.) TRACK SURFACE-Horsemen have questioned the necessity of having the grader on the track since the track was in great condition following the extended rains. Jeff explained that it is necessary to maintain a level and consistent surface.

8.)PROPOSED JOCKEY MOUNT FEE INCREASE-Marty explained that he has received correspondence from Jeff Johnston of the Jockey’s Guild requesting consideration for a fee increase. I have forwarded the request to the President and KHBPA Board. The Horsemen’s Committee expressed the view that under the present circumstances it is difficult to consider a mount fee increase.

9.)PURSE STATUS-Cliff explained that we are currently operating with an overpayment in purses, but he felt fairly confident that Turfway will be able to increase purses for the next race meeting starting in January.

10.) PROPOSED SUMMER STABLING-Dave England reported on the interest and favorable comments he has been receiving from horsemen. He explained that it is important to expand the search to include horsemen in other states. To this end, he will be working with Sherry Pinson, Director of Communications, to develop a brochure highlighting the advantages of stabling at Turfway Park. Weekly updates on progress of the initiative will be forthcoming.

Respectfully submitted, Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The KHBPA is a trade association representing the interest of the vast majority of owners and trainers of thoroughbred horses racing in Kentucky. The KHBPA is affiliated with the National HBPA with nearly 30,000 owner and trainer members nationwide and in Canada.

The KHBPA has been outspoken on the need to preserve the use of the therapeutic medication, Lasix, on race day to prevent the onset of bleeding in race horses. In addition, through its purse contracts at each and every racetrack in the state, the KHBPA assures horsemen an equitable share of wagering revenue for purses.

The newly elected KHBPA Directors include:
Frank Jones, First VP
Dale Romans, Second VP
F. Thomas Conway
Mike Bruder
Dr. Randy Scheen
Pete Salmen
Bill Connelly
Buff Bradley
Kenny McPeek
R.C. Sturgeon

ARCADIA, Calif. – At least three juveniles who participated in Breeders’ Cup races this weekend at Santa Anita bled, according to their connections, contradicting information put out by the equine director of the California Horse Racing Board.

Trainer John Sadler said both Capo Bastone and Monument, third and last, respectively, in Saturday’s Breeders’ Cup Juvenile, bled. Trainer Mark Casse said that Spring in the Air, who finished fifth in Friday’s Juvenile Fillies, also bled.

This year was the first year that the Breeders’ Cup banned Lasix for all races restricted to 2-year-olds. Next year, the Breeders’ Cup wants to ban Lasix in all of its 15 races.

On Sunday morning, Sadler carried in his pocket a copy of an article in the Los Angeles Times that quoted Rick Arthur, the equine director of the California Horse Racing Board, as saying no 2-year-olds bled visibly on the track or at the receiving barns following their Breeders’ Cup races. Endoscopic examinations later showed that at least three horses bled from the lungs.

Sadler said an endoscopic examination revealed that Capo Bastone, who made a huge move from last to be third in the Juvenile, bled a 3 on a scale of 1 to 5. He said Monument, who finished last in the Juvenile, bled a 1 on that same scale.

Sadler was quite frustrated as he read from the Los Angeles Times story.

“So we’re just eyeballing then now?” Sadler said. “What’s that all about? The problem is, some fan is going to read this and say, ‘What were all those people screaming about? No horse bled.’ Anybody that knows anything knows this is just not true.

“I guess we don’t have to X-ray ‘em anymore or take a blood,” Sadler added. “ ’Looked okay to me.’ It’s like we’re going back in time.”

Sadler said that the Breeders’ Cup should have performed an endoscopic examination on every 2-year-old who raced on Friday and Saturday.

“They wouldn’t do that on a dare because it wouldn’t match up their pre-determined conclusions,” Sadler said.

Sadler said that Capo Bastone would be shipped to the Alamo Pintado Equine Clinic in Santa Ynez for an evaluation before determining how to treat him.

“Once we get all the science done then we’ll figure out what we’re going to do, unless of course you don’t believe in science and you’ll just eyeball them,” Sadler said.

Aron Wellman, who heads the partnership that owns Capo Bastone, said the decision to eliminate Lasix could be costly for both his horse and himself.

“From my perspective, it’s frustrating not only to have to consider what it could have cost us today in terms of money and the prestige of a championship Grade 1, but there’s so many unknown factors now moving forward,” Wellman said. “From a physical standpoint we will do everything possible and take the most proactive approach to make sure his lungs heal in a proper fashion.

“When you have a young horse like this, there’s no telling what the long-term psychological effect on this horse will be next time,” Wellman added.

Wellman said he supports Breeders’ Cup’s efforts on medication reform, but he doesn’t support a ban on Lasix.

Casse said Spring in the Air, who finished fifth, “bled significantly” in the Juvenile Fillies. Casse said she was coughing at the barn afterward and then bled her through her nostrils.

“My filly bled pretty significantly. She’s still coughing this morning,” Casse said Saturday. “Some horses never come back from it. The shame of it is they don’t give you an indication then ‘boom.’

Casse said that Dynamic Sky, who ran sixth in the Juvenile, did not bleed.

Todd Pletcher, who won the Juvenile with Shanghai Bobby, had all of his horses scoped and said none of his 2-year-olds bled.

“It doesn’t change my position on being pro-Lasix,” Pletcher said.

Bob Baffert said none of the 2-year-olds he ran in the Breeders’ Cup bled, but he remains against a ban of the medication. He believes by banning Lasix in all Breeders’ Cup races next year, “you’ll see field sizes shrink.”

“There are a lot of owners that are going to get out of the business,” Baffert said. “I have some clients that think it’s inhumane to allow a horse to bleed.”

Fortify, who ran fourth in the Juvenile, did not bleed, according to trainer Kiaran McLaughlin. Fortify was the only horse in the Juvenile field to have never raced on Lasix.

ARCADIA, Calif. – Trainer Mark Casse said Saturday that Keeneland’s Alcibiades winner Spring in the Air bled badly in Friday’s $2 million Breeders’ Cup Juvenile Fillies at Santa Anita Park.

Casse going into the event was an outspoken critic of the Breeders’ Cup rule this year that no horse in its five races for 2-year-olds could run on the anti-bleeder medication commonly known as Lasix.

“Before I was disappointed with the Breeders’ Cup,” he said. “Now I’m just down-right mad. I am furious.”

Casse said owner John Oxley was so upset that they considered – but did not – withdrawing Dynamic Sky from Saturday’s Juvenile.

Casse said Spring in the Air, who went off at odds slightly under 6-1, was traveling well when she acted like she was going to bolt midway through the far turn. He said jockey Patrick Husbands reported that when he got the filly down to a jog pulling up after the race, she started coughing.

“She coughed the entire way back to the barn,” Casse said. “She just constantly, constantly coughed. We called the vet. The vet scoped her and the vet said she bled a 3 out of (a scale of) 5. She put her head down and blood came out of her right nostril. Still this morning she is still coughing.

“I mean, is that right? I’ve got to tell you, Mr. Oxley is so upset about it he said he would never, ever run another 2-year-old without Lasix in the Breeders’ Cup. You just don’t know. This could be the end of her career, which is just absolutely ridiculous. We’ve got all these smart guys (running racing). Let them come back to the barn some time and watch a horse that bleeds cool out.”

Casse predicted Breeders’ Cup entries will sharply drop if the organization continues with its plan to ban race-day Lasix use in all competitors next year.

“These are 2-year-olds, so they’ve had young career. They’re still fairly healthy,” he said. “You go doing that to the older horses, who knows what’s going to happen? Twice I’ve seen horses fall and collapse from bleeding too badly. One at Keeneland, one down at Palm Meadows. One in a racing, one just training. Isn’t that going to be nice? Will they be really proud a horse falls and kills a rider, or kills some other horses?

“They just do not know what they’re dealing with. I have owners talking about not wanting to buy horses any more. Can you blame them? Here you’ve got a filly like Spring in the Air, who is one of the best fillies in her division. Definitely if she couldn’t run on Lasix, her career would probably be over.”

Casse said Spring Venture, who finished 13th in the Juvenile Fillies Turf, also underwent an endoscopic exam and showed no sign of bleeding.

“In my opinion, the turf isn’t near as hard on them,” he said. “Her trip was her demise.”

HORSE PATH-At two separate locations the blacktop adjacent to the horsepath is crumbling and is creating a hazard in the event a horse steps on the rocks. Chip assured the committee that the problem will be addressed.

FAN APPRECIATION DAY-Dave England expressed his appreciation to the horsemen and women who volunteered their time to make fan appreciation day a big success. Chip suggested that soon they will have a debriefing meeting and also discuss plans for future fan appreciation days.

LOOSE HORSE-Recently a horse escaped from its stall and left the grounds. While two outriders stayed on the track, the lead outrider assisted with the capture of the loose horse. Several horsemen and Turfway employees joined in the effort to capture the horse and avert a possible catastrophe. The committee wishes to express its appreciation for their successful efforts. The committee discussed possible measures to assure that a loose horse does not escape from the grounds.

NOTICE BOARD-Dave suggested that a notice board be posted at the security gate that horsemen can utilize if they need a horse to work with their horse or to send a quick notice for other HORSEMEN issues that horsemen can access as they drive into the barn area.

HEALTH CLINIC-A free health clinic is available every Wednesday, from 11:00 until 3:00. The clinic is located between the horsemen’s lounge and the photographer’s office next to paddock. Contact Donna in the KHBPA office to schedule an appointment.

LOUNGE IN THE RECEIVING BARN-Cliff Brown informed the committee that they have been renovating the lounge in the receiving barn. VETERINARIAN SCRATCHES-Several complaints have been received regarding the scratching of horses, by Racing Commission veterinarians, during the prerace examinations. There appears to be a significant disagreement between trainers, racetrack practitioners and the Racing Commission veterinarians. In addition, Dave asked about the availability of a veterinarian to treat horses once Racing Commission veterinarians are administering the lasix shots. Marty explained that the Equine Medical Director had assured that the tracks will have a racetrack practitioner available in the event a horse needs treatment. Chip and Cliff explained that there has been no arrangement with the Racing Commission to have a veterinarian available and nothing is in the budget for such an expenditure.

TRACK MAINTENANCE-Chip and Jeff informed the committee that there is continuing discussions with an engineering firm who is working to develop a substance that will maintain the durability and consistency of the track surface. The engineering firm is communicating with Dr. Mick Peterson a respected expert on track surfaces.

BATHROOMS-Dave mentioned that the crew in charge of cleaning the restrooms is maintaining the bathrooms in a clean and sanitary condition.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

In his honor, several horsemen developed and organized the Blackie Huffman Educational Fund (BHEF). It was their hope to have Blackie’s legacy live on through a program that meant a great deal to him.

The BHEF is a nonprofit fund designed to assist the middle school age children of stable employees develop their educational skills through individual tutoring, mentoring and summer camps.

The BHEF is established in conjunction with the renowned Klein Learning Center located on the backstretch of historic Churchill Downs.

Donations are graciously accepted and may be sent to the Blackie Huffman Educational Fund, in care of the Klein Learning Center at 704 Central Avenue, Louisville, Kentucky 40208; or the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association (KHBPA), 3729 South 4th Street, Louisville, Kentucky, 40214.

Your kind consideration is deeply appreciated.

Frank J. Agrinsoni
Executive Director
Blackie Huffman Educational Fund

The KHBPA is frustrated and extremely disappointed with the Governor’s decision to implement aspects of the Kentucky equine medication policy that the Interim Joint Committee on Licensing and Occupations (L&O) found deficient.

“It is unfortunate that Governor Beshear decided to implement the regulation without providing horsemen and veterinarians the opportunity to explain our side of the issue,” explained Rick Hiles, President of the KHBPA. “On behalf of the thousands of horsemen we represent and veterinarians, I want to express our sincere appreciation to the members of the L&O for their consideration of our concerns.”

Members of the L&O committee questioned the arbitrary language of the regulation and the fact that it would be very costly to the State of Kentucky requiring additional payroll and benefits along with malpractice and liability insurance to cover the newly hired state veterinarians.

Veterinarians commented at the hearing that transferring income of private racetrack practitioners to state hired veterinarians may be a considered a “taking” and perhaps unconstitutional.

In addition, regarding the Butazolidin (Bute) change from 5 micrograms and 2 micrograms, there is no published research that the identification of lameness is compromised at the time of the pre-race exam if a horse was administered 5 micrograms of Bute.

Horsemen and veterinarians throughout the state of Kentucky and adjoining states are very upset with the Governor’s decision.

The fifth and final meeting of the Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee for 2012 was held on Friday, August 31, 2012.

Bob Jackson, Director of Operations; Dan Bork, Director of Racing; and Jason Greene, Chief Financial Officer attended representing Ellis Park.

Mike Bruder, Chairman of the KHBPA Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee, R.L. “Bobby” Williams, and Marty Maline attended representing horsemen.

The Horsemen’s committee is interested addressing issues to be corrected by the 2013 racing season.

ICE DISTRIBUTION-To resolve the issue of assuring every horsemen has an adequate amount of ice, the Committee agreed an attendant is needed each day except Mondays when there is no training.

PARKING LOT-Bob Jackson informed the committee that the issues will be addressed in the off season.

CLEANING DRAINS ALONG INSIDE RAIL-Bob Jackson explained that Glen will be cleaning and flushing out the drains prior to next year.

SAND ON BOTH THE TURF AND DIRT TRACKS-R. L. reminded that additional sand needs to be added to both tracks in preparation for next year’s race meeting. Bob Jackson stated that access to sand will be available immediately after crops have been harvested and will be applied to both track surfaces.

TURF MAINTENANCE-Bob explained the process that will be followed for the turf course including feeding, fertilizing and aerating during the off season.

PADDING UPDATE-Mike informed the committee of the progress on padding portions of the rail, especially where the gap is located.

EXTRA TWO DAYS OF TRAINING-Mike Bruder reminded Bob that the horsemen are entitled to two additional days of training at the end of the race meeting. Bob Jackson agreed with Mike’s assessment.

COMPUTER AND SCHOLARSHIP DAYS FOR 2013-Mike Bruder mentioned that both days will be scheduled on Sundays. Scholarship day on July 28, and Laptop computer day for August 4, of 2013. Bob and Dan suggested that IPADs may be more popular than laptop computers by students. Mike agreed to consider IPADs in place of laptops.

PURSES-Jason reported that it appears that we will end the race meeting with an overpayment that is much lower than originally expected.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

A Kentucky legislative subcommittee, in a surprise vote, found regulations governing equine medication “deficient” Aug. 27, just one week before they are scheduled to take effect.

The regulations call for regulatory administration of furosemide on race day, a ban on adjunct bleeder medications, and a reduction in the amount phenylbutazone that can be administered to a horse 24 hours before a race. The regulations are in line with national model rules approved by the Racing Medication and Testing Consortium and the Association of Racing Commissioners International.

The regulations are supposed to take effect Sept. 4, in time for the Turfway Park meet that begins Sept. 6.

The bipartisan Interim Joint Committee on Licensing and Occupations held its regular meeting Aug. 27, and on the agenda was a report from the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission on its activities. The new drug rules weren’t on the agenda.

According to sources, the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association over the weekend lobbied lawmakers to call the regulations for a vote. All but one of the 20 legislators present for the meeting voted to find the regulations deficient.

“I spoke out against finding it deficient,” Republican Sen. Damon Thayer said. “I was the only ‘no’ vote. The HBPA ambushed the racing commission, and I felt blindsided, too. This wasn’t on the agenda.

“This process (on the regulations) has been going on for a year and a half, and there has been full transparency. It’s a national model rule that has been adopted by other states, so I question the motivation of the HBPA.”

Thayer, who is a member of the Kentucky Equine Drug Research Council, which recommended passage of the regulations, suggested the horsemen’s group is “trying to muddy the waters in advance of action” on proposed rules to ban furosemide on race day in graded and listed stakes in Kentucky effective Jan. 1, 2014.

Kentucky HBPA president Rick Hiles told the Louisville Courier-Journal the action by the interim joint committee could spell trouble for the proposed Salix ban.

“I don’t think they’re going to get it to go anywhere,” Hiles told the Courier-Journal. “If we got this stopped today, the (Salix) ban is probably dead.”

After the KHRC passed the Salix regulations earlier this year, Hiles and Kentucky HBPA executive director Marty Maline told The Blood-Horse horsemen would go to the legislature to make their case.

The KEDRC in August 2011 voted 5-2 to pass the adjunct bleeder drug ban and the reduction in the amount of phenylbutazone that can be administered, and 6-1 to pass the regulatory administration of furosemide. The KHRC then approved the regulations.

Furosemide, also called Salix or Lasix, is an anti-bleeding drug administered no less than four hours before a race in Kentucky. Horsemen’s groups have been vocal in their opposition to any rules to ban Salix, but few have resisted efforts to ban adjunct bleeder medications such as Amicar, Tranex, Estrone, and Kentucky Red within 24 hours of a race.

There also has been little opposition nationally to regulatory administration of Salix.

Phenylbutazone, also called Bute, is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug. The regulations lower the permitted dose from five micrograms per milliliter of plasma of serum to two micrograms.

Thayer said he urged the KHRC to move forward, and encouraged Democratic Gov. Steve Beshear to override the vote by the interim joint committee. He said Beshear “has a chance unilaterally to implement the regulation” Sept. 6.

LEXINGTON, Ky. – Regulations set to take effect in Kentucky on Sept. 6 that would have banned all raceday medications other than furosemide and lowered the threshold level for the allowable amount of the painkiller phenylbutazone in postrace tests were struck down on Tuesday by a state legislative committee.

The committee voted 19-1 to find the regulations “deficient” after representatives of the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association took issue with the new requirements in testimony in front of the committee. With the vote, the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission will be unable to enforce the regulations without action by Gov. Steve Beshear to overrule the committee’s action.

“We will have some conversations with the horse racing commission and others before deciding how we will move forward,” Gov. Beshear said in an e-mailed response forwarded by his communications staff. Kerri Richardson, Beshear’s communications director, said that it was not clear whether Beshear would decide on a course of action before Sept. 6, when the regulations were set to go into effect.

The regulations, passed last year by the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission over the objections of the state’s Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association, would have banned the raceday use of so-called “adjunct bleeder medications” – carbazochrome, transexamic acid, and aminocaproic acid. The regulations would also lower the threshold level for phenylbutazone, commonly called Bute, to 2 micrograms from 5 micrograms and restrict raceday administrations of furosemide, the anti-bleeding medication commonly known as Lasix, to state veterinarians.

All three provisions have been endorsed by the Racing Medication and Testing Consortium, an organization that includes the National Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association on its board, and many major racing states have adopted the rules over the past 12 months as part of a larger effort to address public-perception concerns about the sport’s medication policies.

Damon Thayer, a state senator who is a member of the Kentucky Racing Commission’s Equine Drug Research Council, an advisory group on medication policy, called the opposition by the Kentucky horsemen’s group an “ambush.” He accused the organization of lobbying against the rules because of its frustration over a regulation passed this year phasing out the raceday use of furosemide in 2-year-old stakes races beginning in 2014.

The rule phasing out furosemide has not yet been submitted to the legislature for approval, but horsemen have vowed to fight it as it winds its way through the legislative approval process. Horsemen contend that furosemide is effective in mitigating bleeding from the lungs.

“This was not about yesterday’s regulations,” said Thayer, who was the only legislator to vote for the regulations on Monday. “This was about muddying the waters on the new Lasix phase-out, which is next in the hopper.”

Marty Maline, the executive director of the Kentucky horsemen’s association, said horsemen objected to the three new rules on their merits. He did not, however, deny that the opposition had a political component, claiming that the commission went back on a promise to protect raceday furosemide use when it passed the phase-out earlier this year.

“Right as these regulations started going forward this year, they dropped the Lasix bomb on us,” Maline said. “When they didn’t keep their promise, all bets were off, and it allowed us to re-emphasize our concerns to these issues.”

According to Maline, horsemen objected to the rule restricting the administration of raceday furosemide to state veterinarians because it would have created problems with the “trainer responsibility rule,” which holds the trainer accountable for any postrace positives regardless of circumstances. Supporters of the restriction have said that it protects bettors by restricting raceday access to state vets.

Maline said the horsemen objected to the rule lowering the threshold level for phenylbutazone because the existing threshold level is adequate in enforcing a 24-hour ban on the drug before post. Supporters of the rule have said that the new 2-microgram threshold level ensures that the horse is not feeling any effects of the drug when being checked for soundness during prerace veterinary exams.

As for the rule prohibiting adjunct bleeder medications, Maline said horsemen believed the drugs were effective in combating bleeding. Supporters of a ban have said that there is no scientific proof to support the drugs’ efficacy. Adjuncts were previously legal in only a few states, and most have banned them over the past several years.

The conflict over raceday medications – specifically furosemide – has pitted horsemen’s groups against prominent owner-breeder organizations such as the Jockey Club and Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders Association, which released a joint statement Tuesday that was critical of the Kentucky HBPA’s lobbying for the three regulations to be struck down.

“We found it disappointing that individual members of the Kentucky HBPA and racetrack veterinarians, fearful of any changes in the use of the race-day drug Lasix, are attempting to hold hostage new Kentucky racing rules designed to promote the health, welfare, and safety of the Thoroughbred racehorse,” the statement said.

Trainer Joe Cain, a mainstay on the Kentucky circuit, is battling amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), known as Lou Gehrig’s Disease. For years, Cain has operated out of his farm in the faraway town of Russell Springs in the south-central part of Kentucky, driving tens of thousands of miles each year to run his horses at Ellis Park, Turfway Park, and other tracks. Before the races on opening day, July 4, about 50 friends and colleagues hosted Cain in the Ellis track kitchen, giving him a warm reception and a plaque honoring his tenure in racing. Cain also was honored with a blanket presentation following the second race of the meet.

“It was all pretty touching,” said owner Mike Bruder, who organized the events as director of the local Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective chapter. Some $2,000 was raised on Cain’s behalf.

ALS is an incurable, degenerative, fatal disease that affects the nerve and spinal cord. Cain, 55, is not yet wheelchair-bound and is trying to keep the stable going in tandem with his wife, Peggy, but clearly his life is becoming more difficult with each passing day.

Cain began his training career in 1991 and has won nearly 500 races for stable earnings of $6.7 million. His best horse was the sprinter Private Horde, a five-length winner of the Grade 2 Vanderbilt at Saratoga in 2003.

Donations to help offset Cain’s medical expenses can be sent to Vanderbilt University Medical Center; Attention: Peter Donofrio, M.D.; Dept. of Neurology, VUMC; A0118MCN; Nashville, Tenn., 37232.

The KHBPA will be holding Board Member Nominating Meetings at the following locations:

Ellis Park- Saturday, August 11th at 10:00 a.m. at the picnic grove on the backside.

Thoroughbred Training Center- Monday, August 13th at 10:30 a.m. next to the HBPA office.

Keeneland- Monday, August 13th at 12:30 in the recreation hall next to the kitchen.

Churchill Downs- Tuesday, August 14th at 10:30 a.m. in the recreation hall. River Downs – Wednesday, August 15th at 10:30 in the track kitchen.

All horsemen are welcome and encouraged to attend.

The second meeting of the Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee was held on Friday 13, 2012.

Bob Jackson, Director of Operations; Dan Bork, Director of Racing; and Jason Greene, Chief Financial Officer attended representing Ellis Park management.

Mike Bruder, Chairman; Robert Williams and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee.

PADDING FOR RAIL-Bob Jackson explained that they have located padding and they will replace areas in poor repair. Mike Bruder reminded that the focus should be on the various gaps to protect horses from the sharp edges.

PURSE ACCOUNT STATUS-Jason Greene explained that it appears that the underpayment, including the purses money received from Kentucky Downs, totals $867,816. However, he commented that there is a substantial overpayment from prior years. Marty Maline explained that the KHBPA accountant would review the figures once they are made available.

STRIPING THE HORSEMEN’S PARKING LOT-Mike suggested getting an estimate on patching, sealing and striping the horsemen’s parking lot.

BETTING MACHINE IN THE KITCHEN-Bob Jackson explained that the problem is due to static in the cable, correcting the problem will require significant time and money. Mike Bruder suggested alternative measures which can be performed. Bob Jackson agreed to contact the repairmen to suggest alternatives.

OWNER’S CONCERNS-Marty Maline explained that he received a call from an owner who expressed concern with the Ellis Park receiving barn. He indicated that the stall door fell off its hinges and injured his horse. Bob Jackson said that he has investigated and received a different version regarding what actually has taken place.

WEATHER PROTOCOL-Marty informed the committee that he recently talked with another horse owner regarding the decisions that were made prior to the running of the seventh race on opening day. There was a storm in the vicinity, yet horses were called to the paddock and after a lengthy delay horses were sent out on the track and immediately returned to the paddock. Dan Bork stated that he will talk with the stewards and other officials to determine the protocol followed when extreme weather is in the area.

LABTOPS, SCHOLARSHIPS, AND $1.00 SUNDAYS-Mike requested an update on the status of the various days. Bob Jackson, informed him that everything is in place, however we have not received a schedule of the dates of the events.

Respectfully submitted, Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

By, Gregory Hall

11 FRANKFORT, KY. — Kentucky’s effort to lead the nation in restricting the use of furosemide in select stakes races may be in line for a legislative setback, a co-chairman of a legislative committee that reviews state agencies’ new rules said Tuesday.

“I think it very well could be in trouble,” said Rep. Johnny Bell, D-Glasgow, who made the statement after the Administrative Regulation Review Subcommittee approved another medication rule despite objections from a horsemen’s group that supports the use of furosemide.

The rule approved by legislators Tuesday would eliminate the use of so-called adjunct anti-bleeding medications that can be given in addition to furosemide, more commonly known by a brand name, Lasix. That rule change also called for a commission veterinarian to give the race-day anti-bleeding medication rather than private practitioners.

But the larger issue ahead is a fight over the commission’s approval last month of another rule eliminating race-day furosemide altogether in selected stakes. The racing commission voted 7-5 to make Kentucky be the first state in the country to restrict the use of furosemide on race day in the state’s 85 races each year that are considered graded stakes or “listed” stakes races.

Rick Hiles, president of the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association that represents owners and trainers, acknowledged to legislators that he originally went along with the rule banning adjuncts. But he said his initial support was predicated on a promise that there wouldn’t be an effort to ban furosemide altogether, a promise he said has been violated. Racing commission officials disputed that any such promise was made.

The argument Tuesday was the opening round in the Kentucky legislature for a nationwide debate about medication policy. The question of whether U.S. and Canadian racing should join most of the rest of the world in banning the drug on race day is the most heated debate in the industry. The drug has been shown to reduce bleeding in the lungs and other pulmonary organs when horses race.

But supporters say the generic drug, furosemide, is a performance enhancer and is overused with horses who haven’t had problems with bleeding. Additionally, supporters, including Gov. Steve Beshear, argue bettors need assurance that horses aren’t getting improper help from drugs. Opponents like the Kentucky HBPA argue the medication is therapeutic, in the best interests of racehorses’ health and is disclosed to bettors. They also say Kentucky risks losing horses to other states that allow the drug. Churchill Downs officials have said they are troubled by the possibility that Kentucky would finalize the rule, without any other state following suit. That would put Kentucky tracks at a disadvantage in luring horses for its stakes races, beyond the disadvantage already faced in keeping horses from being transferred to states that boost purses with casino revenues, Churchill officials say.

The restriction would be phased in over three years, beginning in 2014, if it clears legislative review and any court challenges. If found deficient by a legislative committee, the racing commission could either try again with a new regulation or Beshear could override the deficiency, which would put the rule in place at least until the legislature meets next year.

Officer attended representing Ellis Park management.

Mike Bruder, Chairman; Robert Williams and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA

Horsemen’s Committee.

MANURE BIN-Bob Jackson reported that the manure bin near barn 13 has been repaired.

HOUSE JOCKEY-Dan Bork explained that he will locate a suitable jockey to serve in this position. In the event a jockey is needed due to the original jockey scheduled to ride cancels and no replacement is available.

RECEIVING BARN-An inquiry was made about the possibility of moving the receiving barn to a more central location. Bob Jackson explained that the barn suggested has several horses stabled there.

PURSE ACCOUNT STATUS-Jason explained that he will have up to date figures on both the purse account and other accounts of interest to the horsemen’s committee on a weekly basis.

INSTANT RACING UPDATE-Bob Jackson explained that he is confident that the Instant Racing machines will be in place and operating before the race meeting is completed. Mike Bruder stressed the importance of having the Instant Racing operating as early as possible.

SAND ON THE RACETRACK-Bobby Williams explained that sand is needed on the racetrack. Bob explained that access to river sand is not available during planting season and can only be obtained once crops have been harvested.

STRIPING THE HORSEMEN’S PARKING LOT-Bobby Williams also mentioned that striping the parking lot will avert the congestion in the horsemen’s parking lot on opening day.

LABTOPS, SCHOLARSHIPS, AND $1.00 SUNDAYS-Mike Bruder suggested Ellis Park and KHBPA join forces and provide funding for the events. Bob explained that he will discuss the possibility with Ron Geary.

PREPARATION FOR HEAT-Bob Jackson explained that he felt confident that the necessary precautions are in place to protect horses from the extreme temperatures. The Kentucky Horse Racing Commission has provided four veterinarians that will be vigilant while monitoring the condition of the horses. The horse ambulance is loaded with ice. There are four separate water stations, strategically located along the racetrack. All horses will be required to return in the same direction. This will allow the veterinarians to observe each horse after he pulls up after the race, and provides each horse ready access to the water and ice positioned along the racetrack. No horse will be penalized in the event the owner and trainer decide not to run.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline Executive Director KHBPA

***Trainer Petition is listed below****

I am an owner of Thoroughbred race horses. I am concerned for the health and welfare of the horses that I own. Based on all the available scientific research, I, the undersigned, support the continued use of furosemide (Salix/Lasix) as a race day medication to inhibit Exercise Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage (bleeding) in race horses.

OWNER NAME (Please Print) SIGNATURE
KHRC LIC. NO.

DATE: ____________________

Please complete and return via:

FAX: 502-367-6800

Or

MAIL TO:

Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association
3729 S. 4th Street
Louisville, KY 40214

Questions? Please call the KHBPA at (502) 363-1077

Based upon my personal experience as a professional horseman and Thoroughbred trainer, my personal responsibility and concern for the welfare of the horses in my care, and upon veterinary advice and all available scientific research, I, the undersigned, support the continued use of furosemide (Salix/Lasix) both as a training aid and as a race-day medication to inhibit Exercise Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage (bleeding) in race horses.

TRAINER NAME (Please Print) SIGNATURE KHRC LIC. NO.

DATE: ____________________

Please complete and return via:
FAX: 502-367-6800

Or

MAIL TO:
Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association
3729 S. 4th Street
Louisville, KY 40214

Questions? Please call the KHBPA at (502) 363-1077

The proposal includes the following points:

• Jan. 1, 2013. No furosemide on race day allowed in graded or listed stakes for foals of 2011 or to any other horse of any age that is entered to compete in a graded or listed stakes race against a horse of the 2011 foal crop.

• Jan. 1, 2014. No furosemide on race day allowed in graded or listed stakes for foals of 2011 and 2012 or to any other horse of any age that is entered to compete in a graded or listed stakes race against a horse of the 2011 or 2012 foal crops.

• Jan. 1, 2015. No furosemide on race day allowed in graded or listed stakes for horses of any age.

• The prohibition shall not apply to any other type of race, including non-graded stakes, non-listed stakes, claiming and allowance races.

All interested parties are invited to attend and contribute to the discussion.

Date: June 5, 2012
Location: Capitol Annex, Room 169, Frankfort, Ky.
Time: 1-4 p.m. EDT

By Drs. Thomas Tobin and Kimberly Brewer

The story of Lasix is a classic American horsemen’s story. For many years, American horsemen withheld water prior to racing, believing that horses raced better when water was withdrawn. Then, when furosemide became available in the late 1960s, horsemen found that they could accentuate the water withholding effect by administering Lasix. Among the benefits was a reduced incidence of “bleeders,” technically epistaxis, acute bleeding from the nose during or post-race.

Bleeders have been known for 300 years or more; classically, about one percent of horses bleed from the nose during or post-race. Bleeding is associated with poor performance and, very occasionally, with death of the horse. Based on the perceived efficacy of Lasix in reducing the numbers of bleeders, Lasix was approved for use throughout the United States starting in the early 1970s.

In the 1970s, the flexible fiber-optic endoscope became available, and post-race inspection of the windpipes (tracheas) of racing horses commenced. What was found was that virtually all Thoroughbreds show blood in the trachea post-race. The amounts vary, from barely detectable to very substantial, including amounts associated with bleeding out the nostrils, or epistaxis. Additionally, bronchial wash techniques made clear that all Thoroughbred horses bleed into their lungs during racing; the only variable is the amount of bleeding. The condition also acquired a new and more scientific name, Exercise-Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage (EIPH).

It also became apparent that pulmonary damage due to EIPH is cumulative, so as horses age, their incidence of bleeding increases. Steeplechase horses, which tend to be older and to have the added stress of heavier jockeys and jumps, show the highest rates of epistaxis. Postmortem studies on horses retired due to EIPH show that the lung lesions are located at the top of the lungs, below the backbone (technically, the dorsocaudal lobes), a highly specific and unusual location. Related work showed that pulmonary blood pressures in racing horses are unusually high, leading to the theory that blood pressure driven stress failure (rupture) of pulmonary capillaries vessels was the cause of EIPH.

In 1995, New York became one of the last American states to approve the use of Lasix. Furthermore, the New York authorities kept records on the incidence of epistaxis in horses racing in New York, both before and after the introduction of Lasix. These data were reported by Bill Heller in his book “Run Baby Run,” published in 2002. These data show that for several years prior to the introduction of Lasix in New York in September of 1995, the rate of epistaxis, or EIPH, was just about five incidents per month. However, as soon as Lasix was introduced, in September of 1995, the number of epistaxis cases dropped to about one per month – an almost 80 percent reduction – and remained at this much lower rate for the following five years. These are extremely compelling data and fully support the claims that American horsemen had been making since the late 1960s (and which one of us (Tom Tobin), had presented before Congress in 1983) concerning the efficacy of furosemide in the prevention of EIPH.

The Jockey Club, however, remained unconvinced, and in or about 2008 commissioned a study supported by the Racing Medication and Testing Consortium (RMTC), the Grayson Jockey Club Research Foundation, and The Jockey Club of Southern Africa. In a very carefully designed and executed study, an international team of veterinary scientists headed by Dr. Ken Hinchcliff conclusively demonstrated that furosemide significantly reduced the incidence of high-score EIPH, very similar to the results observed in New York ten-plus years previously. This Jockey Club-supported study was published in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association in 2009, at which point the efficacy of Lasix in the prevention of EIPH was unequivocally established scientifically.
,br/> The next question one might ask is how Lasix acts to reduce the incidence of EIPH. Approaching 20 years ago, the human pulmonary physiologist West and his coworkers proposed that EIPH was associated with pulmonary capillary rupture caused by the unusually high blood pressures observed in the pulmonary systems of racing horses, the “capillary/stress failure” theory of EIPH. More recently, however, Schroeter, a basic scientist by training, has proposed that EIPH is caused by stride-associated shock waves being transmitted up the forelimbs. These shock waves enter the lungs, continue “north” through the lung tissue, and are reflected back into the lung at the upper surface of the lungs, where they act to rupture the delicate alveolar/capillary tissues. This shock wave hypothesis provides an immediate explanation for the unusual location of the EIPH lesions, at the reflection point at the top of the lung, where the shock waves travelling “north” are reflected back into the lung tissue.

Consistent with this shockwave theory, EIPH is not observed in swimming horses, supporting suggestions that EIPH is caused not by exercise, but by strides. Even more interestingly, in treadmill horses that favor a particular lead, evidence of EIPH as assessed by bronchial wash techniques is found only on the lead limb side. Apparently, the lead limb is the limb through which the most substantial stride-related shock waves are transmitted, and as such the hemorrhage occurs predominantly in the lung on that side. In passing, we also respectfully note that these observations suggest that the term Exercise-Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage may be a misnomer, and that the condition might more correctly be called “stride” induced pulmonary hemorrhage.

One argument presented by those wishing to eliminate Lasix is that its use “weakens the breed.” There is little scientific literature to support this theory and much to refute it. First, horses have bled as far back as the days of Eclipse, who bled so severely at times that he collapsed. Because the genes of Eclipse are prevalent in the lineages of most modern Thoroughbreds, if one wished to breed from “bleeding-free” pedigrees, there are very few pedigrees from which to choose. Furthermore, bleeding is not determined by genetics or heritability, but is simply a result of applied physics. Bleeding occurs due to stride-related shock waves acting on lung tissues, as demonstrated by the fact that all horses bleed. Furthermore, bleeding is related to shock waves in the lead leg, and physical factors such as racing surface, speed and distance traveled, weight carried, number of performances, hydration status, shoe type and so forth, all likely come into play in exerting shock wave stress on the horse’s lungs. Exercise Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage, therefore, is a stride driven phenomenon and not something that can be prevented purely through genetic manipulation.

With regard to the mechanism of action of furosemide, the shock wave theory of EIPH suggests that Lasix (or water deprivation) may act in part by reducing the water content of the delicate lung alveolar/capillary tissue, thereby reducing its susceptibility to shock wave damage. This possibility is particularly intriguing in view of the fact that the original approach to epistaxis was to withhold water, suggesting that American horsemen were correct all along when they withheld water prior to post and also when, more recently, they began administering furosemide to racing horses.

This mechanism action of Lasix may also help answer the question of why furosemide is effective in the prevention of EIPH four hours after administration, after the drug has largely been eliminated from the horse. The answer is now obvious. While the furosemide is, as a practical matter, gone from the body of the horse by race time, the critically important change in the fluid balance of the horse persists fully until after the race, when the horses is again allowed free access to water.

As well as reducing the susceptibility of the lung to shockwave damage, we must also consider the likelihood that what I will call a “dry,” or water-withheld, lung is a more efficient lung. In this regard, it is well established that if you put too much fluid into a horse, the ability of the lung to oxygenate the blood is reduced, most likely because the extra lung water increases the distance that inspired oxygen has to travel from the alveolus to the pulmonary capillary red blood cells. This is important because the horse, as a practical matter, is unable to fully oxygenate its blood at maximal exercise. As such, any factor which improves the oxygenation of blood has the potential to optimize the delivery of oxygen to the musculoskeletal system of the horse, and thus its athletic performance.

The above leads to an unexpected possible outcome with regard to the banning of furosemide in racing horses. This is because a prohibition on Lasix may make it easier to run horses “hot” and “cold,” as follows. In this procedure, a “cold” horse would be a horse from which water has not been withdrawn, or a horse to which additional fluid has been provided to reduce its pulmonary efficiency and the oxygenation capacity of the lung. Conversely, the “hot” horse would be a horse from which water has been withdrawn to the maximum amount, which horse would race as close to racing on furosemide as would be possible in the absence of furosemide administration. With virtually all horses currently running on furosemide, and furosemide use being very carefully regulated, the betting public is in a much better position to assess the pulmonary and performance capacity of the Lasix horse than a horse in the absence of Lasix, where the hydration status of the horse can be manipulated at will, and for which manipulation no test is available.

Finally, manipulation of the betting outcome is improper, but in the last analysis involves only money. There is, however, another clear-cut outcome to the banning of furosemide that involves human and equine lives. When Kentucky instituted its first routine necropsy program for racing horses, one of the early necropsy candidates was a horse that had “crashed” on the racetrack about one-quarter of a mile out of the starting gate. On necropsy, the horse was found to have two fractured vertebrate, but full necropsy established the proximate cause of death as massive pulmonary hemorrhage. This horse was a classic EIPH-related sudden death, in which a horse bleeds sufficiently heavily into its lungs to die acutely on the racetrack or soon post-race. Based on this experience, we noted that the definition of EIPH should be extended to include an incidence of sudden death on the racetrack, and these EIPH-related sudden death events place at risk the lives of both horses and jockeys.

These EIPH acute sudden deaths have been reported in Pennsylvania, Kentucky, Caracas, Arizona, New Mexico, and elsewhere. Based on data reported by our colleagues in Pennsylvania, the estimated incidence of EIPH-related acute sudden death on the racetrack is about one episode in every 1,500 races. Because pretreatment with Lasix is close to 80 percent effective in reducing the incidence of high score EIPH and epistaxis, there is no reason not to think that pretreatment with Lasix does not equivalently reduce the incidence of acute deaths associated with EIPH in racing horses. As such, the administration of furosemide serves to protect the lives of both horses and their riders/jockeys, which creates a compelling ethical circumstances for veterinarians and others associated with the protecting the health and welfare of racing horses and their riders.

In summary, American horsemen had long observed that withholding water prior to post improved the performance of racing horses and reduced the incidence of epistaxis. When injectable Lasix became available 40 or so years ago, American horsemen rapidly and correctly identified its ability to prevent EIPH. They lobbied for its approval in American racing, and its use spread throughout the entire Americas. Science now fully supports their long-held belief that Lasix prevents EIPH and allows horses to run more consistently and truer to form. Additionally, the presence of Lasix makes it more difficult to alter the performance of horses by manipulating their hydration status prior to post. More importantly, EIPH/epistaxis is associated with a small incidence of sudden death in racing horses, with an attendant risk to life and limb for horses and jockeys. Withdrawal of approval for Lasix in North American racing will, therefore, increase the risk to life and limb for horses and their jockeys, and also increases the potential for manipulation of the hydration status of horses prior to post, for which manipulation no testing procedures are currently available.

Asked three years ago about Churchill Downs’ future in Louisville without the addition of slot machines, the company’s top official predicted fewer race dates.

“We probably become more of a boutique (meet),” said Bob Evans, the chairman and chief executive officer. “Just exactly how big, I don’t know. It kind of depends on what’s happening at that time with everybody else.” Today, what’s happening is this: The Kentucky General Assembly recently refused once again to allow expanded gambling. Breeders and trainers are being lured increasingly to tracks where casino revenues boost purses — most notably in New York.

And Kentucky is considering becoming the first state to ban the race-day use of the anti-bleeding drug furosemide for certain stakes races. Those conditions worry horse owners, trainers and breeders groups, who fret that as early as next year, Churchill Downs Inc. — which, despite record Kentucky Derby Week profits, says it loses money on racing the rest of the year — will cut back on race dates at its 138-year-old Central Avenue namesake.

Shortages of horses since 2009 cut the spring meet to 38 days last year and 39 this year — the shortest meets since 1975. About half of the fields this week — the first after the Derby — drew eight or fewer horses before scratches. Bigger fields give bettors a chance for better returns on their bets.

“I wouldn’t be surprised that they don’t apply in 2013 for going back to a 30-day meet or something like that,” said David Switzer, executive director of the Kentucky Thoroughbred Association and Kentucky Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders. “The business model doesn’t show that they’re making money on racing.”

No immediate changes

Evans said in an interview before Derby Week that there are no immediate plans to significantly alter the spring meet, when the Louisville track conducts most of its racing.

But Evans attached major caveats to that promise.

For example, while he expressed confidence that there will be racing at Churchill Downs 138 years from now, Evans said, “The question becomes, how much? That depends on whether we’ve got enough fans and enough horses to conduct as much racing as we do today.”

Efforts such as night racing help shore up the fan side; he said: “I’m confident we’ll have fans.”

But horse supply is jeopardized by declines in the number of thoroughbreds and the increasing trend of entering those horses at tracks where casino revenue is boosting purses.

Churchill officials have long argued that Kentucky racing needs such revenues to compete and supported a constitutional amendment to allow casinos, which failed in this year’s General Assembly regular session. “If the horses all disappear,” Evans said, Churchill’s racing “becomes a boutique meet not by choice but by just dealing with reality.” Additionally, he said he’s concerned owners and trainers may take their horses elsewhere because of efforts to put Kentucky on a regulatory island, chiefly through a ban on race-day anti-bleeding medication injections. An effort to pass a ban died on a 7-7 Kentucky Horse Racing Commission vote earlier this month, but another attempt is expected to pass a more limited ban, for certain stakes races on a phased-in basis. “Put that all together in the stew and mix it up; we could have a pretty big problem in Kentucky for everybody, not just Churchill Downs,” Evans said.

One of the challenges is larger purses at New York’s three biggest tracks, because of slots at Aqueduct Racetrack.

The increases already have led one of Churchill’s top trainers — Dale Romans — to shift many of his horses to New York that previously would have been at Churchill, while top jockey Julien Leparoux has shifted his base after Derby Week to Belmont Park, where purses are increasing 44 percent, and then Saratoga Race Course, where purses are jumping 39 percent.

State Sen. Damon Thayer, R-Georgetown, who sponsored the casino bill that was defeated, said he believes Churchill can still be competitive nationally.

“Not all the horses can race in New York,” Thayer said. “Some of them are going to need to race other places, and Churchill Downs still has a compelling purse structure.”

Any reduction in race dates at Churchill would have to be made — under the state simulcasting law — with the approval of two horsemen’s groups. Officials indicate that the one headed by Switzer likely would be willing to reduce dates, while the other, the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association, likely would oppose it.

“We have to look at reality,” Switzer said. “And what is real versus what we would like may not be the same thing. And reality is, nationwide, we’ve got too much racing. … We’ve got to make adjustments.”

The HBPA traditionally has opposed date reductions, saying horsemen need the most opportunities possible to make money, although it went along with cuts in the past three years as Churchill had trouble filling races.

But HBPA executive director Marty Maline said his group expected those cuts to be temporary, and the group of owners and trainers likely would oppose further cuts. “It’s pretty much a boutique meet now because we’re actually running less days in the spring than Saratoga is, which is considered the most (prized) boutique meet in the country,” Maline said. “… We should be trying to figure out ways to increase days so horsemen can justify to their owners staying here.”

Is shorter better?

Maline said Churchill could explore other alternatives to improve racing, such as installing the slot-like Instant Racing game in use at Kentucky Downs.

Simply cutting dates isn’t a long-term solution, he said.

And indeed, horsemen agreed to cuts at Turfway this winter, but the Florence track still cut purses 25 percent.

To justify further cuts at Churchill, Maline said, the company will “have to make an awfully strong case. I think they know where we’re coming from. … We can’t cut any more. We’re a boutique meet now. Less is not better in this situation, because you’re going to lose more and more horses.”

Evans, meanwhile, said in the recent interview that he believes a small meet can be successful, citing Keeneland’s success with fans and horsemen. The Lexington track’s 15-day spring meet ended last month with a record cumulative attendance of 269,292 and a record average of 17,953 per day. Betting from all sources jumped nearly 14 percent to $133,483,793. Boutique meets work, in part, because they limit access both to the quantity and quality of racing, forcing fans and bettors to take advantage of it while it’s there.

Regardless of the length of the spring meet, the biggest thing going for the long-term future of racing at Churchill is Derby Week — beginning with opening night and running through the Kentucky Oaks and Derby. “It’s very important because the rest of racing as an economic event is pretty unattractive,” Evans said.

Churchill Downs Inc. doesn’t disclose how much it profits from Derby Week, although it does release year-to-year comparisons and acknowledges they’re at record levels.

Derby Week profitability — before taxes and other accounting factors are considered — is up nearly $15 million since 2008, including a $6.4 million increase last year and an estimated increase this year of between $4.5 million and $5.5 million, according to annual figures released by Churchill.

The only year-to-year decline in the run was in 2009, when the company said the larger economy contributed to softness in sponsorships, supplemental seating and corporate hospitality areas.

Banking on Derby Week

Churchill’s successes — including its record profits, Derby Week performance and stock price at its highest levels in a year — are all factors cited by casino opponents who question whether Churchill really needs the boost from casino gambling.

But casino proponents say Churchill shouldn’t be faulted for making Derby Week profitable.

“People continue to get upset that Churchill is doing everything they can to maximize the value of the Derby,” said state Rep. David Osborne, R-Prospect, who is a horse owner. “But it’s the only day of the year they get to make any money. And I think that until we … can get to a situation where racing is a profitable venture for them — normal (everyday) racing — then I think that you will continue to see those race dates compress. It only makes sense.”

Osborne said year-round racing should still be the goal for Kentucky because of the jobs that go with it, but he said he wouldn’t be surprised to see Churchill’s spring meet cut to 30 days. How much the meet is compressed also could be influenced by other tracks, Osborne said, both in Kentucky and in nearby states like Indiana.

Louisville Mayor Greg Fischer echoed that concern, bemoaning legislators’ resistance to approve expanded gambling to help the horse industry. “It’s like having a company and you have the leading product in the world, and you’re just knowingly watching it go away,” he said. “That’s not very smart.”

And fewer racing days would affect Louisville’s economy on several fronts, he said.

“When people come here, they expect there to be some action (at the track), not just for one weekend a year,” Fischer said. “So there’s that touristic element to it as well. And then of course there’s the whole supply chain of the thoroughbred industry. Many of those businesses are located here. … So we need to be expanding and growing our presence in the thoroughbred industry, not shrinking it.”

By a single vote, the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission last week failed to pass a resolution that would have banned the use of the anti-bleeding medication furosemide, commonly known as Lasix, in Kentucky racing. The 7-7 vote within the commission – a majority is required and a deadlock is a failure – surprised and frustrated proponents of the ban, who have vowed to renew their efforts in the months ahead.

In the meantime, here’s a suggestion for them: If they really believe that furosemide is bad for horses and racing, why don’t they just stop racing their horses on it? By failing to do so, the small but vocal group of owners and breeders who are crusading against the use of furosemide come off as being opportunistic at best and hypocritical at worst.

The furosemide debate in American racing has become downright bizarre. At one time, there was widespread uneasiness about the use of the diuretic because of its masking qualities. A generation ago, administering it could flush illegal substances out of a horse’s system and make them undetectable in post-race tests. Now, though, more precise testing and a greater reliance on plasma than urine has made that argument moot. Objections now focus on furosemide’s being part of a so-called “culture of drugs” that is allegedly diminishing public support for the sport.

“Perception is reality today,” said one of the Kentucky commissioners, explaining her vote for the ban. Others have argued that it doesn’t matter whether or not furosemide is a humane treatment that allows horses to race without choking on their own blood – if the public believes it has something to do with drugging up defenseless animals, it must be banned.

The problem with this approach, in addition to its inherent deceptiveness and insincerity, is that it proceeds from a highly questionable assumption – that if furosemide were banned tomorrow, people would suddenly believe racing is squeaky-clean and they would begin attending the races in greater numbers.

Perhaps some owners and breeders actually think this is true, but I have yet to meet a racetrack operator, horse trainer, or horseplayer who believes this. Banning furosemide will have no positive impact with civilians, who barely know what it is, and who will hardly be reassured or attracted to the game once it has been explained to them that racing has banned a medication that is used to keep horses from hemorrhaging during a race.

It is very tricky to crusade against a medication while simultaneously acknowledging its usefulness. The Jockey Club, which supports a ban, could not have made this clearer than it did in a presentation at its annual Round Table last August: It put up two slides, the first of which read “Lasix is good for horses,” followed by one reading “Lasix is not good for horse racing.”

I think they were trying to say that the drug has its efficacious properties but is being overused and has contributed to misperceptions about the sport. But by following up the “good for horses” declaration with a call for a ban, it seemed to be proposing that we stop doing something that is good for horses.

You can’t have it both ways. Most ban proponents continue to race all of their horses on furosemide, and over 95 percent of runners are treated with it on race day at every level of the sport, from claiming races in New Mexico to next month’s Kentucky Derby, where every entrant is expected to have an “L” for Lasix next to his name in the program. Some of those owners say they support a ban – so why not put some teeth in their position and impose one on themselves?

It just doesn’t cut it to say you want to ban a medication from racing but that you will continue to race your own horses on it until it becomes the law of the land that you may not. Every time a furosemide opponent races one of his own horses on the medication, he is tacitly approving of the drug and confirming its efficacy. Obviously furosemide is being overused when 95 percent of horses race on it and no one believes that even half that many horses have a legitimate bleeding problem. So who among the country’s most prominent owners races even less than half of his horses on furosemide?

Walking “hots” for Hall of Fame Trainer Elliott Burch back in the 70s, Ann Banks learned the right way to treat racehorses.

Nobody yelled at them; they weren’t shanked around; and never did the blare of loud music disrupt the sanctity of the stabling area.

“It was peaceful and quiet,” she recalls. “I learned to be respectful, and to speak softly to the superstar racehorses.”

Stars she knew personally, by their quirks and charms, included Horse of the Year Arts and Letters and Key to the Mint, Eclipse Award American Champion Three-Year-Old Male.

On her summers off from the University of Kentucky, where she earned degrees in horse husbandry and agricultural communications, Banks learned from the Rokeby Stables crew at Belmont Park that horses, who worked so hard for their owners, deserved to be treated well.

After she graduated, and soon after embarking on an intense career of breeding and training racehorses, Banks says she found her “mission.”

“For the next 24 years, I dove into all the racetrack stuff. And once I got onto the backside, I understood very quickly that there are different degrees of failure for horses, of not being able to do their job,” she says. “This is where it became obvious to me that if a horse couldn’t win to pay his expenses, the horse should be stopped from racing while he still has legs, and helped into a new home.”

Growing up an avid equestrian, who felt deeply privileged to work those early years for the fabled race farm, it was ingrained in her that an ex-racehorse could do many other jobs if the one at the track didn’t pan out.

“There was never an ah-ha moment,” Banks says. “It was always understood that if a horse couldn’t do this, that maybe he could be a fox hunter, or a jumper or an eventer.

“It never occurred to me that a racehorse couldn’t do something other than race.”

Her first off-track Thoroughbred English Jack, for example, became her favorite personal eventing horse after 115 starts in nine years.

“By the time I met Jack, he had been through the wars at cheap tracks at the end of his career, but he never bore a grudge,” Banks says. “His red badge of courage was a bigger than normal cannon bone on one leg, where he must have fractured it. But, the amazing thing about Jack, and about Thoroughbreds I’ve met, is that they’ve never held a grudge, no matter what circumstances they survived.”

The endurance of her own “big class horse,” who possessed the “look of eagles in his eye,” and memories of the racing greats she hot-walked as a young lady, stuck with her through myriad experiences in the horse world.

“I always felt a huge responsibility to be a good steward of the horses in my care because they have given me such joy,” she says. “I strive to help Thoroughbreds be good ambassadors of the breed—I learned early that Thoroughbreds were given a bad rap as a difficult breed— and to prove to the sporthorse community that there are responsible Thoroughbred people who take care of their horses.”

She did this in spades while working for her husband David Banks, and his racing stable, with such successful results: She estimates that over 100 ex-racehorses moved on to new careers from her farm.

By working methodically, Banks studies a new horse in her care, watching the retired racehorse move around the backyard of her house. Her keen observations inform her of the horse’s soundness, personality, and potential talent for a new job.

“The horses that are big movers and carry themselves up and round are great candidates to go eventing,” she explains. “And the ones who carry themselves long tend to make the best hunters.”

When Dancing Dynamo, a son of Three Chimneys pensioned stallion and former stud Dynaformer, arrived at her farm, there wasn’t much that characterized him, good or bad.

“In fact, he was laid back,” she says, adding, “Dynamo did not distinguish himself at the races … and he was here for a long time.”

While he grazed in a herd of retirees, she let his feet grow out, and his body fill in.

And when she decided he might make a children’s hunter prospect, she shipped him to Winner’s Circle Farm outside Nashville, where longtime partner in training, Dwight Hall, has developed some beautifully retrained racehorses.

“Dynamo came around very quickly,” she says. “Dwight takes a lot of time to evaluate a horse, too. But, it didn’t take him long to figure out that Dynamo would make a great children’s horse.”

Banks and Hall weren’t wrong. He was sold to one of Hall’s young riding students, and in no time, the pair was winning championships throughout the Tennessee region.

Among his honors, Dynamo was the 2011 Middle Tennessee Hunter/Jumper Association Reserve Champion in two divisions, pre-children’s hunter and modified junior hunter, and was the 2010 Middle Tennessee Hunter/Jumper Association Reserve Champion in modified junior hunter.

What delights Banks about Dynamo’s new career is watching the obvious affection between horse and rider, and the great precision with which the once lackluster racehorse tackles a jumps course.

He proves, as did her long-time mount English Jack, and so many horses in between, that Thoroughbreds are brilliantly sensitive creatures willing to give 110 percent toward their job, she says.

“On Long Island, where I grew up, Thoroughbreds were the breed of choice,” Banks says. “I learned early on that they deserved to be treated with respect, and that it was important to be a good steward for the horse.”

Ann Banks is on the board of the Kentucky HBPA, and was one of the first riding instructors at Kentucky’s Masterston Station Park. She also served as a stadium-jumping steward at Rolex for 10 years.

BY FRANK ANGST

KENTUCKY TO the core, trainer Dale Romans memorably expressed his distaste for Tennessee whiskey in the acclaimed documentary “The First Saturday in May.”

The Bluegrass has Romans’ heart, but at some point business is business. And for Romans that point will be the spring of 2012 as the Louisville-born trainer will stable the majority of his horses in New York, shifting away from Kentucky in favor of the New York Racing Association’s lucrative, casino gaming-enhanced purses.

“I’m going to have 40 to 60 horses in New York and all of my best horses there,” Romans said. “I will only have a few horses in Kentucky and generally they will be of lesser quality. For the first time, I’ve rented a house in New York and for the first time I’ll have a full barn at Belmont Park.”

Racing news in the past few months has been at polar opposites in New York and Kentucky.

The Resorts World Casino New York City launched in November at Aqueduct, generating considerable money for NYRA purses. In February, NYRA announced purses for Belmont Park maiden special races would be $70,000 for sprints and $75,000 for routes this spring and summer.

The 56-day Belmont meeting will offer stakes purses of $9.05-million, up 26% compared with 2011; while Saratoga Race Course’s stakes purses will be up 27% to $13.35-million. For comparison, Churchill Downs will offer just 39 scheduled race days and 24 stakes worth $7.3-million.

“The purse increases for overnight and stakes races for the upcoming Belmont Park and Saratoga meets confirm NYRA’s leadership position in Thoroughbred racing,” said NYRA Director of Racing P.J. Campo. “The enhanced purses should result in larger field sizes, stimulate additional wagering activity, and increase profitability for NYRA.”

Meanwhile, Kentucky continues to compete for fans and horses against casinos and racinos that virtually surround the state. In Indiana, riverboat casinos have poached fans and soon-to-open Ohio casinos will do more of the same. Meanwhile, racinos in Indiana, West Virginia, and Pennsylvania have pulled race horses out of the state.

The Kentucky racing industry received its latest legislative setback in February when the state Senate voted against a constitutional amendment that would have allowed Kentuckians to vote to allow added gaming at state tracks. While Kentucky already has been impacted, particularly Turfway Park, Ellis Park, and Churchill Downs after Kentucky Derby (G1) and Kentucky Oaks (G1) weekend, Romans expects an especially negative impact this year, even at the state’s top levels of racing.

“I think Keeneland will be the most impacted,” Romans said. “For the purses being offered in New York, it almost becomes a hassle to set aside a couple of weeks to race at Keeneland. You’ll see quite a few horses shipped from Florida straight to New York.

“New York is going to have a huge impact on Kentucky. Churchill is down to 39 days of racing in the spring and that will be tough.”

Fresh faces

New York Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Association President Rick Violette Jr. expects to see plenty of new faces in New York this year as owners see the opportunities.

“We all know it’s difficult to break even in this game but these purses give owners a fighting chance,” Violette said. “Most owners realize they’re going to lose a percentage of their money but these purses make their love of racing a little easier to justify economically.” Violette said the Aqueduct casino has provided more amenities for fans—better food and service and noted that facility improvements including a new sports bar are planned. He credited NYRA with keeping the emphasis on racing as new money for the racing association and purses has flooded the sport in Empire State.

“They’re doing a lot of things with the simulcast show,” Violette said. “They’re all over social media. Other tracks have come under casino ownership and maybe racing takes a backseat but NYRA is keeping the emphasis on racing. With those efforts, the handle has been way up at Aqueduct.”

Through February, total all-sources wagering at the Aqueduct meeting was up 47.7% to $133,693,761 compared to the same meeting in 2010-2011. Increased race days account for some of that improvement but average daily all-sources handle also is up 19.6% to $6,366,370.

Meanwhile, Romans thinks Kentucky will face additional cuts in racing dates. One hope for some relief in the state is Instant Racing, although the major tracks are allowing litigation to conclude regarding the machines that look like slot machines but pay off in a pari-mutuel manner. “Kentucky has David Williams to blame for this,” Romans said, referencing the Republican state senate president who led opposition to allowing the statewide vote on expanded gambling.

The purses in New York figure to be a game-changer, impacting Kentucky as well as tracks throughout the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic region. Besides attracting top horses, regional tracks already may be feeling the impact in claiming races, even tracks that already boost purses with money from added gaming.

At Laurel Park in Maryland, which subsidizes purses with money from off-track casinos, claims per race day are up 84.9%, compared to the same meet last year, to 3.07 each day. Some of that activity may be attributed to increased interest in Maryland, where purses are expected to be up about 10% at the current meet.

Increased purses from added gaming is more established in Pennsylvania and the increased claiming activity at Parx Racing may be more telling for NYRA. Claims per day this year at Parx are up 57% to 5.72.

In New York, the claiming game has picked up significantly as horsemen attempt to structure their stables to take full advantage of the inflated purses. In 55 days of racing this year, claiming activity was up 160.6%, compared with the January 1-April 13, 2011 Aqueduct race dates, to 6.62 a day.

Romans expects plenty of claiming activity at the Keeneland meeting. “You’ll see them taking horses out of that meet,” Romans said. “They’ll be claimed, taken to New York, and Kentucky won’t see them again.”

Frank Angst is senior writer for THOROUGHBRED TIMES.

The Jockey Club today released an updated version of the Reformed Racing Medication Rules that features a new categorization of medications, more clearly defined regulatory limits and dramatically remodeled penalties. The organization is encouraging all Thoroughbred racing jurisdictions to implement them in order to improve the integrity of the sport and enhance the safety of its athletes.

The Reformed Racing Medication Rules were introduced at The Jockey Club’s Round Table Conference on Matters Pertaining to Racing in August 2011 after consultation and collaboration with representatives of the Racing Medication & Testing Consortium, the Association of Racing Commissioners International and the International Federations of Horseracing Authorities.

“We have been refining this document since then and the result is a dramatically streamlined set of regulations that is on par with international standards,” said James L. Gagliano, president and chief operating officer of The Jockey Club. “It creates a new enforcement scheme with far stiffer penalties and deterrents for repeat offenders. We look forward to continuing our collaboration with industry organizations and national, state and local regulatory agencies to see these rules adopted.”

The new rules feature a cumulative penalty system featuring stronger penalties for repeat violations. Fines, disqualifications and even lifetime suspensions would be possible for those persistently operating outside regulatory limits.

Among the main tenets of the Reformed Racing Medication Rules:
• Horses should be allowed to compete only when free from the influences of medication
• Medications permitted in the race horse are subjected to stricter regulatory thresholds with increased recommended withdrawal times.
• Furosemide is currently prohibited although this may be effected through a transitional process
• Only RMTC-accredited laboratories are permitted to test samples, with results available to the public
• Medication violations result in points that accumulate to trigger stronger sanctions for repeat violations; up to lifetime suspensions
• Medication histories for all horses available for review
• Contact with a horse within 24 hours of post time of the race shall be subject to surveillance; certain regulations and track ship-in policies may be subject to adjustment
• Reciprocal enforcement of uniform mandatory rest periods among racing regulatory authorities for horses with symptoms of exercise induced pulmonary hemorrhage
• Expansion of regulatory authority to include all jurisdictions where official “workouts” are conducted
• Administration and withdrawal guidelines are published for all approved therapeutic medication subject to regulatory control
• Best practices for improved security and monitoring of “in today” horses are provided for guidance to racing associations
“As we have said many times before, The Jockey Club believes that the overuse of medication endangers our human and equine athletes, threatens the integrity of our sport and erodes consumer confidence in our game,” Gagliano said. “Horses should compete only when they are free from the influence of medication, and these reformed rules represent a giant step toward achieving that goal.”

Craig Fravel, president and chief executive officer of Breeders’ Cup Limited, said, “Safety and integrity are values that are paramount to the viability of Thoroughbred racing. We must dedicate our efforts to adopting uniform national rules that ensure a level playing field and that ensure those who do not wish to abide by those rules can no longer compete against those who do.”

Dan Metzger, the president of the Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders Association, said, “The Reformed Racing Medication Rules provide a reasonable and common sense approach to achieve uniformity and impose severe penalties on those who repeatedly violate rules. Adoption of these revised rules will provide our industry with necessary, responsible and positive reform.”

The Jockey Club, founded in 1894 and dedicated to the improvement of Thoroughbred breeding and racing, is the breed registry for North American Thoroughbreds. In fulfillment of its mission, The Jockey Club provides support and leadership on a wide range of important industry initiatives and it serves the information and technology needs of owners, breeders, media, fans and farms, among others. Additional information is available at jockeyclub.com.

A meeting of the Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee was held on Wednesday, March 28, 2012.

Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Cliff Reed, Chief Financial Officer; Rick Leigh, Director of Racing; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Wayne Mogge, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen at Turfway Park.

DRAIN ADJACENT TO THE HORSEPATH-This has been an ongoing issue that needs attention. There is a drain in poor repair next to the horsepath. A large crevice had developed which could prove dangerous if a horse steps into the hole as they enter and exit the track near the quarter pole.

HELMETS FOR STARTING GATE CREW-Apparently, at Churchill Downs there has been discussion that assistant starters may soon be required to wear helmets while performing their duties. Will Turfway Park also require assistant starters to wear headgear? Chip said he will check to see if that is a new requirement by the NTRA safety alliance or the Racing Commission. It was suggested that the idea should be discussed with the starters and the assistant starters to determine the advantages and possible disadvantages.

PURSE STATUS-Cliff estimated that at the end of the race meeting the overpayment should be in the range of $200,000 to $300,000 which is manageable. In fact, he suggested that, most likely, the purses will be reinstated to the level prior to the 25% purse cut for the 2012 Fall race meeting. Bill and Wayne suggested that this word needs to be circulated since many horsemen are contemplating other arrangements due to the severe purse decrease. By increasing the purses, horsemen exploring alternatives may decide to return to Turfway Park.

There is some confusion, since it had been previously reported, just a week ago, that the overpayment was at $800,000 a few days prior to Spiral stakes day, which negatively impacts the purse account approximately $500,000. Therefore, it was estimated based on the figures supplied by Turfway Park to the horsemen that the overpayment would be in excess of $1,000,000.

Cliff explained that the discrepancy involved the fact that simulcasting revenue from Ellis Park, Kentucky Downs, and “source market fees” from ADW was not factored into the number given to the horsemen. He expects to rectify the problem with a new system that will provide the additional information to horsemen.

FUTURE OF TURFWAY PARK-Cliff was quick to dispel rumors that Turfway Park will not reopen after the 2012 Winter/Spring race meeting. In fact, as he reported earlier, he fully expects that the purses will be increased to the level prior to the 25% decrease for the 2012 Fall race meeting. He stated that the contract is up with horsemen at the end of the 2012 Winter/Spring race meeting and many issues will need to be discussed and resolved.

SUMMER STABLING-A discussion ensued regarding the amount provided by Cliff that Turfway Park would need in order to make summer stabling work. Based on the number, it would average approximately $5,276.00 per day to keep the barn area open. Yet, Ellis Park estimates it costs less than $2,000 to keep their barn area open, Churchill Downs trackside training center estimates it costs $3,125 to keep their barn area with approximately 600 horse capacity. Palm Meadows in Florida, which everyone agreed is “state of the art” with a 1,400 horse capacity cost approximately $6,000. Cliff explained that he had figured into the estimate approximately an 8% profit and also a cost of wear and tear on the track surface. Chip explained that next year when there is more time to explore the possibilities perhaps something can be worked out. Later, after the meeting, Chip stated that he had forgotten to inform the committee that major road construction will be undertaken this summer that will, most likely, close sections of Turfway road for extended periods of time. He is not sure there will be access available to the barn area.

TRACK MAINTENANCE-Jeff explained that he plans to do some renovation to the track surface in an effort to reclaim some of the wax that may have filtered to the track base.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

It has come to the attention of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission (the “KHRC”) that Previcox tablets, (containing the active ingredient firocoxib and carrying label approval for use in canines), are being administered in lieu of Equioxx paste or injectable (also containing firocoxib, but carrying label approval for use in the equine).

Please be aware that the KHRC does not endorse the administration of any medication to a horse that is intended for, and dosed for, any other breed of animal, when a corresponding product exists that is approved for equine use. It is difficult, if not impossible, to accurately dose a horse with firocoxib using the canine‐labeled product, and any owner, trainer or veterinarian doing so runs a significant risk of administering that substance in violation of 810 KAR 1:018, 811 KAR 1:090 and 811 KAR 2:096. This substance should only be administered per the instructions and dosage on the packaging materials, and in a manner consistent with the requirements of 810 KAR 1:018, 811 KAR 1:090 and 811 KAR 2:096.

If you have questions or concerns, don’t hesitate to contact Dr. Mary Scollay.

Robert M. Beck, Jr. Chairman

Editor’s note: Tommy Drury Jr., 40, has had a trainer’s license since he was 18. He had Hansen at Skylight Training Center in Goshen, where he trains year-round, before the colt was sent to Mike Maker. Among the places Drury races regularly is Turfway Park, which on Thursday announced a 25-percent purse cut.

My mother always told me I would be better off if I just kept my head down and my mouth shut. My dad used to joke that you should never discuss politics publicly. Obviously, as of late, I have struggled with both of these worthy pieces of advice.

In all honesty, I usually don’t discuss politics publicly, but it’s not really from me taking dads advice. It’s more because I honestly don’t always feel I can offer an educated opinion on a lot of subjects. I personally don’t have a clue as to the best way to lower gas prices, offer free health insurance to the world, or how to keep David Williams from losing another $36,000 at the casino boats. I am a horse trainer, with nothing more to offer the world outside of horse racing, than a high school GED. Horse racing is all I know, all I have ever wanted to do, and all I have ever done my entire life. After all, I am from Kentucky….

Having said that, because of my individual background, I do feel I can offer somewhat of an educated opinion on the recent joke that took place within our state senate over expanded gambling in Ky. I honestly feel that some of our senators know as much about horse racing, and the potential effects of expanded gambling as I do about why the people of Louisville would continue to vote for someone like Julie Denton to make decisions for them. Obviously, she thinks we are all a bunch of addicts who can’t go to a casino without gambling our life savings away.

For the first time in my life, I went online, and actually watched live, as our senators debated both sides of this argument, and I simply couldn’t believe some of the things I heard. They argued that the racetracks shouldn’t have such a stronghold over the state, they argued religious beliefs, they argued gambling addiction. And of course the best: The No. 1 argument made – are you ready for this???? – a guy actually stood up, and said he simply had to vote “no” because his dead grandfather, who was a baptist minister, would have never approved of such a thing.. Well I think my dead grandfather who spent his entire life in the Kentucky horse industry, would have looked at this a little differently.

I think my grandfather would have reminded our senators that if they took a trip to Timbukto, and told people they were from Kentucky, they would more than likely know the Kentucky Derby (Or as I recently found out personally in St Lucia, “horses!!” “horses!!”) as that is what this state is known for world wide. I think he would remind our senators that because of the $4 billion economic impact of horses, and horse racing, in the state of Kentucky, a lot of people not directly tied to horse racing would still be greatly affected by this decision. I think he would remind them that the people of Kentucky are not 3 year olds who need our hands held, to be told where we should, and shouldn’t go, and treated like we aren’t capable of using good judgment when faced with a decision to vote on… And I think lastly, he would have reminded them that they have an obligation to do what’s best for the people of this state, regardless of their own political agenda, religious belief, or what their particular party leader is telling them they should do…

Kentucky has over 128,000 people tied to the equine industry, who rely on its success to feed our families, and we deserve a fair chance to continue to make a living, doing the only thing some of us know how to do.. And that’s all we have ever asked for.. For trainers like Todd Pletcher and Steve Asmussen, who already have multiple strings of horses, in different areas of the country, this is nothing more than a relocation decision for them to make.. They will simply send their horses, and staff, to another state and enjoy the benefits of the 40% increase in purses, that some states now offer. Some of the bigger breeding farms such as WinStar and Vinery already have some of their stallions and mares relocated to other states to take advantage of the incentives offered by certain state bred programs.. Jockeys like Julien Leparoux will simply pack their tack and go where the money is, which looks to be New York in his particular case.. Churchill Downs Inc, will continue to invest their money in other tracks in other states that have casino gambling, such as their recent purchase of Lebanon Raceway in Ohio and they will survive this.. And while all of this takes place, the small guys trying to make a living in Kentucky by racing here year around will continue to go out of business.

This is not about the top 20 percent of the people from Kentucky who are involved in racing, or Kentucky’s two major tracks. This is about the other 80 percent of the people involved in racing, and the three smaller tracks. This is about the little guys who have always been the backbone of this industry. Trainers like Chris Bindner, who has grown up in Kentucky racing, had a few horses in training and just recently gave up and got out of the business. Or trainers like Ralph Nicks, who has been a Kentucky fixture for over 20 years, who recently sold his house here and is attempting to relocate to simply save his business. Breeders like Dick Storey, whose hobby is to take care of his Louisville farm, and his two broodmares. One of which is now living in Pennsylvania. Owners like David Richardson – who comes to the barn every Saturday morning, just for the enjoyment he gets from watching his horses train – who now has horses racing in Louisiana.

There is a very good chance that our senators may have just put the last nail in the coffin for not only the smaller people in the horse industry, but places like Turfway Park Kentucky Downs and Ellis Park, as well… These smaller tracks will not overcome this obstacle that has been placed in front of them, and will eventually go under, placing hundreds of their employees next to Richie Farmer in the Kentucky unemployment line. Because of this, I have one final thought. Well… it’s actually not a final thought… It’s more of something that’s becoming a reality, and is causing me to lay awake at night staring at the ceiling…

Turfway goes under, and doesn’t run next winter, or if they do attempt to run, the purses are so bad you can’t justify going, or in some cases, can’t get your owners to agree to race there… Beulah Park increases purses, and gets moved to Youngstown, Ohio, as they have said they are going to do now that they have expanded gambling in Ohio.. This means that there is no live racing, during the winter months, within six hours of the state of Kentucky.. So where exactly are all the little guys who normally live and race in Kentucky year around supposed to go??? What about guys like Billy Denzik, and Tommy Drury, who have lived in Kentucky all their life, and race here year around??? What about guys like Jason Cook, and Tom Shartle, that make their living hauling horses to these smaller tracks on a daily basis??? How about the Kentucky training centers that have invested millions of dollars in racetracks and equipment that are gonna be sitting empty???

How exactly are we supposed to feed our families from December, to April? How about our employees and their families??? The vets, and blacksmiths who take care of our horses??? The local farmers who sell us hay??? The tack shop that we buy our horse feed and supplies from?? The local stores that we shop at???? The restaurant that we eat lunch at??? Or the many others that we do business with that will suffer from this trickle-down effect???

Many states that have already approved casino gambling, have just been sitting back, foaming at the mouth, waiting for our politicians to drop the ball, so they could throw the knock-out punch at us.. I honestly don’t think Ali, in his prime, could have done a better job of doing so. Is it a coincidence that New York and Florida both announced their purse increases litterally the day after Turfway announced a 25-percent cut in purses???? Is it a coincidence that New York waited until after the senate hearing, to let the public know of the 1.6 million dollars that is going into their states breeding program, due to the success of their casinos??? Is it a coincidence that Churchill Downs waits until after the hearing, to let everyone know that they are now buying into an Ohio racetrack??? I think not.

I also think this issue was important enough to this state that it could have been taken more seriously by a lot of elected officials, rather than rushed through… But don’t worry, these politicians will be held accountable for this, once Joe Public sees first hand just exactly what economic impact horse racing really has on this state, and feels the effects of what’s about to trickle down to him…

David Williams was quoted after the senate hearings as saying “The issue of expanded gambling in the state of Kentucky, is dead, and it’s time to move on”… Well, don’t worry Mr. Williams, you have put us all in a situation that we have no choice but to move on… Thank you for all your support in this matter….

02.22.2012

11:25pm

We’ve been going at this for nearly 20 years and now Kentucky Senate President David Williams is in a hurry and feels the need to fast track SB 151 in today’s session in Frankfort. Has the embattled Republican leader had a sudden change of heart and now wants to make sure the bill allowing Kentuckians the right to choose on expanded gaming has its hearing as soon as senatorially possible? Of course not. Williams seems hell bent on a Thursday hearing because two Democratic “yes” votes in Sen. Joey Pendleton and Sen. Gerald Neal have scheduled absences on Thursday.

This is the time to make our voices heard and Senate Majority Leader Robert Stivers is likely the only chance of getting the vote delayed until Friday when a full senate is scheduled to be on the floor. You can call Sen. Stivers’s office at 502 564-2450 or send an email to Robert.Stivers@lrc.ky.gov.

Before the committee hearing, we half-jokingly suggested extremely long lunch breaks for those employed in the Thoroughbred industry in order to be in Frankfort at noon. But what Sen. Williams has done is an act of aggression against the Thoroughbred industry and those who have fought for this issue.

We challenge all employers connected to the Thoroughbred industry to give their employees the opportunity to call and/or email Sen. Stivers and make calls to the offices of other senators as time permits. A list of Kentucky senators can be found by clicking here and can be reached by calling 800-372-7181.

Can Williams steamroll the process and make a mockery of our system? Or will Kentuckians stand up against such an outright abuse of power from a politician still licking his wounds from the drubbing he took in November’s gubernatorial election?

The answer to that question may very well be up to you. New to the Paulick Report? Click here to sign up for our daily email newsletter to keep up on this and other stories happening in the Thoroughbred industry

Thanks to your overwhelming phone calls, Senator Schickel voted in favor of Senate Bill 151.

The Senate Standing Committee on State and Local Government favorably approved the expanded gaming bill by a 7 – 4 margin.

The bill will be heard next on the Senate floor. Thank you for your efforts and continuing support!

KY Senate Panel Approves Expanded Gaming Bill
By Blood-Horse Staff
Updated: Wednesday, February 22, 2012 2:55 PM
Posted: Wednesday, February 22, 2012 2:52 PM

An amended bill that would authorize a constitutional amendment on allowing up to seven casinos in Kentucky was approved Feb. 22 by the Senate Committee on State and Local Government and will be sent on to the full Senate for consideration.

The vote by the committee, which is chaired by Republican State Sen. Damon Thayer, a co-sponsor of the gaming legislation, was 7-4.

Before passing, the committee adopted revised language in the bill that removed the original provision that of the seven casinos, five would be at racetracks. Although the stipulation that five casinos be located at racetracks and two at non-track locations was removed, the amended bill retained the provision that any of the casinos not at racetrack locations could not be within 60 miles of a track.

The committee vote came after an open hearing in which proponents and opponents addressed the proposed legislation. During the hearing, Gov. Steve Beshear, a Democrat who made expanded gaming a priority in his successful re-election campaign last year, answered questions about the legislation and casinos.

During his presentation, Beshear reiterated that, although he supports expanded gaming, the bill allowing a vote on the issue has support from both opponents and proponents of casino-style gaming because it will allow voters to decide the issue.

He also reiterated that casinos throughout the state could help provide much-needed revenues for various programs across the state and help the horse industry remain competitive with other states where racetrack purses are enhanced by gaming money.

Read more: http://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-racing/articles/67600/ky-senate-panel-approves-expanded-gaming-bill#ixzz1n8x8vOAA

ATTENTION HORSEMEN:

Call Senator John Schickel at 502-564-8100 ext. 617 and ask him to vote for a committee substitute for Senator Thayer’s Senate Bill 151.

When you call please identify yourself and your county of residence.

All calls must be placed prior to Wednesday February 22nd at noon.

Please ask friends and family to call as well.

Thank you,
KHBPA

Expanded gambling has been a part of Kentucky’s political discussion for the better part of 20 years.

For much of that time, poll results have indicated a large majority of Kentuckians think they should decide the issue by voting on a constitutional amendment.

In a recent survey conducted for the state’s racetracks, 87 percent of likely voters in this year’s elections held that opinion.

For several years, this editorial page maintained that same position for a variety of reasons.

Besides being a more politically acceptable route to take, an amendment seemed to us the best way to limit the number of casinos or slots facilities in the state.

It also was the best way to ensure some of the revenue generated from such an expansion helped Kentucky’s Thoroughbred racing industry compete with its counterparts in states where purses and breeding incentives are supplemented by other forms of gambling.

A couple of years ago, we concluded that the racing industry’s future looked sufficiently grim in the absence of some similar supplements here to prompt us to change our position and support the approval of racetrack slots by statute as the quickest means to the desired end of offering one of the state’s signature industries some relief.

But statutory approval of racetrack slots didn’t happen, and the discussion now has returned to a constitutional amendment. Specifically, the current discussion concerns the proposed amendment introduced this week by Republican state Sen. Damon Thayer and backed by Democratic Gov. Steve Beshear.

If an amendment is the option of the moment, we’re fine with it. Our concern is the future of Thoroughbred racing as this state has known it for several decades — a year-round circuit that provides thousands of Kentuckians year-round employment.

If an inability to compete with tracks in “racino” states causes one of Kentucky’s tracks to close, thereby breaking this circuit, the people involved in small and mid-sized racing operations will start looking elsewhere for year-round employment. And Kentucky — all of Kentucky — will be the worse for it.

Thayer’s proposed amendment simply puts before voters the question of whether the legislature should approve licensing up to seven casinos with up to five of those licenses going to Kentucky racetracks.

If the answer is yes, we’ll move on to the discussion of how the licensing process and regulation of those casinos will be handled.

While there’s room for debate of the specifics of any amendment, it’s time —way past time — for a decision on expanded gambling.

Some form of an amendment needs to be on the ballot come November so voters can fulfill their desire to settle the question.

Read more here: http://www.kentucky.com/2012/02/16/2070765/lets-settle-the-casino-question.html#storylink=misearch#storylink=cpy

Bill Connelly, Dave England, Jeff Greenhill, Wayne Mogge, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee. Marty Maline recorded the minutes.

DRAIN NEAR HORSEPATH-Horsemen continue to express their concern with the crevice in the vicinity of the horse path. Troy explained that he has attempted to fix it on several occasions, but has not been successful. He will continue to explore a solution to the problem.

GUTTERS SWINGING FROM VARIOUS BARNS-Horsemen have expressed concern with damaged gutters on barns. Chip asked if work orders have been filled out, that will allow them to determine if the problem is widespread.

TRAINERS 10% DEDUCTION-The committee requested consideration for trainers to received their 10% from winning purses similar to the jockeys. The procedure was developed at Churchill Downs and Churchill Downs legal staff produced a form which must be signed by the owner. This will enable the trainer to receive their 10% from winning purses on a timely basis. Bob suggested that they will explore the possibility once he and Turfway Park’s attorney have reviewed the form.

TVG SHOWING TURFWAY PARK RACES-Repeatedly, horsemen have questioned why TVG might show the paddock and post parades at some tracks and only show a limited number of Turfway Parks races live. Bob explained that he has had discussions with TVG representatives. He mentioned that on Saturdays Turfway Park is a featured racetrack, but on some nights the majority of the races are on taped delay. He will continue to discuss the options with TVG in an effort to receive more coverage.

OUTRIDER PROTOCOL-Comments have been received that during training hours a horse was running off with an exercise rider and the horse ran around the track three times before the outriders attempted to catch the horse. Bob explained that they would investigate the matter, but obviously that is not the established protocol.

PURSE STATUS-John Griffith, KHBPA Treasurer reviewed the present status of the purse account with Cliff Reed, Chief Financial Officer. Cliff informed John that because of the measures taken by Turfway Park to reduce some stakes purses and eliminate others they are confident that at the end of the race meeting the overpayment/underpayment of the purse account will be near zero.

MANURE PICK-UP-Bill Connelly suggested that the crew in charge of manure pick-up needs to focus on not spilling manure and straw all over the barn area. Troy explained that part of the problem is the indiscriminate parking of cars in front of and next to the manure bins. The committee discussed the idea of security fining anyone who leaves their car too close to the manure bin. Cliff Read suggested possibly picking up the manure at night when no one is around. The committee is exploring that possibility.

HORSEMEN’S BOOKKEEPER ACCOUNT-Horsemen have expressed concern with the fact that they can only pick up their winning purse checks when the horsemen’s bookkeeper is working which is currently only three days a week. Therefore, if a horsemen earns purse money on a Friday night he cannot pick up purse money until the following Friday. Bob explained he recognizes the problem and they will make an effort to resolve the issue and accommodate horsemen.

TRACK SURFACE-Horsemen have requested that every effort should be made by the track superintendent not to cultivate the track between race days. Bob expressed the view that barring an unusual weather pattern requiring drastic measures, he will explore the possibility with Jeff Chapman of not renovating the track in between race days.

SLOTS UPDATE-Bob updated the committee on the gaming initiative currently being considered in Frankfort. He explained that Senator Damon Thayer deserves the respect and appreciation of the Kentucky racing industry for his efforts in conjunction with Governor Steve Beshear to allow the citizens of Kentucky the opportunity to vote on this issue as a constitutional amendment. The hope is that the gaming legislation will be introduced next week.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Executive Director KHBPA

Posted: 12:00am on Jan 26, 2012; Modified: 2:24pm on Jan 26, 2012

FRANKFORT — Senate State and Local Government chairman Damon Thayer of Georgetown said Wednesday he was “strongly leaning” toward sponsoring Gov. Steve Beshear’s constitutional amendment to expand gambling.

Thayer is a Republican, and the governor is a Democrat.

Thayer said the amendment would mention casinos at racetracks and other locations, but he declined to say how many.

The amendment also would be brief and outline in a “general way” where proceeds would go from expanded gambling, the lawmaker said.

Beshear, who has tried since taking office in December 2007 to expand gambling in Kentucky, is expected to unveil his constitutional amendment in a few days for lawmakers to consider.

“Sen. Thayer and I have agreed on language for the bill, which will be introduced in the Senate very soon,” Beshear said in a statement.

“We will spend the next few days laying the groundwork for its introduction. We are hopeful that our senators will give this bill the full consideration it deserves, since repeated polls show that Kentuckians are demanding an opportunity to vote on this issue.”

Beshear always has blamed the Republican-controlled Senate for blocking expanded gambling.

At his inauguration last month, Beshear said an amendment needed to start in the Senate because the House, led by Democrats, already has gone on record in support of expanded gambling.

If the legislature approves Beshear’s plan for a constitutional amendment, Kentucky voters would decide the issue at the polls in November.

Senate President David Williams, a Burkesville Republican who failed to oust Beshear in last year’s race for governor, has said Beshear should “completely vet” any proposed amendment with the public before presenting it to the legislature.

Williams, who opposes expanded gambling, said during the campaign that he thought there were votes in the Senate to approve expanded gambling.

Thayer said Williams “has said publicly and told me privately that he will not stand in the way of a constitutional amendment coming to a vote in the Senate. I have no reason not to take him at his word.”

Some Democrats have expressed concern that placing a gambling amendment on the ballot this fall could attract conservatives to the polls and hurt Democratic candidates. All 100 House seats and half of the Senate’s 38 seats are up for grabs this year.

Thayer said that he was not counting votes in the Senate on expanded gambling and that he had asked the governor to “line up the votes.”

The issue has been around since 1994, Thayer said.

Meanwhile, a spokesman for the Family Foundation predicted Wednesday that if Beshear did not release his expanded gambling proposal by the end of the week, the issue would effectively be dead this session.

“By the time the governor and his friends in the gambling industry finish divvying up all the millions of dollars they think they’re going to pocket through this legislation and come out of their smoke-filled room over in the Capitol building, this whole thing will be over,” said Martin Cothran, spokesman for the group. “In fact, the gambling bill may already be dead.

“Support for the gambling legislation is collapsing faster than a $10 tent in a hurricane.”

Read more here: http://www.kentucky.com/2012/01/26/2043079/damon-thayer-says-he-likely-will.html#storylink=misearch#storylink=cpy

Available to children of horse farm and back stretch employees. Students can pursue any field of study. Scholarships are for tuition only, up to $6000 per year for up to four years for an undergraduate student. Multiple scholarships will be awarded.

To be eligible for this scholarship, a student must

• be 24 years old or younger as of September 1 of the application year,
• have at least a 2.85 cumulative GPA,
• have an annual household income of less than $50,000 OR be financially independent from parents.*

Supporting materials that must be scanned and uploaded as PDF files include:

0 Essay on ONE of the following three topics (Please limit essay response to 500 words or less.):

1) What was the last book you read for enjoyment only, not for a class, and why did you choose that book and what did you learn from it?

2) Tell us about a facet of Thoroughbred racing that interests you and why.

3) What interests do you have outside the equine industry or chosen career field?

0 Two letters of recommendation (must be signed but not in sealed envelope);

0 Current official transcript (seal can be broken);

0 Student Aid Report (from FAFSA)

0 If you have NOT received your Student Aid Report, you must submit either your parent/guardian’s previous year’s tax return and current year’s W2 form OR the current year’s tax return. (Additional years may be requested.);

0 Financial aid award letter(s) (including other scholarship awards).

Applicants apply online ONLY. Applications will be reviewed by The Race For Education Selection Committee and finalists contacted for a personal interview. Scholarship recipients will be selected by the Board of Directors, and all applicants will be notified by May 31st each year. Inquiries about the scholarships may be directed to The Race For Education at (859) 252-8648 or apply@raceforeducation.org

*To be considered financially independent, a student must be at least 23 years old OR married OR a veteran OR an orphan OR have dependents of his or her own. Applicants who have been legally emancipated must provide documentation indicating such. No exceptions will be considered.

Go to http://www.raceforeducation.org/scholarships/ for more information.

FRANKFORT — Kentucky lawmakers got a peek inside the checkbook of racehorse owners and small Thoroughbred breeders Wednesday. The numbers were bleak.

Rep. Susan Westrom, D-Lexington, said she arranged the hearing as background education, particularly for freshman legislators, on the current financial situation in the Thoroughbred breeding and racing industry.

“It’s a different day from what it was in 2006,” Westrom said. “We truly are facing a crisis.”

Robert Feenick, senior vice president at PBI Bank in Lexington, told the House Agriculture and Small Business Committee that Kentucky’s position as the top state for stallions and breeding has been eroding as other states have beefed up purses and breeders’ incentives with money from racetrack casinos.

According to figures compiled by The Jockey Club, Kentucky has maintained and even increased its percentage of mares bred in recent years as the breeding industry contracted during the economic downturn, but breeders are worried that the tide is about to change as major breeding states like New York jump in with millions from slots.

Rep. Royce Adams, D-Dry Ridge, asked whether a constitutional amendment to allow expanded gambling is the only thing that could turn Kentucky around.

“From my perspective, a healthy breeding business has to be hooked to a healthy racing environment. Otherwise you leave yourselves exposed,” Feenick said. Breeders incentives, such as those currently funded with the sales tax on stud fees, won’t be enough, he said. “I don’t think you’re going to be able to support it and compete with the likes of New York.”

Gov. Steve Beshear is campaigning for an amendment to be placed on the ballot in November to allow casino gambling. Beshear’s bill has not been introduced yet.

Westrom said this was the first chance she has had to make the horse industry’s case for allowing casino gambling at tracks. Westrom said she was alarmed to hear recently from Frank Taylor at Taylor Made Farms, a major breeding operation in Jessamine County, that the farm has gone from 700 mares boarded in 2009 to 300 today and just laid off 10 workers.

John Greely of Wintergreen Stallion Station in Midway said that is happening on a different scale all across the Bluegrass as mares either left production or left the country during the economic downturn, or went to other states for more lucrative pastures, breeding sheds and racing purses.

Greely said that in the past three years Wintergreen has lost 35 percent of its mares, many going to other states.

Dr. Eric Peterson, an equine veterinarian in Lexington, said one farm his firm works with that boarded 90 mares shipped out 30 in the past month. “It’s real. It’s happening,” Peterson said. “We just want a level playing field. Please consider expanded gambling.”

David England, who until this winter trained a string of about 20 horses at Turfway Park in Florence, walked legislators through the numbers to explain why he has given up his training license for now.

Racehorse owners at the bottom-level claiming races could either compete for $6,000 in Kentucky or run in the same kind of race but against weaker horses in Indiana for $10,000, in West Virginia for $11,000, or Pennsylvania for $17,000, he said. For horses bred in those states, the money is even higher.

To break even on the costs of training alone, a horse would have to win six races in Kentucky or three in Indiana, he said.

“I have owners who will not let me race their horses in Kentucky,” England said. The constant drive to other states just got to be too much for him.

Rep. David Osborne, R-Prospect, said he will likely be the owner of the top Indiana-bred racehorse for the third year in a row, something he said he takes no pride in.

But, Osborne said, the success of his horse, Unreachable Star, has kept the rest of the Kentucky-based stable afloat.

The new threat to Kentucky tracks, trainers, racehorse owners and breeders is New York, which opened a hugely successful casino at Aqueduct last fall.

That casino will pour $40 million to $80 million into breeders’ incentives next year, he said.

“There are still lots of ‘deniers,’ people who deny that our breeding industry is in trouble,” Osborne said. But with breeders looking at an average of $10,000 available per mare in New York versus $1,000 per mare in Kentucky, movement is inevitable, he said.

Churchill Downs racetrack president Kevin Flanery said after the hearing that the time to act is now, when Kentucky horsemen are still trying to hang on rather than moving their businesses and their families to other states.

“Time is running out,” Flanery said. Two years ago, Churchill closed its trackside training facility to winter training because the number of horses stabling there had dwindled from 425 in 2006 to 70 in 2010. And last year the track dropped Wednesday racing in the spring meet after the Kentucky Derby because there just weren’t enough horses to fill the races.

“That’s a 20 percent reduction, a 20 percent pay cut for everybody,” Flanery said. “This is about an entire economy. It’s real people, a real industry, and it’s leaving.”

Reach Janet Patton at (859) 231-3264 or 1-800-950-6397, Ext. 3264.

Read more here: http://www.kentucky.com/2012/01/19/2033326/kentuckys-horse-industry-in-dire.html#storylink=misearch#storylink=cpy

by Tim Thornberry

Business Lexington

William “Buff” Bradley, owner of Indian Ridge Farm in Frankly County, Ky. Lexington, KY – Kentucky’s horse land: acre after acre of rolling green pastures with white planked fences, majestic horse barns and, of course, beautiful Thoroughbreds.

That is the image most get when it comes to horse farms here, and while these massive estates establish a beautiful picture of the industry, a broad network of smaller farms scattered throughout the state make up the backbone of the business.

Indian Ridge Farm is one of those, located in Franklin County an hour or less from the state’s biggest racing venues, Keeneland and Churchill Downs. It is also just a few minutes from a major interstate, so logistically it couldn’t be in a better spot to get horses to and from the places race horses go in Kentucky.

William “Buff” Bradley grew up on the 300-acre farm and is raising his family there as well. His father, Fred, moved there in 1972 and began to raise tobacco and corn, along with a cattle operation and a few Thoroughbred horses.

“My brother and two sisters all worked on the farm, growing up. We kind of did everything, and now it’s strictly a Thoroughbred horse farm,” he said.

The tobacco buyout signaled the end of crops on the farm, although Bradley said they still grow their own hay. But for the most part, the main crop on the farm is the horses that are bred and raised there. At any one time, he keeps nearly 50 horses on the farm and another 20 to 25 at Kentucky-based race tracks.

Indian Ridge is a true working farm and family farm. Bradley said his youngest sister takes care of the bookkeeping duties while his father, who is 80, still serves as the “night watchman” for the 10 to 14 broodmares kept on the farm. And, as he and his siblings did, Bradley’s children take part in the chores, along with his wife.

‘They are all involved in that part of the farm — in feeding and taking care of the horses,” he said. “I don’t expect them to take over or try to make a living that way, but we do want them to learn that. I think it is good responsibility for them, as well as learning how to take care of the animals, knowing how important it is. When you are committed to it, you’re committed to it.”

Bradley said he thinks many of the horse farms in the state are like his, noting you won’t see the white boarded fences when you come there.

“It’s not a big showplace. It’s a working horse farm and serves its purpose in what we do and how we do it,” he said.

What they do and how they do it has proven to be successful for the Bradleys. One of their most successful horses, Brass Hat, still resides at the farm. The Thoroughbred raced for seven seasons, winning 10 times, breaking two track records and winning more than $2 million.

“He was foaled and raised right here on this farm, and he is retired there now. He was a very popular horse in this state. It’s neat to have a horse like that, that everybody knows,” Bradley said.

He emphasized that the operation is not really a commercial business. They breed to race and have been successful at that, he said, and currently the farm has one of the top fillies in the country.

But the horse industry — particularly the Thoroughbred industry — has stumbled a bit over the last few years, something that concerns Bradley and others like him. Once the undisputed champion of the equine world, Kentucky has seen many of its owners and trainers take their operations to other states where incentives and purse money are better.

“I’m 48 years old, and I’ve been working with horses since I was eight years old. I’ve seen [the industry] go up and down a few times, but this is the lowest I’ve seen it,” he said. “I think a lot of Thoroughbred owners and breeders have left this state. Some have gotten out, but I’ve seen a lot that have picked up and looked for a better place to go, as far as breeding incentives and purse levels.”

Bradley added that in the past, with all the horse farms in Kentucky, one could see a lot of horses occupying those farm fields at any given time, a sight that has diminished of late.

“It’s kind of depressing. You don’t see as many anymore. A lot of our good stallions are going to different states where they have breed programs that are better than Kentucky’s,” he said. “It’s really sad to know that our state has gotten in that shape. We don’t have what we did, at all. We’re not even close, and I’m not sure what’s going to bail us out. That’s the scary part. I have a family here and a very good geographic location to the race tracks and the breeding farms and thought I was pretty well set.”

Bradley has been forced to leave one of the winter venues here to go south for the winter racing season in search of better purse money. South usually means Florida, where the Thoroughbred industry is big. Ironically, a sign on Interstate 75 through Ocala, Fla., welcomes visitors to the “Horse Capital of the World.” About 750 miles north, along the same interstate, a similar sign welcomes visitors to Lexington, Ky.

While that debate is likely to continue, the bottom line here is the bottom line, and incentives that breeders get from a horse’s winnings are less in Kentucky then before and less than in many other states. In fact, Bradley said he could give away a foal in Indiana, for instance and still be OK, due to the larger breeder incentives there and the fact that it takes up to $20,000 to get a foal ready for the track.

Kentucky has also not recognized horses as being livestock, but instead considers them companion animals. Horses are therefore ineligible for tax breaks like the ones that cattle producers receive. Some attempts have been made by the state’s General Assembly to remedy that, but to no avail so far.

Thus far, the biggest push to raise revenue for the horse industry in this state has been through the idea of getting expanded gambling passed through legislation, an idea that has fallen short each time it has come before lawmakers.

Bradley said he doesn’t know if that route is the complete answer to all the horse industry woes, but it certainly could help to have expanded gambling venues at Kentucky tracks.

“I don’t think that’s a cure-all for it but my thoughts are, we have to get our purses back up, number one, and that would also help the breeders’ money, because that’s based on what you win as a purse percentage,” he said. “To get the purses up — and I hate to say slots and gaming devices are going to be what’s got to get us there, because I think that’s only temporary — but I think we are so far behind now, because we didn’t get that here early on … like all the surrounding states.”

Bradley said the industry is risky for someone looking to get in right now, which is one reason he has “partnered” more lately, with several people having an interest in a horse as opposed to one person baring the full brunt of paying the entire bill for training a racehorse.

“We’ve tried to keep our costs down by doing our own work, like raising our own hay, doing our own fencing and doing our own foaling. I think people struggle because it does cost so much to be in this,” he said. “I try to do more partnerships now, instead of having the one single owner, because the single owner can’t make it or they’re not in it for very long.”

Bradley added that it is the excitement and the “want-to” that plays a big part in being in the horse business, and partnering with other people is something he likes doing because it gets more people involved.

And getting more people involved may be the very thing that keeps Kentucky the Horse Capital of the World. For more information about Bradley and his racing stables, go to the website at www.buff racing.com. For more information about Brass Hat, go to www.brasshat.us.

MEMORANDUM

TO: HORSEMEN AND RACETRACK PRACTITIONERS

FROM: MARTY MALINE

RE: RACING COMMISSION’S MEETING ON RACEDAY MEDICATION

NEXT MONDAY, ON NOVEMBER 14, AT 10:00 A.M., THE RACING COMMISSION HAS SCHEDULED A MEETING OF THE KENTUCKY HORSE RACING COMMISSION’S RACEDAY MEDICATION COMMITTEE.

THE MEETING WILL BE HELD IN FRANKFORT, KENTUCKY, AT THE CAPITOL ANNEX BUILDING IN ROOM 169.

THE PURPOSE OF THE MEETING IS TO HEAR COMMENTS REGARDING THE ADMINISTRATION OF RACEDAY MEDICATION TO RACEHORSES. IT IS EXPECTED TO FOCUS ON THE USE OF SALIX (LASIX) ON RACEDAY.

DR. ALICE STACK WILL PROVIDE A SCIENTIFIC PRESENTATION ON EXERCISE INDUCED PULMONARY HEMORRHAGE IN THE HORSE, CURRENT KNOWLEDGE OF ITS CAUSES, EFFECTS, AND EFFORTS TO MITIGATE OR PREVENT ITS OCCURRENCE.

ORGANIZATIONS SCHEDULED TO SPEAK INCLUDE:

THE JOCKEY CLUB
THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES
TOBA
THE JOCKEYS GUILD
KENTUCKY HBPA
ARTHUR HANCOCK
LINCOLN COLLINS
NATIONAL HBPA
PEOPLE FOR THE ETHICAL TREATMENT OF ANIMALS (PETA)
KENTUCKY ASSOCIATION OF EQUINE PRACTITIONERS
THE BREEDER’S CUP
AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF EQUINE PRACTITIONERS
ASSOCIATION OF RACING COMMISSIONERS INTERNATIONAL (ARCI)
NATIONAL THOROUGHBRED RACING ASSOCIATION (NTRA)
UNITED STATES TROTTING ASSOCIATION

SINCE THIS IS AN OPEN MEETING, OTHER PEOPLE ATTENDING WILL BE ENTITLED TO SIGN UP AND BE HEARD BY THE COMMITTEE FOLLOWING THE COMMENTS OF THE ORGANIZATIONS LISTED.

The meeting schedule is as follows:

Keeneland Track Kitchen, Rec Room
Monday, October 10 at 11:00 a.m.

Churchill Downs, Rec Hall
Tuesday, October 11 at 10:30 a.m.

Turfway Park
Monday, October 17th at 10:30 a.m.
,br> For questions, or additional information, please feel free to contact me at mary.scollay@ky.gov or at 859 246-2040 (office) or 859 489-7677 (cell).

I look forward to seeing you there.

Sincerely,

Mary Scollay, DVM
Equine Medical Director
Kentucky Horse Racing Commission

http://search.espn.go.com/paul-moran/By Paul Moran
Special to ESPN.com

There has never been want of the suspicious, unethical, disingenuous and dishonest among the political class of New York, which has often boasted a wealth of scoundrels. In a state populated by the folks who have repeatedly re-elected the disgraced Charlie Rangel, put Eliot Spitzer, Anthony Weiner and Pedro Espada in positions of public trust, the simply ignorant are too often overlooked in the political kaleidoscope. At times, however, an individual proves to be so dedicated to making a meaningful contribution to the body of political flatulence with a single act so ignorant that time and space are almost suspended and the only sound heard is that of jaws dropping in incalculable numbers.

The reference to nosebleeds may produce a laugh or two, but the humor is short lived in the face of such somber, irresponsible rhetoric.

The last week has seen the introduction of a piece of racing-related legislation in Albany so morbidly incompetent that it qualifies as a landmark.

New York State Senator Thomas K. Duane, a Democrat whose constituency resides on the west side of Manhattan, last week introduced an out-of-nowhere item of legislation that would ban the use of the anti-bleeding medication furosemide, or Lasix in the racetrack vernacular, on any horse participating in a state-sanctioned race.

The initial reaction was, “Who?”

Duane is not a name that has ever been associated with matters pertaining to racing. The senator, best known as a gay-rights advocate, must have an excess of room on his schedule now that same-sex marriage is the law in New York. But he and others of similar background have somehow found themselves appointed members of the state’s senate and assembly racing committees, which have in early hearings been exposed for their almost humorous lack of an even tenuous grasp of the sport’s basic structure and issues. One grotesquely uninformed lawmaker, during a hearing held during the recent race meeting at Saratoga, suggested that a reduction in purses would be a fine way to cut operational expenses at the New York Racing Association.

Whoa.

Lacking the basic tools required of drafting original work, Duane produced legislation based on an absurd federal model that is pending without great support before the U.S. Senate, which has produced knee-jerk reactions in the halls of racing leadership but is widely opposed by those whose participation is conducted in the sport’s trenches and probably a non-starter in Washington. A Lasix ban will inevitably contribute to the inflation of unemployment statistics and bigger fish await space in the frying pan with only a quarter remaining before an election year.

“Lasix is not used outside the United States and some parts of Canada,” Duane said, perhaps the only accurate statement contained in a press release announcing his brave new vision for racing in the nation’s most important market. “For more than two decades, New York showed tremendous leadership by being the only horse racing state in the nation that banned Lasix. Sadly, in 1995 the New York State Office of Gaming, Racing, and Wagering [Note: there has never been such an agency, further evidence of Duane’s abject incompetence in this matter.] succumbed to the pressure of the horse racing industry and lifted the ban … We ban all other athletes in every other sport from taking performance-enhancing drugs both for their safety and to maintain the integrity of their sports. Yet we embrace the idea of dispensing Lasix to horses so they won’t have a nosebleed or develop blood in their lungs during a big race. This is unacceptable.”

Nosebleed?

The reference to nosebleeds may produce a laugh or two, but the humor is short lived in the face of such somber, irresponsible rhetoric. Duane’s bald ignorance of the industry he seeks to influence profoundly is profoundly disturbing.

Not wagering on horses treated with Lasix would effectively bring the entire industry to a grinding, economically catastrophic halt

“Many horses, dubbed ‘Bleeders,’ [capitalization by Duane] have a tendency to suffer from nose bleeds,” the senator said in the announcement. “Too many nosebleeds can permanently bar a horse from racing thus ruining the owners’ investment made on the horse. Lasix made thousands of younger horses eligible to compete.”

Note to Sen. Duane regarding this astonishingly ignorant statement: The term is “exercised induced pulmonary hemorrhage,” not “nose bleed.” A nosebleed is what happens after one reads the tripe to which the senator boasts authorship. Lasix also keeps thousands of older horses in competition. In fact, more than 95 percent of all horses racing in the U.S. are treated with Lasix for good reason — it helps in the control of exercise induced pulmonary hemorrhage. It works well for the intended purpose and there is no evidence that it enhances performance. Rather, it facilitates performance that would otherwise be diminished by — guess what — exercise induced pulmonary hemorrhage. And yes, it does assist owners, most of whom lose money in any given year, in protecting their investments at least to some degree by participating in competition, which among other benefits produces tax revenue for the state, creates employment and supports a significant segment of the state’s agricultural economy.

The release also urges: “Everyone to refrain from wagering on any horse that is being dosed with Lasix — or worse.”

“Or worse,” is not noted on the program or in past performance charts. Not wagering on horses treated with Lasix would effectively bring the entire industry to a grinding, economically catastrophic halt.

This, an affront to logic and critical thinking if not the literate portion of the state’s electorate — in addition to more highly publicized crimes against the people and the more than occasional ethical lapse — is what we have come to expect from our elected officials in the Empire State. We reap what is sewn.

There is, however, an undercurrent of rationality in the Lasix debate if not faith that logic will prevail. Trainer Rick Violette, president of the state’s Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Association, told the Daily Racing Form: “I would be glad to sit down with the good senator to educate him and show him the error of his ways, but the overwhelming science shows that over 80 percent of horses bleed without the administration of Lasix and to introduce legislation banning the therapeutic use of Lasix would simply be premeditated animal abuse.”

There are laws that prohibit animal abuse, premeditated and otherwise. Now there’s a cause — one easily understood, uncomplicated and widely championed — that the good senator might take up next.

Paul Moran is a two-time winner of the Media Eclipse Award, and has received various honors from the National Association of Newspaper Editors, Society of Silurians, Long Island Press Club and Long Island Veterinary Medical Association. He also has been given the Red Smith Award for his coverage of the Kentucky Derby. Paul can be contacted at pmoran1686@aol.com.

Sunday, August 14, 2011

The name Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association is old-fashioned, befitting an organization that was founded back in 1940.

Yet the Kentucky chapter of what goes by “HBPA” has taken a modern-day approach to its mission of helping people connected to horse racing and promoting the sport.

The KHBPA was out in full force at Ellis Park on Sunday, where, as it has all season, it covered the cost of Dollar Day concessions while also, for the fifth year, presenting nine lucky college students with laptop computers through a random drawing.

The result: a season-high attendance of “between 6,500 and 7,000” by track owner Ron Geary.

“Our laptop day kind of plays off the KTA (Kentucky Thoroughbred Association) college scholarship day (where nine $1,000 grants are awarded),” said Mike Bruder, an HBPA board member. “The idea is to get younger people into this sport in one form or another, as owners or just as fans coming out.”

While the Kentucky HBPA dedicates a special fund to helping the sport, promotions are far from all the organization does.

About 6,000 of the 35,000 HBPA members are horse owners and trainers in Kentucky. The group negotiates contracts with race tracks and provides insurance to members while helping support the hot-walkers and grooms who are the lifeblood of the industry, with English language classes, ride programs to grocery and department stores, and recreation programs designed to create a community.

The HBPA also steps up after disasters and has been busy over the years at Ellis, helping horsemen recover from barn fires and from the 2005 tornado that tore through the track.

“Two of our biggest areas are contract negotiations, to insure that horsemen receive a fair share of revenue, and the emergency assistance,” said Marty Maline, the group’s executive director. “Most recently, we’ve been involved with Instant Racing (the slots-type game that is scheduled to debut at Kentucky Downs in September), making sure horsemen receive an equitable share.

“The nice thing about that contract is that if it goes great guns (at Kentucky Downs), we’ll have the ability to move some of that money to Ellis Park for purses. That’s the sort of things we’re involved with, both with the tracks and in the legislature.”

The public face of the HBPA in Kentucky comes through promotions. The group has sponsored mystery voucher giveaways, a concert starring former jockey Shane Sellers, and a free sun visor day “that didn’t go over even a little bit,” said Maline.

But the most popular event at Ellis is Laptop Day, when hundreds of students attend in hopes of winning a computer.

“It’s incumbent to race tracks to try to draw some younger people back; the bigger an ontrack handle the bigger the share for our horsemen,” said Maline. “Churchill Downs has done well with its night racing. Turfway is having some success with dollar beer nights on Fridays. And Ellis is seeing families coming out through our support of concession prices on Sundays.

“It’s much more fun to have a crowd at the races and to have younger people excited about it. That’s the future for our sport.”

http://www.paulickreport.com

(Editor’s Note: The following commentary is from Steve Montemarano, a board member of the Ohio Thoroughbred Fund and an equine sales executive for Merck.)

Eliminating race day medication has little to do with protecting horse health, improving the breed, or making Thoroughbred racing a better sport. In reality it is a veiled attempt by elitists to push the little guy out.
,br/> The abolishment of veterinary administered anti-bleeder medication will cripple the small stable. Experts say that 75% of Thoroughbred racehorses experience exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhaging (EIPH). Veterinarians say if race horses aren’t treated with furosemide that these athletes will suffer. And who wants that? As equine athletes fall by the wayside legions of owners will go, too. Purses will be redistributed across a condensed spectrum; namely the wealthy. It’s a reverse Robin Hood plot where racing’s backbone is being bullied by affluent stakeholders. It’s time to speak up.

Class Warfare

Proponents of eliminating EIPH treatment assert that European horses do not race on medication, are tougher and bleed less. If number of starts is a metric for toughness, then according to the Irish Jockey Club their Thoroughbreds average 3.8 starts per year on the flat. American based Thoroughbreds achieve an average of 6.1 starts annually.

As for medication European horses need help just like any other region. Even one of Queen Elizabeth’s horses recently tested positive for an illegal drug given to prevent hemorrhaging. “The substance concerned was administered by my vet entirely in the interests of the horse’s welfare, which is always paramount,” said the Queen’s trainer.

An argument exists that foreign horses experience less EIPH. However, the counting mechanism differs between continents. Some foreign jurisdictions tally epistaxis (nose bleeds originating from lungs) whereas American veterinarians use endoscopic exams to detect trace blood internally. Epistaxis rates are low (less than 2%) and arguably consistent between continents. Yet, those opposed to race day medication harp that foreign Thoroughbreds bleed less. That logic is akin to comparing apples to hubcaps.

An Irish Turf Club representative mentions that USA bloodstock appears tainted by medication. Yet, top Irish stallions are by American sires. Sadler’s Wells was born in the United States and sired by Northern Dancer. Urban Sea, the dam of Irish super-stud Galileo, was herself sired by Miswaki – a U.S.-based stallion. Coolmore has a substantial business selling Americanized bloodlines in two hemispheres. So the bashing of American bloodstock doesn’t make sense.

A landmark study was performed in South Africa regarding EIPH treatment. It employs methods heralded as the gold standard. The study concludes after analysis of 322 Thoroughbred performances that “pre-race administration of furosemide decreased the incidence and severity of EIPH.” Furthermore, the American Association of Equine Practitioners (AAEP) “supports the use of furosemide as a day-of-the-race medication to control EIPH.”

Yet, despite sophisticated studies and expert veterinary opinion leading executives within racing want to ban furosemide. The logic is mortifying. The issue is shaping up as a trial without jury, with The Jockey Club, RCI and Breeders’ Cup leading the lynch mob out to kill the legal use of race day medication.

This rhetoric is stimulated because swanky American breeders aren’t selling many million-dollar yearlings. This is due to a weak global economy. Moreover, demand for American bloodstock is dull because foreign buyers scarfed-up the best American horses over several decades. The result is a self-sustaining breeding colony based internationally. American breeders “sold-out” and now some want to pout about it.

There are Breeders’ Cup (BC) implications, too. It’s reported that only 2% of international horses are eligible for BC events. To date the total number of BC starters from Europe is 414 (16%). While these horses add a dynamic to the event, a question is: Should medication rules change to accommodate the minority? If you participate in BC events, then decide yourself upon using approved race day medication. Much like the connections of champion Goldikova have.

But our racing executives see Europe as the mother lode. Increased stallion nominations and entries from Europe and Asia may revitalize BC revenue. Also racing execs want to tap overseas gambling pools. Ostensibly more international BC entries will stimulate global gaming income. It’s a case of salesmanship and follow the money.

The issue is complex but plain answers are found by talking to folks in the trenches – like trainers at Belmont Park. One says he receives regular calls from Europe to train horses because they bleed. Another dreads that without race day furosemide the backstretch will become the Wild West where unproven drugs and weird herbs will be explored. Trainers wonder that since furosemide is legal, safe, and testable why take it away?

What happens in societies where raceday medication for EIPH is banned? Look in the back section of your favorite racing magazine and see. Billionaires garner the limelight. Is this a consequence of so-called medication-free racing?

An endearing aspect of American racing is that a cowboy can win the Kentucky Derby with a gelding. Also, an $11,000 filly may earn another Eclipse Award – perhaps that is just Blind Luck. American racing is about dreaming and equal opportunity.

In summary, the primary question regarding race day medication should be what is best for the health and welfare of racehorses. Thus far, medical evidence and common sense supports the continued legal use of race day anti-bleeder medication.

Perhaps The Jockey Club, Breeders’ Cup, and RCI will attempt to ban medication in the workplace, too. All this gives me a headache. I am going to take an aspirin.

By Jennie Rees – The Courier Journal

Visit Jennie Rees’ Blog at http://blogs.courier-journal.com/racing/

More questions for regulators considering the movement to ban anti-bleeder medication in the United States (following up on two earlier blog posts):

Why would racing want to be the only sport I know of that makes a deliberate choice to spurn advances in modern medicine?

The most definitive study on horses bleeding and the efficacy of the anti-bleeder medication commonly called Lasix (but whose trade name now is Salix and generic name is furosemide) was conducted in 2007 in South Africa, with the results published in 2009. It was a collaboration of researchers at the University of Pretoria, University of Melbourne and Colorade State University.

The study determined that up to 75 percent of thoroughbreds experience exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhaging, which we commonly call bleeding, and that it negatively impacts the performance of horses when they do bleed. The study established the furosemide is an effective way to prevent such bleeding.

At the time, the researchers suggested that maybe the United States had it right, that other countries that do not allow race-day Lasix might want to rethink their policies.

“It is likely that racing jurisdictions will reconsider, in one way or another, their position on the use of furosemide,” they (researchers) say, according to a report on the study published in the British online site the-race-horse.com. “However, the decision to allow or disallow the use is based on the balance of a number of factors, and resolution of this complex situation will take some time.”

“… The challenge will now be for countries such as Australia, England, Hong Kong and South Africa that do not currently permit race-day use of furosemide, to balance the animal-welfare aspect of being able to prevent or reduce the condition against the imperatives for drug-free racing. Additionally, instituting race-day administration of furosemide would be a significant added expense to racing.”

The-racehorse.com report (here’s the link) called the research the “gold standard of scientific studies.”

Why is The Jockey Club, Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders Association, Breeders’ Cup, RCI and Frank Stronach suddenly ignoring those findings?

Why are they making the use of legitimate, therapeutic medications that are used in incredibly small amounts sound like it’s doping horses? As Daily Racing Form’s Steve Crist so elegantly pointed out, they are intertwining two very different situations. Here’s the link to one of his columns on the subject, which I consider the most thoughtful written to date.

Why doesn’t The Jockey Club, TOBA, Breeders’ Cup, RCI put the same energy and zeal into going after real cheating substances?

Why is it considered it a better thing for the integrity of racing to let a horse bleed and stop in the stretch of a race as the 4-5 favorite than to have raced on Lasix and very possibly prevented that? Is that good for the fans and bettors?

Does anyone think that’s humane? Especially given the damage a bleeding episode can do to a horse?

Does anyone think it’s humane to go back to the Stone Ages and have trainers having to “draw up” horses before a race (see 1990 Derby winner Unbridled for the Belmont, back when New York banned race-day medication)? Do we think it’s humane to pull horses’ water 24 hours out?

Does anyone really think it would stop any cheating, if there is cheating? If there’s cheating (and I’m not saying there is, but the fear or suspicion of illegal drugs is something that does discourage some horse players from betting) it’s with sophisticated undetectable drugs, and it’s being done by the people who can afford it, not the guys with the nickel claimers.

Does anyone thing getting rid of Lasix would force cheaters to stop? (Because the days that one could claim that Lasix masks illegal substances are long over. If a testing-lab chemist claims that, that racing jurisdiction needs a new chemist.)

By Jennie Rees – The Courier Journal

Visit Jennie Rees’ Blog at http://blogs.courier-journal.com/racing

The Lexington-based Association of Racing Commissions International (RCI) is conducting a special meeting on race-day medication – specifically phasing in a complete ban on bleeder medication in the U.S – July 26 at Saratoga Springs. It’s a follow-up to an early summit held at Belmont Park in June, with this one billed as offering the opportunity for more expert opinions and to allow regulators to ask follow-up questions.

Here would be some of my questions (with more to come under a later post):

Why does anyone think America needs to emulate Europe and other racing countries?

European racing has its own issues and problems. It’s a completely different game than here, including almost all-turf racing where they go really slow the first part and only sprint home the last part. There is no dirt racing. There isn’t year-round racing, at least at the top level. Purses aren’t anything special for the most part. A card might have only six- or seven races with more limited racing seasons. British racing has Royal Ascot with its top hats, but overall it is in great need of a purse infusion. Purses are better in France, but there is largely not the passion for the sport as Britain or Ireland.

Germany has the strictest medication rules – very strict as far as entering the breeding production chain – in Europe. But that racing’s top end is about Grade III here.

Hong Kong might have the world’s strictest medication rules. But Hong Kong has no breeding industry, has two tracks that race one day a week each, with a racing season that spans about six months for a total of 83 racing programs a year.

Also, the young horses that are sold at auction over there are true iron horses, tested so many times for the presence of any medication before they can be sold. Do American breeders really want to go “there”? (Ask the American breeders that have consigned horses to that sale. You wouldn’t get many horses sold here using the Hong Kong criteria. But that’s what makes it possible for their horses to withstand their strident medication rules, including an extremely low incident of horses who bleed.)

In other countries, racing still truly is the sport of kings, or at least the very rich. Having a chance to break even or – not likely but maybe possible – make a few dollars – is not a major consideration. But in America, truly the land of opportunity, thousands of regular folks like you and me can own at least a piece of a horse. That’s not possible in Europe. (And in Hong Kong, the Hong Kong Jockey Club has iron-clad control over who can own horses, who can train and who can ride, with only a finite number of each.)

Do American breeders really want to emulate a sport where average, middle-class citizens can’t participate as owners? (Update: Some readers of the Paulick Report (paulickreport.com) took me to task for suggesting that Europe doesn’t have syndicates and partnerships. They do, and I linked to some of them on a response on paulickrreport.com)

Why do you think so many British, Irish and French horsemen come over to the United States? Because it indeed is the land of opportunity, where a guy with only a horse or two can still participate, including at a top level. (Try that in any other country).

Look, I love watching European racing, love the European horses and horsemen who come to the Breeders’ Cup (and sometimes the Derby). They add so much. But it is apples and walnuts, as a friend suggested.

Is Lasix really keeping foreign buyers from buying U.S. horses? I just don’t believe that. Coolmore, Darley and Shadwell are still enthusiastic buyers but they also have their own well-established breeding programs. And there is this thing going on called the shaky global economy.

If American breeders are so worried that foreign buyers from Japan, Hong Kong, Germany or Australia aren’t buying their horses, perhaps it’s not because Lasix is allowed for racing here but because too many (not all) breeders have knowingly put bad bleeders (as well as bad throated, poorly conformed horses, etc.) into the breeding pipeline for short-term profit.

Does Europe really want America to outlaw Lasix?

After all, who would they sell all their bleeders to? And that’s no small thing. Think of all the top turf horses who started out as seeming underachievers in Europe but became champions in America. Without the Yankees to sell to, the Europeans are going to eat a lot of horses, so to speak.

And I want to emphasize, lost in this almost hysteria is the fact that there is virtually no race-day medication in the U.S. outside bleeder medication – and Kentucky now is one of the strictest jurisdictions in the country.

Here’s the link to an article in tomorrow’s Daily Racing Form on Gulfstream Park owner Frank Stronach’s request to Florida regulators that he be allowed to ban race-day bleeder medication for 3-year-olds at the 2012 meet. (Which would be a very good way to help the Louisiana Derby, which is on the same day as the Florida Derby. That close to the Kentucky Derby, in hot weather, will trainers and owners want to risk a horse bleeding in a race five weeks out from the Churchill Downs classic?)

Here’s what Derby-winning trainer Graham Motion, certainly not considered a big medication guy, had to say in the same article (including on the horses he gets from Europe specifically because they are bleeders):

“I just worry about having a knee-jerk reaction over the Lasix issue somewhat like what happened with the synthetic tracks in California. Look where that ended up. I worry that if we do away with Lasix, everybody is going to start using other things under the table – just like what happened in New York before Lasix was legalized. Everyone needs to be a little more open minded. I couldn’t care less about other medications, but Lasix is something that can be controlled by the state. What people might administer their horses if they cannot use Lasix cannot be controlled.

“- “The bottom line if that if Lasix is taken away, there are going to be certain horses you will not be able to run at Gulfstream. I get horses sent to me from outside this country specifically to run on Lasix. It’s just cut and dry – that’s all. Am I going to stay away from Gulfstream if they institute this policy? No. But it will certainly restrict the number of horses I run there, more than likely some of the better ones in my barn.”

By Jennie Rees – The Courier Journal

http://blogs.courier-journal.com/racing/author/jrees/

Lots going on in racing (at least off the track) right now, including yesterday’s bombshell announcement that the Breeders’ Cup will ban the use of race-day bleeder medication in its 2-year-old races starting next year and for all horses starting in 2013.

I just want to quickly say for now that any movement to tighten what already are incredibly restrictive medication regulations – just compare them to any other sport, and yourself, for instance – must start with the people who are producing the horses: the breeders, whose major representatives have gone on record as supporting the end of race-day Lasix.

I say, if that’s the case, then no medication – no Lasix, no anti-inflammatories – should be allowed in horses who are being not only sold, but when they are being shown beforehand at the weanling, yearling and 2-year-old sales.

It is unfair to the owners, and the trainers charged with trying to get them to the races, to buy horses who benefited from medication when being sold but then no longer be able to use such therapeutic substances when undergoing the stress of a race. If a yearling needs an anti-inflammatory before or after it is hauled in and out of its stall to be shown 20 times a day at a sale, then maybe that yearling isn’t one to withstand the rigors of training and racing.

If a 2-year-old needs an anti-inflammatory before or after a breeze show, or to have it at its best as it gallops into a sale, then maybe that 2-year-old isn’t one to withstand the rigors of more serious training and racing.

Maybe such horses shouldn’t be sold. Harsh? Yes. Draconian? No more so than the current hysteria over legal, therapeutic, beneficial medications for race horses.

So no bute, no banamine, no joint injections, no oral Vetalog, nothing to calm down a head case in horses even in the days before they are sold. No DMSO, Ibuprofen, Isoxsuprine, Robaxin. No Clenbuterol or Albuterol, not even the recommended 72-hour restriction some sales have.

Keeneland’s current sales policy recommends – “recommended” is the word its website uses – no more than two non-steroidal anti-inflammatory and no more than one corticosteroid.

That’s far more than is allowed in horses who race at Keeneland and Kentucky’s other tracks. And there’s no recommending about it at the track. It’s the law. A Kentucky trainer last month was handed a 30-day suspension after one of his horses tested for slight overages of both bute and banamine – because only one such substance was allowed to be in the horse’s system for racing. (Up until several years ago, both substances – and more – could have been given up to four hours before post time). The horse in question, a winner, also was disqualified.Now that’s getting Draconian.

I know the sales have greatly cut back on the medication of horses being sold at auction (including a ban on bleeder medication for breeze shows at some of the 2-year-old auctions and reining in on steroid use). But the sales arena remains far more permissive than for racehorses. That needs to change before decisions are made on the racing end.

Something else that needs to change is the policy where it’s only voluntary that consignors disclose conformation surgeries that yearlings have undergone to straighten legs. That should be mandatory.

Equine surgeons I greatly respect have told me there can be real benefit in these surgeries beyond allowing the horse to fetch a higher price at sale. But if a crooked leg is a genetic trait (which certainly might not be the case), shouldn’t such surgeries be fully disclosed before the sale – and before that horse goes in the breeding production chain?

More thoughts on this later.

Visit Jennie Rees’ Blog at http://blogs.courier-journal.com/racing/author/jrees/

News that Turfway Park will shut down its year-round stabling April 15 for the spring and summer is another nail in the coffin of Kentucky’s racing circuit.

But the corpse of a true Kentucky, year-round circuit has long gone cold. The ending of the stabling, which Turfway started when it added the synthetic Polytrack surface in 2005, might not seem like a huge deal. But it is.

There is a solid core of horsemen who live in Northern Kentucky who have stabled year-round at Turfway. Those trainers now have to move, and some surely will be moving out of Kentucky, which will impact Keeneland and Churchill Downs’ spring meets and quite possibly into the fall, Ellis Park’s summer meet and Turfway’s fall meet. And no doubt it’s winter meet – if Turfway is still operating by then.

Why? As long as those trainers were at Turfway, a lot of their horses were going to run at other Kentucky tracks, even Ellis, with its long ship. When you’re paying out-of-season stall rent for horses, you’re a free agent and can go wherever you want. And certainly the Turfway horsemen ran a lot of Indiana Downs and Hoosier.

But if those horsemen get stalls now in Indiana, they’re going to be obligated to running at those tracks. They won’t be shipping out to Churchill or Ellis. If they get stalls in Pennsylvania, they really won’t be sending those horses to Kentucky.

Some might try to get stalls at Churchill Downs. But they probably can’t get what they need there, making Indiana or Pennsylvania – maybe Louisiana, Delaware if they can get in – more attractive.

Keeneland is only a limited option because everyone but those who lease barns.

Once these trainers have to move from their hometown, they might not be back. Look at Greg Foley. For years he spent the winter stabled at Churchill’s Trackside (which closed for winter training for the first time this year) and running at Turfway because Louisville was home. But then his owners started insisting their horses go where there was better purse money.

Foley went to the Fair Grounds in New Orleans, loved it, and this winter he had just about all his horses down there.

A trainer like Bill Connelly has the stock to have left his Turfway base several years ago. But he has a home there, and has supported that track. He always has some stalls at Churchill in the spring, and is trying to get a few more, but kept the rest at Turfway. Now those horses might be stabled at River Downs, where he has run for years. He can shuttle horses in and out, but still will be expected to race a lot of those horses at River, whose purses are worse than Turfway’s but which stand to increase when slots are instituted at the track.

Horsemen don’t want to leave Kentucky but they’re being forced to. A Louisville guy like Rob O’Connor went to Delaware three years ago and has been back ever since, meaning those horses aren’t racing at Ellis or Turfway’s fall meet.

Richard Kohnhorst, a mainstay in Kentucky for more than two decades, is completely out of the state, racing at Indiana and Tampa – though he has a home in Oldham County.

You might think Keeneland won’t be impacted, but it will. For one thing, both Turfway and Keeneland are Polytrack so it’s logical for Turfway horses to run there. And two, Keeneland has its share of cheaper races, too.

The big outfits will always come to Churchill Downs, because those trainers can afford to split up. But the medium and small stables – racing’s middle class – don’t have all the same options. As they are forced to leave the state or be squeezed out of the business entirely, the big outfits will start feeling the pinch when certain types of races don’t get enough entries to be used, because too few outfits have all the horses.

Turfway is closing its off-season stabling because, even though stall rent was charged, management says it doesn’t have enough horses to even break even – another sign of the racing stock leaving the state. Turfway is not in position to do an endeavor that loses money. And this is going to allow the track to cut year-round jobs, such as track and backside maintenance, I’m assuming.

Keeneland is Turfway’s co-owner with the Harrah’s casino conglomerate. But Keeneland has had its own cutbacks in the wake of its sales being about 50-percent off amid the struggling global economy and does not seem interested in putting money into Turfway.

Kentucky needs to decide if its extremely labor-intensive horse-racing industry is important enough for the state to take steps to reverse the downward trend. We’re not talking handouts, but the ability to compete on a level-playing field with Indiana, Pennsylvania, Louisiana and soon Ohio.

I can’t believe I just wrote that sentence. Not just compete, Kentucky should be up there with New York as the country’s premier circuits. And wait until the slots money from Aqueduct starts pumping into those purses. You’ll see an exodus to the north.

Churchill and Keeneland continue to hold their own. But they are seeing erosion of their racing product. Look at Arlington Park and the tragic state of Illinois racing, which is even worse than what Kentucky’s faced. Top tracks can slide down the same slope just the same as their smaller sisters.

Sadly, I don’t think the state will fully realize what it lost until it loses a track or two.

Tom LaMarra

Nothing is going on here.

It was foolish to believe the Kentucky General Assembly would take substantive action involving the horse industry during the short 2011 session with a gubernatorial election looming in November. Politics usually wins out over constituency.

There was talk last fall of comprehensive racing-related legislation being introduced—even indications a constitutional amendment on racetrack gaming could be offered in advance of 2012—but it was nothing more than talk. The game of smoke and mirrors continues.

Two racing bills did pass both chambers, but you can’t blame the horse industry for not getting too excited. One authorizes Kentucky to join an interstate racing compact, while the other mandates licensing and reporting of pari-mutuel handle by advance deposit wagering companies.

The compact, though important, is more about the big picture. The ADW bill is about 10 years overdue; the Kentucky Thoroughbred Development Fund, which derives revenue from ontrack bets but not from ADW, has lost millions of dollars a year since the launch of account wagering because the KTDF statute was never revised. No one blinked an eye until last year.

In short, neither bill does anything for Kentucky purses and breed development this year and may not in future years. Meanwhile, the beat—or beating—goes on: Turfway Park has told horsemen it plans to shut down for off-season stabling and training because of a lack of money and horses. This follows on the heels of the Churchill Downs Training Center’s closing this winter for the first time because of a dwindling population of racehorses in the state.

It’s the latest sign of a struggling industry many lawmakers call “signature.” Few, however, are willing to sign on the dotted line to ensure its long-term viability.

All was not lost during the recent General Assembly. Both chambers found time to discuss and easily pass a constitutional amendment for 2012 ensuring the rights to hunt and fish are protected. They already are by statute.

So what about action on horse racing and breeding, and on supporting an economic engine Kentucky would be sorry to lose? That’s not happening any time soon.

“It’s shameful, absolutely shameful,” said former Kentucky governor Brereton Jones, owner of Airdrie Stud and chairman of the Kentucky Equine Education Project. “Everyone should be judged according to their productivity, and I think this speaks loudly to the people in Frankfort.”

The horse industry isn’t without fault for a situation that has developed over many years. Opportunities have been lost and mistakes have been made. Egos have thwarted progress. Shortsightedness and a “me” mentality haven’t helped the cause.

The industry, however, isn’t guilty of not asking for help and offering solutions. How many times does the same thing need to come up in the General Assembly before lawmakers get the message?

With each passing year of fewer horses, lower purses and breed development funds, bankruptcies, farm closures, and taxpayers leaving the state to spend money elsewhere, it becomes clear that leadership and guts are needed in political circles. The lack of action is odd, given the fact not only is the horse industry valued at $4 billion a year, it’s unbelievably popular with a public that, according to poll after poll, supports racetrack gaming in what we’re told is an anti-gambling state.

It’s frightening to think what needs to happen to racing and breeding before politicians step up. In Kentucky it’s no longer a case of the occasional worm in the apple or a damaged leaf. Neglect has led to an infested orchard that will take years to nurse back to health.

Racing isn’t going away any time soon, and neither are the stallions that keep the state’s breeding industry from becoming backwater. But when a state with the horse-related infrastructure of Kentucky can’t support year-round racing and the jobs it provides, it doesn’t bode well for the horse racing and breeding industries in other states—even those with gaming revenue.

In mid-February, Democratic Rep. Susan Westrom was one of a group of public officials that attended a Lexington reception at the new offices of the TwinSpires.com ADW call center. When asked then whether someone was going to pull a rabbit out of the hat for the horse industry this year, she answered honestly. No.

“It hurts my soul to think our signature industry is taking a back seat,” said Westrom, a frequent sponsor of racing bills. “Sometimes it takes a lot of courage (to get things done), but courage is a bit sparse right now.”

Indeed it is. What a shame—and an embarrassment.

The Administrative Regulation Review Subcommittee will be meeting again on Tuesday, December 14, 2010, at 1:00 in room 149 of the Capitol Annex in Frankfort, Kentucky. At this meeting they will be revisiting the safety vest issue.

Since the last meeting, members of the KHBPA have met with members of the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission (KHRC) staff on the concerns expressed by horsemen.

One of the issues expressed is the lack of communication between the KHRC and horsemen prior to the decision to implement regulations affecting them. The KHRC staff explained that they will, in the future, consult with horsemen in order to get feedback prior to passing regulations that affect them.

We then inquired, as far as the new vests not being as safe as the old vests due to lack of protection in the shoulder area, tailbone, liver and kidney areas the KHRC staff explained that protective plates can be purchased to address areas of concern. Also, additional vests are available that have the protections that are of interest to horsemen. The KHRC also agreed to compose a list of the specific types of vests that meet the safety standards along with a list of the various distributors that have the various vests available and prominently display the information for everyone to view at the racetracks and training centers. In addition, they will have the number of PJ Cooksey available on the information sheet.

We have requested that the implementation of the safety vest regulation be delayed for a reasonable amount of time to allow the horsemen the opportunity to digest the information received, just last week, and pursue the various outlets that have the vests available.

BOB ELLISTON
TURFWAY PARK
7500 TURFWAY ROAD//P O BOX 8
FLORENCE KY 41042

Dear Sir:

Equine piroplasmosis (EP) continues to be a disease necessitating greater attention from all of us. Since October of 2009 there have been no fewer than 550 horses throughout the United States found to be infected with the causative protozoan (predominantly T. equi but some B. caballi) that results in equine prioplasmosis being contracted. Though the vast majority of cases have been discovered in quarter horses, there is growing evidence the disease is present in the thoroughbred racing population as well. Because of limited testing having been conducted in this class of animal, the established prevalence continues to be an unknown. A map depicting the geographic distribution of horses tested and found to be positive during this period is attached for your information. The map was compiled from data provided by the USDA’s Veterinary Services. Additionally, equine piroplasmosis continues to be listed and described by the USDA as a Foreign Animal Disease.

With the recent discovery that equine piroplasmosis does have some level of prevalence in the racing populations, many states and/or race tracks have begun requiring horses seeking entry onto their grounds to have been tested and reported negative for piroplasmosis prior to being allowed entry onto the backside. I am currently aware horses destined to tracks and/or training facilities in Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Iowa, Louisiana, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Texas are required to present proof of having been tested negative for piroplasmosis. This listing should not be construed as complete, and my advice to horsemen and veterinarians shipping to any race track since October of 2010 has been to check the entry requirements prior to departing.

Given the data and knowledge we have today, Dr. Stout and I are of the opinion that until such time that we can better identify the disease prevalence and understand what risk the disease presents to our racing populations (not breed specific), piroplasmosis testing for entry onto all Kentucky tracks is warranted. In addition, we have discussed this growing concern with the Kentucky Racing Commission’s veterinary staff and find they share a similar opinion.

Based on the above information, and under the authority found in KRS257.030, the Kentucky State Veterinarians Office is directing that until further notice all equine animals (racing and nonracing) seeking entry onto a race track in Kentucky must be accompanied with a certificate demonstrating the horse(s) was tested for piroplasmosis by a C-ELISA assay for both T. equi and B. caballi and reported to be negative. We are stating that the testing should begin immediately and that effective January 1, 2011, no horse shall be allowed entry onto a Kentucky race track without verification that the required testing has been completed. The testing shall be performed and the results reported by a laboratory certified and approved by the USDA to conduct the testing and shall be completed on a blood sample collected from the horse during the 12 month period preceding the animal’s entry onto the grounds. The testing is not a requirement for racing, but simply qualifying the horse for access to the track. This testing is in addition to the established health requirements that include each horse entering a Kentucky track demonstrate that they have tested negative for equine infectious anemia, been vaccinated against equine herpes virus type 1 and accompanied with a Certificate of Veterinary Inspection stating the animals to be free of disease and known exposure to a communicable disease.

We currently anticipate the requirement of testing for piroplasmosis to continue through the fall race meets and reserve the right to amend the testing requirement and/or frequency as deemed appropriate.

Feel free to contact me directly should you have any questions, comments or concerns regarding this directive.

Respectively,

E.S. (Rusty) Ford
Equine Programs Manager

The Kentucky Horse Racing Commission will look into delays in horsemen’s payments in the wake a postponement by Keeneland Race Course in awarding purse money earned on October 9.

Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association Executive Director Marty Maline said because one drug test came back with a “suspicious” result on October 9, Keeneland Race Course has held up all purse payments to horsemen for that date.

KHRC Chairman Robert Beck said he was aware of the problem and that the commission is looking into it.

Keeneland decided to not pay the purse money while the suspicious finding is being resolved through a split sample.

A KHRC rule allows tracks to delay payouts if a suspicious drug test is detected. The tracks pushed for the rule, noting that they previously paid out all purses based on race results and sometimes had difficulty collecting purse money if a horse later was disqualified.

When a drug positive carries with it a forfeiture of purse money for a winning or placing horse, purse money has to be redistributed based upon the new order of finish. Tracks said they were being placed in the role of collection agent in situations where they had paid out purse money and then were forced to go back to disqualified owners and ask for the money to be returned.

The new rule allows tracks to hold up purse money after a suspicious result, but the October 9 situation seems to expose problems with the rule. Maline said that because secrecy of test results is maintained early in the process, Keeneland officials explained that they did not know in which race the suspicious result occurred.

Kentucky HBPA President Rick Hiles said the rule needs to be changed to prevent an entire day’s purse payouts from being delayed. He said today that some horsemen still have not been paid for horses who won or placed on October 9.

“Can you imagine winning the Kentucky Derby (G1) and then having to wait to get paid until the results of some claiming race held the same day are finalized?” Hiles said.

Hiles added that many horsemen are on tight budgets and that payout delays create problems as they have their own bills, from paying for feed to veterinary care, to payroll.

Frank Angst is senior writer for Thoroughbred Times

For the first time in several years, horsemen and management at Turfway Park are at odds over terms of a contract that would be in effect for the holiday meet that begins Dec. 2 and runs through Dec. 31.

As the racing industry has been negatively impacted by the downturn in the national economy, the contract that stipulates how much money goes to purses and how much goes to the track had been extended from meet to meet without any changes.

Now, however, Turfway and its partners—Keeneland and Harrah’s—are seeking a larger percentage of the takeout from wagering than has been the norm in recent meets. Management contends the track needs to get more to offset the downturn in business and revenues and that it has done its part to cut costs wherever possible.

“What has been requested has been a change in the percentages we would pay (to purses) from various sources of wagering revenues,” Turfway Park president Bob Elliston said of the contract proposed to horsemen. “At Turfway Park, the wagering numbers have declined yet the percentages attributable to purses have not changed at all. At the same time, we have had to reduce staff, have had to reduce payments to staff that continue to work here, and have had to reduce the expenses we can make on our physical plant.”

Elliston declined to say how much more the track is seeking from horsemen, adding “We have a difference of opinion with our horsemen as it relates to the specifics of the contract. I am not going to go into the specifics of the contract.”

While they understand the economic pressure facing Turfway Park’s ownership, horsemen have also felt the brunt of the down economy by having seen purses slashed and having fewer opportunities to race as the northern Kentucky track has cut racing dates, according to Marty Maline, executive director of the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association. “They have a position that they need some concessions from horsemen, and horsemen at the same time are not prepared to give concessions,” Maline said, adding that there was no animosity between the two parties. “Anything that would further decrease purses is something we are not prepared to do at this time.”

“It’s tough for them and we understand they are not in the business to lose money, but horsemen cannot afford a significant hit either,” he continued. “He (Elliston) is understanding of our position and we are understanding of his position.”

It is unclear whether the contract issue must be resolved before Oct. 26, when the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission meets to consider 2011 race dates. At the dates’ committee meeting last week, committee members and KHRC staff were unable to clarify that an agreement must be in place before dates could be awarded.

Under state statute, a track must have the permission of horsemen if it is seeking a number of live racing dates that is “less than 100%” of live racing dates raced in 1994, considered the traditional dates raced by a Kentucky track. But it remains unclear if that agreement is required before the dates are awarded or prior to meet taking place.

Elliston would like to see that stipulation in state statute changed since virtually every track in the state is now racing fewer dates than in 1994. The inability of the track to have a contract with horsemen could also impact the ability of the track to send its simulcast signal to other tracks and wagering outlets. Under terms of the Interstate Horseracing Act of 1977, horsemen have the right to reject a signal from being sent if there is no contract with management.

Maline said neither party hopes the stalemate gets to the point of the simulcasting being threatened.

Maline said the economic picture for both horsemen and the racetrack could change if the state’s tracks are able to offer a form of Instant Racing, or historical racing. Instant Racing, in which bettors wager electronically on previously run races but without knowing the outcome, has boosted purses at Oaklawn Park. The racing commission and tracks have requested a court opinion on the legality of being able to offer Instant Racing, which is opposed by an organization called The Family Foundation. But Maline said the possibility that Instant Racing will become reality soon and will generate revenues for purses is not sufficient for horsemen to agree to the concessions being sought by Turfway Park.

“Our feeling is if we are in some way fortunate to have that (approval of Instant Racing) happen, maybe there is light at end of the tunnel,” he said. “But we just can’t allow purses to be diminished in hopes that it will be.”

ANDERSON, Ind. – For nearly a century, racing in Indiana has been identified with one world-famous institution: the Indianapolis 500. But in recent years, a different kind of racing has crept into the sporting conscience, partly at the expense of the horsey bluebloods to the south.

Indeed, Thoroughbred racing in Indiana is coming of age. Its prominence is traceable to a political sagacity that has allowed the state to reap hundreds of millions of dollars annually in casino revenues while simultaneously fostering the rise of horse racing. Once non-existent, horse racing in Indiana has become vibrant and relevant. Last Saturday, the winner of a Triple Crown event raced in the state for the first time when Preakness winner Lookin At Lucky captured the Indiana Derby at Hoosier Park, much to the delight of fans and racing officials.

Meanwhile, horse racing is suffering in Kentucky, which long has been regarded as the sport’s crucible and an exemplar of tradition. This weekend, while thousands of casual racegoers frolic in a pastoral setting at Keeneland Race Course in Lexington, Ky., any shift in power might not be apparent. But the fiscal might of onsite slots has permitted the two Indiana tracks, Hoosier Park and Indiana Downs, to fuel purses that are threatening Kentucky’s two smaller tracks, Turfway Park and Ellis Park, while chipping away at the two major ones, Keeneland and Churchill Downs. Horsemen from throughout the Midwest have been lured to Indiana with the promise of a better way to make a living.

“Horses have to go where the money is,” said Kevin Greely, a Kentucky native and longtime racing official who became the racing secretary at Hoosier in January. “Trainers have to make money for their owners. It’s pretty simple.”

Parimutuel wagering in Indiana became legal in March 1989, and in October 1990, the northeastern Indianapolis suburb of Anderson became the first city to apply for a racetrack license. Churchill Downs and the Pegasus Group, which later reorganized as Centaur, were the first owners of what became Hoosier Park, where the first harness meet was held in 1994 and the first Thoroughbred race on Sept. 1, 1995.

The early days at Hoosier were marked by growing pains. Purses were small. Horses were slow. Crowds, such as they were, wagered tentatively.

But Hoosier was built to an efficient scale. With government-mandated casino subsidies helping to supplement its purses even before the track became a racino, the Hoosier operation included an indoor capacity of just a couple of thousand seats and a modest network of off-track betting parlors.

Indiana Downs, in the southeastern Indianapolis suburb of Shelbyville, opened in 2003. Built on a similarly modest scale by an Indianapolis corporation, Oliver Racing LLC, the new track also took advantage of the purse subsidies, which were funded by the state’s 11 non-racing casinos at a time when the issue of slots at tracks was being seriously considered by the state legislature. That concept came to fruition when racetrack gaming was passed in April 2007, and in a little over a year, both tracks had slots. In exchange, the subsidies were phased out in 2008, by which time about $290 million had been paid to the Thoroughbred, Standardbred, and Quarter Horse industries, according to the Indiana Horse Racing Commission.

Thoroughbred purses in Indiana in 2009 were an estimated $20.8 million over 125 dates, according to The Jockey Club, up from $3 million in 1995 and $11.2 million in 2003. In 2009, racino slot revenue allocations accounted for a whopping $16.2 million of those purses, or some 80 percent, according to the commission website.

“I was here the year [Hoosier] opened, and maidens ran for $12,000,” said Richard Kohnhorst, a longtime Kentucky trainer who began shifting his emphasis toward Indiana in 2003 and was the leading trainer at the 63-day meet at Indiana Downs earlier this year. “They’ve had that beautiful facelift in the clubhouse at Hoosier, and now maiden races are $35,000 and still on the way up. There’s a future here.”

Hoosier Park, now wholly owned by Centaur, is not picturesque. Its backdrop is plain and its infield lake would not remind anyone of, say, Gulfstream Park or Saratoga. The stable area is drab and paved, and unlike the grounds at Churchill or Keeneland, there are no spacious grasslands for grazing a horse. Light stanchions for night racing encircle the track and do nothing for aesthetics, at least in the light of day. With only a seven-furlong, bullring-type oval and no turf course, there are some unmistakable second-tier aspects to a racing facility best described as spartan but adequate.

But step inside the building, where slots money has afforded nearly every upgrade, and the place is impressive. It is shiny and spotless, high-tech and hip, with good food, friendly staff, and synergies between the casino and racetrack to encourage cross-over among customers.

At Indiana Downs, a lavish steakhouse tucked away in a quiet corner and a glitzy circular sports bar are main features of the casino area, which has more of a physical separation from the racing plant than Hoosier does.

Slots opponents within the racing industry argue that, at some point, racinos will wake up and realize that their racing operations are a drag and no longer worth being carried by the more profitable casino. But the law rules out such a scenario at Indiana tracks, according to Joe Gorajec, executive director of the Indiana Horse Racing Commission.

“Indiana is the only racino state that provides both statutory minimums and maximums for live race dates,” Gorajec said. “One reason Indiana racinos stand out is the commitment to the racing program. Horse racing is an integral part of the operation – not just a necessary sideshow.”

Jeff Smith has been a first-hand witness to the best of times in both Kentucky and Indiana. Smith was a young staffer under Churchill president Lynn Stone in 1983, when, as Smith recalled, future track president Tom Meeker “was still the house attorney.” Smith continued in various roles for Churchill, including helping to oversee the early development of Hoosier, until 2001, when he became full-time at Hoosier, where he is now the general manager of racing.

Smith saw Kentucky racing rejuvenated by the introduction of interstate simulcasting in the early 1990s, with surging purses making Keeneland and Churchill major powers on the national racing scene. Similarly, he has seen Indiana racing thrive with the help of slots. He believes the changing face of racing in this region to be primarily a function of politics.

“We still have a close business relationship with Churchill,” Smith said between greeting a steady flow of smiling faces on Indiana Derby Day. “They sell our simulcast signal and conduct business with us on a number of levels. They’re going through some very tough times.

Gaming has been a pretty big equalizer for us, obviously, and from a personal standpoint, it’s been extremely gratifying to see the growth we’ve undergone here at Hoosier Park.”

Last winter, Smith seized an opportunity to hire Greely, who grew up in Lexington as the son of retired Keeneland president Bill Greely and the nephew of owner-breeder J.J. Greely of Wintergreen Farm. Kevin Greely, 46, had been a racing official in his home state since his early 20s before going overseas to Dubai to work for 11 years in various capacities for the Emirates Racing Association. He returned to America to work for four seasons (2006-09) as racing secretary at Arlington Park in Illinois.

“We have a mandate to improve the quality of racing and the industry in this state,” Greely said, “and that’s what I’m here to help out with.”

That Smith and Greely – both well regarded in industry circles – have switched sides, so to speak, seems to say plenty about how Indiana has been able to attract a higher caliber of horses, trainers, jockeys, and racing officials.

Tom Amoss and his wife, Colleen, have made their primary residence in Louisville for 16 years, where they have raised their two daughters. Since his first year of training in 1987, horses sent out by Amoss, 48, have won more than 2,300 races and $60 million in purses, mostly while he traveled a circuit of Fair Grounds in his native New Orleans in the winter and Kentucky at other times of year.

In increasing measures, instead of racing at Kentucky tracks, Amoss has been running horses at Hoosier, where through Sunday he was the leading trainer with 21 wins from 55 starters at a meet that began July 30 and runs through Oct. 24. In 2009 and 2010, Amoss has had a combined 194 starters at Hoosier and Indiana Downs while in the nine previous years (2000-08), Amoss ran only eight starters in the state.

“It’s a very interesting time for trainers in Kentucky, particularly myself,” Amoss said. “My second daughter is a senior in high school in Louisville, and she’s the last child we have in the house. After she graduates in May, the ties that bind us to Louisville are going to be gone. I don’t say that with any great pleasure. Louisville has been a great place to raise a family, and I love the idea of racing at Keeneland and Churchill. But a wise businessman goes to the place where he can make the best living.”

Ben Huffman, racing secretary at Churchill and Keeneland, said he has no quantifiable evidence that Hoosier and Indiana Downs are luring horses and horsemen away “other than it’s become very obvious that many of our trainers are racing more and more up there,” he said. “We’re going to have to put our heads together in this state and try to slow this thing down.”

Amoss is not alone among trainers with deep local roots in Kentucky who have largely abandoned racing there during certain times of the year. They include David Banks, Buff Bradley, Bernie Flint, Greg Foley, Paul McGee, and Rob O’Connor.

“You just can’t make enough money in the winter at Turfway to justify sticking around,” said Bradley, who last winter took his stable to Gulfstream for the first time.

“There’s no doubt about it – Indiana Downs and Hoosier are very competitive with Kentucky right now, and it’s changing the landscape of racing in the Midwest,” Amoss said. “In August and September, it’s the best racing around here – better than Arlington, Ellis, and Turfway. It’s no secret anymore.”

In Kentucky, the state legislature has refused to approve alternative gaming at tracks, with Senate president David Williams, a Republican from the rural town of Burkesville, at the forefront of the opposition. Williams, the racing industry’s arch-villain, regularly invokes the moral issues involved in expanded gaming while insisting that the industry should be able to succeed on its own longstanding merits.

Wagering handle has fallen steadily and purses have been stagnant or cut at all Kentucky tracks in recent years while race dates have been reduced at all but Keeneland. Total purses in Kentucky dropped from an estimated $81.7 million in 2007 to $67.8 million in 2009, the lowest figure since 1994, according to The Jockey Club. The once-proud Kentucky Cup series was canceled this fall at Turfway. Churchill recently announced it is closing its 500-stall Trackside training facility for the winter because of the costs. In addition, earlier this week Churchill announced Churchill Downs Entertainment, its live-music unit, will be dissolved and that 64 jobs will be cut from its online gambling companies.

Sen. Williams and his proponents argue against slots for state racetracks, pointing out that Churchill has the almighty Kentucky Derby and has invested heavily in nonracing ventures. Keeneland, with its normally lucrative horse sales and boutique race meets with high purses, is a non-profit association and shielded somewhat from competitive forces.

But Ellis and Turfway are both “hanging by a thread,” said Marty Maline, the executive director of the Kentucky division of the Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association. Maline echoes what the top brass at both tracks – Ron Geary, the owner of Ellis, and Bob Elliston, president of Turfway – have been saying for years. Geary has threatened on at least two occasions to permanently close Ellis, only to relent, albeit by running considerably fewer dates. The 2009 and 2010 Ellis meets were cut to 28 and 27 days, respectively, down from the 48 or so that had been customary. The nearly 60 percent decline in race days at Ellis from 2008 to 2009 compares with an average national decline of 2.6 percent from 2008 to 2009 and 7.4 percent so far this year from 2009

“Year after year, we in the industry all spend a tremendous amount of time and money trying to sell this legislature on what is needed, but it seems like we just hit one roadblock after another,” Maline said. “It’s frustrating beyond words.”

Rogers Beasley, director of racing at Keeneland, said the fall meet at Keeneland will not be affected to a great degree by racing at Hoosier but acknowledged declines in the racing and breeding industry in Kentucky. “It’s all pretty frightening,” he said.

In autumns past, Hall of Fame trainer Bob Baffert was a perennial key player in the Kentucky Cup series at Turfway when shipping star horses such as Silver Charm, Captain Steve, Point Given, and Vindication to the northern Kentucky track from his southern California base. Turfway officials gladly catered to Baffert and other such nationally recognized racing personalities, knowing the presence of their horses enhanced the stature and reputation of their event.

But last Saturday, while Turfway ran a steady diet of low-level claiming races one week after what would have been Kentucky Cup Day had it not been canceled, Baffert was front and center in the Homestretch Steakhouse dining room at Hoosier, where he not only won the $500,000 Indiana Derby with Lookin At Lucky, but also the $200,000 Indiana Oaks with Always a Princess.

Seated near the three partners who co-own his latest stable star, Lookin At Lucky, Baffert was on hand throughout the afternoon, making an in-house television appearance while chatting up well-wishers and passersby. The room was jammed with horsemen, local dignitaries, and horseplayers, including a charter bus of high rollers from the Twin Spires program who had traveled for the day from Louisville.

Mike Pegram is the most well known of the Lookin At Lucky owners, having previously raced horses such as Real Quiet, Silverbulletday, and Captain Steve under the same red and gold silks carried to victory by Lookin At Lucky. Pegram is a native of Princeton, Ind., in the southern part of the state, and thereby comes by his pride in Indiana naturally.

“This is a great day for Hoosier Park,” said Pegram, who professes an abiding love for Kentucky, having won the 1998 Kentucky Derby with Real Quiet. “It’s good to see them doing so well.”

Officials at Hoosier, where admission is free, estimated on-site attendance last Saturday at 12,000 to 13,000, which publicity director Tammy Knox said is a track record. But even with the big crowd, a 14-race card, and all the national interest in Lookin At Lucky, the all-sources handle was just $2,676,618, the second-largest in track history – but not even half of what Keeneland or Churchill might handle on a typical 10-race Saturday card.

Clearly, the racino business model has rendered moot the cyclical racetrack maxim that good horses beget large handle, which begets big purses, which draw good horses, and back around again. Hoosier and Indiana Downs still are not major draws in the national simulcast market, but the ripple effect of their slots-fueled purses – like all North American racinos – are being felt in enormous ways in neighboring areas.

“I always like coming to Kentucky,” Baffert said. “Everybody knows that. But you’ve got to follow the money, man.”

A handful of positive tests for a drug that mimics the effects of steroids by building muscle mass have been turning up across the country, and with four cases in Louisiana, the state racing commission has proposed some rule changes to address what it calls an “emerging trend.”

The drug is ractopamine, and it is the active ingredient in “finishing” feed supplements used to bulk up swine in the weeks before they head to the show ring or slaughter. It is not a steroid, but as a repartitioning agent it helps keep nutrients from going into fat stores so as to enhance muscle mass. Ractopamine is approved by the government for use in swine, but not horses.

Since 2005, there have been nine ractopamine positives nationally, with eight of those cases since 2009, said Ed Martin, president of the Association of Racing Commissioners International, which has long tracked the drug in its role as a trade association for state regulators.

“It didn’t show up for years, then it started popping up in a few incidences,” Martin said.

Martin said the positives, which only count closed cases, have come in California, Louisiana, Minnesota, New Jersey and New Mexico.

The RCI lists ractopamine as a Category 3 drug, or drugs that may or may not have a therapeutic use in horses and may have the potential to affect performance. The RCI’s recommended penalty for ractopamine, in the absence of mitigating circumstances, is a trainer suspension of one to three years and a fine of $10,000 or 10 percent of the purse, whichever is greater.

“The recommended penalty is the harshest penalty because this is a substance that has no business being in the horse,” Martin said. “What we believe is happening since the prohibition of anabolic steroids is that some people are looking to this, which is a feed supplement to swine, which we interpret as a move to cheat.”

Louisiana has adjudicated two ractopamine cases and has two pending, according to Barker. The Louisiana Racing Commission is seeking to add a clause to its rules that prohibits possession of “any feed products containing drugs not otherwise and expressly approved for use in race horses.”

Final approvals for the Louisiana rule changes could take up to six months, with the state commission having taken the first step by adopting them for proposal.

“The Louisiana Racing Commission was very proactive,” Barker said, noting it contacted the Food and Drug Administration and got advice on how ractopamine is being sold and used in Louisiana.

Trainer Terry Vance had Louisiana’s first ractopamine positive in December, and while he does not dispute he fed the horse a product containing the drug, the mitigating circumstances he brought forward in an appeal led the commission to reduce his suspension from six months to 60 days.

“The reason I went before the commission was I was just buying this stuff as a feed additive for weight gain for horses, horses I couldn’t kept weight on,” Vance said. “A number of people were feeding it. It was word of mouth. I was buying it over the counter at the local feed store. I wasn’t trying to get around anybody. I didn’t know any different at the time.”

Vance said when he learned of the positive test, he and his veterinarian went through the different feed supplements in his stable.

“We had to do some digging to see where this stuff came from,” Vance said. “It was in a product I was feeding called Explode.”

Ractopamine is the active ingredient in Paylean, which is in some “finishing” products including Explode. Vance said he has stopped feeding the product, which he said costs about $25 for a 25-pound bag.

Oklahoma has not had a positive for ractopamine, but regulators have heard about instances in other states in which feed for horses has been contaminated by products containing the drug. It adds to the complexity of the issue.

“I’ve heard that feed mills have already been seen to cause a problem by using Paylean one day and making some sweet feed product the next day for equine,” said Tino Rieger, the executive director for the Oklahoma Racing Commission. “If they don’t clean their machinery efficiently enough, all of the sudden you have some contamination, and that contamination is completely unbeknownst to the trainer, and all of the sudden he’s got a potential violation.”

But Rieger said there are horsemen who will deliberately use ractopamine for its steroid-like qualities and he has been closely following the drug, as well as the emergence of zilpaterol, a similar drug for cattle. Rieger said he first heard of ractopamine during the spring of 2009.

“We have aggressively looked for the drug in samples for more than a year now, more like a year and a half, and we have not seen one hit in Oklahoma,” he said. “There are a few of our folks out there that will take a shot, and hopefully, we can catch them. That’s the purpose of extensive drug testing.”

The popular affair graciously hosted by Ron and Linda Geary and held at their palatial home in Louisville, Kentucky, attracted a host of friends and supporters from throughout the state and especially from the 36th district. “It was our extreme pleasure to host Rick’s inaugural fundraising event,” commented Ron Geary. “We are confident that this will serve as a catalyst to successfully launch Rick’s bid to become our next senator representing the people of the 36th district.”

The lawn leading to the entrance of the home was conspicuously adorned with “I Pick Rick” and “Rick Hiles for State Senate” signs and the large throng of supporters were enthusiastically greeted by Rick and Ron as they entered the house.

“I am both humbled and excited by the number of people who have attended to show their support for my candidacy,” Rick stated. “We are in this together and I believe with hard work and dedication we will be successful.”

Rick and Ron took time to thank everyone who attended and thanked their wives Gina Hiles and Linda Geary for their efforts in assuring that it would be a successful event.

“The people of the 36th district need someone serving as their Senator to be accessible and willing to listen to their concerns. I am that person,” Rick stated to the cheering crowd chanting “I Pick Rick.”

Q-Rick why have you decided to run for the State Senate.

A-Actually, there are several reasons. All my life I have been willing to invest the time and effort necessary to make things just a little better for myself and others. I enlisted in the Air Force and proudly served during the Viet Nam conflict. Fast Forward several years, after establishing my career as a thoroughbred horse trainer, I decided to become involved with the KHBPA. I felt that perhaps I could provide some assistance in the governance of the organization that impacts the lives of so many people. I have served in various capacities with the KHBPA for several years as a Director, Vice President, and President. I have volunteered my time because I believe I can make a difference and assure that horsemen are treated fairly and receive an equitable share of wagering revenues. Also, I have been appointed by two Governors of Kentucky to the Equine Drug and Research Commission and I am the Vice Chairman of the Kentucky Racing Health and Welfare Fund developed to provide medical benefits for needy individuals on the backstretch. In addition, I have also served a term as the National HBPA President representing the interest of 40,000 horsemen nationwide.

I have now accepted the challenge to run for Kentucky State Senate. It is time that the people begin to take back our government. Legislators like my opponent have become entrenched in their positions and have lost touch with their constituents. It is interesting as I talk with many people in the district who do not even know her name. Yet they are well aware how far our state has plummeted in both job growth and education.

Q-Do you feel you have a chance to win.

A-Yes, I recognize that my opponent is well funded and is an incumbent, but as I previously mentioned she has lost touch with the interests and concerns of her constituents. I have been to several functions throughout the district and I have listened to the views of many people regarding where the current legislative leadership has taken our great state. Our unemployment is staggering and we continue to languish near the bottom of the entire nation in education. A case in point is the racing industry. It has long been the signature industry of Kentucky, employing nearly 100,000 people and represents a 3 to 4 billion economic benefit to the state of Kentucky yet the state senate refuses to consider efforts which could save the industry. People are ready for change, they are no longer interested in long winded speeches and promises about how legislators are going to make things better, they are interested in seeing results. I will not be intimidated by legislative leadership, I will fight for what I believe is important to the citizens of Kentucky.

Q-How is your election important to the horsemen racing in Kentucky.

A-Kentucky racing is in a freefall. Owners and trainers are vacating the state at an alarming rate or are opting to simply leave the racing industry. Efforts to make our industry competitive have been met with total resistance by senate leadership in Kentucky. There is a movement to end the gridlock that not only threatens the racing industry and the economic development it represents, but also any initiatives that will improve job growth and Kentucky’s stagnant education system. It will take free minded legislators that are not easily intimidated by the intransigence of current senate leadership. I will provide the impetus for change.

I have been appointed to serve on the board of the Equine Drug and Research Council (EDRC) by two Governors of Kentucky and I am proud to be a part of this important oversight committee. The EDRC in addition to determining the amount of research funds that will be expended on various worthwhile projects, we also serve in an advisory capacity to the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission (KHRC) of a broad range of issues affecting Kentucky racing.

Recently, we addressed the KHRC’s attempt at a regulation on out of competition testing. The EDRC had previously discussed this matter and had reached a consensus that the Association of Racing Commissioners International (ARCI)’s model rule specifically addressing doping agents may be something to consider. However, the regulation that the KHRC proposed, was distinctly different from the proposed ARCI model rule. Various therapeutic agents, like for instance stem cells, are prohibited under the present rule. The KHBPA is especially concerned regarding the draconian penalties that are levied against both owners and trainers. Hopefully, by the time this article is published in September we have been successful in helping to restructure the regulation in order that it more closely conforms to the ARCI model rule.

Congratulations to Frank Jones, Vice President of the KHBPA, for his reappointment by Governor Beshear as a Commissioner to the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission. You may recall Frank is the architect behind the electronic foal paper initiative and provides his business acumen and experience as a horse owner to benefit the KHRC for a second term.

Also, Pete Salmen, Director of the KHBPA, has been appointed by Governor Beshear as a member of the Kentucky Thoroughbred Development Fund for another term.

The proposal for instant racing at the racetracks is still being formulated, the Racing Commission has filed litigation to determine the legality of the proposal. Prior to implementation, the racetracks are required to reach an agreement with the KHBPA on the distribution of revenue for purses.

Good luck in your racing endeavors.

Rick Hiles, President KHBPA

One does not have to look very far to find the explanation. The hard evidence is contained in a recent document titled “America’s Top States for Business 2010—A CNBC Special Report.” Following is CNBC’s methodology:

“We scored all 50 states—using publicly available data—on 40 different measures of competitiveness. States received points based on their rankings in each metric. Then, we separated those metrics into the ten broad categories, with input from business groups including the National Association of Manufacturers. We weighted the categories based on how frequently each is cited in state economic development marketing materials.

Here are the ten categories ranked in our study: cost of doing business; workforce; quality of life; economy; transportation & infrastructure; technology & innovation; education; business friendliness; access to capital; cost of living.”

Overall, in 2010, Kentucky ranked 40 out of 50 states, making it one of the most inhospitable jurisdictions to do business. Moreover, the Commonwealth is getting worse rather than improving: it ranked 34th in 2009. While Kentucky did very well on three criteria (cost of doing business, transportation & infrastructure, and cost of living), it ranked mediocre to poorly in the other seven categories.

According to CNBC, Kentucky has an unemployment rate of 10.4 percent, a projected 2011 budget deficit of $780 million, and ranks 37th in education. Kentucky’s elected leaders’ answer to this predicament is apparently to become even more anti-business: On CNBC’s criterion of “business friendliness,” the Commonwealth ranked 39th of 50 states, down from 31st in 2009. The CNBC study defined business friendliness as “the perceived ‘friendliness’ of [a state’s] legal and regulatory frameworks to business.”

It is of little solace to people in the Kentucky horse racing and breeding industry to know that they are not alone in the way state government has treated them—the state’s elected officials, as a group, are hostile to business per se. They are largely inhibitors and destroyers of economic activity, job killers rather than job creators. Reminds me of Green Bay Packers’ right tackle Henry Jordan’s quip about legendary Coach Vince Lombardi: ”He’s fair, he treats us all the same–like dogs.”

Senate President David Williams has been getting too much credit/blame for his antipathy toward racing. Although Williams is culpable, he evidently has plenty of vocal and silent co-conspirators in Kentucky government from both political parties. He did not make Kentucky so anti-business by himself and this kind of negative climate has been generations in the making. Kentucky should have had racetrack slots many years ago, so there is a lot of blame to go around to current and former elected officials in Frankfort. In my research, I can find no other case of where a state government worked against the economic interests of its signature industry.

No doubt the spin out of Frankfort will be that the CNBC report is flawed. Judge for yourself the next time you see that a Kentucky racetrack has cut purses, or read of a trainer moving his or her stable to a racino venue, or see that a stallion is being relocated from Lexington to another state with better incentives.

By the way, two other historically prominent but currently troubled racing states–New York and California—rank 45th and 49th, respectively, on “business friendliness.”

Copyright © 2010 Horse Racing Business

Friends of Rick Hiles – Democratic Candidate

in the general election on November 2, 2010

for Kentucky State Senator in

Jefferson County – Senate District 36

Hosted by:
Ron and Linda Geary
Corey and Debbee Johnsen
Nelson and Judy Clemmens
D. Wayne Lukas
Frank Jones

Thursday, July 29, 2010
5:30 p.m. – 8:00 p.m.

At the home of Ron and Linda Geary

603 Flat Rock Road
Louisville, Kentucky 40245

RSVP at 502-244-5393
or email campaign@hilesforsenate.com

Suggested contributions of $100 per person
Up to a maximum of $1,000

Please make contributions payable to:
Rick Hiles for State Senate

Paid for by Rick Hiles for State Senate
Douglas E. Morris, CPA/Treasuer
9300 Shelbyville Road
Suite 1100
Louisville, KY 40222
www.hilesforsenate.com

Industry representatives the weekend of July 10 indicated movement regarding Instant Racing, legislation for which died in the Republican-controlled state Senate in late spring even though the office of the Democratic attorney general said Instant Racing could move forward with only statutory changes.

Instant Racing machines, offered at two Arkansas racetracks, resemble video lottery terminals but the outcome of games is based on previously run races, which makes them pari-mutuel in nature.

Officials said the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission, which would implement rules for Instant Racing, may address the plan at its next meeting July 20. Democratic Gov. Steve Beshear would have to sign an emergency order should the KHRC pass regulations.

A tax rate, however, would have to be set by the state legislature. Some expressed concern over talk of the state wanting to take twice the amount of revenue the state of Arkansas receives from Instant Racing, which in Kentucky was introduced as a way to increase purses and breed development funds.

The devices haven’t been tested in a crowded gambling market, so revenue projections for Kentucky tracks are sketchy. A hefty tax rate could keep tracks from building facilities to accommodate Instant Racing, officials said.

“We heard (Instant Racing is in the mix), and we also heard the state wants to over-tax it,” trainer William “Buff” Bradley said July 10 at Ellis Park. “We’ll just have to wait until something happens.”

“I can’t help but think that in a Democratic form of government, the legislature will hear the wishes of the people and see that its signature industry is fading away,” Ellis Park owner Ron Geary said. “But I always try to be realistic. It’s really hard to handicap.”

When legislation authorizing racetrack video lottery terminals made no headway in the General Assembly earlier this year, and Instant Racing was torpedoed later in the session, there was speculation little if anything would happen the rest of 2010. Action on Instant Racing, as well as a look at pari-mutuel statutes, could change that.

Republican Sen. Damon Thayer said July 11 proposed legislation has the working title “Horse Racing Reform Act of 2011.”

“I am reviewing all the statutes affecting racing in Kentucky and considering reforms that could help the industry,” Thayer said. “A potential bill could include some of the elements the Senate passed this year, like (advance deposit wagering) reporting and transparency, as well as changes to Kentucky Thoroughbred Development Fund eligibility that would allow funds to be used for claiming races.”

Thayer said he met with David Switzer, executive director of the Kentucky Thoroughbred Association, to seek input. The KTA, he said, has formed a working group to offer suggestions and ideas.

Thus far there has been no public discussion about the prospects for racetrack VLTs in 2011, which will feature a gubernatorial election in Kentucky.

Surprises at Ellis Park

The racing opening weekend at Ellis Park, located about three hours west of Lexington, caught some by surprise. Purses averaged $176,000 over two days, while average field size was 9.63, according to The Jockey Club Information Systems.

Also-eligible lists and excluded horses were common when entries were drawn. Most of the higher-level maiden and allowance races filled.

“We’re pleasantly surprised based on the Churchill Downs meet and the problems they had filling races,” Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association executive director Marty Maline said. “I think our cheaper races and turf races will work really well as long as the turf course holds up.”

Geary, who purchased Ellis Park from Churchill Downs Inc. in 2006, credited racing secretary Dan Bork for the early success.

“We’ve had total cooperation across the state of Kentucky,” Geary said. “Dan has been monitoring it and said a lot of Kentucky trainers are going to leave some horses here to take advantage of the good purses. I’m optimistic now, and usually I’m pretty guarded.”

With Indiana Downs and its turf course ending its Thoroughbred meet July 14, Ellis Park will catch a break before Hoosier Park in Indiana opens July 30 to overlap the rest of the Ellis Park meet through Labor Day. But Ellis Park has a turf course; Hoosier Park does not.

Geary said cutting live racing days in half to 27 last year was out of “desperation,” but proved a success, so he requested a similar schedule for 2010. He currently plans to apply for 2011 dates, but isn’t sure how many.

Ellis Park benefited from a 2009 purse underpayment of a couple hundred thousand dollars, money that helped increase purses for 2010. Geary said the shutdown of full-card simulcasts saved operating costs and is part of the survival plan even though the track generates no off-season purse revenue and would rather not lay off more than 70 employees.

The track will close Sept. 30 and probably not reopen until spring of 2011.

“It worked out to be a good plan—better than we thought,” Geary said. “A good portion of our purses comes from live handle. Anymore, our simulcast handle is not a major contributor to purses. Long-term it’s not going to get us there, but it gives us a chance for survival down the road.”

Maline said the Ellis Park shutdown, approved by the KHRC, took about $200,000 in purse money out of the mix for the Turfway winter/spring meet. He said when full-card simulcasts became law in 1994, the revenue splits were predicated on all tracks being open year-round and contributing to purses.

“It really can’t work unless everybody is rowing in the same direction,” Maline said.

Ongoing Turfway Park concerns

Maline said horsemen are dealing with the fallout from the July 6 announcement that Turfway Park has eliminated this year’s Kentucky Cup Day of Champions to save $400,000 that will go to maintain overnight purses at about $125,000 a day. A cutback to four days of live racing from five for the late summer-early fall meet wasn’t unexpected.

“The problem is the purse structure up there,” Maline said. “When it was formed, the idea was for breeders to help sponsor Kentucky Cup. When simulcasting was new in Kentucky, purses averaged $250,000 a day at Turfway, so we were able to sustain the purses without sponsorships.

“The day-in and day-out horsemen saw themselves losing several hundred thousand dollars in purses. Last year it almost looked like we’d have to cut purses after Kentucky Cup.”

Bradley, a member of the Kentucky HBPA board of directors, called the Turfway situation “depressing.” He will race in Kentucky through the fall, then probably ship to South Florida like he did last winter.

“It’s hard to believe Kentucky’s signature industry is in so much trouble and we don’t see anybody (doing anything to help it),” said Bradley, whose father, Fred, was a Kentucky lawmaker in the 1980s. “Someone needs to take control of this.

“You can’t have a whole stable and run across the board (with horses at various levels) in Kentucky anymore. We’ve got to look at the whole picture of Kentucky racing. People are trying out different circuits (with tracks that have purses aided by gaming revenue) to experiment, but at some point, they’ll leave Kentucky entirely.

“We really need a year-round circuit to keep everyone in the state.”

Turfway president Bob Elliston said the combination of a purse overpayment necessitated by four-day weeks in March and a 17% decline in full-card simulcast handle created problems for the upcoming meet, which runs through early October. Elliston indicated, however, the horse population should be sufficient.

“What the quality of the racing will be, I don’t know,” he said. “We’ll probably have to card more claiming races than we would prefer to see, but there are a good number of Kentucky-bred horses in proximity to us when they come back to prepare for the Keeneland and Churchill meets.”

Longtime owner Mike Bruder, who has reduced his stable from more than 20 horses to less than 10, said he ships horses to Indiana Downs and Presque Isle Downs in Pennsylvania whenever they can get in races because of the purse structures. Years ago, he raced predominantly in the Bluegrass State.

“If they don’t get alternative gaming in Kentucky, put a fork in it,” Bruder said. “This place is in dire straits, and Turfway is in dire straits. Until the legislators in Kentucky come up to the plate, it’s going to be like a rollercoaster going downhill without any breaks.”

Said Geary, who is a tad more optimistic this year: “As a Kentuckian, never in my wildest dreams did I think the Kentucky legislature would turn its back on the horse industry. That being said, it doesn’t mean we can’t find a way to make it work.”

Among the casualties is the entire Kentucky Cup Day of Champions card, which has produced the winners of seven Breeders’ Cup races. The Kentucky Cup was reduced to three stakes in 2009 — the Grade II Classic, Grade III Distaff and Grade III Sprint — after its two 2-year-old races were dropped.

The winner of last year’s Classic, Furthest Land, went on to win the $1million Breeders’ Cup Dirt Mile.

“It’s just another blow to Kentucky racing,” said Mike Maker, who trains Furthest Land. “That’s terrible.”

Maker has won more races in Kentucky than any trainer, but he said that cuts in race days and purses at Kentucky tracks could make him reconsider where he races.

The only fall stakes that will be run is the $100,000, Grade III Turfway Park Fall Championship. That 1½-mile race is part of the Breeders’ Cup Challenge “win-and-you’re in” stakes, and its winner automatically qualifies for the Breeders’ Cup Marathon field.

The Kentucky Horse Racing Commission will review the track’s planned cuts at its July20 meeting. If the commission approves them, which is almost a certainty, Turfway will run Thursday through Sunday Sept.9 through Oct.3, with 16 cards instead of the previously scheduled 20.

The track also has asked to move its fall post times on Thursday and Friday to 5:30p.m. instead of 7p.m.

“It’s unfortunate, but that’s what we’re about now: cutting days,” said Marty Maline, executive director of the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent & Protective Association.

“If we lose Turfway, for all intents and purposes, we lose Kentucky racing from the standpoint of a circuit,” he said. “It’s barely viable now. But we will lose so many of our horsemen who are forced to make other arrangements. … It’s almost not ‘if’ anymore but ‘when’ we lose it. That’s what’s scary.

Elliston said eliminating Wednesdays and moving the $400,000 from the Kentucky Cup races into non-stakes races will allow the track to average about $125,000 a day in purses. That’s the same as 2009 and 2008, which he said were the lowest since whole-card simulcasting began in the early 1990s.

Indiana Downs’ purses are about double those offered by Turfway after a recent 30percent purse increase, Elliston said. While Indiana Downs closes next week, Turfway will face competition from Hoosier Park, whose purses should be similar to those of Indiana Downs.

Both Indiana tracks have purses enhanced by video slots.

“It’s just extraordinary how they’ve managed to use alternative-gaming supplements to support their purse program, like West Virginia Derby did before, like Pennsylvania did before,” Elliston said in a phone interview. “So here we find ourselves having to maintain a level that’s not even competitive, honestly.”

Elliston noted that every track in the state has made cuts, including Churchill Downs from a five- to four-day race week in the spring, Ellis Park racing three days a week and Keeneland cutting more than $1million out of its fall purses.

The Kentucky Cup was created in 1994 by former track owner Jerry Carroll. The first year, Preakness and Belmont winner Tabasco Cat beat a field that included future Hall of Famer Best Pal in the Classic. The purse for the Classic got as high as $500,000 before being gradually cut to $200,000 last year.

KC Classic winners included Derby and Belmont winner Thunder Gulch and Derby and Preakness winner Silver Charm (in a dead-heat).

MEMORANDUM

TO: Ky. HBPA President and Board of Directors
FROM: Marty Maline
RE: Starving horses

On Thursday, March 18, 2010, Mike Bruder and I travelled to the Vanderburgh County 4-H center where we viewed, first hand, the horses recently confiscated from a farm in Evansville, Indiana, and donated a check from the KHBPA to assist the care and feeding of the horses.

Having viewed the aftermath of three fires and a tornado and the devastation they caused I felt I was prepared to deal with what Mike and I were about to witness. I was terribly wrong.

The appalling physical condition of the eighteen horses was beyond comprehension and you wonder how anyone would allow this to happen.

There were two very young horses suspected to be near six months old, yet their body weight was closer to a foal of two months of age. One of the young horses, due to his lack of proper nutrition, had one leg that appeared to be useless and would probably not survive.

Another horse was suffering from some type of fungus that had literally eaten away the hide on his back. Several of the horses are in danger of losing their feet. Many were emaciated and very weak. Manure was caked on their fur so thick and so close to the skin that in order to cut it off would require cutting into the skin. A halter was embedded into one of the broodmare’s neck, yet it could not be sutured due to the danger of infection from the manure.

One young filly had experienced numerous episodes with colic and is not expected to live. Yet she struggled to her feet and on very unsteady legs walked over to me and nudged my hand.

Several horses had only stubs for tails since the others had eaten them for the little amount of food it provided. The broodmares are in foal, but the babies are expected to be born dead since all of the mares are skin and bones and not capable of providing any type of nutrition to the foals they are carrying.

The people caring for the horses are volunteers and they are in need of help. People are donating bedding and some feed, but for eighteen horses the need is great. Mary, one of the ladies, explained that they are using poultice on many of the horse’s legs in an attempt to draw out the fluid collecting there. Yet the cost is nearly forty dollars per pail. Apparently, the swelling is due to the fact that most of the horse’s kidneys are not functioning correctly, instead of urine flushing waste from their systems the flow is white like condensed milk.

They estimated that many of the horses when recovered from the farm were approximately two weeks away from dying from starvation.

People interested in donating to the horse’s valiant effort to survive can be mailed or dropped off to:
Animal Care and Control
Attn: Spirit Medical Fund
815 Uhlhorn Street
Evansville, Indiana 47710-2729

The second meeting of the Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee for the 2010 Winter/Spring race meeting was held on Friday, March 5, 2010.

Robert Elliston, President; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Cliff Brown, Plant Engineer; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent, attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Dave England and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

IGNORING BARRICADES-It has been reported that people are driving down the main road during training hours ignoring the barricades. Besides endangering people and horses going back and forth to the racetrack, it is also against the rules. Security will be closely monitoring this situation and anyone violating the track policy will be brought before the stewards for disciplinary action.

ELECTRICAL ISSUES IN BARN 15-Chip reported that Mayer’s electric has repaired the breaker box that had created concern to horsemen in the barn.

OFFICE SPACE-Due to the replacement of the furnace in the administration building, the office originally occupied by representatives of the Kentucky Racing Health and Welfare Fund (KRHWF), the Thoroughbred Addiction Council of Kentucky (TACK) and the Horsemen’s Retirement Fund is now housing the heating unit. Chip explained that the Clocker’s office will be moved and office space will be available in his old office. They will see that the equipment presently in his office will be moved.

METAL FOUND ON THE RACETRACK-Jeff explained that the two small pieces of metal found in the chute at the quarter pole were portions of two teeth that dislodged from track equipment. He explained that it was an isolated event and was by no means a common occurring event.

HORSE PATH-Chip reported that security continues to monitor vehicle traffic on the horse path and violators have been admonished and repeated events may lead to exclusion from the backstretch.

TRAINING IN THE AFTERNOONS-Turfway Park and the Horsemen’s Committee agreed that no training should take place in the afternoon. It may create a dangerous situation and will not be tolerated. Training will only be allowed during training hours.

TRACK KITCHEN-A discussion ensued regarding the track kitchen. Specifically, the fact that rent was increased appreciably. Therefore, prices for food have been increased and hours of operation reduced. Bob Elliston explained that rent has not been increased in twenty-five years and Turfway expects that the kitchen operation will not be drastically changed.

PURSE STATUS-Currently the purse account is overpaid approximately $50,000 as compared to $40,000 underpaid last year which is a $90,000 difference. Bob Elliston explained that out of state simulcasting of Turfway’s signal is up 19% due to the large fields. On track and in state simulcasting to the other Kentucky racetracks has been decidedly reduced. He further explained that by not sending to Ellis Park, Turfway Park’s revenue for purses and Ellis Park’s revenue for purses is down approximately $200,000 at both locations.

POTHOLE DETAIL-Cliff reported that approximately 100 holes have been patched but as the weather moderates plenty more work is scheduled to be done. Bill Connelly pointed out some key areas which need attention.

HYDRANTS LEAKING-Cliff explained that they continue to address hydrant issues, he requested that horsemen not tie horses to the hydrant. In one instance, they had to repair a hydrant twice that had been damaged due to being used as a hitching post for a horse.

LEAKING IN BARN 22-Cliff maintains that the issue in barn 22 with water in stalls has been corrected.

LEGISLATIVE UPDATE-Bob Elliston explained that they along with other horsemen’s representatives continue to visit with legislators in an effort to explain to them that help for the horse industry is needed now and without it racing in Kentucky will continue to erode. He appealed to horsemen to, once again, contact your legislators and express your concern.

EQUIBASE-Bob Elliston explained that Equibase will soon have a new program available for horsemen in Kentucky. Once they receive an owner and/or trainer’s e-mail address, they will make Past Performances available for the specific race the horse is in via e-mail. Bob explained that he expects the program to be available for Turfway Park’s Fall race meeting.

Respectfully submitted,

Martin Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The first meeting of the Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee for the 2010 Winter/Spring race meeting was held on Thursday, January 14, 2010.

Robert Elliston, President; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Cliff Brown, Plant Engineer; and Rick Leigh, Director of Racing attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Dave England, Wayne Mogge, Jeff Greenhill, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

1.) LEGISLATIVE UPDATE-Bob Elliston provided a legislative update. He explained that, as reported, he and Kevin Flannery, President, of Churchill Downs met with Senator Damon Thayer regarding his proposed legislation. Both he and Kevin felt it was prudent to meet with Senator Thayer in an effort to review concerns that participants in the Kentucky racing industry have with Damon’s legislation. Specifically, the open bidding process, that may allow another casino interest the opportunity to outbid a racetrack and build a casino in the same county as the racetrack. This will surely cause the demise of the racetrack and thousands of jobs will be lost. In addition, the time lost attempting to pass the constitutional amendment will enable the Ohio casinos to become solidly entrenched. Finally, both Ohio and Indiana will spend millions of dollars to defeat the constitutional amendment in Kentucky. The consensus is that Damon was not swayed to help the racing industry and the thousands of jobs it represents.

2.) PURSE STATUS-The current status of the purse balance is approximately $208,000 overpaid. In 2009 this figure was a $450,000 underpayment. Bob explained that due to the full fields of horses, out of state simulcasting has been very positive. Bob expressed his appreciation to horsemen and jockeys that have braved the frigid conditions thus far to assure full fields without cancellations. In addition, the horsemen’s efforts in opening the ADW markets have proved beneficial. The shortfall is from on track handle and the intertrack wagering at Kentucky’s racetracks. He stated that Turfway has been especially hard hit by Ellis Park’s decision not to open this winter. This is due to the fact that not only does Turfway Park split what is wagered on Turfway Park races, they also receive half of the commissions on wagering from all other simulcasting signals received by Ellis Park like Gulfstream, Fairgrounds, Santa Anita and Oaklawn. By sending to the Indiana OTB in Evansville, Turfway Park only receives a portion that is wagered on Turfway Parks racing signal and not the other racetracks.

3.) PUBLICITY EFFORTS-The committee discussed publicity and advertising in an effort to stimulate on track business. Bob assured the committee that even though they have been incredibly frugal due to the severe economic climate they have not reduced their advertising budget. In addition, they are using Facebook and other means to generate interest in coming to Turfway Park.

4.) INSTANT RACING-In response to a question regarding the instant racing machines that are currently in use at Oaklawn Park, Bob explained that Turfway is exploring every option including the instant racing machines, although he emphasized that they do not produce the same amount of revenue for purses and racetracks that slot machines generate.

5.) SUMMER STABLING-Bob informed the committee that they have no intention of shutting down Turfway Park for summer stabling. He explained that maintaining at least 400 horses on the grounds is essential, but they anticipate that will be accomplished especially since Indiana Downs has limited stabling and being at Turfway Park provides horsemen the option of running at several different locations.

6.) WORK ORDERS-Chip explained that if anyone, after filling out a work order, feels it is not being addressed on a timely basis please call the switch board and ask for him.

7.) RACING SURFACE-Several members of committee expressed confidence in the racetrack since Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendant began using the new piece of equipment called a “cultivator.” Recently, in addition, several jockeys and horsemen have also been complimentary according to Chip.

8.) TRAINING-Chip requested a clarification from the committee on what they might consider a justifiable reason for canceling training. The committee stated that it hinges on weather conditions. They explained that at 5 degrees or below it would probably be appropriate to cancel training. However, they cautioned that if the forecast predicts the next day it is going to be zero degrees, than the 5 degrees may be acceptable. They cautioned that the problem is losing multiple days in succession. A discussion ensued regarding the day that training was rescheduled from 5:00 to 7:00 instead of the normal 6:00 to 10:00. Bob explained that with the impending snowstorm they wanted to give horsemen the opportunity to train. He emphasized that even though the track remained open until the snow actually started falling, the surface was in jeopardy because they did not have the opportunity to properly prepare it. Therefore in the event of a similar situation, horsemen will be required to end training to provide for a suitable amount of time to prepare the track for the snow.

9.)HORSE PATH-The committee expressed anger at the person who repeatedly is driving on the horse path causing ruts that freeze at night and create a dangerous condition to horses using the horse path in the morning. The person responsible is placing their privilege to drive on the backstretch in jeopardy.

10.) GROOM ELITE PROGRAM-Chip explained that the nationally acclaimed groom elite program will be offered at Turfway Park in late February and early March. The program provides an opportunity for grooms and potential candidates to be grooms to improve their horsemanship skills. As the time approaches further information will be provided to anyone interested.

11.) HUMANE EFFORT-Dave England expressed his appreciation to horsemen, Turfway Park, and KHBPA with a special recognition to Jamie Fowler for donating and collecting feed and supplies for the horses that were found starving on a farm in Bethel, Ohio. The effort was a perfect indication of how horsemen come together to help at a time of crisis.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline
Executive Director, KHBPA

The second meeting of the Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee for the 2009 Holiday race meeting was held on Friday, December 18, 2009.

Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Cliff Brown, Plant Engineer, Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; and Rick Leigh, Director of Racing attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Dave England, Wayne Mogge, Jeff Greenhill, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

1.) LIGHTS ON THE BACKSTRETCH-Cliff Brown explained that upon attempting to correct the lights issue near in the vicinity of the receiving barn they became aware that it was actually a wire problem. He is attempting to pull the wire through the conduit underground but so far has been unsuccessful. It may require trenching the area to access the wires. At the present time, he has corrected the problem on a temporary basis. The lights in the parking area that occasionally are not working is due to a timer issue and requires overriding the timer to assure that the lights are on. In response to a question by Dave England regarding the speaker system, Cliff Brown suggested that they will see if it is attributable to the amplifier.

2.) OUTRIDERS-The issue still exists. Horsemen have requested that one outrider be positioned on the backstretch of the racetrack to address problems that occur near that gap. Chip explained that the outriders are of the opinion that when there is a loose horse they work better in tandem. The horsemen’s committee questioned this logic. Chip suggested that he will contact other racetracks to see what protocol they follow.

3.) PURSE STATUS-After a discussion with Cliff Reed, Chief Financial Officer, the previous morning it appears that the December race meeting will end in the vicinity of $200,000 overpaid in purses. He is of the opinion that with the limited days in January and February, hopefully, that can be eliminated. While the reduced race meeting is uncharted waters, so to speak, he is hesitant to suggest that purses will be increased any time soon or that extra days can be added. He did mention that possibly if entries remain strong and that is reflected in more money being wagered perhaps more races can be added on the days that we are racing.

4.) HAY TRUCKS ON THE HORSE PATH-Feed trucks or horse vans maneuvering on the horse path are causing deep ruts which may be dangerous to horses. In an effort to alleviate the problem, Chip suggested that a strongly worded letter will be composed explaining that any van or feed truck found to stray onto the horse path without alerting the guard shack may have their privileges to travel on the backstretch revoked.

5.) ELIMINATING TRAINING ON MONDAYS-The horsemen’s committee agreed to poll horsemen at Turfway Park to determine if it is acceptable not to train on Mondays when the race meeting reduces to three days in January and February. Horsemen committee members emphasized that this is a temporary solution and should not be contemplated as a permanent alternative.

6.) CO 2 TESTING-On occasion, the racing commission veterinarians are cutting it too close and taking blood from horses just as they are ready to leave the barn to race. Rick Leigh expressed the opinion that it is the purview of the stewards to rectify this problem and make sure the veterinarians are taking blood samples within a reasonable amount of time.

7.) POTENTIAL SNOW EMERGENCY-Chip explained that they are well prepared to deal with the inclement weather. Salt has been distributed to the barns and the company responsible for salting and scraping the barn area is prepared. Chip also mentioned additional salt is available to horsemen at the salt pile.

8.) WATER LINE PROJECT-Bill Connelly commented that the water line problem has been satisfactorily corrected. However, the pile of debris left behind is creating a hazard. Cliff Brown assured that the issue will be addressed promptly.

9.) RACING SURFACE-Horsemen have commented that kickback and balling up in the horses feet continue to be significant issues. Jeff commented that they are attempting to address the issues with the cultivator which appeared to work at Woodbine in Canada. In addition, they are in constant communication with the polytrack experts in an effort to alleviate the two issues. He expressed the opinion that watering the track is not a solution especially with temperatures below 32 degrees. In addition, the weight of the water tracks also creates additional problems, but if water turns out to be the only solution, Jeff will contact Keeneland since they have trucks better suited to distribute the weight on the track.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline
Executive Director, KHBPA

The first meeting of the Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee for the 2009 Holiday race meeting was held on Wednesday, December 2, 2009.

Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Cliff Reed, Chief Financial Officer; Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; and Cliff Brown, Plant Engineer attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Dave England, Wayne Mogge, and Marty attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

PURSE STATUS-The committee discussed the state of the purse account comparing last year to this year. In 2008, starting with the Holiday race meeting, the underpayment of horsemen’s purses was $902.000. This year the purse account starting with the Holiday race meeting is $22,500. The question to Cliff Reed, will the purses be maintained at the present level running five days per week and twelve races on Friday? Cliff felt confident that the purse level can be maintained at this level, but he cautioned that there are no guarantees.

OUTRIDERS-Horsemen have asked that one of the outriders be positioned near the gap on the backside of the racetrack. Chip said he would address the situation with the outriders.

RUTS AT THE END OF THE ROAD-The committee requested that the ruts in the vicinity of the horse path at the entrance of the racetrack near the newer barns be smoothed out. Bill Connelly also reminded Jeff that the entire horse path needs to be attended to on a regular basis now that the weather is changing and the possibility of frozen ruts becomes an issue.

LOADING CHUTE-The committee requested that Turfway consider constructing another loading chute in the vicinity of barn 14 which allows plenty of room for vans to maneuver. Chip said he will see if this is a project that can be addressed with Backstretch Improvement Commission funds.

RACING SURFACE-A discussion ensued regarding tilling the surface and the problems it causes. Committee members explained that the degree of change and lack of consistency are the major issues. Jeff explained that he receives several calls about it, but it is absolutely necessary and recommended by the developer of the racing surface. Chip explained that they are attempting to communicate with horsemen to give them advanced notice of when the surface will be tilled. Jeff also mentioned that they have recently purchased a new piece of equipment that the track superintendent at Keeneland highly recommends. It may enable Jeff to till it less and use this equipment more which will not cause the drastic changes in the depth of the track surface.

TRASH CONTAINERS-Chip agreed to make more trash containers available, they just need to know who needs them. One committee member suggested since trash pickup is three days a week the present number should be adequate.

EXTRA HALF HOUR OF TRAINING-Committee members felt that the current 6:00 to 10:00 schedule is appropriate. As far as safety issues, the lights are creating shadows in the morning. Cliff Brown suggested that he will make sure that the lights are working properly.

ESPN CHANNELS ON THE BACKSTRETCH-The committee asked Chip to address the fact that someone in the video room on the front side is constantly switching channels so that people living on the backside are being deprived of seeing ESPN on a regular basis. He said he would look into the situation.

CHRISTMAS PARTY-The annual Christmas party for horsemen and their families will be held on Tuesday, December 8, from six o’clock until eight o’clock on the third floor of the terrace in the grandstand. Dinner will be served at 6:00 and presents will be handed out to children from ages 12 and under starting at 7:30 until 8:00.

SALT BARRELS-The salt barrels will be out and filled with salt by tomorrow.

PROJECTS-Cliff Brown explained that the waterline in the vicinity of barn 19 will be fixed. The walls of the manure bins will be reinforced and the issue of the pothole in the vicinity will be addressed.

Respectfully submitted,

Martin A. Maline
Executive Director KHBPA

Marion County:
-Lebanon
-Loretto

Mercer County:
-Harrodsburg
-Burgin

Nelson County:
-Bardstown
-New Haven
-Bloomfield

Washington County:
-Springfield
-Willisburg

Taylor County:
-Campbellsville

Also, if you are in House District 96, please be sure to get out and vote for that special election as well. Barry Webb is the candidate supportive of the gaming issue in this race. Thank you!

The Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association (KHBPA) unanimously elected Rick Hiles to his second consecutive term as KHBPA President. Rick also was elected as KHBPA president for two terms in the 1990s.

“It is both an honor and privilege to serve horsemen in this capacity,” Rick commented. “We have proactively addressed the ADW issue to assure horsemen an equitable share of the revenue and we will continue our efforts to pursue a slot initiative with the General Assembly.” Rick will also continue his appointment by Governor Beshear as the KHBPA representative to the Kentucky Equine Drug Council.

Frank Jones and Dale Romans were elected by the Board as First and Second Vice Presidents respectively.

Upon Rick’s ascendancy to the position of President, Dave England the first alternate is now a Director.

The Finance Committee consists of Frank Jones, Mike Bruder and Kenny McPeek.

The Benevolence Committee is composed of Ann Banks, Dr. Randy Sheen and Pete Salmen.

The Backstretch Committees are Wm. “Buff” Bradley and Dale Romans at Churchill Downs; Bill Connelly and Dave England at Turfway Park; Mike Bruder and R.L Williams at Ellis Park and Dave Banks and R.C. Sturgeon at the Thoroughbred Horse Center.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

November 23, 2009

The accounting firm of Buschermohle & Company, PSC has certified the election of the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association (KHBPA) Board of Directors.

Owner Directors:

Ann Banks
Mike Bruder
Frank Jones, Jr.
Peter Salmen, Jr.
Dr. Randy Scheen

First Alternate:

Jack Stewart

Owner/Trainer Directors:

William “Buff” Bradley
William Connelly
Rick Hiles
Kenneth McPeek Dale Romans

First Alternate:

Dave England

The first meeting of the newly elected Board of Directors is scheduled for Monday, November 30, 2009. The Board will elect a President.

Trainer or Owner/Trainer Candidates

William “Buff” Bradley
William Connelly
Bert Edwards
David England
Jerry Joe Greenwell
Rick Hiles
Kenneth McPeek
Dale Romans
Jere Smith Jr
R.C. Sturgeon
Keith York

Owner Only Candidates

Ann Banks
Mike Bruder
Nelson Clemmens
Murrell Farmer
Frank Jones Jr
Joan Miller
Dana Ollier
Peter Salmen Jr
Dr. Randy Scheen
Jack Stewart

A meeting of the Turfway Park horsemen’s committee was held on September 18, 2009.

Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Cliff Reed, Chief Financial Officer; Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; and Cliff Brown, Plant Engineer; represented Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Wayne Mogge, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

NTRA SAFETY & INTEGRITY ALLIANCE-Mike Ziegler, Executive Director, of the NTRA Safety & Integrity Alliance accreditation program explained the purpose and significance of their efforts to approve Turfway Park for accreditation.

PURSE STATUS-Cliff Reed reviewed the current status of the purse account as it compares to the Fall race meeting of 2008. In 2008 the race meeting began with an underpayment of $1,342,113. This year in contrast that figure is $515,000. He explained that various issues are involved that have created the drastic difference. We left the 2008 Spring race meeting of 2009 with a sizable overpayment in purses as compared to 2008. The TVG source market fees are appreciably lower, together with a downturn in business have reduced the revenue available for purses.

In response to a question regarding the purse structure for the winter meeting, Cliff explained that he and Bob Elliston will be making projections following the Fall race meeting. At that point they will determine the most reasonable approach for the winter race meeting taking into account the number of days and the purse structure to be offered.

TRACK SURFACE-Jeff Chapman explained the steps including additional wax and carpet fiber added to the track prior to the Fall race meeting. Based on research conducted by Dr. Mick Peterson, and Dr. Phillips the feeling is that this will greatly reduce the problems with kickback and surface sticking to horse’s feet. In addition, Jeff mentioned that it appears that the improved surface requires less maintenance.

WATER LINE ISSUES ON THE BACKSTRETCH-Cliff Brown reviewed the status of water line issues in the barn area. He explained that they are bringing in a backhoe to address the lines that are creating the nuisance. In addition, he discussed his method of resolving the continued clogging of drains in various areas. Chip commented that the projects including wash racks and paving have been completed with the exception of the problem area adjacent to the administration building. Thus far, one car and two entry clerks have disappeared in the vicinity of the mammoth hole.

GARBAGE PICKUP-A discussion ensued regarding the revised system for garbage removal on the backstretch. Committee members remarked that the system actually works well especially with the reminders from the guard shack to get your garbage cans ready. Horsemen having difficulties, they suggested, are probably not aware of the new procedure that garbage cans must be placed next to the main road. If there is confusion, check with other horsemen or track security and they will explain where to locate your can.

RACING PROGRAM AVAILABILITY-The committee requested that the programs be made available earlier than 10:00 each day. Apparently, Ellis Park has the same company making programs, but they were available much earlier. Chip explained that he would see if an earlier time is possible.

MUTUAL CLERK IN HORSEMEN’S HALL-The committee requested that Turfway consider, once again, having a mutual clerk in the recreation hall. It is creating a tremendous hardship on the kitchen proprietor and an inconvenience to horsemen. Chip said that he would explore the idea with Bob Elliston.

WORK ORDER DELAY-Cliff Brown explained that occasionally he must prioritize work orders, but he will do his best to address the problems in a timely manner.

INDIANA “STRANGLES” OUTBREAK-Chip explained that they are in constant communication with the Department of Agriculture and are taking all precautions necessary to assure that the contagious disease does not spread to Turfway Park.

MANURE PICKUP-The committee requested that the company responsible for picking up the manure should attempt to focus on not spilling straw and manure throughout the barn area. It is especially frustrating to the outfits attempting to keep their areas clean. The committee suggested pursuing the purchase of a vacuuming unit similar to Presque Isle that would assist in keeping the barn area clean.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

KHBPA and Turfway Park sign contract extension.

The Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association (KHBPA) agreed to an extension of the purse contract until the end of the 2010 winter/spring race meeting. The contract extension was signed by Rick Hiles, President of the KHBPA, and Bob Elliston, President of Turfway Park on September 1, 2009. The KHBPA has sent the customary letter of consent to simulcast the Turfway Park racing signal to various outlets.

“The KHBPA board felt that a contract extension was the pragmatic approach to the fluid situation that currently exists in Kentucky with regard to the racing industry,” commented Marty Maline, Executive Director of the KHBPA. “We realize that Turfway is in a vary precarious position due to the competition of surrounding racing jurisdictions fueled by slot enriched purses and we encourage horsemen to support racing at Turfway Park by filling the entry box just as they did at Ellis Park.”

• Turfway Park, 10:00 am in the recreation hall on August 26
• The Thoroughbred Center, 10:00 am outside the HBPA office on August 27
• Keeneland, 12:00 pm in the track kitchen on August 27
• Churchill Downs, 10:00 am in the recreation hall on August 28
• Ellis Park, 10:00 am in the picnic area on August 29

Members may also submit a nominating petition with at least 15 signatures. Please contact your local HBPA office with any questions and to obtain a petition or you can get one on our website at www.kyhbpa.org. Thank you!

The second meeting of the 2009 KHBPA/Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee meeting was held on Friday, July 31, 2009.

Attending the meeting representing Ellis Park, Greg Hardt, CFO/Executive Vice President; Bob Jackson, Director of Operations and Dan Bork, Director of Racing.

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee includes Mike Bruder, Chairman, and Marty Maline recorded the minutes.

PURSE STATUS – Greg presented an update and while it has dipped a little the wagering is still strong. Mike Bruder suggested that after monitoring a Friday or two, we should seriously consider a purse raise if the business warrants it. The horsemen who have supported Ellis Park with the limited amount of race days offered should be rewarded for their perseverance.

PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEM – The P.A. system continues to be an issue. Mike suggested that the steward’s should be alerted so that in the event horses are late to the paddock because of not hearing the message they will receive consideration and not be fined.

TVG – Mike requested that Bob impress upon the TVG hierarchy that the horsemen and wagering public are interested in viewing Ellis Park’s races on a more regular basis. Bob explained that, thus far, HRTV has shown a number of the races, but TVG has been somewhat disappointing in their coverage.

HORSEMEN’S PICNIC – The annual KHBPA/Ellis Park horsemen’s picnic is scheduled for Thursday, August 27, 2009.

DRIVING THROUGH BARRICADES – People driving through the barricades early in the morning are endangering horsemen and horses going to and from the track. Monitoring will begin immediately and those violating the policy will be dealt with severely, beginning with a trip to the stewards to explain why they feel they should be entitled to violate this safety policy that has been in place for several years.

WAGERING MACHINES ON THE BACKSIDE – Mike suggested that the self service betting machines should be turned on and available in the room adjacent to the kitchen for horsemen who would like to wager on other tracks on the days that Ellis Park is dark. Bob felt he should be able to get this done.

ENTRIES – Dan Bork requested that horsemen please help by getting the word out that, with Racing Commission approval on Tuesday, we will be racing on Fridays starting on August 7, 2009.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The first meeting of the 2009 KHBPA/Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee meeting was held on Thursday, July 16, 2009.

Attending the meeting representing Ellis Park, Greg Hardt, CFO/Executive Vice President; Mark Geary, Director of Development, Bob Jackson, Director of Operation, and Dan Bork, Director of Racing.

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee includes Mike Bruder, Chairman; R.L. “Bobby” Williams, and Marty Maline recorded the minutes.

MANURE/TRASH PICKUP – Bob Jackson explained that the delay in manure and trash pickup is due to both of the “loaders” being down. He expects the repairs to be completed by today.

P.A. SYSTEM – Cards have been ordered for the amplifiers and are expected to be inserted in the very near future.

STRONG ENTRIES – Dan Bork reported that entries have remained fairly strong, especially entries in the grass races. Regarding running on Fridays during August, he explained that his understanding is that they will review that possibility after assessing how entries go for the next two weeks.

PURSE STATUS – Greg Hardt stated that he has not received the figures necessary to provide an up to date status of the purse account. Marty explained that it is difficult to determine if additional days are appropriate without knowing the status of the purse account. In addition, Mike Bruder requested an update on the underpayment available from the off season. Greg informed the committee that due to the ice storm during the winter which caused Ellis to lose several days of simulcasting and also Churchill Downs cutting back in days, the revenue for purses was significantly decreased from prior years.

HORSE ELECTROCUTED – Marty informed the committee that the HBPA fire and disaster insurance is prepared to pay for the horse that was tragically electrocuted when it bit into a fan cord.

TVG UPDATE – Bob Jackson explained that they still do not have an arrangement with TVG to televise Ellis Park races. Marty stated that the KHBPA President and Board are disappointed that this matter has not been resolved, and he has been instructed to contact TVG in an effort to facilitate a deal. In addition, Bob explained that HRTV, owned in part by Churchill Downs still refuses to show the Ellis Park signal.

HORSEMEN’S PICNIC – There will be a horsemen’s picnic; the date is still to be set.

BREEDER’S CUP – After being informed that the Breeder’s Cup had decided to withdraw funding part of the Ellis Park Turf Stake the KHBPA contacted them. They have agreed to fund $25,000 of the race and the other $25,000 will be funded by the marketing account.

POST TIME CHANGE – Mike Bruder asked about the reasoning behind the earlier post time. Bob explained that it coincides well with other racetracks across the country. In addition, Dan commented that it works well with the number of ship-ins and their interest in getting on the road as soon as possible.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline
Ex. Dir. KHBPA

There is going to be a post-vote rally at the Keeneland Sales Pavilion on Wednesday, June 24, at 6:30pm for all Kentucky Horsemen. Both Governor Steve Beshear and Speaker of the House Greg Stumbo are expected to attend.

Spread the word to everyone you know! Please plan on attending and take whomever you can with you to this important demonstration. We need to show our resolve despite the negative vote from the Senate Appropriations and Revenue Committee Monday evening.

Keeneland is located at 4201 Versailles Road in Lexington. Click for directions.

Kentucky racetrack operators said May 20 the state’s horseracing and breeding industries have reached a critical juncture, and without legislative assistance in the form of on-track gaming, the damage could be irreparable.

Click here to view the full story or copy and paste the following link into your browser: http://news.bloodhorse.com/viewstory.asp?id=50870

BALTIMORE — Chip Woolley says that if it weren’t for legislative action taken in New Mexico a decade ago, he would not have had Mine That Bird to take to — and win — the Kentucky Derby.

In interviews leading up to today’s Preakness Stakes, the trainer frequently called his home state an excellent blueprint for how slot machines at tracks can help the labor-intensive racing and breeding industries.

Woolley said New Mexico’s greatly enhanced purses made it feasible for owners Leonard Blach and Mark Allen to pay $400,000 for Mine That Bird last year. In fact, they purchased the gelding with the $800,000 Sunland Derby in mind.

“In New Mexico the legislature finally gave us slot machines at the racetracks and protected horse racing when they did it,” he said. ” … It has improved our program. I wouldn’t have this horse if it wasn’t for that.

“Churchill just cut purses and cut a day (per week) of racing. That’s terrible. It’s the standard to the industry. So you hate to see that, and hopefully these other places will … stop watching their money leave their state.”

Blach explained that 20 percent of the income from slots at New Mexico tracks goes into purses, with the rest divided among the state, the tracks and the breeding industry.

Woolley’s New Mexico circuit goes from Sunland Park (near El Paso, Texas) to SunRay Park in Farmington (currently racing) to Ruidoso Downs to Zia Park and back to Sunland. There also is racing at the Downs at Albuquerque, and a track is scheduled to open next year in Raton.

Blach says when he arrived in New Mexico in 1972, purses were $800 or $1,200. Now 2-year-old maidens run for $28,000 or $32,000, he said.

“It was hanging by a hair,” he said of New Mexico racing. “Had it not been for slots, we wouldn’t exist right now.”

Blach said all the New Mexico tracks are having Preakness simulcast parties for Mine That Bird.

“The governor called us; he’s making a big deal out of it, too,” he said of Bill Richardson, a former presidential candidate. “It’s really turned that state on. Everybody is excited.”

Woolley said he’s heard from “hundreds” of folks back home — “everybody that does not owe me money,” he joked.

No horse based in New Mexico had ever won the Kentucky Derby before Mine That Bird. In fact, 1998 winner Real Quiet was the first Derby starter to have even raced in that state, going 0 for 2 there.

“I must have watched it 100 times, making sure it was real,” said New Mexico trainer Joel Marr. “Until about the quarter pole, it was just a dream. Then the last 24 seconds it went from a dream to, ‘I think this could happen.’ ”

Marr trained New Mexico-bred Peppers Pride, who won a modern-day-record 19 consecutive races to retire unbeaten last year. He said the program for New Mexico-breds is so lucrative now that it made no sense to race elsewhere.

“I’m extremely proud of what she did … but you kind of had to go look for it to follow it,” he said of Peppers Pride. “Mine That Bird, there was no way around it. Everybody saw it; everybody knows about it. I think it will do more for awareness not just to New Mexico but every smaller jurisdiction in the country. It gives everybody that little taste of, ‘We could do that. Look at them; they did it. We’ve got a shot.’ ”

A major beneficiary is the Sunland Derby, which has tried to achieve graded status for five years. Not only did Mine That Bird finish fourth in the Sunland Derby, but fifth-place Advice went on to win Keeneland’s Grade II Coolmore Lexington before competing in the Derby. Runner-up Mythical Power won the Grade III Lone Star Derby in his next start.

“The people who grade these races have to really take a long look and say, ‘Look, we’ve got to give this a grade,’ ” Woolley said. “They shouldn’t even start as a Grade III; it ought to be a Grade II.”

Sunland and Zia Park offer some of the largest purses in the Southwest at more than $200,000 a day.

Woolley said he expects his gelding to race again in New Mexico someday. SunRay racing director Lonnie Barber said he’d welcome that, “but I’m hoping he’s good enough that he can stay back there with the big boys.”

Woolley said he’s heard from “hundreds” of folks back home — “everybody that does not owe me money,” he joked.

No horse based in New Mexico had ever won the Kentucky Derby before Mine That Bird. In fact, 1998 winner Real Quiet was the first Derby starter to have even raced in that state, going 0 for 2 there.

“I must have watched it 100 times, making sure it was real,” said New Mexico trainer Joel Marr. “Until about the quarter pole, it was just a dream. Then the last 24 seconds it went from a dream to, ‘I think this could happen.’ ”

Marr trained New Mexico-bred Peppers Pride, who won a modern-day-record 19 consecutive races to retire unbeaten last year. He said the program for New Mexico-breds is so lucrative now that it made no sense to race elsewhere.

“I’m extremely proud of what she did … but you kind of had to go look for it to follow it,” he said of Peppers Pride. “Mine That Bird, there was no way around it. Everybody saw it; everybody knows about it. I think it will do more for awareness not just to New Mexico but every smaller jurisdiction in the country. It gives everybody that little taste of, ‘We could do that. Look at them; they did it. We’ve got a shot.’ ”

A major beneficiary is the Sunland Derby, which has tried to achieve graded status for five years. Not only did Mine That Bird finish fourth in the Sunland Derby, but fifth-place Advice went on to win Keeneland’s Grade II Coolmore Lexington before competing in the Derby. Runner-up Mythical Power won the Grade III Lone Star Derby in his next start.

“The people who grade these races have to really take a long look and say, ‘Look, we’ve got to give this a grade,’ ” Woolley said. “They shouldn’t even start as a Grade III; it ought to be a Grade II.”

Sunland and Zia Park offer some of the largest purses in the Southwest at more than $200,000 a day.

Woolley said he expects his gelding to race again in New Mexico someday. SunRay racing director Lonnie Barber said he’d welcome that, “but I’m hoping he’s good enough that he can stay back there with the big boys.”

Jennie Rees can be reached at (502) 582-4042.

LEXINGTON, Ky.—According to the principals of Kentucky’s horse racing tracks, Kentucky’s equine industry is in need of legislative action. Bob Evans, president of Churchill Downs, Nick Nicholson, president and CEO of Keeneland Association, Bob Elliston, president and CEO of Turfway, Ron Geary, owner/president of Ellis Park, Corey Johnsen, president of Kentucky Downs, Rick Hiles, president of Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association, Inc., and David Switzer, executive director of the Kentucky Thoroughbred Association and Kentucky Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders, among others, will be on hand to address current threats to—and possible solutions for—the industry.

WHAT: Press conference on the current state of the equine industry in Kentucky
WHEN: Wednesday, May 20, 2009, at 1:30 p.m.
WHERE: The paddock at Churchill Downs, Louisville, Ky.
WHO: Race track operators and others involved in the equine industry
WHY: Kentucky’s $4 billion equine industry is threatened by enhanced purses and breeding incentive awards in other states.

The final meeting of the Turfway Park horsemen’s committee was held on April 1, 2009.

Bob Elliston, President of Turfway Park; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; Steve Peterman, Starter; and Cliff Brown, Plant Engineer; represented Turfway Park management.

Wm. “Buff” Bradley, Bill Connelly, Wayne Mogge, Jeff Greenhill and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

PURSE STATUS-The total overall handle for the Turfway Park winter/spring race meeting is down 25.1% with the out of state portion of the handle being down 34.2%. This downturn in business has attributed to a severe overpayment in horsemen’s purses. While the TVG source market fee component has yet to be factored in, the estimated overpayment balance still will be significant. The KTDF supplement remains fairly constant when comparing it to last year’s balance.

TRACK SURFACE-Jeff explained that they may be adding additional wax later in the summer and perhaps some additional fiber as part of a reconditioning effort. Bob Elliston informed the committee that Turfway Park is included in an ongoing study of various racing surfaces being conducted by Dr. Mick Peterson and Dr. Wayne McElraith. They are traveling across the country measuring the compaction and compression rates of racing surfaces to determine the biomechanics along with the optimum components necessary to assure a safe race track.

MAINTENANCE PROJECTS-Chip explained that while no major projects have been planned they do intend to refurbish some barns on an as needed basis. The hope is to minimize the inconvenience to horsemen. Bob Elliston informed the committee that there is revenue available with the backside improvement fund and while they are limited perhaps the committee will compose a list of projects that horsemen would like to see addressed.

LEGISLATIVE UPDATE-Bob Elliston explained that it is important for everyone involved in the racing industry to continue efforts to convince members of the General Assembly that racing in Kentucky is under siege by riverboats and racinos in surrounding states. Ellis Park and Kentucky Downs are indicating that they will not be able to run their allotted dates and Turfway Park’s downturn in business is directly related to fewer entries due to competition for horses from Indiana, West Virginia, and Pennsylvania all with higher purses fueled by slot revenue. There is a glimmer of hope that the Governor and members of the Kentucky legislature will decide to address the gaming issue in a special legislative session.

SUMMER STABLING ISSUES:

1.) Training Hours-Training will be from 6:00 until 10:00
2.) Watering policy-Jeff explained that they did not plan to water the track, but they will monitor the situation. Members of the committee explained that the track is much better when wet.
3.) Starting Gate availability-Steve Peterman informed the committee that the starting gate will be open Tuesday through Saturday 7:30-9:30.
4.) Horses shipping in to train-Just as last year the daily charge for each horse shipped in is $15.00. The receiving barn will be barn 22.
5.) Stalls will be allocated by the racing secretary and monitored by Chip and Steve.
6.) Dormitory rooms will be reallocated and inspected to determine who is occupying the dorm rooms.
7.) Moving horses-Chip explained that some barns will be consolidated, but for the most part larger outfits will stay where they are.
8.) Horses not staying for the summer are required to be vacated by April 12, 2009.

GARBAGE PICK UP-The committee suggested a concerted effort to clean up garbage on the backstretch, perhaps a cookout, sponsored by Turfway Park and the KHBPA as an incentive to enlist the help of horsemen and members of the Turfway maintenance staff.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

FRANKFORT — It was just one day, and a makeup day at that. But when Turfway Park canceled its race card Monday due to a lack of entries, it provided a snapshot of racing’s future in Kentucky if lawmakers don’t give the state’s tracks the opportunity to compete with their counterparts around the country.

As Turfway President Bob Elliston noted in announcing the cancellation, the lack of entries stemmed from a very simple reason. “Horses that otherwise would prefer to run in Kentucky, and traditionally did so, are instead racing in jurisdictions where purses are enhanced with revenue from alternative gaming,” Elliston said in a statement.

Read More…

In order to expand Groom Elite’s ability to offer the program to Americans for little or no cost the Groom Elite Program is going to be offered to international trainees for a small tuition and that would be one way to fund the program. Reid McLellan Executive Director and instructor of the Groom Elite, Tommy Azopardi of Texas Horsemen’s Partnership and Remi Bellock Director of the National HBPA realized that it had to be done this way last year.

In order to bring international trainees into the country we applied thru a petition with immigration for 50 H-3 applicants last year and got an approval from (USCIS) immigration, but the consulate in Monterrey Mexico refused to issue the visas to the trainees on the basis that there were for productive employment rather than training. This was around July 2008; it has been an ongoing battle trying to convince them otherwise. Last December the Consulate sent the Kentucky HBPA petition back to immigration with the recommendation to revoke it. Well immigration reaffirmed it (reapproved it) but later said it had made a mistake and sent us a letter questioning our KY petition on the H-3 Visa Motion of Intent to revoke dated Jan 8, 2009 from USCIS that gave us until February 10 to respond.

We had about 30 days to prepare for the response so attorney Will Velie prepared the Legal Brief, Reid McLellan attempted to respond in detail with the week by week 52 week syllabus training information of the Groom Elite Program attached and supplemented this with letters from National and Member HBPA’s as well as universities, International Association letters, Jockey Clubs as well as program graduates and any other dignitaries who will support the fact that this is a training program and not a work program.

Julio Rubio, the Hispanic Services Coordinator for the KYHBPA, had to contact and convince the various International Horsemen’s Associations and Jockey Clubs to sign letters in support of the program. With such a short notice, he was able to get Mexico to sign, as well as the International Race Track Chaplaincy. In total we got Mexico, Uruguay and Jamaica signed on.

Thanks to the coordination from Remi Bellock who is the CEO of the National HBPA and the hard work of immigration attorney Will Velie and his staff with Horsemen Labor Solutions along with the great effort from our affiliates, we were able to get the 147 page Petition Response out in time which should take approximately 30 days to get a response.

Amidst the dire economic picture for both the racing and breeding industry in Kentucky, we received a glimmer of hope with the recent legislative leadership elections in the Kentucky General Assembly. Greg Stumbo is the new Speaker of the House and Larry Clark has retained his position as Speaker Pro Tem. Both Greg and Larry have been strong advocates of the Kentucky’s signature industry. For the first time in many years, through the leadership of Greg and Larry, the legislation HB 158 received a unanimous vote of the members of the House License and Occupations (L&O) Committee. We remain cautiously optimistic that there may be an opportunity to have favorable gaming legislation at the racetracks in Kentucky, if not in this year’s short session, then perhaps in 2010.

For the time being we have reached an agreement with Track Net, Churchill Downs’ advance deposit wagering (ADW) company. It has been a long and protracted struggle, but we feel we have accomplished what we set out to do by restructuring the host fees we receive from the ADW company, broad distribution to all ADW companies, and a source market fee component. A special vote of thanks to the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group (THG). It was through their efforts, raising the awareness of the inequities in the pricing structure involving ADWs and how they inadequately share revenue with both horsemen and racetracks.

I suspect that the ADW issue will be explored more fully by both the Kentucky General Assembly and the Kentucky Racing Commission in the not to distant future.

Our best wishes go out to Bob DeSensi, a KHBPA Director for several years. Bob is on the road to recovery from a very serious illness and operation. He has been a dedicated and impassioned spokesman for horsemen’s rights and it is an honor to serve on the KHBPA board with him.

I have been asked by horsemen to comment about the KHBPA’s position on the jockey fee issue. You may recall that the jockeys have requested a significant increase in losing mount fees. The board felt that, at this juncture, it is prudent to delay discussion on this issue until we see the results of the effort to increase purses through favorable gaming legislation.

Good luck in your racing endeavors.

Rick Hiles
President, KHBPA

A meeting of the Turfway Park horsemen’s committee was held on Friday, February 20, 2009, at Turfway Park.

Those in attendance included Bob Elliston, President of Turfway Park; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Rick Leigh, Director of Racing; Steve Peterman, Starter; Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; and Jim Pendergast, Polytrack expert.

Track Committee members in attendance included, Bill Connelly, Wm. “Buff” Bradley, Wayne Mogge, Jeff Greenhill and Marty Maline who recorded the minutes.

INSECT INFESTATION-Chip explained that they will have spray bottles of insecticide available at the guard shack available to anyone interested in spraying their rooms. The committee suggested that Turfway have someone available to spray the dorm rooms if a stable employee is not comfortable doing it himself. Chip stated that will be arranged.

POP MACHINE IN PONY BARN-Chip informed the committee that the fire marshall has informed them that the extension cord is suitable and safe.

REIMBURSEMENT FOR CANCELLATIONS-The committee suggested that horsemen should be compensated for the days that races are cancelled without advanced warning. Chip stated that he will communicate the wishes of the committee to the proper authorities.

ICE MACHINE REPAIR-Chip offered that the ice machines in poor repair have been corrected. Bill suggested that the door leading to the ice machine near barn 19 is broke causing the ice machine to freeze and cease to work.

SELF DEFENSE/AWARENESS CLASS-The committee suggested that it must first be determined how much the class will cost and if there is any interest.

CIRCUS TICKETS-Circus tickets are available in the KHBPA office, the cost is $7.00 per ticket and the horsemen have a block of seats for Saturday, February 28.

SUMMER STABING-Bob Elliston informed the committee that the barn area will remain open for summer stabling if 400 stalls are filled. Rick Leigh explained that the summer stabling applications are available. Also, he will be contacting various horsemen to see if they are interested in renting stalls in order to see if Turfway is assured that 400 stalls will be filled.

KHBPA/TURFWAY PARK APPRECIATION DINNER AND DANCING-The annual dinner dance prior to the Lanes End Spiral Stake will be held on Tuesday, March 17 at the Receptions in Florence, Kentucky.

LEGISLATIVE UPDATE-Bob Elliston explained that he has received positive feedback from the meeting with local legislators Addia Wuchner, Sal Santoro, and John Schickel. Horsemen did a fine job of explaining the importance of Turfway Park to local horsemen and others associated with the track. Bob implored horsemen to keep up the good work of communicating that message to legislative leaders. The legislation supporting gaming at racetracks, House Bill 158, still has many hurdles to clear in the short legislative session, but the momentum of support is encouraging. Bill Connelly suggested that we must be prepared to drive to Frankfort on short notice if it is determined that the full house is prepared to vote on House Bill 158. Members of the committee echoed Bill’s sentiment.

ROADS/POT HOLES-Chip explained that they are currently doing as much hot patching as possible to correct some of the major problem areas recognizing that additional ice and snow removal plays havoc with patch jobs.

WORK ORDERS-Chip informed the committee that their maintenance staff, headed by Cliff, not to be confused with CFO Cliff, has been inundated with plumbing and electrical issues. In the interim, Chip, is attempting to coordinate and address smaller maintenance problems.

PURSE STATUS-Following a review of the present status of the purse account which is comparable to last years figures, a discussion ensued about running on Mondays to make up cancellations. The consensus of the committee is that with the dwindling entries this may put too much strain on the horse population and the smaller fields of horses is not conducive to simulcast betting on the Turfway Park races. The committee agreed that the races have already been carded in the condition book and should be run, but perhaps in the future, running the extra races may not be in the best interest of Turfway Park and horsemen.

TRACK SURFACE-The committee discussed the protocol that should be followed prior to canceling races. Bob Elliston explained that he has reemphasized the proper procedure to be followed so that everyone is on the same page. Jeff Chapman reviewed the maintenance schedule and the daily reports he receives from several exercise riders and trainers on the condition of the track each and every morning. Watering and track depth were also explored. In addition, Jim Pendergast, a Polytrack expert, has been on hand since Monday, monitoring consistency of the cushion depth and measuring compaction levels of the track. He explained that the track appears to be functioning well and in accordance with recommended guidelines.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

A meeting of the Turfway Park horsemen’s committee was held to discuss the status of gaming legislation for Kentucky’s racetracks.

Also discussed was the upcoming meeting on Monday, February 16, at 10:00 A.M. in the Turf Club on the fifth floor at Turfway Park with Representatives Sal Santoro and Addia Wuchner and Senator John Schickel.

Those in attendance included Bob Elliston, President of Turfway Park, Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Rick Leigh, Director of Racing; Steve Peterman, Starter; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent.

Wm. “Buff” Bradley, Bill Connelly, Wayne Mogge, Jeff Greenhill, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee.

Bob Elliston reviewed the present status of the gaming legislation. He explained that the legislation passed the License and Occupation Committee unanimously yesterday morning. He expressed the view that he is encouraged by the momentum that the legislation is gaining. Specifically, he mentioned that Speaker of the House, Greg Stumbo, who sponsored the bill, has stated that many legislators are supporting the legislation and find it politically palatable. In addition, a recent poll by the leading radio station in Kentucky, WHAS, suggested that approximately 69% of voters in the poll expressed the opinion that they are in favor of locating slots at racetracks, while only 26% are opposed with the rest being undecided.

While the legislation still has a long way to go, it has cleared an important hurdle and will now be considered by the Appropriations and Revenue committee which is standard procedure for legislation addressing tax and finance matters.

Regarding the meeting with Representatives Sal Santoro, Addia Wuchner, and Senator John Schickel on Monday morning, it is important for those in attendance to share personal experiences and perspectives on the importance of racing especially to those of you who live and work in the Northern Kentucky community. It is totally acceptable to express your heartfelt feelings regarding the industry that you depend on for your livelihood, but please be courteous. Nothing is gained by venting your anger or being insulting to the legislative leaders who have come to Turfway Park to listen and attempt to understand your plight.

REMEMBER THE MEETING IS ON MONDAY, FEBRUARY 16, AT 10:00 A.M. IN THE TURF CLUB ON THE FIFTH FLOOR OF THE GRANDSTAND.

SPECIAL REPORT: Horsemen who call Kentucky home year-round are taking a beating, and they predict even more owners and horses will leave the state. Whether there will be legislative relief any time soon, however, remains to be seen.

Click here to view the full story or copy and paste the following link into your browser: http://news.bloodhorse.com/viewstory.asp?id=49163

From the West (Louisville):
• Exit 1-64 at exit number 53-B to Highway 127 (Northbound)
• Drive North on 127 to intersection of 127 and 676 (the East-West Connector) turn Right on 676. Go down the hill.
• At the stoplight, turn left onto Big Eddy Road, and follow it along the Kentucky River (if you go over the Kentucky River, you have gone too far)
• After about a mile, you will come to a building hanging over the roadway, on your left. This is the Capitol Annex garage entrance.
• Turn left into the Garage. Park on floors 4, 5, or 6. Take elevator to 1st Level. Exiting elevator the Annex will be in front of you across parking lot. Enter annex at second (middle) doors. You will go through security.

From the East (Lexington)
• Take either 1-64 or U.S. 60 to Frankfort. From 1-64, exit Right onto US 60.
• Follow U.S. 60 to the intersection of U.S. 421 (Leestown Road/Main Street)
• At the intersection (2nd stop light), turn left on to the East-West Connector. (The East- West Connector to the right is U.S. 421. To the left, it is State Route 676.)
• Follow the East-West Connector until you come to the Kentucky River.
• Just after the Kentucky River Bridge, there is a road with a sign to the Capitol to the right. Turn Right on “Big Eddy Road” which follows along the side of the river.
• After about a mile you will come a building hanging over the roadway, on your left. This is the Capitol Annex garage entrance.
• Turn left into the Garage. Park on floors 4, 5, or 6. Take elevator to 1st Level. Exiting elevator the Annex will be in front of you across parking lot. Enter annex at second (middle) doors. You will go through security.

For more information about the bill, please visit the KEEP website at www.horseswork.com/support_bill_158.htm

Thanks again for all of your support!!

We have received word that Kentucky State Representatives Sal Santoro and Addia Wuchner both from the Boone County area are leaning against voting to have gaming machines located at Turfway Park.

It is important that each and every one who relies on Turfway Park to make a living for you and your family make your feelings known.

Do not rely on someone else to fight for your survival, Call now:

Representative Sal Santoro 859-371-8840 (home); 502-564-8100 Extension 691(office)

Representative Addia Wuchner 859-525-6698 (work); 502-564-8100 Extension 707(office).

Tell them to please support and vote for House Bill 158, it is a matter of survival for Turfway Park and the thousands of people who rely on the racetrack to make a living. If you do not have a phone available, call from the KHBPA office.

In addition, Representatives Sal Santoro and Addia Wuchner along with Senator John Schickel will be at Turfway Park on Monday, February 16, at 10:00 A.M. in the Turf club on the fifth floor of the grandstand.

It is important to attend and let them know how you feel about the future of Turfway Park. We must send a strong message that we need help now.

We would also like to encourage everyone to please call or email their legislators in support of this bill. You can contact your legislature by calling 1-800-372-7181 or click here to send them an email and urge them to pass House Bill 158. Please send this on to anyone who might be interested in helping. Thank you and please let us know if you have any questions.

The first meeting of the KHBPA/Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee for the Winter/Spring meeting was held on Friday, January 2, 2009, at Turfway Park.

Bob Elliston, President; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; and Steve Peterman, Starter, attended representing Turfway Park management.

Wm. “Buff” Bradley, Wayne Mogge, and Jeff Greenhill, attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee. Lanny Kohnhorst attended representing the KTA. Marty Maline recorded the minutes.

TRACK SURFACE-Bob Elliston explained that measures are currently being taken to address track surface issues. He began by informing the committee that an expert representing the developers of Polytrack is on the grounds and is currently taking samples to determine the present consistency of the surface and also testing the compaction level of the racing surface to ascertain the amount of concussion experienced by horses racing at Turfway Park. In addition, Professor Peterson, the preeminent authority on racing surfaces will be continuing his study at various racetracks including Turfway Park and testing the level of cushion. This is all in the process of evaluating the racing surface. The question arose whether a portion of the old Polytrack stockpiled near the receiving barn should be added to the track to restore the buoyancy of the racing surface. Bob explained that the material is not suitable to be mixed with the present surface and the best approach, if any, is still to be determined.

Jeff Chapman addressed the rocks that occasionally appear on the surface. He explained that he contacted Mike Young the track superintendent at Keeneland. Mike informed him that this is part of the porous asphalt macadam which encompasses the drainage system and while it continues to be monitored, it is not uncommon.

Jeff also mentioned that they maintain a daily Polytrack log which continually monitors the climate conditions and how the track reacts to fluctuations in the weather.

HORSE PATH-Wm. “Buff” Bradley commended Jeff Chapman for his improvement of the horse path leading to the racetrack by removing a portion of the surface and leveling it out.

CHECK CASHING POLICY-The policy continues to be a source of frustration to horsemen attempting to cash checks at the information window. Recently a forlorn KHBPA employee attempting to cash a check was ostracized by the clerk at the window for not having used his “Fasttrack” card on a regular basis and threatened that he will be charged $5.00 per check cashing if his gambling did not appreciably increase. The employee was last seen running to the mutuel window to place a bet.

BACKSTRETCH PARKING POLICY-There appears to be a state of confusion regarding the recently initiated parking policy on the backstretch. Chip explained that it is his understanding that a memorandum was distributed reviewing the newly implemented parking policy. The problem is that no one has seen the memorandum, and while limiting the access of cars on the backside is a positive approach to an increasing traffic problem, horsemen and other backside personnel need to know what the new policy is before requiring everyone to operate within the boundaries set forth.

WORKORDER BACKLOG-Chip explained that due to the holidays the work order completions are running behind schedule. He intends to have a plumber and electrician on the grounds at the beginning of next week in an attempt to get on a three day turn around schedule on most major issues. Jeff explained that minor issues may continue to lag behind due to more pressing issues. Chip did mention that there are heaters available at the guard shack for emergency situations.

KITCHEN CLOSING-The horsemen’s committee asked Chip to investigate the unsubstantiated rumor that the kitchen will be closing at 1:00 each day. In addition, a discussion ensued regarding the elimination of betting windows in the recreation hall and the fact that according to the kitchen manager this has severely impacted his business. Bob explained that they are currently reviewing the amount of play at the recreation hall location, but in the meantime they intend to install money handling mutuel machines in the recreation hall which he feels will allow horsemen on the backside to wager as they have in the past.

PURSE STATUS-Bob Elliston explained that they are pleased that Turfway Park has continued to buck the national trend and wagering remains fairly strong.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The first meeting of the KHBPA/Turfway Park Horsemen’s Committee for the 2008, Holiday meeting was held on Friday, December 5, 2008, at Turfway Park.

Bob Elliston, President; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent; Steve Peterman, Starter; and Rick Leigh, Director of Racing attended representing Turfway Park management.

Bill Connelly, Wm. “Buff” Bradley, Wayne Mogge, David England, and Jeff Greenhill attended representing the KHBPA horsemen’s committee. Lanny Kohnhorst attended representing the KTA. Marty Maline recorded the minutes.

TRACK SURFACE-Horsemen have expressed concern regarding the depth of the surface and the amount of “kickback.” Jeff explained that he has purposely set the harrows deeper due to the significant drop in temperature. Bob Elliston stated that it is important that Turfway receives feedback from horsemen. He mentioned that they observe the times of races, and attempt to regulate the depth of cushion to assure that better horses are running appreciably faster than bottom conditioned claimers. Kickback can be regulated by the moisture content. Various horsemen on the committee favorably commented about the surface. One horseman recalled the old dirt surface and the myriad issues associated with it. Another suggested that the previous problems associated with build up in the hoofs appears, thus far, to be resolved. In addition, the issue with coughing appears to have lessened significantly. It was the general consensus of those in attendance at the meeting that they prefer a surface with cushion as opposed to a surface that is too firm.

RECEIVING BARN-Following a discussion regarding the potholes in the vicinity of the receiving barn. Chip Bach explained that they would use asphalt patch to address the issue. In addition, stall preparation in the receiving barn has been hampered by a shipment of straw that was not conducive to separating or shaking out. Jeff assured that the issue has been resolved.

POST PARADES-Horsemen have expressed concern that further abbreviation of the post parades may be detrimental for horses attempting to get a proper warm up prior to racing. Bob Elliston explained he will endeavor to assure that there are at least eight minutes or longer for horses being on the track in the post parade prior to racing. This is important for the welfare of the horse and allows the betting public ample time to observe the horses before wagering.

CHRISTMAS PARTY-The Christmas Party for children of backstretch personnel will be held on Tuesday, December 9, from 6:00 until 8:00, on the third floor of the grandstand in the Terrace Room. Santa will be in attendance.

PURSE STATUS-The underpayment at the start of the Holiday race meeting is at $900,000 which is approximately $200,000 higher than last year. A discussion ensued regarding rumors that purses will be slashed in the not too distant future. Bob Elliston stressed that there is no truth to the rumors. He explained that some betting actually is showing a positive trend. While he cautioned that the economy and the number of people losing their jobs nationwide is significant, there is no purse cut being contemplated in the immediate future. Bob also wanted to recognize the efforts of horsemen assuring that the entries for racing remains strong. This is incredibly important when selling the Turfway Park simulcast product to the various outlets throughout the nation.

FEED ROOM REPAIR UPDATE-Chip explained that the repair of the feed rooms damaged by the wind storm has been completed. They will continue to repair additional rooms as the need arises.

ICE AND SNOW REMOVAL-Chip informed the committee that they are prepared with a similar plan as last years when the snow and ice arrives this year. In addition, salt will be distributed in the barn area in order that horsemen may salt specific problem areas that they encounter.

FIRE AT RIVERSIDE PARK-Bob Elliston explained that Turfway Park will be donating to the horsemen’s relief fund for the horsemen that suffered losses of their horses and tack in the tragic fire at Riverside Downs.

HORSEPATH-Members of the horsemen committee requested that Jeff roll the horse path regularly to maintain an even surface.

BEDBUG UPDATE-Chip explained that they have hired Orkin, a professional exterminator to address this recurring problem.

CHECK CASHING POLICY-Bob Elliston explained that they plan to continue the present policy of charging $5.00 to cash checks and reminded that horsemen and backside personnel along with patrons can cash checks at no cost with a “Fastrack Card.”

MANURE BINS-Jeff acknowledged to the committee that there are a few manure bins that need to be repaired.

PARKING FEED TRAILERS-Chip addressed the ever growing number of feed trailers on the backside. He explained that as a courtesy they had made space available, but he feels that the feed men have taken advantage of the situation.

FUTURE PROJECTS-Bob Elliston explained that they would like input from the horsemen’s committee on possible backside improvements that will be presented to the Backside Improvement Commission.

WORKORDERS-Chip explained that due to workforce issues they have gotten behind on work orders. However, they will strive to improve their efficiency. In the meantime, they are giving priority to heater repair work orders that they receive.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline
Executive Director, KHBPA

On November 20, 2008, during the early morning hours at a small Western Kentucky horse training center every horseman’s worst nightmare was realized when a barn fire completely engulfed a barn full of thoroughbred race horses. In its wake, twenty-seven horses were lost along with all the tack and equipment that the horsemen stabled in the barn have accumulated over decades in the racing business. Many of the horsemen involved were just finally recovering from the devastating tornado that nearly put them out of business just three years ago at Ellis Park.

Bobby LaRue, a veteran trainer of more than fifty years, lost eight horses in the fire, and was emotionally drained by the fire as were many of his fellow horsemen.

“Many of us were just getting back on our feet after the tornado, and then this happens, sometimes you just wonder is it worth it,” he stated.

“I feel so bad for the horses,” commented Shirley Greene another longtime horsemen who lost four horses. We all wish we could have been there to help, I cannot stand the thought of them suffering.”

Benjie LaRue was fortunate he was able to save three of his five horses before the fire became so intense he was forced to leave the barn. One of his horses, a filly, refused to vacate her stall. Benjie, unable to withstand the heat, finally gave up the effort and left her behind. As he left the barn, the filly followed him. Her tail was on fire, but they quickly extinguished it.

The Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association (KHBPA), has started an effort to raise funds to assist the horsemen and employees that have lost so much. They have begun calling organizations including the National HBPA, to assist in the fundraising effort.

In addition, a separate bank account has been set up, for horsemen and interested parties to donate. A group of horsemen, including Ellis Park Chaplain Ron Crawford, will determine the appropriate distribution of the donations received. The KHBPA will see that all funds received are distributed to the proper parties.

Anyone interested in donating, just go to the local branch of Fifth Third Bank and donate to the Riverside Downs Fire & Disaster Fund, or contact the KHBPA at 1-800-928-4272.

LEXINGTON, KENTUCKY, September 25, 2008—Mace Siegel, one of North America’s leading owners and a founder and current vice president of the Thoroughbred Owners of California (TOC), has given $100,000 to support the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group (THG) and its efforts to protect live horse racing.

Ever since advance deposit wagering was authorized in California in 2002, Siegel has “been constantly championing the idea that ADW has to make an equitable return to tracks and horsemen, because without it, both will fail,” said TOC President Drew Couto, who also serves as vice president of THG.

THG was formed by horsemen to help ensure the best distribution of racing signals for wagering and the maximum return to racetracks and horsemen to support the live racing product.

“No individual horseman has been more concerned about the rates of return for the industry than Mace Siegel,” Couto said. “He became a huge supporter of the idea that it was a shared responsibility among horsemen and racetracks that we create a modern model for ADW and other simulcast issues. When the THG was created, he was extremely interested in it succeeding.”

Siegel, who operates Jay Em Ess Stable with his daughter, Samantha, has served on the TOC board since its inception in 1993. Last year, Jay Em Ess ranked among North America’s top 20 owners by earnings, and in 2004, the stable raced champion juvenile Declan’s Moon.

“Mace’s leadership with the formation of Thoroughbred Owners of California, and the example he has set as an advocate for the rights of Thoroughbred owners, is an inspiration to all owners in our sport,” said THG President Bob Reeves. “The Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group is another step on a national basis to protect the rights of Thoroughbred owners and the sport of Thoroughbred horse racing.”

The founder and chairman emeritus of Macerich, one of the largest owners, operators and developers of retail property in the United States, Siegel serves on that company’s board of directors. He is a resident of Beverly Hills, California.

For more information, contact:

THG President Bob Reeves 615-385-5052

A meeting of the Turfway Park/KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee for the 2008 Turfway Park Fall meeting was held on September 19, 2008.

Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Cliff Reed, Chief Financial Officer, Steve Peterman, Starter/Stall Manager; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent attended representing Turfway Park.

Wayne Mogge, Dave England, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee.

PURSE STATUS-The current underpayment stands at $1,173,691 as compared to $628,828 at the same time last year. Purse money generated from wagering, thus far, in 2008, $730,868; in 2007 during the same time period $842,640. However, purses paid in 2008, $899,290 as compared to 2007 where $1,113,812 had been paid in purses during the same time period. Similar decreases exist in generated purses and purses paid for the KTDF fund from 2007 to 2008. The telling figure is that wagering is down from all sources almost $5,000,000 which is a decrease of 16.72%.

$5.00 CHECK CASHING FEE-A long discussion ensued regarding the recent change in the check cashing policy, requiring horsemen and backstretch workers to pay a check cashing fee of $5.00 per check. Cliff Reed explained that bad checks and checks that they repeatedly send back to the bank for clearance has adversely impacted Turfway Park by $25,000. He informed the committee that approximately 20%-30% is attributable to horsemen. In addition, “fast track” patrons are entitled to cash checks for free. Therefore, it would appear that horsemen are making up the difference for 70%-80% of bad checks that many fast track patrons are cashing. The committee suggested several alternatives to alleviate the burden on backstretch workers. The committee suggested no other racetrack charges a similar fee. While Cliff said he would take their concerns and suggestions under advisement, he would not guarantee that they would change the policy.

TRACK SURFACE-Committee members suggested that additional water should be applied. Jeff Chapman that additional water is not necessarily the answer due to the tremendous drainage of the racetrack. Dave England recommended the addition of a substance to the water which he used in his landscaping business that may slightly slow the draining process. Chip Bach agreed to research the substance.

ICE MACHINES-There was discussion regarding the lack of ice available from the ice machines. Chip explained that Hamilton refrigeration was scheduled to come out last Wednesday to see if the machines are functioning correctly, but due to the weather related issues, they have postponed until next week. Committee members suggested part of the problem is some people are taking all of the ice very early in the morning. It was suggested that the machines should be opened approximately 5:45 in the morning that way horsemen can police each other and make sure that a few are not emptying the bins leaving none for anyone else. Also, it was suggested that the ice making machines at Presque Isle should be explored. Apparently, additional ice is collected on trays underneath which continues to deposit ice even when the bins are full.

HEALTH CERTIFICATES-Horsemen shipping into Turfway Park to run continue to express concern with the health certificate issue. In Kentucky, each horse must acquire a new health certificate every 72 hours. In Indiana, a health certificate is required every 45 days. Chip agreed to contact Rusty Ford of Kentucky’s agriculture department to see why there is such a wide discrepancy especially since Turfway is competing with Hoosier Park for horses.

BLACKTOP UPDATE-Chip explained that there are only a few places left to patch, he suggested that if horsemen have blacktop issue not readily apparent to the blacktop contractors, please submit a work order. He did mention that currently they are approximately a week and ½ behind in addressing work orders.

HAYROOM UPDATE-According to Chip there is one new hay shed left to finish. However, several sheds were damaged due to the strong winds on Sunday. He recommended that horsemen submit work orders regarding storm damage.

TRASH REMOVAL-Chip informed the committee that they will be instituting a new trash pickup program that he feels will be more efficient and less noisy. He suggested that the committee survey their fellow horsemen to determine the opportune time to pick-up.

TRAINING HOURS-The horsemen committee felt the present training hours are satisfactory.

MIKE “COWBOY” FAULKNER-Special recognition to “Cowboy” for his successful attempt at beautifying the backstretch by planting flowers in several locations.

BAND PLAYING ON THE APRON-The horsemen committee reminded Chip to have someone monitor the band’s playing as horses are lead over to the paddock and warming up prior to racing in front of the grandstand. Chip said the issue has already been addressed. As far as the horses getting loose, it was suggested that the horse was extremely agitated in the paddock prior to going out on the track and they felt a reimbursement was not appropriate in this instance.

STRONG WINDS CANCELLING RACES-The horsemen’s committee agreed that those horsemen that lost the opportunity to race due to the high winds on Sunday should be reimbursed as is customary during inclement weather cancellations during the winter race meeting.

INSURANCE CERTIFICATES-Tyler Picklesimer, assistant racing secretary, commended horsemen on getting their insurance certificates up to date.

MANURE BINS and SPEEDING-Jeff Chapman cautioned horsemen about parking in front of manure bins and others mentioned about speeding through the barn area. It was suggested as opposed to announcing over the intercom, security should track down the repeated culprits and take them to the stewards.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Executive Director KHBPA

With horsemen and Hollywood Park unable to come to agreement on revenue splits from account wagering sources for the upcoming autumn meet at the Inglewood track, the California Horse Racing Board agreed to conduct a special hearing to settle the impasse.

Click here to view the full story or copy and paste the following link into your browser: http://news.bloodhorse.com/viewstory.asp?id=47139

What, Exactly, Is the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group Doing? The Horsemen’s Journal – Fall 2008

by Bob Reeves, Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group President

When traveling down the road of history, it is often difficult to perceive the key landmarks that indicate significant changes lying ahead. Sometimes they might be small enough to evade immediate notice, and sometimes there is just so much else on the horizon that they escape detection. The huge warning signs on the path of horse racing’s future have become abundantly clear, however: without some change in the way revenue from account wagering is divided, live racing is threatened with a strangulation of funds for both racetracks and horsemen. Ever since the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group (THG) was formed in late 2007, we have been working diligently to ensure that racing’s leaders see and understand these signs.

With account wagering the only real growth sector in pari-mutuel racing, advance deposit wagering (ADW) companies and licensed offshore operations now handle about 25% of the $15 billion wagered on Thoroughbred racing annually. Yet these businesses, eager to keep as much of the money for themselves as they can, return to racing interests 80% less per wagering dollar than do on-track or inter-track betting outlets.

What is the solution? It is constructively changing what has long been referred to as the “broken simulcast model.” We believe the best way to do that is to set aside two-thirds of account wagering revenue for racetracks and horsemen.

While that proposal does not immediately appeal to the ADW companies, they should look at the corresponding opportunity to gain unlimited and simultaneous access to all North American racing content.

The way to increase handle—and thus revenue to all parties—is to increase opportunities for betting. Ideally, racing would have an automated teller machine at every convenience store to reach the widest possible audience. Since that is not possible in this highly regulated world, ADW represents an excellent way to make our racing product available to the public.

We need to end the content wars. Part of THG’s aim through licensing negotiations on behalf of horsemen’s organizations is to help account wagering companies obtain racing content. If the ADW operations are ensured a steady supply of quality content, their customers will be able to depend on them and become more loyal—thus likely betting more.

We also need to stabilize access to racing content for the wagering public. There should be no need for someone to have accounts with three different ADW companies in order to bet on all the tracks they want to play.

Supplying content and guaranteeing a proper flow of revenue are the key factors in our efforts to enhance the account wagering system while supporting live racing.

We all must ask ourselves the question: do racetracks and horsemen exist to support betting companies, or do the betting companies exist in order to support horse racing? Horsemen and racetracks should not be spending the vast sums of money necessary to run our businesses just to make betting companies profitable.

It’s time to stop subsidizing the ADW companies. Rather than make a patchwork quilt of pricing, we should charge reasonable prices for our racing products and sell them to all the ADW operators and then let the ADWs compete. The point is we need to create a level playing field and let the ADW companies compete for customers based on the quality of their service.

Horse racing needs to wake up and smell the roses and declare that the reason these betting outlets exist is because of live racing. Without live racing, they have no product, and thus it is in everyone’s interests to keep live racing healthy through a proper supply of revenue from wagering. In addition to representing the horsemen in negotiating for licensing agreements with the ADW companies, THG also can help racetrack owners by offering a multi-jurisdictional conduit to horsemen’s groups, greatly simplifying the task of negotiating for simulcast rights. THG now has 19 members with the recent addition of the Oregon Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association.

THG leaders continue to meet with horsemen’s groups around the continent in order to receive input, as well as keep them informed, on various issues, including the ADW question. In August, we traveled to Saratoga Springs and Del Mar for some of those meetings, and we continue to consider a variety of ways to strengthen live racing.

We have also been holding extensive discussions with executives at Magna Entertainment Corp. (MEC), who have been very receptive to working with horsemen. MEC Chairman and leading North American breeder Frank Stronach has told us that he views himself as a horseman and supports horsemen, and we’re working with him to come up with a solution to this ADW problem. A cooperative arrangement with MEC could be very significant. Not only does the company own such major racing venues as Santa Anita Park and Gulfstream Park, it also is a partner with Churchill Downs Inc. (CDI) in TrackNet Media Group, which buys and sells simulcast signals that account for 35% to 40% of total handle in the United States.

CDI, however, has sued the THG, its officers, the Kentucky HBPA, and the Kentucky Thoroughbred Association, alleging that our efforts to work on a solution to the ADW issue violate anti-trust laws.

In late July, attorneys for THG and the Kentucky groups filed a motion to dismiss the suit. We believe the Interstate Horseracing Act gives horsemen the right—and indeed requires them—to negotiate the percentage of off-track wagering revenues targeted for purses.

“Horsemen must protect themselves,” the motion states. “And they do so through their collective negotiations with entities like CDI. When those negotiations do not reach a mutually agreeable conclusion, the (Interstate Horseracing Act) is very clear: the horsemen have an absolute ‘veto’ right to withhold their consent, and that means there can be no interstate wagering on the affected races.”

CDI nonetheless claims that horsemen violate the law if they work together to negotiate new account wagering revenue distribution models. But our motion points out that “courts have consistently recognized that it would be nonsensical and would undermine statutory intent to preclude multiple groups from collectively engaging in the same conduct, to accomplish the same objectives that each group has a statutory right to engage in on its own.”

Meanwhile, the experience of Ellis Park has provided an intriguing insight into what can happen when racetracks and horsemen agree on how account wagering revenue should be distributed.

Before Ellis’ meet began this summer, Kentucky horsemen held firm on receiving a greater share of revenue from wagering. Ellis Park owner Ron Geary at first objected and said he might close the track, sparking Thoroughbred Racing Association (TRA)’s Executive Vice President Chris Scherf to criticize the THG and other horsemen for their efforts.

Scherf said, “Unfortunately, some horsemen’s groups believe their share can be increased beyond prevailing market rates by forcing the tracks to agree to a minimum pricing structure set forth by a new, third-party organization.

Tracks have been unwilling to pursue this approach because of legitimate business and legal concerns. Before additional damage is done to the racing industry, horsemen and racetracks must see the difference between short-term gains and a long-term strategy to be developed jointly. One side dictating to the other clearly will not work.”

Misunderstandings created by statements like these are unfortunate and place obstacles in the path of reaching constructive solutions. We responded to Mr. Scherf that we very much want to work with racetracks and would like to meet and discuss our strategies to increase the revenue distribution from account wagering for both tracks and horsemen, and we are pleased that he has invited THG to make a presentation as part of a panel at the International Simulcast Conference, which the TRA co-sponsors, on September 29.

Kentucky horsemen and Ellis Park eventually came together and agreed on a model similar to what we have been advocating and under which Ellis’ signal would be widely distributed among ADW companies for maximum wagering opportunities. This model has worked so well that the track implemented a 5% purse increase beginning on August 13 and extending through the rest of the meet.

“We are very excited about the partnership we have with the Kentucky HBPA,” Geary said in announcing the purse increase. “We hope our agreement with the Kentucky HBPA will positively impact the entire Thoroughbred racing industry. The innovative agreement Ellis Park leadership reached with Kentucky HBPA has allowed us to not only keep our doors open, but to buck an industry trend of declining purses.”

We appreciate Ron Geary stepping up to address the problem. Now he’s making money and horsemen are benefiting, too. It’s obviously working. The Ellis Park experience shows what broad, non-exclusive distribution can accomplish.

All of us in racing need to take a similar approach and be brave enough to take that step to ensure that live racing, both through purses and racetrack operations, is properly supported.

While we represent horsemen, our stand also is very racetrack friendly because we’re here to preserve racing. We want to keep the racetracks and the horsemen that provide the sport at those racetracks strong and healthy as far down the road to the future as we can foresee—and even further.

President’s message.

As I reported to you in my last message, the disagreement with the advanced deposit wagering (ADWs) companies over the equitable sharing of wagering for purses continues.

Racetracks appear to understand horsemen’s plight, but they are not prepared to accept the fact that change is necessary if horse racing is to remain viable. You may recall, Bill Casner, immediate past Chairman of the Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders Association (TOBA), commented at our last general horsemen’s meeting “The future of our purses comes down to how these issues are resolved.”

During this summer racing season we observed both ends of the spectrum as it pertains to handling of ADWs. At Del Mar race course in California, following a successful experiment where horsemen, racetracks, the California Racing Board, and ADWs agreed to provide the simulcast signal to all ADWs, TVG, the largest ADW, decided prior to the Del Mar race meeting to withdraw their support for the experiment. Del Mar was forced to cut purses for the first time in thirty years. A perfect example of the “tale wagging the dog.” At Ellis Park, on the other hand, it was decided that in order for the ADWs to receive the simulcast signal of the Ellis Park races, horsemen must receive 6% of the wagering revenue for purses. While negotiations were contentious, an agreement was reached with Ellis Park. Subsequently, purses were raised 5% twice.

“We are very excited about the partnership we have with the KHBPA,” Ellis Park owner Ron Geary said. “The innovative agreement Ellis Park leadership reached with KHBPA has allowed us to not only keep our doors open, but to buck an industry trend of declining purses.”

This is a difficult struggle, but as Bill Casner, said it is a battle that must be won. We, as horsemen, must stay the course.

We continue to monitor legislation proposing slots at Kentucky’s racetracks. It is difficult to embrace a proposal that we know so little about, but we plan to meet with legislative leaders early and often to assure that if slots are to become a reality that horsemen will receive an equitable share of the revenue for purses.

Dr. Jerry Yon is the new Chairman of the Kentucky Equine Drug Council, I have had the opportunity to speak with him and I am confident he will move this important advisory council to the Kentucky Racing Commission in the right direction. As a member of the Kentucky Equine Drug Council, I look forward to working with him and the other members of the Council. It is important that we once again aggressively pursue important drug research.

I want to take this opportunity to congratulate Frank Jones, KHBPA Vice President, recently appointed by Governor Steve Beshear, to serve on the Kentucky Racing Commission. Frank has always been a steadying influence on the KHBPA Board and his business acumen will serve him well as he and other Commission members tackle difficult regulatory issues.

Good luck in your racing endeavors.

HORSEMEN AT ODDS OVER LICENSING INCREASE

During a recent meeting, the Racing Commission proposed several changes to racing rules and regulations. While most of the regulations are mostly housekeeping in nature, raising the license fee from $100 to $150 for owners, trainers, and jockeys drew the ire of several horsemen.

“It is already one of the highest, if not the highest license fee, of any racing jurisdiction,” commented Marty Maline, KHBPA Executive Director. “While we understand the Racing Commission is financially strapped, it is not fair to make horsemen carry the burden of funding the regulatory body. Recently, Governor Beshear appointed a blue ribbon committee to study various issues in racing. Hopefully, they will arrive at funding mechanism that does not include a fifty percent increase in license fees.”

The KHBPA plans to voice concerns of horsemen as the regulations are presented to the Kentucky legislature.

KEENELAND AND TURFWAY ANNOUNCE TOE GRAB POLICY

Following the Racetrack Safety Summit held at Keeneland earlier in the year and research indicating toe grabs and turndowns may be a cause of injuries to horses, both Turfway Park and Keeneland decided to institute a new policy. Essentially, no toe grabs higher than two millimeters or turn downs will be permitted on horses racing at either location.

The policy departs from the model rule proposed by Racing Commissioners International (RCI) and the Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders Association’s (TOBA) graded stakes committee. Their rule only pertains to front shoes and not to back shoes.

“We recognize the need to responsibly address this issue and we applaud those efforts,” commented Buff Bradley, KHBPA director. “The problem here is that there was no discussion with the KHBPA prior to implementation of the policy. Many horsemen have expressed concern that including the toe grab and turndown ban to the back feet may well cause problems if horses are unable to get traction especially at the start of a race. We would have liked to have had the opportunity to present the proposal to horsemen and listen to their concerns.”

FRANK JONES APPOINTED TO KENTUCKY RACING COMMISSION

FRANK JONES, KHBPA Vice President, has been appointed by Governor Steve Beshear to the Kentucky Horse Racing Commission formerly the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority. Previously, during the 1990s he served two terms as the Vice Chairman of the Kentucky Racing Commission. In addition, to his work with the KHBPA and the Racing Commission he also serves on the Board of Directors of the Kentucky Racing Health and Welfare Fund and the Kentucky Thoroughbred Owners organization.

EQUINE DRUG COUNCIL APPROVES STEROID BAN

On Thursday, August 14, 2008, Dr. Jerry Yon, Chairman, of the Equine Drug Council presented a proposed regulation effectively banning anabolic steroids in thoroughbred and harness racing in Kentucky.

The KHBPA recognizes that the majority of racing states are addressing the issue, but uniformity throughout the various racing jurisdictions is important in order that horsemen can race from state to state without concern that there are variations in the rule.

The Association of Racing Commissioners (RCI) in conjunction with the Racing Medication and Testing Consortium (RMTC) are pursuing model rules, it is the hope of horsemen that the Kentucky Racing Commission conform to the model rules. In conversations with representatives of the KHBPA, Dr. Yon has assured us that the concerns of horsemen will be addressed.

H-3 AND H-2 VISA UPDATES

On June 26, 2008, Kentucky and Minnesota HBPA Groom Elite applicants had appointments at the U.S. Embassy in Monterrey, Mexico. Of the 74 applicants all were approved to receive visas, however there was a week long delay due to the Groom Elite program having to undergo review by Vice Consul Hodel. After reviewing the program the Consulate in Monterey refused visas for the applicants. Attorney Efren Hernandez III has been assisting the HBPA and he was able to find out through contacting the State Department in Washington D.C. that the Groom Elite Program was sent to their office for review by their advisory committee. The State Department states they will not approve the program because it appears the Groom Elite is for productive employment rather than training. Therefore, they see the program as a circumvention of the H-2B program. We have sent additional information to the review board for reconsideration and we urge our horsemen to please contact their state representative or senator for assistance with this issue. Please contact Julio Rubio with the KYHBPA at 502-645-7215 for more information.

Our petition for H-2B work visas for Kentucky was approved on July 16, 2008. Currently there are 144 applicants for close to 22 trainers. Appointments are confirmed on August 26 for the first group of 50 in the U.S. Embassy in Mexico City. In order to keep these workers in status for the winter we urge trainers to please contact Julio Rubio with the KYHBPA as soon as possible. We thank you very much for your cooperation.

Trainer, if you have a groom currently in the United States on a valid H2B Visa, it is vital to transition that worker to another H2B. Please contact our Hispanic Services Coordinator Julio Rubio at 502-645-7215 so he can facilitate this transition to insure a steady stream of workers. If you have a groom on an unexpired H2B please call him immediately.

The fifth meeting of the 2008 KHBPA/Ellis Park Horsemen’s meeting was held on Friday, August 29, 2008.

Attending the meeting representing Ellis Park, Ron Geary, owner and President, Greg Hardt, CFO/Executive Vice President; Mark Geary, Director of Development; Bob Jackson, Director of Operations; and Dan Bork, Director of Racing.

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee includes Mike Bruder, Chairman; R.L. “Bobby” Williams and Marty Maline who recorded the minutes.

RECOGNIZING A JOB WELL DONE -The horsemen’s committee resoundingly expressed their appreciation to Dan Bork, Director of Racing, Tia Borgemenke, Assistant Racing Secretary, and the entire staff of the Racing Department. They have done a yeoman’s job of maintaining attractive fields throughout the racing season at Ellis Park. “It is a partnership, between horsemen and the racing department,” explained Mike Bruder. “We appreciate their efforts to make things work.” Ron Geary explained that in recognition of their work ethic, he is hosting an appreciation dinner for the racing department staff.

PROJECTS FOR THE WINTER – A roof for the equisizer and an extension for the basketball court are two projects that will be considered for the winter months. Greg Hardt explained that he will have balances for the horsemen’s committee account and the marketing account in the very near future.

PURSE STATUS – Greg also explained that due to a slight dip in wagering revenue last week, the overpayment appears to be in the range of $95,000. Mike Bruder commented that if the overpayment is below the $100,000 threshold by the end of the race meeting it is within the acceptable level. Ron Geary suggested that with a strong final weekend we could possibly be well below the $100,000 level of overpayment. Ron also briefly reviewed their plans for racing days in 2009. He explained that it will be a difficult struggle with the slot enriched purses and extended race meetings at the two Indiana racetracks. Ron suggested that they are currently comparing figures of the other 26 racetracks that race in the summer in an attempt to determine if there needs to be a revision in the exact days that Ellis Park runs, for instance, running on a Monday instead of perhaps a Thursday.

CONTRACT – The KHBPA and Ellis Park will be meeting during October of this year to discuss a new purse contract.

OPENING STARTING GATE – Dan Bork assured the committee that the starting gate will remain open for the closing days of the race meeting. Upon the conclusion of the season, Bob Jackson informed the committee that the starting gate will remain open one day a week. The exact day will be determined at a later date.

CAMELS AND OSTRICHES – Bob Jackson informed horsemen racing prior to the 5th and 7th races that there will be a delay in coming to the paddock since the camels and ostriches will be racing prior to those races. If the competition in your race has a hump on his back or a large beak it means you have probably arrived too early.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The third meeting of the 2008 KHBPA/Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee meeting was held on Friday, August 8, 2008.

Attending the meeting representing Ellis Park, Ron Geary, owner and President; Greg Hardt, CFO/Executive Vice President; Mark Geary, Director of Development, and Bob Jackson, Director of Operations.

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee includes Mike Bruder, Chairman; R.L. “Bobby” Williams, and Marty Maline who recorded the minutes.

TRACK KITCHEN – The Horsemen’s Committee explained that several horsemen have complimented the kitchen and the quality as well as the quantity of the food. Local horseman, John Hancock, suggested that he feels it may well be the best kitchen in Kentucky.

CHAPLAIN RON CRAWFORD’S COOKOUT – Horsemen have reported that the cookout recently held by Chaplain Ron Crawford was a big success. Another one will be held on Thursday, August 28, immediately following the races.

HORSE AMBULANCE – The Horsemen’s Committee has received concerns that the Horse Ambulance attendant occasionally in the mornings leaves the horse ambulance unattended for stretches of time. Bob Jackson explained that he has not heard this, but he will check into it.

BASKETBALL COURT – The Horsemen’s Committee has suggested that the basketball court on the backstretch should be improved adding an additional goal and making it larger. This provides a great amount of enjoyment for many on the backstretch.

KHBPA/ELLIS PARK HORSEMEN’S PICNIC – This coming Tuesday, the annual horsemen’s picnic will be held at Ellis Park which features Sonny’s Famous Barbecue. The picnic will begin at 6:30 and dinner will be served at 7:00. Bob Jackson is in charge of securing a Disc Jockey for the event and he has graciously accepted the responsibility.

SANDY WATKINS DAY AT ELLIS PARK – Due to health issues, it appears a day recognizing Sandy Watkins, Judge Executive, Henderson County, for his efforts on behalf of Ellis Park may have to be postponed.

TRACK MAINTENANCE – Just as in the week prior, horsemen have suggested that in order to preserve the track surface it is advisable to have the dogs out during training hours when inclement weather has caused the track to be muddy or sloppy. Bob Jackson stated that he will talk to the track superintendent to see why there has been a change in the policy regarding the track and inclement weather.

PURSE ACCOUNT UPDATE – Greg Hardt announced that wagering at Ellis Park has improved this week and therefore he has updated his estimated overpayment of purses at the end of the race meeting. Ron Geary attributed the rebounding to various factors. He explained that Ellis Park now is in the top five or six of ADW signals currently being wagered on throughout the country and Canada. “It is especially encouraging due to the fact that Del Mar has recently been forced to cut purses due to the economy and Saratoga is down 20%,” Mike Bruder commented. Ron Geary suggested that he feels a 5% increase in purses is in order. After further discussion, where Mike Bruder explained that it is important that we do not leave the current race meeting with a sizable overpayment, everyone agreed to raise the purses 5% starting with the race card for Wednesday, August 13.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The second meeting of the 2008 KHBPA/Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee meeting was held on Friday, August 1, 2008.

Attending the meeting representing Ellis Park, Ron Geary, owner and President, Greg Hardt, CFO/Executive Vice President, Mark Geary, Director of Development, and Bob Jackson, Director of Operations.

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee includes Mike Bruder, Chairman, R.L. “Bobby” Williams, and Marty Maline who recorded the minutes.

PURSE ACCOUNT UPDATE – Greg Hardt provided the Committee with the purse update including an estimate of where the purse account will end up at the end of the race meeting. The purse account started this 2008 race meeting with a $600,622 balance as opposed to $874,000 as an underpayment balance starting the 2007 race meeting. So this race meeting started with $274,000 less in the purse account. The purses earned from the new advance deposit wagering agreement (adw) amounts to approximately $300,000 in additional revenue for purses. Ron Geary explained that the revenue from the adws has been hampered by HRTV’s lack of cooperation in showing Ellis Park races on television on a regular basis while showing race track signals with less of a following. Therefore, Greg Hardt estimates that the race meeting will end with an overpayment of approximately $75,000 in the purse account. Ron Geary suggested that we continue to monitor the figures on weekly basis, to determine if a purse raise is warranted.

VANNING EXPENSE – At the request of horsemen that ship to Ellis Park on a regular basis, the committee asked if there is any consideration for shipping expenses. Ron Geary explained that he had actually considered some type of travel voucher to assist with the gas expense, but he was unable to make it work financially.

WATER AT THE GAPS – Horsemen have requested that assistance be provided to assure that all the water stations on the track are maintained. Bob Jackson assured the committee that they will provide the attendant with access to the racetrack so that she will have the ability to service the water buckets without encumbrances.

HOURS FOR THE EQUISIZER – Bob Jackson informed the horsemen’s committee that the hours of the Equisizer are from 6:00 until 11:00.

BACKSIDE RESTROOMS – The horsemen’s committee suggested that the cleanliness of the restrooms on the backstretch needs to be addressed.

TURF COURSE – Horsemen have mentioned that the turf course is especially firm and perhaps additional water needs to be applied. Bob Jackson explained that the sprinkler system is turned on every night, but he will check to see if it can be adjusted to slow down the process which in turn applies more water.

MAIN TRACK – Horsemen have suggested that when the track is muddy in the morning, it is a good idea to put the dogs out as opposed to just announcing that horses should not be galloped along the rail.

SANDY WATKINS DAY FOLLOWUP – Bob Jackson informed the committee that he has talked with Judge Executive, Sandy Watkins, and he will let us know very soon, the day that he will be available for an event in his honor.

FURTHER CONSIDERATION OF ELIMINATING THE BREAK – Dan Bork, Director of Racing, has completed his survey of horsemen regarding eliminating the break in the mornings. Apparently, it is evenly split. The committee decided that the break will be eliminated on Mondays and Tuesdays effective this Monday. On racedays, the break will be changed to 7:30 until 8:00.

FLY ERADICATION FOLLOW-UP – R. L. “Bobby” Williams informed the committee that it appears that the fly eradication system has been serviced and the fly problem has improved. However, he suggested that it is still important that a sheet showing the times they have serviced the boxes should be available for accountability.

DISTURBANCE AT THE GUARD SHACK – Horsemen have expressed concern regarding the recent disturbance at the guard shack. They have inquired why only one guard attempted to intervene while the other guard failed to get involved. A brief discussion ensued, but no real answers to the inquiry were forthcoming.

UPCOMING EVENTS –

• Monday, August 4, Del Cato’s picnic and barbecue at the picnic grove.

• Tuesday, August 5, the KHBPA/Ellis Park Golf Tournament contact KHBPA office for details.

• Friday, August 8, the annual backstretch Health Fair above the track kitchen, lunch will be served. Starting at 11:00 A.M.

• Tuesday, August 12, the KHBPA/Ellis Park annual horsemen’s picnic featuring Sonny’s famous barbecue. Starting at 6:30, dinner at 7:00.

• Thursday, August 14 and August 28, the Chaplain will serve dinner on the backstretch.

• Monday, August 18, the second annual Ellis Park backstretch cook-off; everyone is invited. Starting at 5:00, cash prizes for the winners.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Executive Director, KHBPA

The first meeting of the 2008 KHBPA/Ellis Park Horsemen’s Committee was held on Thursday, July 24, 2008.

Attending the meeting representing Ellis Park were Ron Geary, owner and President, Greg Hardt, CFO/Executive Vice President, Mark Geary, Director of Development, Bob Jackson, Director of Operations, and Dan Bork, Director of Racing/Racing Secretary.

The Horsemen’s Committee includes Mike Bruder, Chairman of the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee, R. L. “Bobby” Williams and Marty Maline recorded the minutes.

PERSONNEL ISSUES-The Horsemen’s Committee reviewed concerns they have received regarding the Stall Superintendent. Dan Bork explained that he will discuss the issues with him.

FLY ERADICATION PROGRAM-The Horsemen’s Committee discussed the heavy fly infestation in the barn area. Mark Geary reviewed the program that was patterned after the successful program at Lone Star race track in Texas. Bobby Williams explained that perhaps monitoring the system closer to assure that the system is being serviced regularly is a good idea. In addition, strategically locating additional devices next to the manure bins may be appropriate.

WATERING THE RACETRACK-The Horsemen’s Committee has received several comments regarding the lack of adequate water on the racetrack during Wednesday’s races. Apparently, one of the water trucks broke down and there was no backup. Bob Jackson explained that he was unaware of the problem. Mark Geary suggested perhaps they could lease a water truck from Arlington Park since now that they have Polytrack they do not water their track as frequently. Bob Jackson assured the committee that the problem will be addressed.

SANDY WATKINS DAY AT ELLIS PARK-The Horsemen’s Committee suggested having a day at Ellis Park in honor of Sandy Watkins, Judge Executive of Henderson County, Kentucky, in recognition of his genuine interest in the continued survival of Ellis Park. Marty Maline recalled during the aftermath of the tornado, Sandy was on the backstretch several days assisting with the relief efforts. He truly cares about the continued survival of Ellis Park. Bob Jackson explained that there is a day when several Judge Executives from the surrounding counties attend the races so perhaps there could be a presentation in conjunction with that day. Ron Geary agreed with the proposal.

CONSIDERING CANCELLING THE BREAK-The Horsemen’s Committee explained that they have been contacted by horsemen interested in canceling the track break in the morning. After several minutes of discussion, it was decided to poll horsemen to see if they are interested in having a break Wednesday through Sunday with the starting gate open from 7:00 until 8:00, a break from 8:00 until 8:30, afterward, the starting gate open from 8:30 until 9:30. On Monday and Tuesday there would be no break and on Monday the starting gate is open from 7:00 until 9:00 and the gate is closed on Tuesday. This approach would be done on a trial basis. Horsemen interesting in expressing their view should contact the Racing Secretary’s office or the KHBPA office.

UPDATE ON IMPROVEMENTS-Mike Bruder requested an update on the improvements to the backstretch. Bob Jackson explained that air conditioning/heating units have been added to 58 rooms.

PURSE ACCOUNT UPDATE-The Horsemen’s Committee requested a purse account update. Greg Hardt explained that they have been finding it difficult getting the information from Churchill Downs who is responsible for their reconciliations. Ron Geary explained that he expects that the problem will be resolved by the next meeting on Friday of next week. Mike Bruder emphasized the importance of getting weekly updates, in order that the purses account can be monitored. He felt that if it is warranted, the KHBPA would like to consider a purse raise in recognition of the horsemen’s strong support of Ellis Park by entering their horses. Ron Geary expressed the view that they shared the same feelings and would also like to recognize the efforts of Dan Bork and his racing office staff. In addition, Ron Geary reviewed the betting at the various ADW companies and explained the strong support Ellis Park is receiving from the betting patrons. He did express his disappointment with Tracknet, who has steadfastly refused to show the Ellis Park signal on HRTV on a regular basis, even though it is preferred by bettors over other racetrack’s simulcast signals getting full coverage.

UPCOMING EVENTS-Mark Geary announced that Ellis Park continues to provide the popular Tuesday night suppers at the track kitchen starting at 5:00. Everyone is welcome.

Tuesday, August 5, is the KHBPA/Ellis Park Golf Tournament. Contact KHBPA office for details. Mark Geary informed the committee that Ellis Park will donate $500 for prize money.

Friday, August 8, is the annual backstretch Health Fair above the track kitchen.

Tuesday, August 12, is the KHBPA/Ellis Park annual horsemen’s picnic featuring Sunny’s famous barbecue.

There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

With cooler weather and the first of two big giveaway days for college students, the track in the Henderson County bottoms had its biggest crowd of the young meet and more energy than it had seen the two previous days.

Griffith and Bruder, representing the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association, were happy to hand out 11 laptop computers in a blind draw among 500 college students who entered.

“As an industry, we need to see more young people out here,” said Bruder, a horse owner from Evansville and member of the HBPA board of directors. “The Kentucky Thoroughbred Association does a nice job with their scholarship program (and will present 10 $1,000 scholarships to students at Ellis on July 27), and we decided a few years back to join in.”

Griffith, the HBPA treasurer, nodded. “Any kid going to college can use a scholarship, and any kid going to college can use a laptop,” he said. “It seemed like a natural tie-in.”

Patrick Coomes of St. Wendel, Ind., wouldn’t argue. The Reitz High School graduate, bound for Ivy Tech, won one of the computers on Sunday.

He was talked into coming to the track by his date, Diana McConnell, who was joining her mother and aunt on an outing. Coomes wound up the luckiest one in the group.

“It’s cool that they do this,” he said. “You see a lot of people from a lot of schools out here.”

Laptop winners represented eight universities Ivy Tech, Indiana (3), Purdue, Southern Indiana (2), Louisville, Vanderbilt, Centre College and Ball State. They bet a little, took advantage of Sunday’s reduced prices on concessions and seemed to enjoy the day.

“Some of their parents are probably wagering a little,” said track owner Ron Geary. “But mostly you have to love the way they’re invigorating the whole plant. There’s an energy that you love to see.”

Geary isn’t releasing daily attendance figures but confirmed the first two days averaged about 3,800. Sunday’s crowd was larger, likely in the 5,000 range. “The crowd’s bigger and it’s younger, and that’s definitely something we like to see,” said Geary.

The all-sources handle, gleaned from mutuel pools reported to equibase.com, was $2,041,905, down from $2,249,992 on Friday and $2,485,009 on Saturday.

The AP news story appeared in the July 10 USA Today.

http://www.usatoday.com/sports/horses/2008-07-10-1902701958_x.htm

Racing struggling to divvy up growing Internet pie

By Will Graves, AP Sports Writer

LOUISVILLE, Ky. — There aren’t any Triple Crown contenders in John Hancock’s 24-horse stable.

The 48-year-old trainer is just a horseman trying to make a living, hoping to make enough money during Ellis Park’s annual summer meet to last the year.

The track, nestled along the Ohio River20in Henderson, Ky., about two hours from Louisville, has seen just about everything in the 86 years since it opened. Floods. Fire. Tornadoes.

What Mother Nature threatened to do to Ellis Park but could never quite finish off, the racing industry appeared to accomplish just days before this year’s summer meet was set to begin.

Blame it on the Internet.

In a tense meeting less than 48 hours before Opening Day, track owner Ron Geary announced he was closing the park’s doors for good after reaching an impasse with a horseman’s group over how to divvy up the track’s share from online and phone betting, called advance deposit wagers, or ADWs.

“I felt like somebody had hit me over the head with a club,” Hancock said. “I had three horses in the first day, three on the second day. … When he made that announcement, I thought I had lost everything.”

Hancock wasn’t the only one. Geary, who purchased the track from Churchill Downs Inc. in 2006, thought his dreams of rejuvenating the track were over.

“I was the sickest I’ve ever been mentally,” Geary said.

A potentially groundbreaking deal between Geary, horsemen and advance wagering companies on July 5 means there will be racing at Ellis Park this summer. But the kind of brinksmanship displayed by all sides is symptomatic of the industry’s problems.

While the racing business has largely been stagnant for the last decade – the amount of money wagered on racing in the U.S. over the last five years has dropped 3 percent according to the Jockey Club – interest in ADWs has skyrocketed.

The amount of money wagered through licensed account wagering hubs in the state of Oregon in 2001 was over $80 million. By 2007 the number had risen to nearly $1.6 billion.

To the bettor, it means plunking down a $2 win ticket on your favorite horse is usually just a phone call or a click away.

Yet rather than working together to find a way to pique interest in racing, tracks, horsemen and account wagering companies across the country are fighting over how to split the industry’s largest area of growth. At times, the battles can be bloody.

At Ellis Park, it almost meant the end of a tradition that goes back generations.

Horsemen learned a costly lesson over the last two decades when simulcasting – the tracks’ ability to send their races via satellite or closed circuit TV to other tracks and off track betting facilities – took off.

While OTB parlors flourished, horsemen never challenged the economic model built around simulcasting. They took their cut – typically between 1.5 and 3 percent – and watched as other people got rich.

Not wanting to be caught looking as ADWs gained popularity, several horsemen’s groups have begun aggressively challenging tracks for a larger slice of the ADW pie.

Typically in racing, around 82 percent of the gross receipts are awarded to the winning bettors. The remaining 18 percent is split between tracks, horsemen and in the case of ADWs, the account wagering companies.

For some tracks, like Ellis Park, the percentage of money received from the account wagering companies is similar to the amount received from simulcasting and OTBs. In 2007, Ellis Park split its 5 percent take from account wagering companies with the horsemen, according to Geary.

To horsemen groups, the math doesn’t add up. In their opinion too much money is going to the account wagering companies, and not enough to the owners and trainers that keep the sport a float.

Under the system, if $15 million is wagered through ADWs on races at the track, Ellis Park would get $375,000, the horsemen would get $375,000 and the account wagering companies would get over $2 million.

“It shows the gross injustice of the allotment and horsemen are finally feeling that we’ve got to do something to resolve the matter,” said Marty Maline, executive director of the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protection Association.

This spring the KHBPA began flexing the only muscle it has: blocking the signal from the track to go to other tracks, OTBs and online sites, a right guaranteed the group through the Interstate Horse Racing Act.

A week before Ellis Park was scheduled to open, Geary received a letter from the KHBPA saying it would block the signal. Geary tried unsuccessfully to get a court to block the KHBPA. He had two other options, cutting purses by 25 percent or closing the track. Geary chose the latter, a move that shocked horsemen.

“We recognized that this was going to be a difficult struggle,” Maline said. “We’ve heard racetracks and others in the industry saying for a long time that the economic model was broke, but it appeared to just be rhetoric.”

It makes for a vicious circle and the kind of standoff the industry can hardly afford given its perceived drug and safety problems.

“The judge, even though he ruled against me, told me (the horsemen’s decision) was cutting off their nose to spite their face,” Geary said.

Similar disputes between horsemen and tracks affected purses at Churchill Downs in Louisville and Calder Race Course in Florida this spring season.

Such fights could be on the horizon at dozens of tracks throughout the country. Rather than fight each individually, the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group was created in 2007 to act as an intermediary between horsemen in several racing states and other business entities throughout the industry in an effort to level the playing field.

“I see horsemen not being able to pay their feed bills,” said THG president Bob Reeves. “What happened is this has gotten so dag gone complicated, I think they realized they had to work together. We’ve got to get this thing fixed.”

In a perfect world, Reeves sees tracks, horsemen and account wagering companies splitting the revenue equally.

It won’t be easy. It never is in horse racing.

Account wagering companies have their own expenses. TVG, one of the largest account wagering companies in the industry, runs a costly cable television racing channel. There are fees and overhead and investors to pay. Twinspires.com, owned by CDI, employs dozens20of people and is constantly developing software to entice younger bettors.

Both also need to turn a profit to stay afloat. If they fail, racing’s Internet boom goes bust.

“From our perspective, what Churchill Downs and Twin Spires is trying to do is grow the business and attract new customers,” said CDI spokesman Kevin Flanery. “That’s what we should all be talking about. Instead we’re talking about how we’re dividing up a diminishing pile of money.”

It’s a pile of money that Geary says will disappear completely for him this summer. After negotiating with numerous account wagering companies, Geary is opting to give his entire stake from the ADWs to the horsemen at Ellis Park.

It’s a move that will allow the track to remain open and perhaps make more money in the process.

Rather than limit the track’s signal through one or two account wagering companies, Geary reached a deal that will make Ellis Park races available across 10 Internet platforms.

It’s the kind of freedom that could attract bettors, who are sometimes forced to use different Web sites to place wagers at specific tracks due to exclusivity agreements between the tracks and certain account wagering companies.

“I’m taking a one-year sacrifice, it’s a dice roll on my part,” said Geary, who projects losi ng money during the meet, which will have 39 racing dates instead of 44 due to the late start. “But I’m optimistic.”

If the early returns are any indication, Geary may be right. The track had 96 entries for 10 races on Friday, and over 100 for 11 races on Saturday. That’s far from the bare-boned five- or six-horse field Geary envisioned if he had to cut purses.

The track’s 900-stalls could be full by late-July, as more trainers opt to race at Ellis Park following Geary’s decision to give his entire ADW allotment to the horsemen.

It also means Hancock, who quit his job driving a bus for a local school system last year to take one more shot at training full-time, will be plenty busy this summer.

“It looks like we may be the springboard to a great deal for a lot of horsemen around the country,” Hancock said. “If this gets some momentum and builds, I think we won’t be talking about this anymore.”

The Associated Press

On July 5, 2008, following a lengthy meeting with a large contingent of horsemen at Ellis Park, an agreement was reached with Ron Geary, owner of Ellis Park, which solidifies the KHBPA position on Advanced Deposit Wagering (ADWs) companies, and assures horsemen racing at Ellis Park an equitable share of ADW generated revenue for purses.

“Horsemen will benefit greatly from the efforts of KHBPA,” commented Rick Hiles, President, of the KHBPA. “We feel we have set the wheels in motion which will provide an impetus for ADW agreements nationwide for years to come.”

The agreement matched the demand of the KHBPA that Ellis Park shall contribute to the purse fund an amount equal to six percent (6%) of the ADW handle or 1/3 of the takeout from wagers placed through the ADW companies on Ellis Park races, whichever is greater.

Bob Desensi, KHBPA director, reviewed with horsemen at the meeting the importance of the KHBPA stance pertaining to ADWs. “We can no longer stand by and watch ADWs siphon off the lionshare of betting,” Bob explained. “We must maintain a proactive approach to dealing with them. Afterall, we put on the show that is making them wealthy and we deserve an equitable share.”

Mike Bruder, Buff Bradley, and Joe Cain, KHBPA directors also attended the meeting fielding questions from horsemen and were instrumental in finalizing the agreement with Ellis Park.

John Hancock, a local horseman who organized the meeting, expressed his appreciation to the KHBPA directors for their support and getting the job done. “They showed they were genuinely interested in helping us,” John explained. “I felt confident if we could get the two sides together positive things could happen.”

Racing will begin at Ellis Park on July 11, 2008.

TO: HORSEMEN AND OTHER CONCERNED PARTIES.

FROM: KENTUCKY HORSEMEN’S BENEVOLENT AND PROTECTIVE ASSOCIATION (KHBPA).

REGARDING: THE CLOSING OF ELLIS PARK.

By now you have probably heard the disturbing news that Ron Geary, owner of Ellis Park, has decided not to begin racing on July 4, 2008, and to close the race track.

Briefly, I want to explain what we perceive are the reasons for the horrendous decision and the measures the KHBPA will be exploring in an effort to deal with the crisis.

Several weeks ago, the KHBPA approached Ron Geary to discuss our concerns with the small percentage that the advanced deposit wagering (ADW) companies are paying toward horsemen’s purses. We explained that in Kentucky we are competing against racetracks that have the benefit of other forms of gaming and have been fueled by slot enriched purses. The only alternative is to receive more revenue for betting on Ellis Park’s simulcast signal through the ADWs.

Ron Geary, instead of working toward a reasonable solution, decided to sue the KHBPA and, in a sense, force us to take the deal he had made with the ADWs. We objected, which is our right, and a federal judge ruled in favor of the KHBPA’s stand late yesterday.

Ron Geary immediately announced that he will not open Ellis Park.

We shared the same shock and disbelief of horsemen and the local community that have supported Ellis Park for so many years before Ron Geary happened on the scene.

It is hard to understand the logic behind the decision after all, the lost ADW revenue amounts to approximately $5,000 a day in purses. If the daily purses at Ellis Park are estimated to be between $130,000 to $140,000 per day why would Ron Geary decide to close down the racetrack based on a 3.8% loss in revenue?

One can only wonder if the prolonged labor unrest (mutuel worker’s strike) that has polarized the community or the fact that only slightly more than three hundred horses are currently stabled at Ellis Park may have influenced his decision much more than a small percentage loss of ADW revenue.

It is a tragic situation that must be rectified.

Late last night we talked with leaders of the community who are trying to assess the adverse impact of Ron Geary’s decision on the local citizenry.

Early this morning, the KHBPA will be communicating with the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority in an effort to have them intervene on behalf of horsemen and everyone who will be affected by the loss of Ellis Park.

In addition, we will use our best efforts to communicate with Ellis Park to arrive at a reasonable solution and to salvage the race meeting at Ellis Park.

If you have any questions or comments, please call at 1-800-928-4272 or contact kyhbpa@insightbb.com.

Ellis Park won’t open for its 2008 live thoroughbred racing meet on Friday as scheduled, and perhaps is closed forever.

On Wednesday night, even as Ellis-sponsored television commercials — cajoling Tri-state residents that they have “always loved horses” — continued to air, the racetrack issued a statement that a dispute with horsemen was forcing the closure of the Henderson racetrack.

A formal announcement by track owner Ron Geary is expected at a news conference at 10 a.m. today beneath the grandstand of the 86-year-old racetrack.

Ellis has been bleeding from a thousand cuts:

– A general decline in interest in horse racing from its glory days.

– Shrinking attendance locally.

– A blistering hot 2007 summer meet that discouraged horsemen and patrons alike.

– Competition from the Evansville casino boat for gamblers.

– Competition from casino-subsidized racetracks in neighboring states for racehorses.

– Shortages of horses that resulted in small fields and poor betting odds.

– Reported losses of $2.7 million last year.

– A strike and ongoing picketing by the pari-mutuel clerks’ union after Geary sought cuts in pay and benefits.

– The failure of the Kentucky legislature to ask voters whether casino gambling should be permitted at tracks to subsidize racing.

Then, on Wednesday, came a setback in U.S. District Court in Owensboro. Ellis has been locked in a dispute with the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association (HBPA) over sharing off-track wagering on races at the Henderson track.

U.S. District Judge Joseph H. McKinley turned down the track’s request for a court order forcing the horse owners to sign off on an agreement to transmit Ellis Park’s televised races to advanced deposit wagering (ADW) companies to other tracks and other betting venues, from which the track could receive a percentage of the wagering.

Geary, the Louisville businessmen who bought Ellis from Churchill Downs Inc. almost two years ago, blistered the Kentucky HBPA in a statement Wednesday night.

“It is shocking to think that the KHBPA would choose to close down Ellis Park rather than take advantage of the additional revenue already negotiated with the ADWs for 2008,” Geary said in a news release.

“They know it and they don’t care,” he continued in his statement. “All the KHBPA is focused on is hurting the ADWs this year so they can negotiate a higher percentage next year. What they are doing is a scorched earth strategy with huge collateral damage to the Tri-state.”

Marty Maline, executive director of the Kentucky HBPA, insisted Wednesday night that the Ellis Park owner has overreacted.

For Geary “to take that attitude, to just shut the meet down — we’re in a state of shock,” Maline said. “I just can’t believe it.”

The horsemen hope to persuade state racing officials to step in and force the track to conduct its live meet.

“The first thing is, we’ll contact the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority (today) to see if they can intervene in some way,” Maline said.

“If it requires decreasing purses (to owners of winning horses), so be it,” he said. “We accept that.”

Ellis Park, though, said its office will instead be open for several weeks to “handle refunds and pre-paid reservations and sponsorships” to patrons and companies.

“Meetings will take place immediately with all employees and vendors to communicate the transition,” the track said in a press release.

The track had projected that it would employ more than 500 people during the 44-day live racing meet, which would have run Wednesdays through Sundays through Labor Day.

The statement said Geary has “not released information regarding the future use of the track and its property which he owns.”

The cancellation of the 2008 race meet is a blow to the hotels, restaurants, filling stations and other businesses that benefit from the arrival of racing fans, according to Marcia Eblen, executive director of the Henderson County Tourist Commission.

“I just feel kind of numb,” Eblen said.

“From a regional standpoint, with the closing of the Executive Inn (Rivermont, a major hotel and entertainment venue in Owensboro) and then this, it’s a huge impact on tourism.”

“It really hurts our economy,” she said. “We don’t need this right now.”

1. Henry Montgomery

2. Marty Maline

3. Brent Bass

Hope to see you next year!

Ron Geary said June 24 he hasn’t received consent from the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association for distribution of the track’s racing signal for its meet that starts July 4. The Kentucky HBPA and horsemen’s groups in other states have withheld consent to several tracks in a series of nasty battles over revenue sharing of advance deposit wagering made through Internet and telephone outlets.

Geary, who said he is “sympathetic” to the horsemen’s pitch for more revenue, said he has offered a couple of alternative plans to the Kentucky HBPA in informal discussions, including a phase-in of staggered higher revenue over a five- to 10-year period.

“We’ve discussed that, but they haven’t given me any formal notification either way,” Geary said. “I am optimistic and hopeful that for the sake of continuance of Ellis Park, we will be able to meet some kind of agreement.”

Marty Maline, executive director of the Kentucky HBPA, acknowledged there have been discussions with Geary on the new revenue-sharing plan, which asks for a one-third share of takeout from ADW wagers be used for purses.

“Yes, we are aware it will adversely impact them,” Maline said of a scenario where consent isn’t granted. “We hope serious discussions will begin – they are like two weeks away from starting. Unfortunately, there’s not been a whole lot of movement.”

Geary, who in March told The Blood-Horse Ellis Park lost $2 million in 2007, said without wide-ranging signal distribution to all major ADWs, he projects 2008 revenue will decline 15%. Geary, who in the same March interview said he would consider selling the 231-acre property located in Henderson as a last resort, said he has had no further definitive thoughts on closing the track.

“I’m not making any decisions on that until I get the (horsemen’s consent) letter,” he said. “And then, I will have several options. One, I will appeal to their board if they do to little Ellis Park what they did to Churchill Downs.”

The Kentucky HBPA withheld consent for the Churchill Downs signal to go to a select group of high-volume ADWs, resulting in a 10% drop in handle. The track responded with a 20% purse cut, and filed a federal antitrust lawsuit against various horsemen’s groups and individuals.

Maline said the Kentucky HBPA is aware of the “tenuous” economic challenges facing Ellis Park, and that Kentucky could be without live Thoroughbred racing for part of the summer if Geary closes up shop. He said the track already will be facing stiffer competition from Indiana tracks, which will eventually be bolstered by slots revenue and expanded racing dates, and from Illinois tracks, which could receive additional funds from casino gaming. But he said the Kentucky HBPA can’t make an exception in the case of Ellis Park.

“We can’t suggest a different scenario to Ellis than we can with any of the racetracks,” Maline said. “It would have to be in line with what we are proposing for Churchill Downs, and, eventually, Keeneland or Turfway (Park). Everyone is recognizing this as a growth segment.”

Geary said he is looking forward to the prospects for the upcoming meet, because he had worked out a settlement with Churchill Downs Inc. in which Ellis Park is allowed to negotiate signal rights to all ADWs. Geary purchased the track from CDI in 2006, but was restricted from using such ADWs as TVG and Youbet.com in 2007 when the TrackNet Media Group venture of CDI and Magna Entertainment Corp. was launched.

“I am pleased to say that we now have agreements with TVG and Youbet,” said Geary, who blamed the ADW restriction for a 10% decline in handle last year. “This gives us our best shot. I wanted the widest distribution possible.”

Ellis Park also received $2 million from CDI as part of the settlement, according to the racetrack company’s most recent quarterly report.

Geary said he has not spoken with anyone from the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group, the national consortium of 18 horsemen’s associations. The THG, which was formed last December, is negotiating signal agreements with several tracks on behalf of several horsemen’s groups, including the Kentucky HBPA.

Bob Reeves, the president of the THG, said the national group is not yet involved in negotiations with Ellis Park. “They have not yet asked us to represent them in negotiations,” Reeves said of the Kentucky HBPA. “But recent history suggests that they will.”

Geary said while the tracks and horsemen are feeling the pinch, the industry may suffer as bettors move on to other forms of entertainment.

“We just had a national handicapping tournament and I spoke with several players,” he said. “They just said, ‘We can’t bet.’ It’s very disappointing to them. Eventually, you will lose some customers, and some of them won’t come back.”

Copyright © 2008 The Blood-Horse, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

President’s message.

As we enter the spring/summer racing season we find Kentucky racing at a crossroads. You are probably aware that, once again, the Kentucky legislature has decided not to allow the people of Kentucky the opportunity to vote on the slot issue. As is the case with many of the horsemen I talk to, everyone is frustrated with the failure of the General Assembly to reasonably address the concerns of not only horsemen, but the citizens of Kentucky in general. As the Governor stated on more than one occasion, over 80% of Kentuckians have expressed an interest in voting on gaming. The unbridled arrogance of our elected officials, not to accede to the wishes of their constituents is beyond reason, and it may well signal the demise of Kentucky’s signature industry on various fronts. While we have many friends in the legislature, certain members of legislative leadership almost appear to be enjoying our unsuccessful plight to convince the General Assembly that gaming legislation structured to enhance the racing and breeding industry is paramount. In the meantime, neighboring states that seem to understand the importance of the thousands of jobs and the economic impact of the racing industry are encouraging the exodus of our best horses and horse people to other states to ply their trade.

On another front, horsemen throughout the United States and Canada are attempting to obtain a larger portion of the lucrative advanced deposit wagering (ADWs) revenue. The Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group (THG) of which KHBPA is a founding member, has been meeting with horsemen’s organizations offering their services to negotiate a more equitable arrangement so that horsemen’s purses are reasonably compensated. It is a negotiation that will not be easy, for too many years ADW companies have been siphoning off large sums of money without providing horsemen a fair share of the revenue that they receive from the performance of horses and horsemen.

I am pleased to announce that Governor Steve Beshear has appointed me to the Kentucky Equine Drug Council (KEDC). This is the group that advises the Kentucky Racing Authority on expenditures for important drug research. When I last served on the drug council, Kentucky was at the forefront in meaningful drug research. For reasons beyond comprehension under the previous administration, the funds have not been used for this purpose and they are in danger of being retrieved by a state desperate for sources of revenue to run the government.

The KHBPA has once again moved our offices across from the 5th street stable gate. It was one of the things that I pledged to do upon taking office and thanks to a supportive board we have achieved that goal. Please come in and take a look around I think you will be pleasantly surprised of the various services that we have available to you.

Good luck in your racing endeavors!

Rick Hiles
President, KHBPA

U.S. District Court Chief Judge John G. Heyburn II hosted about a dozen attorneys and others in both his Louisville chambers and via telephone during a conference call to discuss parameters of the temporary injunction motion filed May 23 by the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association. The Kentucky HBPA, which has called the purse cut coercive and in breach of contract, is among the defendants in a federal antitrust lawsuit filed by Churchill Downs Inc. and affiliates.

Heyburn told the participants his main purpose in the conference was to make sure everyone was on the same page in regard to the issues involved with the injunction request, and he spent the better part of the hour-long meeting painting scenarios of different actions.

“I’m not trying to argue the motion for you,” he said prior to setting a June 16 formal hearing. “I just want to make sure we are all of the same thinking.”

Heyburn said that at first glance, the purse cut questions boils down to a few issues: If Churchill Downs misjudged the size of the reduction, but did it within the terms of a 2006 contract signed with horsemen, then an underpayment reimbursement at the end of the meet could clear up those matters. But if it was done, as the horsemen allege, in retaliation for actions that include withholding consent for the meet’s signal to some wagering outlets, then potential damage may have occurred.

“We all agree they have the power to reduce the purses,” he said. “The question is whether they did it in good faith. If they did it in bad faith, or did it unlawfully, that’s a whole different situation.”

Since the purse cut was enacted May 14, purses paid by Churchill Downs have fallen nearly 20.9% to a daily average of $148,960 when compared with a similar 16-card stretch of 2007, according to data compiled by The Jockey Club Information Systems. Total handle during the comparative period has dropped 23.6% to $86,962,865, not including separate-pool wagering, and has declined 8.8% to $356,609,158 for the meet to date.

Heyburn noted that even if he agreed to sign an order for the injunction, at the earliest a week after the June 16 hearing, it would only reinstate the purse levels for the last couple weeks of the Churchill Downs meet, which ends July 6.

“You would have sort of a two-week remedy; it’s an unusual injunctive relief,” he said.

Attorney Douglas L. McSwain, who represents the Kentucky HBPA, said it was still important to get the injunction in place. “We would not want the 20% cut to go into the fall meet,” he said, speaking by telephone.

Conversely, a Chicago-based attorney representing Churchill Downs told Heyburn if the injunction is signed too hastily, it might have negative effects on the fall meet for horsemen.

“If they get the relief they are seeking, and it turns out they are overpaid, then it gets taken away in the fall meet,” said David M. Schiffman via telephone, noting terms in the contract regarding overpayments.

Churchill Downs has said the 20% cut is justified based on projections of lost revenue resulting from the signal boycott, which is aimed at certain advance deposit wagering outlets that handle online and telephone bets.

Under terms of the contract, underpayments from the current meet would only be returned to those in a period of “lowest purse” as designated by the Kentucky HBPA, and can’t exceed “25% of the racing days in which the underpayment occurred.”

“If Churchill Downs is taking action that can’t be fixed, then it may be a valid reason (for the injunction), because there are 75% of the people that won’t get paid,” Heyburn said.

Kevin G. Henry, an attorney representing the Kentucky HBPA, said it would be difficult to calculate damages, because many horse owners who would have raced horses at Churchill Downs have likely shipped to other locations where purses are higher.

“I agree with your analysis,” he told Heyburn. “But I respectfully submit that it only takes into account horses racing through owners at Churchill Downs, and racing conducted at Churchill Downs through July 6. But it doesn’t take into account those that won’t ship in because of the purse cuts, and are instead shipping to places like Mountaineer Park or Presque Isle Downs. For that group, there can be no damage calculation. They are irreparably damaged.”

Since the purse cut was enacted, the average field size at Churchill Downs has been 7.54, down 6.3% from the same period a year ago.

Heyburn said owners have lots of options when faced with economic challenges, including the possibility of filing a lawsuit to try and collect damages. “We all have freedom of action,” he said. “Everyone presumably acts in their own best interest.”

Heyburn compared the horsemen withholding consent to union workers staging a walkout, and noted Churchill Downs was also likely suffering financially. “When you exercise the veto, it’s like a labor strike,” he said. “When you do that, it’s a threat; it’s an economic move. Everybody loses because the revenue stream declines. And you are hoping, just like in a union strike, that in the end it will be better.”

The judge also offered an unprompted early opinion on the charge by Churchill Downs that horsemen have violated federal antitrust laws by undertaking a joint boycott. “I’m not sure how strong that is,” he said of the antitrust allegation.

In addition to the Kentucky HBPA, others listed as defendants in the lawsuit are the Kentucky Thoroughbred Association, the Florida HBPA, and the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group, as well as various affiliated officers.

Downs May Add to Foster Purse

The Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association, one of several defendants named in a federal antitrust lawsuit originally filed April 24 by CDI and other entities, claims CDI has breached its current contract in at least two regards: by not honoring a clause that treats bets made through advance deposit wagering outlets as on-track wagers, and by unjustly reducing purses on May 14 without consulting horsemen’s groups first.

Horsemen claim CDI has failed to pay any portion of the wagering revenues earned by its TwinSpires.com platforms in 2007 or 2008. They charge CDI with breaching a contractual clause they say gives them the right to 50% of fees paid from wagering processed through telephone account outlets and other “electronic media.”

In effect, horsemen claim the contract says wagers processed through CDI’s TwinSpires.com are to be treated as “walk-up” betting at the track. Filings estimate the figure not paid by CDI under terms of the agreement to be about $3 million.

Attorney Douglas L. McSwain, who represents the horsemen, said in a telephone interview the clause governing account wagering was put into contracts “a number of years ago” in anticipation of CDI developing its own ADW platforms. TwinSpires.com was launched in April 2007, and expanded its holdings by adding several AmericaTab platforms last summer.

“We didn’t want to have to battle them in this fashion, but we’ve been left with no choice,” McSwain said of the lawsuit sparring.

CDI and horsemen’s groups are battling over revenue sharing plans for dollars wagered through certain ADWs. Horsemen in their filings claim the purse cut was “coercive” and “retaliatory” to the stalled negotiations, and, thus, in defiance of the three-year contract signed in 2006.

A horsemen’s counterclaim notes the contract states CDI cannot “threaten, intimidate or otherwise coerce any horseman, HBPA member, employee or representative thereof.” Horsemen claim CDI breached that clause by executing an excessive purse cut, and by publicly laying blame on horsemen for projected handle decline.

“CDI’s action to cut the payment of purses by 20% is a wrongful and intentional exercise of dominion and control over the Horsemen’s Account for its own benefit and not for the benefit of Kentucky horsemen …” said the counterclaim, which was written by McSwain.

CDI spokesman Kevin Flanery said the company’s attorneys are reviewing the 200-plus pages of filings.

“Obviously, we will let the court proceedings take place, and let the pleadings speak for themselves,” he said, adding the company is still willing to negotiate with horsemen.

In its complaint, CDI claims certain horsemen groups and individuals have violated the federal Sherman Antitrust law by conspiring to have the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group negotiate on their behalf. The THG, which is also named as a defendant in the lawsuit, is a collective of 18 horsemen’s associations.

In a separate motion for temporary injunction, the horsemen are asking U.S. District Court Judge John G. Heyburn II to return the amount of purse money underpaid by the 20% purse cut, and to order CDI to “consult” with the Kentucky HBPA “on any (and) all matters touching upon the purse account.”

Since the purse cut was executed May 14, Churchill Downs has paid out $765,055 less in purses, or a decline of 19.73%, in comparison to the same time period of the 2007 spring meet, according to data compiled by The Jockey Club Information Systems. All-sources handle, not including separate pool wagering, fell 20.63% to $62,929,729 when compared to the same time period.

An Open Letter to the Racing Industry

Horse lovers and racing fans alike felt their hearts sink at the sight of Eight Belles breaking down shortly after her heroic run in last Saturday’s Kentucky Derby.

The Board of Directors, Officers, Staff and 35,000 horsemen and horsewomen of the National HBPA all felt the very same heartache and our thoughts and support go out to the connections of Eight Belles – owner Rick Porter and trainer Larry Jones – as well.

The trauma of last Saturday remains fresh on the minds of those of us in the racing industry as well as fans, writers, broadcasters and just about anyone who watched the Derby. And, it will most certainly remain fresh on the mind Eight Belles’ trainer Larry Jones.

For over 60 years, the National HBPA has been committed to its motto of “Horsemen Helping Horsemen” and, in the case of Larry Jones, this applies more than ever.

We have sensed a rush to judgment on how Eight Belles was prepared for the Derby. Theories abound and for a little more than a mile and quarter, Larry Jones had done his work to perfection.

Yet now the sense is that Larry Jones, regardless of what facts may surface, is found guilty in the court of public perception. Unfortunately, we live and work in the age of the sound bite, where careers and reputations can be shredded in an instant. Remember the Jose Santos – Funny Cide – battery debacle of 2003?

Like horses, each person is different. Larry Jones couldn’t be more different than Michael Matz, yet both are veteran horsemen with a long track record of success… and both have faced tragic and very public losses of star horses they’d spent countless hours training and pampering. And both may be viewed differently as they face the television cameras and microphones.

Over the coming days, weeks and months, our industry will be scrutinized from within as well as from without. As we navigate this difficult time for racing, let’s avoid any unnecessary collateral damage and give Larry Jones – and all horsemen and horsewomen facing similar circumstances – the benefit of the doubt until all facts come to light.

Joe Santanna
President and Chairman
National HBPA

“The Jones stable is a small family operation, just like Airdrie,” he said.

In the twilight of the following day, Larry Jones also spoke of family after Rick Porter’s Eight Belles, whom he had saddled to finish second in the Kentucky Derby Presented by Yum! Brands (gr. I), had broken down and had to be euthanized.

“These horses are our family,” the trainer said.

And losing a family member is never easy.

Larry Jones wanted to grieve in private. But he understands the role the media plays. Despite wanting to be alone with his wife, family members, and the filly’s groom, Corey York, Jones agreed to speak to reporters in the press box nearly two hours after the tragic event had played out.

Many trainers, understandably, would have declined the offer to address the assembled reporters, but Jones said the filly had gained a number of admirers and wanted them properly informed. “You want to go off by yourself but you owe it to the sport; the public wants to know,” he said.

Jones tried to fight back the tears, without success.

At 6 a.m. the following morning, the first stall by his tack room was closed, an Eight Belles sticker attached to the old, wooden door. Jones’ pony, Pal, was in the next stall, with Proud Spell to his right. In the next stall was the blanket of lilies won by Proud Spell in the Oaks.

In the tack room, Jones spoke about the family member they had lost. His wife, Cindy, cried again, her eyes bloodshot from having wept most of the night.

“When we walked her to the chute before the Derby, she stopped and never moved one foot,” Larry Jones said. “She had her head hanging and was letting us play with her. She thought she was the star of the show.”

During the walkover, in the paddock, and throughout the post parade, Eight Belles never turned a hair. Jones proceeded to a third-floor box above the tunnel to watch the race.

“When they came by the first time, she was happy,” he said. “She was not trying to get away from anybody or anything. The whole race, she never got bumped; never got touched.” After she crossed the finish line, Jones celebrated and headed toward the track.

“Kent (Desormeaux, who rode winner Big Brown) wasn’t jubilant like Calvin (Borel) last year,” Jones said. “Then I saw Gabe (Eight Belles’ jockey Gabe Saez) on the pony and he said, ‘Mr. Larry, they had to put her down.’ I ran for the ambulance.”

When Jones saw Eight Belles, he immediately knew what had to happen next.

But he is still mystified as to why it happened at all.

Jones took out his trainer’s license in 1982 and had two horses he bought for $800 each. Today, he has 50 in the barn, a number that will soon double when the 2-year-olds arrive.

In more than 25 years of training, Jones previously had three horses break down during races and a few others during morning training. You never forget any of them, he said.

In 2006, Jones was among the team of advisers selecting yearlings for Porter, Eight Belles being one of those they approved for purchase. She arrived at his barn after last year’s Derby, in which he sent out Porter’s Hard Spun to run second.

“I thought she was the one to get us to the Breeders’ Cup last year, but she never got into it mentally,” Jones said. “She didn’t know then how talented she was.”

On May 3, everyone found out how talented Eight Belles was. She was perfectly prepared, perfectly ridden, and perfectly happy.

She showed nothing but class on the racetrack.

The same can be said of her trainer.

Recently, I am sure you have heard rumblings about our decision not to send the simulcast signal to the various advanced deposit wagering companies until horsemen receive a more equitable share of the revenue. This decision was reached after careful consideration regarding the overall health of the racing industry.

To every horseman it is all too familiar. “Handle is up, yet purses to decline.”

If a racing jurisdiction has not been fortunate enough to pass legislation providing a supplement to purses from slot revenues, inevitably purses will remain stagnant or decrease.

Quite often we are asked to explain how wagering can substantially increase while purses do not keep pace. It is simply due to the changing betting patterns of the wagering public. Where once people interested in betting came to the racetracks to watch and wager on horses, now for the most part they bet from remote locations or via the computer.

Initially, horsemen and racetracks were encouraged with the broader distribution of the racing product. Eventually, horsemen began to notice an alarming trend, the influx in betting did not result in appreciable purse increases. The dramatic handle increases from remote off track locations where horsemen do not receive an equitable share of wagering has created quite a dilemma.

Most notably, advanced deposit wagering (ADWs) companies, an innovative concept where betting patrons are encouraged to wager via the internet or by phone and view the races on television is the fastest growing segment of the racing industry.

Since its inception, ADWs recognized the distinct possibility that there would be a significant downturn in wagering at racetracks. Early on they initiated “bettor poaching fees,” later referred to as “source market fees,” to address the erosion of betting at the racetrack where horsemen receive a larger share of the wagering dollar. Later ADWs decided to increase the host fees as opposed to source market fees, but in the end while ADWs enjoyed immense profits from siphoning off betting patrons at the racetrack, horsemen continued to experience a decline in purses.

Experts continue to lament that the model is broke, but no one seems to have an answer on how it should be fixed. Exacerbating the problem is that now several racetracks have entered into the national ADW business. Therefore, while the ADWs flourish and racetracks profit from their ownership of the ADWs, horsemen’s problems with a lower share of the wagering dollar are compounded. With this backdrop, horsemen have decided that the time has come to restructure the model to assure that horsemen are receiving an equitable share of wagering revenue.

It was never our intention to alienate the betting public, we are simply attempting to assure that horsemen can continue to provide the quality of racing with reasonable purses that everyone richly deserves.

Rick Hiles President KHBPA

The winds of change often come very slowly in Thoroughbred horse racing, but some badly needed change for our sport is on the way. For as long as there has been simulcasting, horsemen and women have had little, if any, say about the compensation they receive from satellite wagering sites that import the simulcast signal. And let’s keep in mind that the simulcast signal belongs to horsemen at least as much as it does to the racetracks. The Interstate Horseracing Act of 1978 guarantees it.

A new organization called the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group (THG) has been formed by horsemen’s groups in the United States and Canada, including fourteen state-level HBPA groups, two members of the THA, the KTA and the Thoroughbred Owners of California. TOBA has also given a strong endorsement to the THG.

These horsemen’s groups created the THG to bring about change, because they believe that the percentage of takeout that makes its way back to funding purses is becoming dangerously low. The THG, who now negotiates on behalf of many of these horsemen’s groups on contracts with Advanced Deposit Wagering (ADW) companies, is trying to increase the return to purses from bets placed through ADW companies. Now, ADW companies keep about half of their takeout and return only about one-fifth of their takeout to purses, much less than what most simulcasting returns to purses, which is especially disgraceful when the ADW company that’s keeping the lion’s share also happens to be owned by the tracks where the races are run. Horsemen’s one-fifth share needs to increase to a level that better supports live horse racing. That would boost purses significantly throughout the country, from the lowliest county fairs, to tracks in New York & Ky.

As you can imagine, the THG is meeting a great deal of resistance on this issue. It seems that racetracks and ADW operators are very content to pay only a small fraction of their takeout back to purse accounts, which has been allowed to go on for far too long. When THG offered a proposal to open up account wagering on the Kentucky Derby and Oaks Days, CDI’s only response to the proposal was to file a lawsuit against the THG. But the unity from coast to coast that is usually nonexistent in horse racing when it comes to horsemen sticking together, is a positive sign that these changes can and must take place for the betterment of our sport. We can not expect our owners to continue spending $2 Billion a year to keep their racing stock in training when they’re running for only $1 Billion in purse money, which is now the case. These people at the THG representing horsemen’s groups have no agenda other than to see that a fair amount of simulcast money reverts back to purses. If they succeed, the game will be much stronger, which will benefit ALL segments of the sport, including racetracks, owners, trainers, jockeys and breeders. And the ADW companies, too.

On behalf of the Board of Trustees and the Members of the Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders Association, we fully endorse your position to support the Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Group’s goal of reforming the industry’s wagering revenue distribution system.

TOBA applauds the leadership of the Kentucky HBPA and recognizes the short-term financial setbacks that horsemen must sustain during this period. We completely support the goals of the THG to require fair pricing for advance deposit wagering companies, as the shift in wagering from on-track and traditional simulcast outlets to ADW companies has led to less money from pari-mutuel sources being contributed to live racing. We believe that it is only reasonable to ask ADW companies to pay their fair share to purses. Racetrack companies that own ADW companies are incentivized to redirect wagering from on track to their ADW company by the current pricing model, as they are able to retain more revenue from an account wager and pay less to purse accounts than when the same bet is made at their track.

Owners invested approximately $3 billion last year to provide the racing product at tracks across the United States, yet purses were only $1.18 billion. This economic structure is clearly broken and a more equitable pricing model will help ensure the future of our industry. As the most significant investors in our sport, owners must remain committed to the THG and provide the leadership that our industry desperately needs during this very critical moment of time. The mission statement of TOBA is to “improve the economics, integrity and pleasure of the sport on behalf of Thoroughbred owners and breeders.” Your decision to change the current financial model between ADW companies and purse accounts fully supports our mission and we would like to extend our assistance to you in any way possible.

Your courageous decision will have a positive impact on all owners in the United States and we appreciate your leadership.

By DRF READERS

Horsemen’s voice sounds warning call on steroid action

Recently, I presented concerns to the Kentucky Racing Authority regarding the implementation of anabolic steroid regulation, and by doing so it was felt by some that the Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association is attempting to obstruct the process of meaningful changes to current rules in effect. This is absolutely not the intention of the horsemen’s association.

On Feb. 25, a senior representative of the Racing Medication and Testing Consortium appeared before the Kentucky Racing Authority in an attempt to convince them to move forward on an interim anabolic steroid regulation.

I prefaced my remarks to the racing authority by explaining that horsemen generally are fully in favor of addressing this issue, but at the same time it appears that the anabolic steroid regulation proposed by the medication and testing consortium is not yet ready to be implemented.

I quoted comments from the Feb. 17 Daily Racing Form article “Fewer stallions, more broodmares” by Dr. Rick Arthur, equine medical director for the California Horse Racing Board, who also happens to be a respected member of the consortium board. He stated:

“Until we get normal levels in blood, it’s going to be very difficult to regulate those specific products, and there is a big variation.”

And supporting this position, Dr. Rick Sams, a nationally recognized chemist and director of the University of Florida’s Racing Laboratory, and also a member of the consortium board explained:

“What we don’t have is a good handle on even what an average concentration of testosterone is throughout the year or what the range of concentration is.”

And, the article itself noted, “The issue is compounded by the fact that natural steroid levels can vary considerably from horse to horse.”

The communication presented by the consortium board member to the Kentucky Racing Authority made clear that definitive threshold levels and withdrawal times for anabolic steroids will not be available until at least August, despite which regulators in some jurisdictions are deciding to move forward with regulations. The racing authority is to be commended for its careful and balanced approach to this technically complicated situation.

With regard to technical complications, it is interesting to note that Dr. Don Catlin, head of the Equine Drug Research Institute, was quoted by The Blood-Horse as stating at the Welfare and Safety of the Racehorse Summit at Keeneland on March 17, that “you need much more infrastructure” than currently exists in regard to steroid testing, and that “you need to walk before you run.”

These are the on-the record comments of the scientific experts in this field. Given these circumstances, it would be unfair and unwise for any racing authority to implement vigorously an interim anabolic steroid regulation that has the potential to ruin the careers of innocent horses and horsemen and to also damage the racing industry at large.

Marty Maline, Executive Director, Kentucky Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association

Posted: Monday March 17, 4:47 PM

An authority on drug testing, who has worked with the United States Olympic Committee and is now advising the horse racing industry, has urged caution on efforts to regulate anabolic steroids. “You need much more infrastructure; you need to walk before you run,” Dr. Don Catlin said March 17 during the second Welfare and Safety of the Racehorse Summit at the Keeneland sale pavilion in Lexington. “You’re getting there. You’re taking the first steps.”

Catlin, head of the Equine Drug Research Institute, made his comments following a report from Dr. Scot Waterman, executive director of the Racing Medication and Testing Consortium, who noted the progress being made throughout the country in getting racing jurisdictions to adopt rules to regulate four types of anabolic steroids. Earlier, during his presentation to the about 100 industry professionals attending the public portion of the summit, Catlin advocated an outright ban on steroids. A main reason for banning the drugs altogether is that a myriad of different anabolic steroids are available. Even restricting the testing to only four and determing threshold levels that would determine a positive test, he said, will still be cumbersome. For example, stanozolol, one of the drugs on the list to be regulated under the RMTC model rule, “stays around in the body for a long period of time. It stays for weeks and weeks. It can be negative today and positive tomorrow. It is going to be very hard to regulate…levels can vary from day to day,” Catlin said. Stanozolol was the steroid for which Olympic medalist sprinter Ben Johnson tested positive in 1988, causing him to lose the gold medal he won in the Seoul Olympics and be stripped of a world record. Johnson’s positive created a major uproar within the world of international track and field.

“You ban steroids, it all goes away,” Catlin said. Waterman said eight states have adopted RMTC model rules and that the concept of regulation “has a lot of momentum.” He said the steroid tests to be used in the U.S. are based on urine samples and modeled after those used in countries prohibiting steroids in racehorses. He said a mechanism for testing steroids by using blood plasma samples should be available later this year.

In addition to medication, one of the other focal points of the summit was the subject of synthetic surfaces and some of the problems associated with them. Dr. Mary Scollay, the track veterinarian at Gulfstream Park and Calder Race Course, reported on the initial results of information compiled from injury and fatality reports from regulatory veterinarians at 42 racetracks. During the reporting period, there were 244 fatalities from 123,890 starters on dirt, for a ratio of 1.96 per 1,000 starts. For the tracks with synthetic surfaces, the ratio of 58 fatalities from 29,744 starts was 1.95 per 1,000 starts ratio, a figure Scolay said “almost floored me” because the two numbers were so close to each other. A panel of racetrack superintendents provided insights into the difficulties associated with maintaining synthetic surfaces. About 60 summit participants were scheduled to conduct private meetings March 17-18, with a media briefing to follow on the second day of the summit, which was presented by the Grayson-Jockey Club Research Foundation.

A meeting of the Turfway Park/KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee for the 2008 Turfway Park winter/spring race meeting was held on March 13, 2008.

Bob Elliston, President; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Greg Schmidt, Plant Superintendent; Steve Peterman, Starter/Stall Manager; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Wayne Mogge, Joe Davis, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee.

Lanny Kohnhorst also attended representing the KTA.

SLOT INITIATIVE-Bob Elliston reported on the racing industry’s effort to encourage the General Assembly to pass legislation which would allow the people of Kentucky the right to vote on the gaming issue. He explained that it has been a difficult struggle attempting to convince legislators that the horse industry needs help in order to survive. While the possibility of passing of favorable legislation remains alive time is running out. Hopefully, now that the budget has cleared the House of Representatives, they still have time to focus on the gaming issue.

WINDOW UPDATE-Greg Schmitz reported that an independent analysis has been completed of the window project and we are waiting on the written report. The intention is to have the individual talk with trainers on specific issues in addition to his own observations.

TRACK SURFACE-A discussion ensued regarding the racing surface. Bob Elliston explained that as part of their due diligence, they intend to have Dr. Tim Peterson a renowned track consultant, spend several days at Turfway Park following the race meeting measuring the key variables affecting track safety. In addition, it is their intention to develop a strategy for maintaining a consistent racing surface.

PURSE STATUS-Following a review of the status of the purse account, Bob Elliston suggested that he will review the status of the KTDF fund with Rick Leigh, Director of Racing, with the intention of hopefully increasing the supplement.

SECURITY-Chip Bach reported on the security snafu that resulted in someone gaining access to someone else’s dormitory room. He assured the committee that this problem has been corrected. Chip also explained that the individual that had been violated will be made whole.

PONY BARN-Chip explained that issues with the pony barn will be reviewed following the cessation of the live race meeting in an effort to arrive at a reasonable solution.

ICE MACHINES-Chip explained that while he does not recall receiving any work orders that any of the ice machines are not working, he will have the maintenance department check each unit.

PROPOSED HEALTH CLINIC-Following an explanation, both Bob Elliston and Chip Bach agreed to allot space for a proposed health clinic trailer on the backstretch.

SUMMER STABLING-Chip explained that Turfway Park will, once again, provide stall space for horsemen interested in stabling during the summer. The price, as before will be $7.00 per stall and that includes watering of the racing surface.

BACH BOULEVARD-Chip reported that he has petitioned the State of Kentucky for the possibility of having security barriers erected and more sturdy stop signs along Bach Boulevard. In addition, he regrets to inform everyone that the name of the roadway may be changed. Those in attendance at the meeting appeared to be both shocked and disappointed by the news.

EQUISIZER UPDATE-Chip explained that they are still exploring the possibility of an Equisizer on the backstretch, but at this time there is no firm commitment to this project.

EASTER SUNDAY-Jeff wanted to remind horsemen that there will be no training on Easter Sunday, Chip assured the committee that the track kitchen will be open.

HORSEMEN’S SHUTTLE-Chip reminded horsemen that there will be a shuttle available on Lanes End Spiral Stakes day. The shuttle will be operating continually taking horsemen choosing to park on the backstretch, to and from the area in proximity to the paddock.

POTHOLE REPORT-Bill Connelly reported that a sizable pothole has developed in the vicinity of the pony barn.

KHBPA ANNUAL DINNER/DANCE-The 25th annual KHBPA Dinner/Dance will be held on Monday, March 17th, at the “Receptions” Banquet & Conference Center. The event celebrating the beginning of Lanes End Spiral Stakes week, will be from 6:00 P.M. until 11:00 P.M. Contact Donna Davis in the Turfway Park KHBPA office for further information.

CRAWFISH BOIL-Bob Elliston reports that the annual Turfway Park Crawfish Boil will be held the following night, on March 18th, at Turfway Park from 6:00 P.M. to 10:00 P.M. This year the event will benefit Justin Vitek. Bob explained that several items including a weekend trip to the Belmont stakes and the guitar of Dierks Bentley, country music singer, will be auctioned off. All horsemen are welcomed.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Memorandum

To: Kentucky Horsemen

From: KHBPA

Re: Legislative Update

On Thursday night, February 28, 2008, KEEP held a meeting of racing industry leaders to discuss the legislative effort attempting to secure gaming while protecting the Kentucky racing industry.

There was some sentiment not to support legislation for gaming that did not protect the Kentucky racing industry however others felt that with assurances from Governor Steve Beshear and legislative leaders, racing will be adequately protected. It was finally decided to support moving the gaming legislation forward and to continue to pursue language that will offer the protection for the racing industry.

The Speaker of the House and the Governor are both working, attempting to garner support of the members of the House of Representatives. It is understood that the gaming bill will not be brought forward to be voted on if there are not enough legislators in the house that agree to vote in favor of the legislation.

John Cooper, Chief lobbyist for KEEP, signaled out the efforts of the KHBPA and the horsemen for walking the halls and talking with legislators and the boisterous impromptu rally on the steps leading to the House chambers. Many feel that legislators were finally able to put a face to the thousands of horsemen and others who rely on the racing industry to eke out a living.

The second meeting of the Turfway Park/KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee for the 2008 Turfway Park race meeting was held on February 1, 2008.

Bob Elliston, President; Rick Leigh, Director of Racing; Steve Peterman, Starter/Stall Manager; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Dave England, Joe Davis, Jeff Greenhill and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee.

Slot Initiative – Bob Elliston explained to the committee the status of the proposed slot legislation. He reviewed the prospects of favorable legislation and he mentioned that Governor Beshear will be introducing legislation to all interested parties possibly as soon as next week. He expressed confidence that the Governor is cognizant of the importance of the racing industry and will tailor his legislative package accordingly. There is a concern that a proposed fee necessary to receive approval for a slot license may hinder the various racetracks in their effort to provide a facility that is capable of competing with the existing facilities in Indiana.

Purse Update – Marty reviewed the current status of purses at Turfway Park. The underpayment has remained fairly consistent with last year holding at or near $400,000 while the KTDF supplement fund has increased approximately $200,000 as compared to last year. Bob explained that the experiment with day racing fluctuates from day to day, as far as handle figures, but he feels that racing days as opposed to nights has allowed them to race some days when frigid weather conditions at night would have most likely caused occasional cancellations. Bob is most concerned about the out of state wagering revenue figures that are in decline. He attributes this, to a certain extent, to the continued imbroglio involving TVG and other Advance Deposit Wagering companies that does not allow racetracks to have broad distribution of the simulcast signal. Rick Leigh commented that he felt confident that the KTDF supplement can be increased 5% beginning with Friday’s races.

Track Surface – Jeff reviewed with the committee the issue with horses losing footing at the start of races and how the problem was corrected. He explained that the temperatures plummeted creating a freeze dried condition much like a beach and horses were unable to gather traction as they accelerated from the starting gate. Using the rotiller and power harrow they were able to compact a layer of polytrak below the cushion which allows the horses to successfully push off without losing their balance. Another situation, regarding the surface packing in their feet, occurred after a mixed precipitation of snow, rain and ice that was followed by temperatures dipping into the mid-teens with a substantial wind. Bob explained that while the wax applied during the summer has successfully prevented this from being as much of an issue as last year, we are still working to resolve the problem when the combination of moisture and extremely cold temperatures presents itself. He commended the dedication of Jeff and his crew in making the surface as safe as possible under the extreme weather conditions that we have experienced this winter.

Weather Protocol – In an effort to facilitate a better system for canceling races due to weather conditions on a timely basis, the committee proposed a committee of two members from management, two members from the horsemen’s committee and two members of the jockey colony. On days where the temperature is below twenty and sustained winds of twenty miles per hour or more and these conditions will occur during the race card the committee will meet early in the morning to decide if races should be cancelled. While everyone agreed that every effort will be made to run, if the weather is too extreme to reasonably think the race card can be completed than the races will be cancelled. It has been decided that Marty will coordinate the effort.

Jay Bowman – Horsemen have expressed their appreciation to the dedication of Jay Bowman who has been maintaining the backstretch restrooms in a clean and sanitary manner. In past years, problems with the restrooms have been a constant source of frustration, now it is a non issue.

Pest Control – While Steve has aggressively pursued an eradication program, apparently the issue with insect infestation in various dormitory complexes continues. Chip has suggested that they will consult with a professional in an effort to alleviate the problem.

Television Reception – Television reception in the barn area is a problem. It was suggested that perhaps an amplifier is not functioning, since that same issue occurred previously.

Stop Signs On The Connector Road – The stop signs on Bach Boulevard are a casualty of either the high winds or questionable driving practices.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline Executive Director KHBPA

The first meeting of the Turfway Park/KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee for the 2008 Turfway Park race meeting was held on January 10, 2008.

Bob Elliston, President, Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Rick Leigh, Director of Racing; and Steve Peterman, Starter/Stall Manager attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Wm. “Buff” Bradley, David England, Joe Davis, Larry Holt, Melissa Pylant, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA.

Slot Update – Bob Elliston reviewed with the horsemen’s committee the encouraging meeting with Governor Beshear regarding his gaming initiative. The meeting was attended by representatives of the racetracks, horsemen’s organizations, and the KEEP program.

Maintenance Strategy – Chip Bach informed the committee that he feels the implementation of their new maintenance program has proven beneficial to the overall timeliness of addressing maintenance requests. They will continue to hone their maintenance procedure to assure issues are resolved quickly and efficiently. Horsemen are reminded that all maintenance must first be reported to the guard shack in order that it can be logged into the record.

Weather Protocol – Bob Elliston informed the committee that the requested protocol in dealing with potential cancellations of racing has been successfully implemented.

Receiving Barn – Larry Holt explained that several problem areas in the receiving barn that needed attention were addressed on a timely basis and he appreciated the quick response. Bob informed the committee that one of their maintenance crew has the responsibility to check the receiving barn on a regular basis for preventive maintenance. Chip also mentioned that they will be installing signs at the receiving barn to inform ship-in horsemen of the procedure to follow when problems arise so they can be addressed quickly.

Blacktop Update – Chip updated the status of the blacktopping by explaining that the area of concern in the vicinity of the receiving barn has been corrected. Bill Connelly suggested that work still needs to be done near the tack trailers. Jeff explained that he plans to address the area now that the holidays have past.

Monitors Out On Second Floor of the Grandstand – Horsemen have mentioned that various monitors are not working on the second floor of the grandstand. Bob and Chip explained that they were not aware of a problem, but they will check on it. Bob informed the committee that they are installing new flat screen televisions on the ground floor, and they will use the televisions being replaced to replace any monitors not working.

Trash Pickup – Chip explained that a new strategy has been implemented to assist horsemen in trash removal with the help of Turfway employee, Jay Bowman. Buff mentioned that Jay had alerted him to the trash pickup of larger items and he was able to facilitate the removal of a larger item.

Track Surface – Jeff explained that recently he has installed new teeth on the gallopmaster allowing him to assure that the track has sufficient cushion.

Purse Status – Marty reviewed the present status of the purse account. Purses generated and paid are comparable to 2007. The KTDF fund purses paid this year have been $545,640 as compared to $369,285 in 2007. Currently, there is an excess in the KTDF account of $432,070. Rick Leigh informed the committee that Turfway is paying at a higher level than last year 48% as compared to 34% in the 2007 Winter/Spring race meeting. Bob explained that we will monitor the KTDF supplement and if possible they will be favorably adjusted.

Slippery Paddock – Chip explained that the problem he suspects was due to blowing snow. Bob explained that they are hesitant to put salt down in the paddock due to harsh effects on the grass and shrubbery. David England explained that certain chemicals are available that will resolve the problem while keeping the area safe.

Eurosizer – David England asked about the status of the proposed Eurosizer. Bob explained that they are still checking the financial viability of the project.

Pest Control – Steve Peterman explained that they have begun pest control measures in the dormitories and they will continue the program for as long as it is necessary. Chip stated that in the future they will make sure that everyone is given plenty of advanced notice prior to bombing.

Stop Signs – Chip explained that the stop signs are nearing completion and will be installed on Bach Boulevard, the access road from the backside to the front side.

Respectfully submitted, Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

The final meeting of the Turfway Park/ KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee for the 2007 Turfway Park Holiday race meeting was held on December 21, 2007.

Bob Elliston, President, Turfway Park; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Rick Leigh, Director of Racing; and Steve Peterman, Starter and Stall Superintendent attended representing Turfway Park.

Wm. “Buff” Bradley, Bill Connelly, Joe Davis, Jeff Greenhill, Wayne Mogge, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA.

Fence in Proximity to Receiving Barn-Chip Bach explained that the fence adjacent to the receiving barn has been installed.

Bedding in the Receiving Barn-Jeff explained that they have implemented a plan to have additional bales of straw in proximity to receiving barn stalls available to supplement the bedding already in stalls in the receiving barn.

Work Orders Addressing Maintenance Issues-Chip provided a memorandum addressing the procedure to follow when requesting maintenance on the backstretch. Chip stressed that the goal is same day service with the standard being two days. The key is to initiate the request for maintenance at the guard shack so that they can log it in. The memorandum will be distributed along with the minutes.

Traffic Jam at the Guard Gate-The traffic problems continue to be an issue at the guard gate. Following a brief discussion, Bob Elliston suggested that an area be made available for vans, trucks and trailers with issues to pull over allowing other vans with no issues to continue on to the receiving barn.

Manure Pickup-Jeff mentioned that the equipment alleviating the mess in proximity to the manure bins has arrived. Bill Connelly stated that recently he had experienced quite a mess after they attempted to load manure on the truck and apparently missed. Jeff explained that overall he felt the system of picking up manure has immensely improved, but he would delve into what happened at Bill’s barn.

Trash Pickup-Chip explained that they have implemented a program whereby Jay Bauman contacts backside maintenance whenever he sees apparent large trash items that need to be hauled away. The committee suggested that the other ideas involving trash maintenance should be initiated.

Ruts in the Horse Path-Jeff reviewed his attempts to alleviate the problem which included running equipment over the path at various times during the day. If someone notices a vehicle running over the horse path they should be reported and their lack of consideration for the horses using the horse path will be addressed.

Update on Blacktop-Chip reviewed the status of the blacktop repair in the barn area. He explained that several areas have been improved. As far as the area in the vicinity of receiving barn, it is still a work in progress.

Snow and Ice Removal-The committee discussed the yeoman effort to remove the ice and snow on Saturday, December 15, and next discussed the problems associated with ice on Sunday morning in the barn area. Chip expressed the view that they will continue to strive in assuring that everyday, results in the success they experienced on Saturday. In addition, he mentioned that they are beginning a new process of announcing when they will be working in the barn area with snow removal equipment or any other projects that may result in uncharacteristic noise in the barn area.

Windows Project Update-Chip explained that they are currently in the mode of fixing areas of concern expressed by horsemen. Afterward they will be reviewing the project with an independent carpenter.

Insect Infestation-The problem with insects in the dormitories continues to worsen. Bob Elliston suggested that immediately after the Christmas holiday, they will expedite addressing the issue.

Health Certificates-This issue continues to be a source of frustration with horsemen. Bob Elliston explained that everyone should be cognizant of the dangers of being less than vigilant in this area. He suggested that Chip and Marty should communicate with Rusty Ford of the Kentucky State Department of Agriculture and see if a longer period can be established between the need for updated health certificates.

Race Cancellation-The committee requested that Bob authorize the $150 supplement to horsemen who had horses entered on Sunday that were prevented from racing following the cancellation. In addition, the committee suggested that a protocol should be established whereby if jockeys feel it is unlikely that they can complete the racing card due to weather conditions, that management and horsemen should be informed as early as possible to avoid angering betting patrons and requiring horsemen to medicate and ship horses.

Racing Surface-Committee members discussed maintenance of the racing surface. Jeff explained that according to the weather and moisture expected, they use the necessary equipment at frequent enough intervals to assure a surface with cushion. Bob Elliston informed the committee that they are monitoring the times and adjust the level of the equipment accordingly. In addition, he will continue to seek imput from all interested parties.

Closing Track Early-The committee suggested that whenever it is possible, the track superintendent should provide reasonable notice prior to closing the track. This will allow horsemen to train the horses they need to train first. Jeff explained that he makes every effort to do this unless the weather conditions simply dictate otherwise.

No Shipping to Train-Rick Leigh reminded that with the new day time racing schedule there will be no training from the receiving barn on Wednesdays and Thursdays in addition to Saturdays and Sundays starting the week after Christmas.

Policy on Wood Shavings-Chip Bach presented a memorandum regarding the disposal of shavings for horsemen using them for bedding. Shavings can only be disposed of in approved dumpsters. Anyone found disposing of shavings by dumping them in manure bins or dumping the used shavings in shedrows will be held responsible for cleaning the manure bins and shedrows, and may be further disciplined.

Backstretch Christmas Celebration-On Christmas Eve in the rec. hall at Turfway starting at 10:30 A.M. the KHBPA will host a brunch for the backstretch community. There will be barbecue, potato salad and beans along with plenty of desserts and everyone is welcome. That same night, Chaplain Tom will have a service including food and beverages. On Christmas Day, Father Niehaus with the help of Jerry the “Russian” following Christmas service will provide a Christmas feast and gifts to the backstretch community. The KHBPA will provide sandwiches later that day for anyone who is still hungry.

Stop Sign at the Access Road-Chip explained that he is attempting to facilitate securing stop signs at this location. If he cannot receive state approval, Turfway will install their own.

Respectfully submitted,

Martin Maline, KHBPA Ex. Dir.

The first meeting of the December Holiday race meeting was held on November 30, 2007.

Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Greg Schmidt, Plant Superintendent; Rick Leigh, Director of Racing; Steve Peterman, Starter/Stable Manager; and Jeff Chapman, Track Superintendent attended representing Turfway Park.

Bill Connelly, Wm. “Buff Bradley”, Joe Davis, Wayne Mogge and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee. Marty recorded the minutes.

Track Surface Update – Jeff reviewed the schedule that has been recommended for maintenance of the racing surface. He explained that, once a month the rototiller is used which churns the entire surface in order that it is consistent throughout. In addition, once a week, the power harrow is utilized which prevents the surface from becoming too packed and firm. It has been suggested that when using the different equipment that it be used on Sunday night to allow the track surface to settle. Jeff agreed with this suggestion. Jeff explained that to address the surface kickback, they plan to apply water on an as needed basis. The horsemen in attendance explained that they gauge if the track is too firm by the differential in times between better horses and cheaper claimers during works and racing. In addition, another indicator is if you can hear the horses hoof strikes as they exercise in the morning. Chip mentioned that the schedule for using the various track equipment will change when it is warranted.

Fence Near the Receiving Barn – Greg explained that the track adjacent to the receiving barn that had been removed during road construction is scheduled to be installed on Wednesday of next week.

Bedding in the Receiving Barn – Horsemen have explained that when shipping into the receiving barn, there is less bedding in the stalls. Jeff explained that due to a stall shortage the receiving barn is being utilized temporarily after the stalls have been cleaned for horses shipping in. Rick explained that he is working to rectify the situation and it soon will be remedied.

Work Orders/Addressing Maintenance Issues – Chip explained Turfway’s intricate system to address maintenance issues on the backside. He explained that they will soon provide a memorandum on the system which he feels will dramatically improve the response time to issues on the backstretch. The Committee expressed the view that their efforst have vastly improved the reaction to maintenance issues.

Traffic Jam at the Guard Gate – The arrival of ship-ins creates a traffic snafu at the guard gate. The problem is attributed to the requirement of making copies of health certificates and coggins not required at other tracks in Kentucky. Chip explained that he will review the process and attempt to alleviate the traffic backup if possible. Also, he will see that a fax machine is installed.

Manure Pickup – While the horsemen commented that the regularity of manure pickup has dramatically improved, the equipment used creates quite a mess in and around the manure pits. Jeff explained that they have equipment that will alleviate the problem on order and he expects it to be delivered in the very near future.

Trash Pickup – Trash in and around the dorm area is becoming more and more prevalent and unsightly. The committee suggested that perhaps another trash pickup utilizing the cooking skills of Jerry the “Russian”, as an incentive is in order. In addition, it was suggested that a once a week announced trash pickup, where a truck moves through the barn area after training allowing everyone to throw trash in the truck as it passes by, may be worthy of consideration.

Ruts in the Horse Path – The problem with ruts in the horsepath has returned. Jeff explained that he is now, on a regular basis, running equipment over the horse path to keep it smooth. Horsemen explain that it is the lack of drainage that is the issue along with the amount of surface on the horse path and of course the vehicles that drive over the surface creating the ruts. Also, it was suggested that drain tiles should be added under the surface to allow the excess water to drain away from the horse path.

Hoses in the Test Barn – Greg Schmidt informed the committee that this problem was resolved on Thursday of this week.

Receiving Barn Lounge – Greg Schmidt informed the committee that two new heating units have been installed in the lounge.

Blacktop – Chip explained taht several potholes and various areas are scheduled to be patched within the next few days.

Snow and Ice Removal – Greg explained that once a new shipment of salt arrives they will begin to fill the barrels in strategic areas on the backstretch. He also reviewed the plan for snow and ice removal in the barn area.

Window Update – Chip explained the tiered approach to addressing the issues with the construction of the new windows which includes assuring that the windows are water and air tight, evaluating the safety and design in addition to having an independent carpenter review the assembly.

Insect Infestation in the Dormitories – Chip suggested that they will address the units as a whole with the recommendations of an exterminator.

Identifying Occupants of the Tackrooms – Rick and Steve intend to identify the occupants of dormitory rooms and talk with trainers who have been allocated the rooms to determine if the person in the room is employed by them.

Hydrants Leaking – The plumbers are beginning the process of replacing parts in hydrants that are either leaking or appear to be likely to leak in the near future.

Laundry in the Future – Chip explained that it is still Turfway’s intention to develop a laundry convenient to the backside community on the backstretch.

Horse Ambulance – The lack of a suitable horse ambulance was apparent following the catastrophic injury to a horse trained by committee member Bill Connelly on Sunday. Bill reviewed the turn of events. Chip explained that this issue is a priority and will most assuredly be addressed.

Respectfully Submitted,

Mary Maline
Executive Director
Kentucky HBPA

The first meeting of the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee was held on Wednesday, September 19, 2007, for the Turfway Park 2007 Fall race meeting.

Bob Elliston, President, Turfway Park; Chip Bach, Director of Operations; Steve Peterman, Starter/Stable Manager; attended representing Turfway Park.

Wayne Mogge, Joe Davis, Dave England, and Marty Maline attended representing the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee. Marty recorded the minutes.

ABUNDANCE OF FLIES-Horsemen have commented that there appears to be an abundance of flies in the stable area. Chip assured the committee that they are continuing the fly eradication program that was initiated several years ago and there has been no variation. The discussion centered on the continued heat and lack of rain and perhaps this has exacerbated the problem.

BLACKTOP-Committee members mentioned that there are some areas on the backstretch that need attention regarding blacktop repair. Chip requested that areas of concern should be reported to Steve Peterman or the KHBPA and forwarded to him and they will be addressed.

IMPROVEMENT UPDATE-Many horsemen stabled in barns 21 and 22, have favorably commented about the improvements. The windows initially have been a concern, but Chip explained that he is confident early problems have been rectified. Dave England explained that some of the bottom boards are warped and may cause leaking during strong rains. Chip has assured the committee that any issue with faulty boards will be addressed.

WORK ORDERS-Chip explained that the delays horsemen are experiencing in response to submitted work orders was due to a communication snafu and he is reasonably sure that the issue has been resolved.

CABLE ISSUES-Chip suggested that horsemen with poor reception on their television sets should fill out a work order and the problem will be addressed.

MILE RACES-A brief discussion ensued regarding large fields in mile races. Joe Davis stated that problems were much worse with the old racing surface where horses on the outside raced above the crown. Steve Peterman mentioned that he felt gate positioning may help perceived problems to a certain extent.

BONUS PROGRAM-The bonus program which allows that a Grade I winner of the Turfway Park Classic will receive an additional $150,000 from horsemen’s purse money was discussed. Bob Elliston explained the reasoning behind the decision, they are attempting to secure Grade I status for the event and to entice the Breeder’s Cup to declare the race as one of a select few that are considered a “win and your in” event which will entitle it to a possible supplement from the Breeder’s Cup. Members of the KHBPA board have suggested that since the bonus is in conformance with the stakes percentage of the purse contract, that it should be offered to all participants and not just to Grade I winners. While Bob agreed to consider the proposal in the future, he felt since the bonus had been advertised as only to Grade I winners it should remain as is for this year. He stated that he intends to analyze the event with horsemen’s input following this year’s Cup races.

BACKSTRETCH ENVIRONMENT-Committee members expressed concern with the present climate on the backside, specifically alcohol intoxication and possible drug use. Bob Elliston explained that inappropriate behavior will not be tolerated and he will instruct his security accordingly. Multiple offenders will be either taken before the stewards or ejected from the grounds. Safety on the backside is paramount and if people are unable to function due to being intoxicated the possibility that some person or horse may be injured is magnified.

APPRECIATION TO HORSEMEN-Bob Elliston expressed Turfway Park’s appreciation to horsemen for their support in regularly entering their horses. While he is well aware that there are other options available, horsemen have chosen to run their horses at Turfway Park and entries have consistently remained strong.

EUROSIZER PROPOSAL-Chip mentioned that they are continuing their research on the possibility of locating a Eurosizer on the backstretch of Turfway Park. He is interested in horsemen’s opinions on whether or not they will use the device. Joe Davis informed the committee that the Eurosizer was used frequently by horsemen at Ellis Park this summer and he himself regularly utilized it as part of his training regimen.

PURSE STATUS-Purses have remained fairly consistent with the Fall race meeting of last year. Bob Elliston mentioned that TVG source market revenue has increased substantially which should favorably influence the purse account.

Respectfully submitted,
Marty Maline, KHBPA Ex. Dir.

The drug council, which met Aug. 23, stopped short of a recommendation for the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority but said it would tell the agency it favors steroid regulation. Officials said they want to make sure all parties, including horsemen, understand the rules and procedures before anything is adopted.

There is a nationwide push for the regulation of four commonly used steroids–boldenone (Equipoise), stanozolol (Winstrol), nandrolone (Durabolin), and testosterone–all of which are approved for use by the Federal Drug Administration. All other steroids would be banned.

“I think the consensus would be everybody wants constraint on anabolic steroids in racehorses and at sales,” said trainer John Ward Jr., a member of the drug council. “I guess the next question is what the speed limit would be.”

Withdrawal times–the length of time it may take for a drug to clear a horse’s system–for steroids range from 30-60 days, according to reports. Such a time period would preclude their use on race day. FDA-approved steroids are widely believed to have therapeutic value.

“Anabolic steroids are extremely abused in racehorses,” said Dr. Foster Northup, a racetrack veterinarian and former member of the drug council. “They do have a purpose in our industry, but they’re abused. The majority of racetrack vets will agree with you.”

Northup said steroid use isn’t as bad in Kentucky as it is in other states. He claimed they are most abused in New York, where horses may be treated with steroids every 10-21 days. He said steroid use in higher in Florida as well.

“Racetrack practitioners feel it’s incredibly important that if we adopt rules for racehorses, sale companies should have to abide by the same rules,” Northup said. “We are adamant about that.”

David Switzer, executive director of the Kentucky Thoroughbred Association, said he understands Kentucky sale companies working on threshold levels for anabolic steroids and could have regulations in place by early 2008.

Vets said steroids can serve two purposes. They can be “mental performance-enhancers,” the effects of which last about five days, and physical enhancers, the effects of which are gone in about two weeks. Northup suggested a withdrawal time of even two weeks would eliminate abuse.

The Thoroughbred Owners and Breeders Association has asked all racing jurisdictions with graded stakes begin testing for anabolic steroids effective Jan. 1, 2008. Even if Kentucky doesn’t have regulations in place, racetracks could adopt house rules to meet those testing requirements, KHRA executive director Lisa Underwood said.

The drug council also discussed but took no action on a proposal to mandate administration of the bleeder medication Salix by state veterinarians, which currently is required at harness tracks but not Thoroughbred tracks. The plan would require the hiring of additional personnel.

Ellis Park horsemen stabled on the south end of the barn area were being forced by Kentucky Horse Racing Authority veterinarian Lafe Nichols to walk all the way around the far northern turn of the track after a race instead of taking the short way home.

“That means walking six and sometimes seven furlongs (nearly a mile) farther in this heat,” the woman fumed. “It’s totally (inappropriate) for humans and horses to be put through that.”

Trainers also have raised the issue. Several said their solution is to not run at Ellis.

Still, on Thursday, the man who should be in charge, chief steward John Veitch, said he had “complete faith in Dr. Nichols’ decision and backed him 100 percent.”

The bottom line decision was to keep all returning horses within Nichols’ and his employees’ sight. In the event that an animal collapses from heat stroke or exhaustion, they reason that the stricken horse can be reached quicker by Equine Ambulance personnel.

“If we had one go down on one turn and another go down on the other turn, the veterinarians may not be able to reach them in time,” said Veitch.

But that same principle applies to a race, when horses could go down at various points. One recently collapsed in the barn area and was completely out of sight.

What then? It’s never been a problem here before. Like it or not, casualties are part of racing. Trainers know the risk.

Extra water buckets and ice have been placed around the turns. Track owner Ron Geary attempted to intervene by hiring a private veterinarian. He offered putting his own cash up for whatever it took to allow horsemen to walk either way.

But bureaucracy ruled. Veitch said that such a measure would require as much as 60 days worth of preparation and paperwork. The meeting ends in 15 days.

In 1978 and 1981, there were 13 consecutive days of 100 degree heat. at Ellis Park The barn area didn’t house 650 horses like now. There were 1,050 on the grounds and they walked both ways. In an earlier era, there was a bridle path through the center of the soybeans, too. Perhaps it’s a sign of the times. People aren’t what they used to be.

n Getting the horses back to the barns hasn’t been the only problem with stewards this meeting. Earlier this month, only two were in the stand for several days, even though rules plainly state that “aAll three stewards shall be present in the stewards’ stand during the running of each race.”

Veitch said one steward was having surgery, making it an emergency that qualified his decision. But doesn’t it often take longer to be admitted into a hospital than it does to fetch a backup steward?

Veitch said that he was satisfied because a placing judge who also is accredited as a steward was in the next room or on the outside catwalk.

That’s not good enough to protect the public’s interest. Ellis Park isn’t Saratoga or Keeneland. But it’s not the Rockport Fair meeting of 1930.

n On Friday, July 6, the KHRA scratched trainer Tim Glyshaw’s horse, Tahlequah, alleging that the young Evansville horseman had given the horse an illegal substance.

State officials won’t freely admit it on the record, but they got their horses mixed up. The entire operation, from the state investigator who should not have been handling the sample to the proper documentation of paper work was a total joke. There was no illegal substance, merely superior horsemanship keeping a cripple together.

For some reason, results of the test took 30 days instead of the standard three or four. Glyshaw still doesn’t have any hard copy of the results that proves he did nothing wrong. Veitch said he must have left it in the home office.

On Friday, Mark York, spokesman for Kentucky’s Public Protection Cabinet that oversees the KHRA said that “As far as we are concerned, the matter involving Mr. Glyshaw is over with.”

Still, they never offered the hard-working young trainer an apology for actions that harmed his reputation. They should be held accountable, though, especially before the next gubernatorial election.

A public hearing on this administrative regulation willl be held on September 25, 2007 , at 11:00 am, at the South Park Theatre at the Visitor’s Information Center, Kentucky Horse Park, 4063 Iron Works Parkway, Lexington, KY 40511.

Anyone interested in being heard at this hearing should notify the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority in writing by September 18, 2007, five working days prior to the hearing, of their intent to attend. If no notification of intent to attend the hearing is received by that date, the hearing may be cancelled.

This hearing is open to the public. Any person who wishes to be heard will be given an opportunity to comment on the proposed administrative regulation. A transcript of the public hearing will not be made unless a written request for a transcript is made.

If you do not wish to be heard at the public hearing, you may submit written comments on the proposed administrative regulation. Written comments shall be accepted until October 1, 2007. They can be mailed to me at the address below.

Thanks for your willingness to provide comments during the development of this regulation over the past few months.

John L. Forgy
General Counsel
Department of Public Protection
Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet
Counsel for the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority
4063 Iron Works Pike, Building B
Lexington, KY 40511
Phone (859)-246-2040
FAX (859)-246-2039

Attending the meeting and representing Ellis Park were Ron Geary, owner and President; Mark Geary, Director of Development; Bob Jackson, Director of Operations; and Dan Bork, Director of Racing.

The KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee includes Mike Bruder, Chairman of the KHBPA Horsemen’s Committee; R.L. “Bob” Williams, and Jack Byers serving as an honorary member of the committee. Marty Maline recorded the minutes.

PROVIDING ASSISTANCE-Several horsemen have expressed appreciation for the efforts of Susan Steelman giving water to horses and horsemen. Susan has been providing assistance to horsemen and horses as they leave the racetrack during the stretch of oppressively hot days.

PROPOSED PROMOTION-The committee suggested the feasibility of raffling off an automobile at the next Ellis Park race meeting. Mike suggested the promotion, allowing patrons to submit tickets throughout the racing season with a grand drawing at or near the end of the race meeting.

REROUTING HORSES AFTER RACING-A lengthy discussion ensued regarding the Chief State Veterinarian’s decision that every horse must return to the barn area in one direction. While the committee agreed that during the oppressive heat the State Veterinarian’s decision may have been reasonable, had he communicated his decision to horsemen with an explanation it would have been better received. In addition, it was reported that two horses were felled by heat strokes after they had left the racetrack and were making the long trek back to the bottom barn area. The committee agreed that next year it is incumbent upon the Racing Authority to have two State veterinarians one located near the paddock and one in the vicinity of the mile chute that way all the bases are covered.

CLAIMING CROWN SYNOPSIS-Ron Geary explained that they were very pleased with the outcome and most notably for eclipsing the former wagering record for the Claiming Crown by more than a million dollars. He credited his staff and horsemen for a memorable day of racing and singled out Mike Bruder and the KHBPA for their support. In addition, Ron reviewed some interesting trends regarding wagering on the Claiming Crown, he explained that there was a wide disparity between the various advance deposit wagering companies (ADWs), he suggested that like Claiming Crown day had Ellis Park been able to provide their signal to everyone that wished to wager on Ellis’ racing product most assuredly our numbers would have been favorably enhanced, meaning more money for purses and for the racetracks bottom line. Marty explained that horsemen throughout the country are disturbed with the fact that some ADWs are attempting to control the racing industry, a perfect case in point is what has happened at Ellis Park.

RECOGNITION OF RACING OFFICES EFFORTS-The committee recognized the efforts of Dan Bork, Director of Racing, and his staff. Despite being faced with slot enriched purses at other racetracks, Arlington’s installation of polytrack, and the oppressive heat, Dan and his staff have continued to provide race cards with respectable field size. Ron Geary commented that Dan’s team has jelled as the season has progressed.

FLIES ON THE BACKSTRETCH-Committee members voiced concern with the increased population of flies on the backstretch. Bob Jackson assured the committee that they continue to spread the larvae eating wasps eggs on the backstretch similar to Churchill Downs. Mark Geary explained that he has talked with representatives of Lone Star about a fly eradication program they have implemented there.

IMPROVEMENTS FOR NEXT YEAR-Mike Bruder reviewed a list of projects to be considered during the off season. They included water lines to allow for the availability of hoses on the racetrack. Additional air conditioners for dormitories K, M, N, and O. Trees on the backstretch lost due to the tornado, lights for the soccer fields and ball diamonds, and a roof for the Eurosizer. Ron Geary agreed that they will secure bids on each of the projects and further discuss the projects at the next meeting of the committee.

INDIANA DOWNS OTB-Ron explained his reasoning for denying Churchill Downs owned racetracks from simulcasting to the OTB in Evansville. He reviewed the agreement he had reached with Churchill prior to purchasing the Ellis Park to prevent the OTB from cannibalizing betting patrons from Ellis Park.

Respectfully submitted,

Marty Maline, Ex. Dir. KHBPA

Tuesday, August 28th, 2007.
OPEN TO PUBLIC 11AM
Kentucky Horse Park
South Park Theater

For more information please contact Marty Maline at 1-800-928-4272 or email kymarty@aol.com.

It was a disservice to fans, horsemen, management, and to themselves professionally and financially.

The Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association picked up part of the tab, reimbursing every owner $150 for each horse denied a chance to run.

That won’t cover the cost for shippers and race day medication administered by veterinarians. But it helps.

There were exceptions, including Larry Melancon, the classy veteran from Breaux, Bridge, La. He turns 52 next Tuesday. Since handling his first winner in 1971, he’s ridden under the worst possible conditions around the country.

A one-time vice president of the old Jockey’s Guild (Central Region), Melancon has guided more winners and been victorious in more important stakes races than most of the other Ellis Park combined.

He was ready to ride.

He was ready to ride.

While I’ve never ridden a thoroughbred, after charting 40,000 races and countless spills, I’m aware of how dangerous the profession is. That’s why an ambulance follows the field around the track, and that’s why precautions should be taken.

The vast amount of rain did make the surface slippery for the fifth race.

But 30 minutes after Friday’s rain, the track was fine, looking like a beach after the tide ran out.

The jockeys already had refused a test gallop during the sixth race warm-up period and also declined a delay, which would have allowed track superintendent Glenn Thompson and crew to fix the footing.

It all happened so fast that by the time racing secretary Dan Bork, who has done a yeoman’s job carding races, was informed, a decision had been made.

Rushing off was immature on the part of the jockeys and costly to all parties, especially track owner Ron Geary, who has made a huge investment to keep Ellis in business.

Although Kentucky Racing Authority chief steward John Veitch asked the jockeys to be patient and wait, they declined. He found no way to buy time, to prove the track was safe.

In the old days, the motto on all Ellis Park advertising included “rain or shine.” The game never ceased because an open line of communication existed.

Last Friday, the Sky Theater was packed. An enthusiastic crowd was on hand.

They wanted action. Many hung around to wager on other tracks. But others left shaking their heads.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

2007 Claiming Crown Now Available to Larger Audience

Lexington, KY., July 26, 2007 – Heeding the call from National HBPA President and Chairman Joe Santanna during a July 20 speaker forum, TrackNet Media Group (TNM), Television Games Network (TVG) and Youbet.com (YB) on July 26 have agreed to a content sharing arrangement that will benefit horsemen and bettors and will make the August 4th Claiming Crown races – being run at Ellis Park in Henderson, KY for the first time – available to a wider audience than ever before.

The discussions formally began July 23 between TNM, TVG and National HBPA working with The Thoroughbred Breeders Association (TOBA). National HBPA and TOBA are partners in Claiming Crown, Ltd. Both TVG and Youbet.com proposed that any profits from the distribution of the 2007 Claiming Crown should revert to Claiming Crown, Ltd.

Early on Tuesday, July 24th, TNM – which through Ellis Park’s simulcasting distribution agreement with Churchill Downs controls the rights to the Ellis Park signal and, thus, this year’s Claiming Crown races – had formally offered to the Kentucky HBPA (the horsemen’s group representing Ellis Park horsemen) and National HBPA/TOBA to provide both wagering and video rights to the Claiming Crown.

TNM committed that all major industry commercial advance deposit wagering distribution outlets – including TNM’s own outlets such as TwinSpires.com and XpressBet – would pay the same fee.

Both TVG and Youbet.com have agreed to purchase the Claiming Crown rights from TNM for their distribution/wagering networks and have committed to donate any profits – an idea first proposed by TVG – back to Claiming Crown, Ltd. in support of the event.

First run in 1999, the Claiming Crown brings together those “blue collar” horses that have become favorites of fans and horsemen alike. In 2007, the 9th renewal of the Claiming Crown will feature a new title sponsor –Old National Bank – and will offer $600,000 in purses for seven races offered to horses that have started at least once in the past year for a claiming tag ranging from $7,500 (or less) to $35,000 (or less).

Joe Santanna, President and Chairman of the National HBPA said “Our horsemen in Kentucky and across the country couldn’t be happier that TrackNet Media responded to our request to share the Claiming Crown with all commercial advance deposit wagering companies. I commend both TVG and Youbet.com for stepping up and buying those rights for their customers – and offering to contribute any profits back to Claiming Crown, Ltd. While this may only be a small step forward toward solving the larger issues we’ve been addressing, such as content sharing, exclusivity and sublicensing fees, it certainly is a very big step forward.”

“This is a very positive and encouraging decision by TrackNet Media, TVG and YouBet.com and we hope that it leads to more meaningful and decisive discussions on content sharing in the future,” said TOBA president Dan Metzger. “We have witnessed a tremendous commitment by horsemen and Ellis Park to this year’s Claiming Crown and the participation of all advance deposit wagering companies will broaden the distribution of the event and ensure all of our customers have access to the races. “

Under the proposed new rule, a horse scratched for veterinary reasons could not run again for nine days. The current rule allows for a “vet-scratched” horse to run six days after being scratched. The KHRA had previously approved changing the rule to allow the scratched horse to be “entered” six days after the scratch.

Due to varying entry times at the state’s tracks, however, the Authority decided to stipulate the horse could not run for nine days after the scratch.

Representatives of the state’s Thoroughbred tracks had previously voiced support for the longer re-entry period, citing abuse of the present system. They contended some horses are being scratched without having a medical condition and that there is insufficient staff in the state veterinarian’s office to confirm the validity of each scratch.

Some believe that by increasing the number of days before the scratched horse could be re-entered, trainers would be less likely to scratch a horse on the basis of a veterinary problem. This, in turn, would presumably lead to larger field sizes.

Marty Maline, executive director of the Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association, argued that the new rule could have the opposite effect and lead to even smaller field sizes. He noted that the rule would preclude horses scratched for minor problems, such as being treated with medications for shipping purposes, from being held out of racing for an inordinately long period.

Tom Ludt, the only Authority member to vote against the latest version of the rule change, said he believed the changes would unfairly penalize those who scratch their horses for legitimate reasons. He had previously stated he would prefer that the state legislature provide the KHRA veterinary unit with sufficient staffing and funding to police the vet-scratch process.

The proposal would also direct the tracks to maintain records of scratch activity and field sizes for one year to help determine the impact of the new regulation.

Before the proposal would take effect, it must be reviewed by the Legislative Research Commission staff to determine if it complies with state statutes. Then, the proposal will be debated at a public hearing before going on to the General Assembly for action. Copyright © 2007 The Blood-Horse, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

At 3:07 p.m., power flickered off, but surged on seconds later. The second hit came at 3:25 p.m.

Horses were in the paddock waiting to be called postward for the seventh race. Steward Ron Herbstreit, representing the Kentucky Horse Racing Authority, gave Ellis officials until 4:30 p.m. to correct the problem before cancelling the remainder of the 11-race card, partly because of horses’ medication rules.

“Life is a series of setbacks,” said Ellis Park owner Ron Geary. “We’ll come back and have a good meeting. We view this as a flesh wound. “If you can overcome a tornado like Ellis Park (in November, 2005), then we can ovecome this.”

Most of the electricity was restored at 5 p.m. Simulcasting resumed in the clubhouse for those in the crowd of 4,672 — the largest since opening day — who cared to partake.

Ellis Park officials said two transformers on U.S. 41 routing power into the track from Vectren were damaged. The outage entailed two parts of the track’s three-phase system. Power was blacked out in the main grandstand, clubhouse and Sky Theater. One person was trapped in the Sky Theater elevator.

Several parts of the plant including a section of the barn area and racing secretary’s office, remained lit.

Also knocked out were telephone lines sending and receiving wagering information from the betting hub located in Louisville.

Normally, Ellis Park receives its electricity from Kenergy on the Henderson side of the Ohio River. However, Kenergy had to disconnect its power cables over the Twin Bridges while the spans are under repair. Kenergy made arrangements for Vectren to act as server.

“We could have waited and run live. But our allotted satellite time for the remainder of the card to be sent nationwide would have been over with,” said Ellis director of operations Bob Jackson. “With the power rerouted from Evansville, we weren’t totally familiar of where the problem happened at first. It made for strange circumstances with a few areas in power and the main ones out.”

Jackson noted that anyone bringing a Sunday program back on any race day will be issued a free one. Sponsors of canceled races will be given another choice of days.

It was bittersweet for Geary. He was elated by the crowd and enthusiasm generated by the HBPA’s College Laptop Computer Day, but disappointed by the cancellations.

“Everyone stepped up, from the folks in Loogootee Ind., who sponsored the day’s races to the college kids who turned out,” Geary said.

Geary estimated that losing the last five races cost the track $200,000 in total revenue. “Last year, we lost half of the opening Friday. That cost $125,000,” he noted. “There is no insurance for such a thing. It happens. You move on.”

No dates are definite, but Geary said the lost races probably would be made up on Saturdays and Sundays through the rest of the meet. After the cancellation, HBPA reps John Griffith Jr. and Mike Bruder had the names of the remaining laptop winners drawn. They’ll be notified by telephone and can pick up their prizes in the track’s general office by showing a valid student identification.

Race No. 6 began the Pick-Six. Kentucky rules specify the entire pool must be refunded when fewer than three races in the series have been run. The Pick-Three which started on the fifth race will be paid as 7-3-all worth $13.60. The Pick-Three beginning on the sixth race is 3-all-all worth $5.20.

The sixth race was the $26,000 Asher Overnight Handicap for fillies and mares, 3-year-olds and up going 51/2 furlongs